
- •Introduction
- •V. Qualifications for an Effective Mediator
- •VI. Preparing for and Executing an Effective Mediation Process
- •1. Preliminary Arrangements
- •Includes disclosure by the mediator candidates of any and all
- •4. Venting (this is an optional stage in the process)
- •Vent anger or frustration with regard to the disputed issues.
- •11. Bargaining and Negotiation
- •12. Agreement
- •13. Closure
- •Information as often as necessary to be sure that one or both of the parties hear it. Parties
1. Preliminary Arrangements
a. Selection of the mediator by the parties or their counsel which
Includes disclosure by the mediator candidates of any and all
possible conflicts of interest with the parties, their counsel or
other interested parties to the conflict. This might require
the parties to exchange names of mediator candidates and the
fee schedules and resumes of the candidates under
consideration;
b. Communication with the parties or party representatives via
letter or email to arrange the date, time and location of the
mediation and the disputed issues which will be covered by the
mediation process;
Important considerations during this stage of the process:
1. selection of a neutral location for the mediation;
2. brief description of the issues presented to the mediator
in writing;
3. decisions made regarding mediator fee arrangements;
Copyright 2008 Mina Akins Brees page 9
4. length of time needed for the mediation;
5. language of the mediation and whether or not interpreters
are necessary;
2. Mediator’s Introduction
a. Mediator’s explanation of the ground rules that will apply to the
process including:
1. time allotted to the process;
2. agenda for the process;
3. parties’ authority to settle;
4. parties acknowledge that they agree to mediate in good
faith;
5. housekeeping items such as where the restrooms and water
is located and when breaks will take place;
6. parties should not interrupt each other so everyone has an
opportunity to talk;
7. explain the role of the mediator and the mediator’s
qualifications;
8. explain that the mediation process is confidential;
9. explain what the caucus session is and its importance;
10. explain that the process should be calm and parties
should treat each other with respect and be civil;
11. this entire segment of the process is a time for the mediator
to build trust with the parties and their counsel and
demonstrate impartiality.
3. Opening Statements by Parties
a. Each party and/or party representative has an opportunity to
present the issues they believe are in dispute and their
positions on those issues;
Copyright 2008 Mina Akins Brees page 10
b. For counsel representing the parties this is an important opportunity to make an impression on the opposition by
preparing your presentation well to make your points
most effectively;
c. This is the time in which not only the lawyers make their
presentations but also the parties may make statements
as well.
4. Venting (this is an optional stage in the process)
a. The mediator may allow the party or party’s representatives to
Vent anger or frustration with regard to the disputed issues.
The mediator must be careful not to let this venting get out
of control because the parties may get so worked up/angry
that the process may terminate at this point instead of going
forward to resolution. Venting is sometimes a positive process
because the parties reveal their frustrations and rid them-
selves of these distractions early in the process so they can think more clearly and rationally about resolution of the disputed issues instead of how upset or angry they are.
5. Information Gathering
a. This is really the mediator’s opportunity to visit with each party
and party representatives in a separate caucus sessions. The
mediator can gather the facts as each party sees them and
determine where the parties agree on those facts and where
they differ;
b. The mediator should keep notes and attempt to determine which
interests the parties have that are similar;
c. This part of the process may be most beneficial when the parties
are separated into caucus sessions/separate rooms so they
may speak freely about their concerns;
d. The mediator must seek the permission of each party and his/her
counsel when in a caucus session to reveal or share this
information with anyone else;
e. The mediator must keep all information learned from the parties
confidential unless given express permission to share it with the other parties.
Copyright 2008 Mina Akins Brees page 11
6. Issue & Interest Identification
a. Again the mediator’s responsibility is to listen to the parties
and their representatives about the issues which they believe
are in dispute. The mediator takes this opportunity
to learn the positions and underlying interests of the parties on
the issues.
b. The mediators questions to the parties and their counsel are
important and should be asked in a neutral manner
including restating what the parties have said to make
sure that the mediator understood what was said prior
to continuing the process.
7. Agenda Setting (this is an optional stage of the process)
a. Once the issues and interests are identified, the mediator with
input from the parties and their representatives sets an
agenda for consideration of each issue and the interests of the
parties. The agenda also includes consideration of possible
resolutions for each of the issues.
8. Caucus or private session (this is an optional stage of the process)
a. The mediator conducts a caucus or private session with
each of the parties and/or party representatives to gather facts,
identify interests and issues, setting the agenda for
consideration of the issues, and soliciting resolution options;
b. These sessions can be very important times to learn the interests
of the parties;
c. Parties feel at ease and more willing to share information in the
private caucus sessions;
d. The mediator should emphasize the confidentiality of the process
and ask permission to disclose information revealed to
him/her;
e. The mediator should explain to the parties and their counsels that
it is possible that he/she may spend more time with one of
the parties or another but that does not mean the mediator
favors that particular side – only that more time may be
Copyright 2008 Mina Akins Brees page 12
needed for the discussion. This is not an indication of
partiality.
9. Option Generation
a. This is one of the most important parts of the mediation process
because the mediator explores with each of the parties and
their representatives various options for the resolution of the
issues in dispute. The mediator should keep a written record of the options discussed;
b. The mediator should work through each issue in dispute in
an attempt to resolve the dispute;
c. The mediator should encourage the parties to think outside the box
and creatively;
d. The mediator must keep in mind that the parties make the
agreement and resolve the issues not the mediator.
10. Reality testing (this is an optional stage in the process)
a. Once the mediator has gathered the resolution options, the
mediator with the assistance of the parties and the
parties’ representatives should test whether the options
discussed are feasible and whether or not the options can
actually be executed once the mediation is completed.
b. The mediator should ask the parties the question: Can the parties
honor the terms of the agreement?