Теория_КГ / Delone_art1_2

!$%&'((#" )+*-,!)+.0/+132!)+.-465-7#)+8:9;)3<-5-.=)+>!?643@A5-.

/6F8+FC< GIH J KILIJ HNM

OQP RSTU V P RWWXC YZR[!UW\3X ]T^YV-_YZVWU]` V3Ra^TPYUX `cbTWUP TV]Y\6UPY R]^da\eYY; !VaT] -Y bP VfaR^RVUW\6Yg;haRWWYiCYh ReY\ & !a\+ZWVg Ra^TPYUX TZ+bPYZTfYUW\6TeV]h R3Yg6UPdfTVX hTWUY Z WP Vf]VXQY gdfj VXcWadk R\g & l!SWdm-R[!UW\;TWSV]]TWUYf P VRa_ReYYN&Nn RWWXCUPYZR[!UW\3kVU` P V WUPdhUdP`ofR]]` ga\-fbP VfWU RZaV]Y\ UPY R]^da\eYYN&p!PYZTf\UW\ bP TeVfdP`qbP TZVPhY=dWaTZY\!VaT]V Y6TbW` ZR[!UW\+bP TeVfdP`cWaY\]Y\+UPY R]^da\eYrN&

8-H uIvIs &wNRfk R+bTWUP TV]Y\ UPY R]^da\eYY; !VaT] =\Za\VUW\6Tf]Tr _Y=SR_TZ` g;Z6Z` kYWaYU Vax]Tr ^VTX VUPYYN&y]Vr;WZTf\UW\3X ]T^YV-Pd^YVf-RfRkYNzT] R=jTh 3YWbTax_dVUW\3Z+XCRj Y]]Tr6^P RiCYhV Y;^T{ Y]i!TPXCReYT]]` g+WYU VXCRg6fa\=X TfVaYP TZR]Y\=bTZVPg]TWU Vr;Y6PV]\3bP TWUP R]WUZV]]` g6RfRkN&

OCbVPZ` VRfRk RCbTWUP TV]Y\!UPY R]^da\eYY !VaT] IS` aRCbTWU RZaV] RCZ%|}-$^ P RSTU VIWTZ WhT^TCXCRU V{ XCRUYh R!~=&!VaT]V&-$& IV!UPdfTVX hTWUx WTU RZa\VU3 +c ; X VUYkWhYg+TbVP ReYrN&Cd VWUZd[!U Ra^TPYUX `-TWUY^R[!zf UYV+ Tr TeV]hY Z6WP Vf]VXQY gdfj VXQWadk R\g & X V+UPT zY_ZVWU]`0Ra^TPYUX `-z bT_ZTa\[! YV!Z=P\fV Wadk RVZ+fTWUYkx+Z=WP Vf]VXo +;& IVX ]V X zbT=] T\ VV ZP VX \=X ]T^YV!bP Tfa{ m-[!UqP Rx6] dWTZVPj V]WUZTZR]YVXyYZVWU]` gqYqWT_fR]VX#]TZ` gqRa^TPYUX TZ & U TaV] ]VdWU TrkYZTWUx[cP\fR!YZVWU]` g6Ra^TPYUX TZ!Y=]VdfTZaVUZTPYU Vax]` X VX V]XqYg=P RSTU`q] Rax]`P Vg ] RSTP Rg3fR]]` g &

Oo] T\ Vr;P RSTU V WfaR] R+bT` Uh R=haWWYiCYh ReYY6Y;TSS V]Y\+X ]T^Yg+YZVWU]` g Ra^TPYUX TZ=Z

WTTUZVUWUZYY3W bPZVfV]]Tr;]Ym V WgX Tr m YP]` XoZ`!fVaV]`chT]hP VU]` Va^TPYUX-R `!&

$&C P!URYZ]`V V=Ra^TPYUX `-& $&$& 93KIJN v NvIH uIJ =KIv N +&

$&$&$& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvB+tq N qvcNKJ I& $&&C P!URYZ]`V Va^TPYUX-R ` WfVh P TZR]YVXobTYWh R=UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ &

$&&$& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvq NvIKy uNvIsJH#t+K HsJ =F $&&& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvq GINvIKy 3vIuCtuNvIsJHQ¡¢3tKs sH J =F $&&|& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvq NvIKy 3vIuCtuNvIsJHQGIH NtsHKJJNt=F

$&|&C P!URYZ]`V Va^TPYUX-R ` jW PYhTZR]YVXobTYWh R=UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ & $&|&$& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvJq N N yNvIGIvI£Is¥#G;vIK¤uIvIsJ HQ¦IJGIvN& $&|&& 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvq N vIyG£;tvIs vIu¥QG;vIK¤uIvIsJ Hc¦IJGIvN&

$} &C !URYZ]` Va^TPYUX-R ` _XW V]]]`Y XobTP\fhTX fTSRZaV]Y\=U TkVhN& $}$& 46 NvIH uINH= Jq¦IJq KIv N =F $} & 46 NvIH uI = qGIH JNtKIvKI N =FNuI = $} &| 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvq NJ yIuI3¦IJN§=¨;suIvIsy=F

$} &} & 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvqJ KCN yNvIK6 J H©Gª=KIGJ N©HItuIJJ qGIKIvIH J & $} &" 46 NvIH uIJ=KIvqJ KCN yNvIK6 J GNJNtHG J §IF¦IJq«I

&C¬!a^TPYUX `oWaY\]Y\ &&$& /= J.KIv®ts N ­v NH § NF&& .GN§svIHKC uI = Jq KIv®K Ns®uIvIsy 3KIy¦IJqtsvINKI§IF&|&Cp!TaWZ` V Ra^TPYUX ` WaY\]Y\ &

&|&$& /= J KIv N #H NH=¦I§J vIGNJ uIvIJ J;¦IJNF&|&& /= J KIv=¦I§N GN JNH JJ;¦vIJ uIvI NF

|&C¬!a^TPYUX `obP\X T^ -TWUPb TV]Y\ & |&$& 93J ¥J;H = Jq KIv N =F

¯ ITX WhYr+^TWdfRP WUZV]]` r=d]YZVP WYU VUNzi!RhdaxU VU=Y]i!TPXCRUYhYNzbPN&°!V]Y] Rzf &|'z'|}±"±z^ &ITX WhN² {´6µ¶·¸¹º»!¼¸½N&¾¸¿N&À

³

Á¼ Rdk]T{YWWaVfTZRU VaxWhYr3Z` kYWaYU Vax]` r6eV]UP;Â;ÃN QYX!&  &°!TX T]WTZR

|&& p!Tj-^TZ`R V Ra^TPYUX ` W dhTP V]YVXobTYWh R=WTVfVr; !VaT]& |&&$& 93J ¥J;H = J KIv KIuINy = 0tsHvIuIJ y¦IJGI Fv |&&& + s IJ £IuIJH= =q¦IJJq KIv¥; N =F

} & !ZdgbP Tgf]` V!Ra^TPYUX `-& }$& E+H § JNt¦IKuIJ =s3JKIv vIN uIvI­ NF } &C7cJNt vIªuIuN-vILIv= KK JvIGIvIH£Is J KIv N =F } &| 1+vIuIs= qJ KIv N =F } &C8sKIuI-s = J KIv N =F

} &" C/= J KIvvIHKCN uIJQK¨;s¦NJ;KIsuIvI NF } &' 1+su IJ £IuI J= KIv N =F

OoP RSTU V!P RWWXC YZR[!UW\=kVU` PYV-fR=WUPdhUdP;fR]]`Z g6fa\=bP VfWU RZaV]Y\+UPY R]^da\eYYN·

$&=B-® :JNst6 v NF&=E+H J IuI =s6K s KI NF |&=B-® IK s §KI J©;vcuIvIGIvNK s NF } &=B-® vo NKJ© uIvIGIv NF

p!PYZTf\UW\=kVU` PPV-TeVfdP`cbPb TZVPhY6dWaTZY\+ !VaT]·

$&!93K J H 6s®6§H£ KIuIvIs3JuIuIJ¦Iv J GIKI§NvCF ;uIJN&!93K J H ; uIss;H =£suIuIJ uIuIJJ¦Iv qJ GIKI§N©;F;uIJN |&!93K J H§ ; :¦IKs6JN¨6vNvIH;§JJHNF } &!7cJNt vIªuIuN-vIL6¦IKvIKJ H§J ;H ¦IKs;JN¨6vNvIHJ§JHNF

Rhm V TbYW` ZR[!UW\+bUx+bP TeVfdP6WaY\]Y\3fZdg+UPY R]^da\eYr3 !VaT]·

$&=B+t vIINK J I I&&=<- NKvI¦IsKJ IsNKIvNH I& |&=<- NK JK sNKIvIHN¦Is I& } &=<! vI ¦IsKIsuIvIsNK J suIvIsI&

"& <! vI =¦I§ GN JNH ¦IJuI NKIvI§ LIvI C&

CUx\3TP^R]YR _TZR] R3WaVfd[! YXcTSP RTX!& O#PfVaV;R$=TbYW` ZR[!UW\;TS -\3bTWUR R]TZh R3fRkYNz YW{ bTax_dVX ` V3SRTZ` V;Ra^TPYUX `#Y WUPdhUdP` fR]]` g &NO0PfVagqR ]C"RaYYPd[!UW\R kVU` P V;^dbb Ra^TPYUX TZ!bTWUP TV]Y\=UPY R]^da\eYY= !VaT]& !a\ h-T^Tf-a^TPYUXCR!bPYZTf\UW\R TeV]hY3UPdfTVX hTWUY Z-dfjg VXqY3WP Vf]VX Wadk R\g &O Rha[!kV]YY6bPZTfYUW\=WZTf] R\-U RSaYe R ZWVg+P RWWXCRUPYZRVX ` g+Ra^TPYU{ X TZ=W _R]YVX UPdfTVX hTWUYNzWhTP TWUY6P RSTU`o] Rax]`=P Vg6fR]]` g+Y6TS Vr6hWbVP U]Tr;TeV]hYN&

FI)=¦IKssuIvI +vNKI§ G uIuIN§KI!a\­-Rax]Vrjtf& V^T=TSWdm-V]Y\=ZVfVXf ]VWhTaxhT=TbP VfaV{ ]Yr $z|z ·

)=¦IKssuIvNs& =]`RZRVUW\!baR] RPTV PSY]YVCbaTWhTWUYR -] RiCY^dPNzY_ChTU TP` g Tf] RZa\VUW\=Z]Vj-\ ]Vr;SVWhT]Vk]TrNzWUR-Rax]`T V!UP Vd^Tax]Yh RX YN&

)=¦IKssuIvNs#"$% ' )(N& 3]`RZRVUW\=Uh\R UPY R]^da\eY\ zfa\-TUh TP Tr=X Y]XCRax{ ]` r bTaY^T]Nz TgZRU` ZR[! Yr;ZWV+UP Vd^Tax]YhYNz \ZaVUW\6Z` bdha` X!&Y]^da\eY\RIP z ]V+\Za\[! \W\3Z`-R { bdhaTrNz] `R ZRVUW\* +$% & '&

)=¦IKssuIvNs*,. / 0%'1( ' 2( 3%')4N& - . '5 * 6' *+5. $7*( '/ & ]`R{

ZRVUW\=RfRk R WTVfY]V]Y\+RfR]]` g+U TkVh3]VbVP VWh R[! YW\6TUP hV RX Y3U RhXqTSP RTX!zkU TS` Z=bTad{ kV]]Tr3UPY R]^da\eYY+X-d+a[!S`f X Y3fZdX \R]]`-f X Y3URX Y=]Vax_\=S` aT-TWUPb TYUx=]TZ` V TUP hY6SVV_ bVP VWkV]Y\6W V VWUZd[! YN&

wNRfk R bTWUP TV]Y\3UPY R]^da\eYY3bT=YWgTf]TX d3] RSTPd+U TkVh3\Za\VUW\=]VTf]T_] RkTrNzbTU TX d+ZT_{ ]Yh RVUqZTbP TWz h\R_Y;fZdgqPaYk]`R gqUPY R]^da\eYrqadkj V& O0aYU VP RUdP V%( 5 8 ' 0' ]`RZR[!U U Rhd[­PYU R]^da\eY[=z d TP Tr WdX XCR;faY]qZWVg P VSPqX Y]XCRax] R& p!PYqU TXQbTh R]T ± Cz kU T _RfRk RTWUP-b TV]Y\6U RhTr6UPY R]^da\eYY6\Za\VUW\9 :bTa]TrNzUN&V!{ YX VU;WaTm ]TWUx3 =>!?<;&p!TU TX d6fa\ STaxj Y]WUZR-PbRhUYkVWhYg;RfRk3Wd VWUZd[! YV3Ra^TPYUX `obTWUP TV]Y\3TbUYXCRax]Tr3UPY R]^da\eYY3]V{ bPYVX aVX `oZY fd3WaYj hTX Z` WThTr3UPdfTVX hTWUYN&

@ YP Th +YZVWU] R3UPY R^da\eY\+ !VaT]z hTU TP R\=]V=\Za\VUW\+TbUYXCRax]Tr6Z3dbTX \]dU TXqWX ` WaV6$z |z|$ ±z z]T+TSaRfRVU+P\fTX fPd^Yg+bP RhUYkVWhY;ZRm ]` g3WZTrUZ &

)=¦IKssuIvNs3ATZTP\UNzIkUI&Ã T UPY R]^da\eY\ dfTZaVUZTP\VUB 1 '+ CEDF 'zCVWaY Z]dUPx ThPdm { ]TWUYNzNTbWR]]TrqZThPd^;a[!ST^T6bWUP TV]]T^T;UP Vd^Tax]Yh RzN]V3bT RfVU ]Y Tf] R6Y3fR]]` g U UPY R]^da\eYY PW&N$ Rh R\=UPY R]^da\eY\=]`RZVUW\*( DF '&

nIYW&I$IPY R]^da\eY\= !VaT]

)=¦IKssuIvNsTZTP\UNzà T3bR3WVf]Yg;UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ6UPY R]^da\eYY;dfTZaVUZTP\VU3 1 '+ C DF 'zVWaY6U TX d=dWaTZY[cdfTZaVUZTP\VU=UPY R]^da\eY\ zWTWU RZaV]] R\=U Taxh _Y!UYg3fZdg+UP Vd^Tax]Y{ hTZ &

)=¦IKssuIvNsÃTZTP\UNzkU T!UP Vd^Tax]Yh-PYU R]^da\eYY dfTZaVUZTP\VU1 '+ CDF 'zVWaY=U TX d dWaTZY[­fTZaVUZTP\VUqUPYd R]^da\eY\ zNWTU RZaV]] R\ U Taxh _Y6U T^ UP Vd^Tax]Yh R;Y VgqV^T WVfVrVWaY6T]Y6Wd VWUZd[!U&

Â6]T^YV-a^TPYUXR ` bTWUP TV]Y\3UPY R]^da\eYY3 !VaT] YWbTax_d[!U6WaVfd[! d[QU VTP VX d|z'$&

5CsJ K s&C<DF ' 5 '* ')% / (F8) 4 C6' *' ( 0%')( ' . * 1 1( 5 ( '/& %'1 .'+ ( 8 ' % 1( + )%$31' . 7( ' 8 &'+ ! .'+ ( +' C 7 1 '+ CBDF ' F +)%$B( ' 8 &'+ 1 I

nIYW& p!VP VWUP TV]YV=UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ z]V dfTZaVUZTP\[! Yg+dWaTZY[Q !VaT]

Rhd[ TbVP ReY[:bVP VWUP TV]Y\ok T `] Z[!UR %'5C& \ U VTP VXCR ZTa\VU WP TYUx UPY{ R]^da\eY[y !VaT] +bTWaVfTZRU Vax]T z] ZRk RaV+WUP T\;]VhTU TPd[yUPY R]^da\eY[=zNR6bTU TXobTWaVfTZRU Vax]T dadkj-\R VZqWX ` dWaTZY\q !VaT]&Cp!PYcbP TZVPhV dWaTZY\ !VaT] fa\qb RPoWTVf]YgoUP Vd^Tax]YhTZ

³

X Tm ]T-WbTaxY_TZRUx=]VbTWP VfWUZV]]T6TbP VfaV]YVz ]T=Y]^fR-WbTaxY_d[!UW\3fPd^YV WbTWTS`-TW]TZR]]`z V ] RaVfd[!-W Yg6U VTP VXCRg |z"z$ $'&

5CsJ K s <"N&3DF ' '6 ! . ( 5 &1 5 8 ' 21 5 5 ' 5 5 8$73 '+0+1 701+' 7 ( ' 8 &'+*1 . )+1 7)+'45 '*$7 (

5CsJ K s,N&DF ' '6 . ( 5 5 8 ' 1 5 5 ' . 1'+'&* '1( '% 1$7 '&' ')( 8 &'+ 1 . *+1 7)+'45 '*$7 (

OcfR]]` g6U VXCRg3iCY^dPPdVU6]Vh R\+WdX XCRP] R\+gRP RhU VPYWUYh R=ZWVr;UPY R]^da\eYY WdX XCR=X

XCRax]` g=d^aTZ=Ya 3WdX XCR=P RfYdWTZzTbUYX _YPd\=hTU TPd[cX ]=bTadkYUx=UPY R]^da\eY[Q !VaT]&

IPY R]^da\eY\ !VaT] TSaRfRVU!P\fTX;fPd^Yg ZRm ]` g WZTrUZ z`!fVa\[! VVCWP VfY+RaxU VP] RUYZ]` g haRWWTZ UPY R]^da\eYrN& O k RWU]TWUYNz X]T Z`!fVaYUxqWZTrWUZTofZrWUZV]]TWUYcUPY R]^da\eYYo !VaT] fY R^P RX XPV=RSY]Y[ OCTP T]^T6$z'z &

FF <- NKI§tG N§¦IKKINH suIvI uINKIvI§ -hRLIvIvC&bTh `R ZRVU bP RhUYh RzNZ` STP WUdh{ UdP`0fa\;bP VfWU RZaV]Y\ UPY R]^da\eYY Th `R ZRVU Wd VWUZV]]TV;ZaY\]YV+] R;UPdfTX hTWUx Ra^TPYUX TZ z YWbTax_d[! Yg6fR]]d[#WUPdhUdPd z R=UV-hTP]R=WTUx3hT]hP VU]Tr;P VRaY_ReYYN& P V-^TU zWPdhUdPT R UPY R]^da\eYY3X VU6RZYWVUx3TU3eVaY;VV+fRax]Vrj V^T+YWbTax_TZR]Y\ &OcUPY R]^da\eYY6X ]+Z`!fVaYUx UPY6TW]TZ]` g+ZY fR=TS VhU TZ ·4$QU TkhYNzZVPj Y]`!z6TUP_hYV Y' 8 & 0(&

OCT+X ]^Yg=Wd VWUZd[! Ra^TPYUXCRg=bTWUP TV]Y\3UPY R]^da\eYY3 !VaT] !Y;Ra^TPYUXCRg+R] RaY_R-PY{U

R]^da\eYY3k T=YWbax_d[!UW\3WaVfd[! -bVPT ReYYN·

$&' 8 & 4$!·bTadkV]YV=fa\+fR]]T^T=UP Vd^Tax]Yh RP-UVg3TSP d[!R Yg3V^T=daTZ &&' 8 & 6 · bTadkV]YV-a\3fR]]T^T-PUVd^Tax]Yh R=WbYh R=TSP d[!R Yg3V^T=P VSPN& |&' 8 & ( ' 8 & · bTadkV]YV fa\ fR]]T^T UP Vd^Tax]Yh R;WbYh R WTVf]YgqW6]YXyUP V{

d^Tax]YhTZ & } &6 ' 4$!·bTadkV]YV=fa\+fR]]T^T=P VSP R=hTTP fY] RU3TSP d[!R Yg3V^T=daTZ & "& 6 ' ( ' 8 & · bTadkV]YV=fa\+fR]]T^T=P VSP RbYW-h R+WTVf]Yg3WYXqUP-] Vd^Tax]YhTZ & '& 4 6bTadkV]YV=fa\+fR]]T^T=d· aR-bYWhW R+WX Vm ]` g6W P VSPN&

& 4 ( ' 8 & · bTadkV]YV-a\+fR]]T^T=daR=WbYWh R=WX Vm ]` g6W UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ & (&'/& '6 &( ( ·NbTadkV]YV-Z+RfR]]Tr6U TkhV baTWhTWUY;daRzP VSP R+YaY6UP Vd^Tax{

]Yh R&

O0U VgqYa Y]` g Ra^TPYUXCRg ]VhTU TP` V6Y;UYgqTbVP ReYroX T^dUq]V6YWbTax_TZRUxW\ & O0]VhTU TP` g Ra^TPYUXCRg TbVP ReYY-WCSP RXVY X -Z]Yh RUx ]VCk T U TX dSP RV X bP VfWU RZa\UxW\!hTWZV]]T h Rh3Tf] R=Y-UWTP T]6]VhTU TP T^ -PUVd^Tax]Yh R&n RWWX TUPYXq] RYSTaVV-k T=ZWP Vk R[! YVW\6Z+aYU VP RUdP V WUPdhUdP`-&

FFFI<- NKI§BG-® N§­JNKIs+t Ov1( (I& 4$21!1' . 5 a\-fh-T^Tf-_daR UPY R]{

^da\eYY6gP R]\UW\3V^T3hP fY] RU`Q] R+baTWhTWUY Y;Wb Th dh RU Var;] R+WTVfYV+da`0WbYWTh ]TX VP TZ d_aTZzW-TUh TP` X Y+VWUx+TS YV P VSP R6YW& |z} !|&p!T+WdUYNzWbYWTh6WTVfVr6TbP Vfa\VU6Z+]V\ TXqZY fV P VSP R=UY R]^da\eYYN&IP Vd^Tax]YhY6m PY;V-Ub TX ]V bP VfWU RZa\[!UW\3ZTTS VzkU T=\ZaVUW\+TS` k]T+Wd V{ WUZV]]` X V\UWUZYVXcfa\+fRax]Vrj V^T=bPYX V]]Y\3UPY R]^da\eYYN& P V-^TU z]VfTWUT RhTX \Za\VUW\ bVP VX V]]` r3PX VP+WUdhUdP`odRaRz_Rk RWUd[obPYZTf\ Yr+h+]V T]TX ]TX d=P RWgTf -bVPT RUYZ]Tr+b \UY bPY;bTWUP TV]YY UPY R]^da\eYYN& CP Vf]V+kWaT3WX Vm ]` g_aTZ3Z3UPYd R]^da\eYY; !VaT] =P RZ]T3j VWUx U T fTh `R ZRVUW\=bT+Y] fdheYY;Ya 6Y U VTP VX `Q R-aR]T+bRP` g3^P Ri!RgzbTU TX d+bPY;({SRrU TZX bP Vf{ WU RZaV]YY=hTTP fY] RUNz}{SRrU TZ` g eVa` g-{SRrUY+}TZ` g!dh RU Va\g-dXW XCRP]` rS-TVX b \UYNzR]YXCRVX ` r fR]]Tr3WUPdhUdP TrNzWTWU RZa\VU3} :SRrUN&

hTTP fY] RU RhTTP fY] RU R!

" #$%& ' (hTaYkVWUZT+WX Vm ]` g6daTZ= !VaT]

)#*+,- -.0/122" #$%&3 4 65778 9:7; WbYWTh6WX Vm ]` g6daTZ < (=

nIYW& |CUPdhUdP R+f]]` g+UPY R]^da\eYY>a`QW WTVf\X ?Y

nIYW&} &CZ\_Y6daTZ=WUPdhUdP`@>a`cWTWVf\X-W ?Y

FF" FI<- NKI§E+HG JN§IuIK =s+KO1( &(s KIDF+'$6I& W]Zr=UPYT R]^da\eYY+\Za\{ VUW\ WbYWTh TPYV]UYP TZR]]` gqSVPN&V p!PY U TXyh-TV6Pf VSP T ZgfYU Z WPdhUdPd UPY R]^da\eYY fZR{ m-`f-]Tz ] RbP RZaV]]` X YP-ZTUYTTaTmb ]` VCWU TP T]`-&!a\ h-T^T!Pf VSP R!g]\UW\ WaVfd[! YV!dh RU VaYPYW& "z' $}·

$ ] R=hTeVZTr6dVa+P VSP R²] R=WaVfd[! VV=bT=k RWZr3WUP VahV-P VSP T+Z+UP Vd^ax]YhVz] RgTf\ VX W\+WbP RZ =TU6fR]]T^T=P VSP R² | I]PRVSPA>T{SaY_]Ve? zWTVfY]\[! U V m `Va`oUPYVd R]^da\eYYNzkU T-R]]TVz]TY3f-] RbP RZaV]]TV

Z=bP TUYZTbTaTm ]d[cWU TP T]d ²

} ] R=UP Vd^Tax]YhNz] RgTf\ YrW\+WbP RZ -U6PT VSP R&

p!TWaVf]Yr;dh RU Vax3]V=]dm V] fa\+bTWUP TV]Y\;UPY R]^da\eYYNzY;bTU TX d3V^T3] RaYkYV=fTam ]T3TbP V{ fVa\UxW\=Z+RYWYX TWUY;TU3eVaY;fRax]Vrj V^T+bPYX V]]Y\+UPY R]^da\eYYN&

!VfTWU Rh RX Y fR]]TrqWUPdhUdP`­Za\VUW\;bP\ VfWU RZaV]YV;UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ;Z ]V\ TX#ZY fVz R;U V

STaxj Tr P RWgTf b \UYNzNWTU RZa\[! YrqbPYq({SRrU TZXcbP VfWU RZaV]YY hTTP fY] RU Yq}{SRrU TZ` g;dh R{

U Va\g ]V;X V]V '}BSRrUQ]V;dkYU` ZR\ P RWgTf b \UYq] R VfWU RZaV]YV fTbTa]YU Vax]` g fR]]` gqZ

UP Vd^Tax]Yh Rg&

FF, FI<- NKI§B-G® N§ KIs §KI J©3vquIvIGIvONK<1( (s I& 4$ 6 ( ' 8 &

Z!\]TX;ZY fVCRfR[!UW\ ZWVCZY f`qTS VhU TZ!UPY R]^da\eYYN·d_a`-PzVSP R!Y=UP Vd^Tax]YhYN&!a\!h-T^Tf P VSP R

hTTP fY] RU RhTTP fY] RU R!

< (=

)#*+ 65778 9:7;(hT]eVZTr6dVa+P VSP R

)+& 65778 9:7 WaVfd[! -T+kVb RWZr3WUP VahV-P VSP T+Z+UP Vd^ax]YhV WbP RZ%65778 9:7 U RhTV m V PT;SaY]Vez]T+] RbP RZaV]]TV Z+fPd^d[QWU TP T]d% +65778 9:78 ;9: 5 6dh RU Vax+]PR-Vd^Tax]Yh6WbPU RZ

< (=;9: 5B < (=

nIYW& 'CZ\_Y6P VSPqWaVZR CY6]V\ZTV RfR]YV UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ6WbP RZ CZ+WUPdhUdP V0>!ZTr]` V!SP?RV

gP R]\UW\ dh RU VaYq] ZR;hT]eVZ`f g_aRd Y fZR WTVf]Yg UP Vd^Tax]Yh R&I !a\ UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ gP R]\UW\ dh RU VaY3] R=UPY6TSP d[!R Yg3UP Vd^Tax]Yh3P VSP R6YW&z( $$&

!VfTWU RhTX0fR]]TroWUPdhUdP` \Za\VUW\ STaxj TrqP RWgTf b \UYNzIWTU RZa\[! YrobPYc({SRrU TZX bP VfWU RZaV]YY6hTTP fY] RU6Y6}{SRrU TZ` g=dh RU Va\g+bPYX VP]T3( SRrUN&

hTTP fY] RU RhTTP fY] RU R!

< (=

)#*+,- -.0/1223 4 65778 9:7; WbYWTh;hT]eVZ` g+daTZ% +,- -.A/1223 4 65778 9:78 ;9: 5 (WbYWTh6WTVf]Yg3UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ

< (=;9: 5B

,- -.A/1223 4 65778 9:7 WbYWTh6TSP d[!R Yg3P < (=

nIYW&& CUPdhUdP R+f]]` g+UPY R]^da\eYY>a`-PzVSP R=Y6UP Vd^Tax]YhY?

nIYW& (CZ\_Y6UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ6WaVZR CY6SVP WbPV RZ CWUPdhUdP` > a`-PzVSP R=Y6UP Vd^Tax]YhY?

FFANF <- NKI§B-G® :vcN§KINKJ© uIvIGIvOE1( (I& 4$< )( ' 8 & a\+h3f-T^Tf UP Vd^Tax]Yh RCgP R]\UW\ UPY-hdRU Va\!] R d[!R YVCV^T!da` YPY=dh-U RU Va\!] RVm ]` V Vd^Tax]YhYPYW& %zC±$3%zC(zI$ "&N !dX VP ReY\;U TkVhqY WTVf]Yg UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ;bP TY_ZTfYUW\ Z;bTPfhV6TSgTfR6bT k RWTZTr=WUP VahVzbPY+U TX ] RbP TUYZ-U TkhY+W!]TX VP TX $ | P RWbTaR^RVUW\ P VSP T UZVUWUZd[! V WTWVf]VX dqUP V^Tax]YhdqW6U RhYXym V6]TX VP TX!& nIVSP R UZTr UY R]^da\eYYqZ \]TXQZY fV;]V6gP R]\UW\ & p!PY+]VTSgTfYX TWUY3m V!T]Y+S` k]T-PbVfWU RZa\[!UW\=h+dhR RU Vax-] RVd^Tax]Yh+Y3]TX VP+P VSP R]dUPY-Z ]V^T &p!PY+({SRrU TZX6bP VfWU RZaV]YY3hTTP fY] RU=Y=}{SRrU TZ` g!dh RU Va\g-PUVSdVUW\-PYXb VP]T }±6ySRrUN&R]] R\=WUPdhUdP R=UY R]^da\eYY6] RSTaVV k T+bPYX V]\VUW\3] R=bP RhUYhV Z+WYad6WZTVr6hTX b RhU]TWUY6Y TU]TWYU Vax]Tr3dfTS]TWUY3Z+P V&

hTTP fY] RU RhTTP fY] RU R!

< (=;9: 5B

)#*+,- -.0/1223 4 65778 9:7; WbYWTh;TSP d[!R Yg+daTZ% +,- -.A/1223 4 65778 9:78 ;9: 5 (WbYWTh6WX Vm ]` g6UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ

< (=

nIYW& %CUPdhUdP R+f]]` g+UPY R]^da\eYY> a`cY6UP Vd^Tax]YhY?

nIYW&N±$ CZ\_Y6UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ=WUPdhUdP`@>a`cY6UP Vd^Tax]YhY?

nIYW&N$p!P TZVh R=WdX X `cbP TUYZTaVm-R Yg+d^aTZ

kYWaT YWgTf]` g U TkVhN&p!TU TX d!Z TSYg!Wadk R\g!TS VVRUP RkYZRVX TV ZP VX \!] RCbTWUP TVYVCUP Vd^Tax]YhTZ WTWU RZa\VU6 +;&

!U TS` ]VWhTaxhT dbP TWUYUx-a^TPYUX!zXR Tm ]T ZS VCYSRZYUxW\ TU-UZTP T^ !Wadk R\ zbP VfZRPYU Vax]T Z]VW\ Z UPY R]^da\eY[ ]VWhTaxhT U RhYg fTbTa]YU Vax]` g!daTZ zkU T bWP TV]] R\!] RC]Yg!UPY R]^da\eY\CRZV{ fTX T ] TVU+ZWV YWgTf]` V U TkhY+UPY R]^da\eYYN&Rh R\ WUPdhUdP RS`-Tk]T ]`RZVUW\1 % 1( &( '&RP-bRhUYhV=fa\=WdbVP WUdhUdP`QTS` k]T=Z` SYP R[!U6WaVfd[! -RPYZ R]U`#PYW&N$·

R ZVPj Y]`QP RZ]TWU TP T]]V^T=UP Vd^Tax]Yh RzbThP` ZR[! V^T=ZWV X ]Tm VWUZT+YWgTf]` g3U TkVhN²

S ZVPj Y]`QhZRfP RU RzbThP` ZR[! V^T=ZWV X ]Tm VWUZT+YWgTf]` g3U TkVhN²

nIYW&N$O RPY R]U`cWdbVP WUdhUdP

Z ; IU TkVhNzP RZ]TX VP]T-P RWbP VfaV]]` g+bT-hPdmT ]TWUYNzbThP` ZR[! Vr+ZWV X ]Tm VWUZT-WgTf]`Y g

U TkVhN²

^ 6 U TkVhNzP RZ]TX VP]T+P RWbP VfaV]]` g;bT3hZRfP RUd zbThP` ZR[! d6ZWV-X ]Tm VWUZT+YWgTf]` g U TkVhN²

f CYWgTf]` V U TkhYNzbTb Rf[! ]`R-bdhad[QTSaTkhd+XZ ]Tm VWUZR=YWgTf]` g3U TkVhN& O­( CbPYZTf\UW\;PdaxUV R`0hWbVPYX V]U Rax]T^T;WP RZ]V]Y\ PaYk]`R g ZRPY R]U TZ6WdbVP WUdhUdPN&

p!PY+U TX bTh `R ZRVUW\ zkU T bPY+YWbTax_TZR]YY+WdbVP WUdhUdP`o] RaYk`P RgWb-P RVfaV]Y\g+YWTf]` g fR]]` g6ZT_X Tm ]T6h RdZVaYkV]YV+WhTP TWUY P RSTU`#Ra^TPYUX TZ zU Rh Y VV+W]Ym V]YVzN]T6]V+STaVV=kXQ] R $± 6&

°![!STV!fTSRZaV]YV ]TZTr+U TkhY3ZPY-UR]^da\eY[oU VTP VYkVWhY6X VU3] RPdj YUx-VaTWU]TWUx+dWaTZY\e!VaT]VzbTU TX d+bTWaV=fTSRZaV]Y\=U TkhY3TS` k]T=WP d6mR PV-TY_ZTfYUW\+aThb Rax] R\-PbTZVPh R=UPY R]^da\{ eYY6] R=dWaTZV- !VaT]& U R=bP TZVPh R3fTam ] R=TgZUYUx=ZWV-]TZx+bTWUPZ TV]]` V=UP Vd^Tax]YhY6Y;WTVf]YV W!]YX YN&TaYkVWUZT=U RhYg+bVP VWUP TV]Yr Z=gdfj VXqWadk RV X VU3bPYZVWUY6h3bTa]TX d=bVP VWUP TV]Y[yZWVr UPY R]^da\eYYNzbTU TX d=UPfTVX hTWUx=bVP VWUP TV]Yr;WTU RZa\VU3 +;&l f] RhT=WP Vf]VV kYWaT=U RhYg=bVP V{ WUP TV]Yr;] Rax]`-P Vg6fR]]` g3WTU RZa\VU3U Taxh =ThaT-PUVg (&

RhYXqTSP RTX!z] RYSTaxj Yr6ZhaRf+Z=UPdTVX hTWUx+YU VP RUYZ]T^T+Ra^TPYUXCRRVU3bP-f TeVfdP R=bTYWh R TkVP Vf]T^T UP Vd^Tax]Yh R& !X V]]T!bU TX d!ZWVCYU VP RUYZ]` VCRa^TPYUX ` bTWUP TV]Y\ UPY R]^da\eYY- !VaT] TUaYk R[!UW\+fPd^+TU6fPd^R-aRZ]`^ XqTSP RTXqU Taxh -PbTeVfdP Tr6bTYWh R=TkVP Vf]T^T+UP Vd^Tax]Yh R&

" F!93KIJN Qv NvIH uIJ=KIvo% '1( '5E ( ( + '5N ' (F5TYWh6b TkVP Vf]T^T

UP Vd^Tax]Yh R!P dUW\=WaVfd[! YXqTSP RTX!&~CVP VUW\=a[!STr+UP Vd^Tax]YhNzdm V bPY] RfaVm-R Yr3UPY R]{ ^da\eYY ] RbPYX VPNzZ` SYP RVUW\3Wadk Rr]TzY;bTWaVfTZRU Vax]` X Y6bVP VgTfRX Y;bT+WZ\_R]]` XoUP Vd^Tax]Y{ h RXqY VUW\+YWhTX ` r6UP Vd^Tax]YhN&

p!PY6U TX Z3gdfj VX Wadk RV-PYgTfYUW\3bVPb VWh RUx6ZWV UP Vd^Tax]YhY;UPY R]^da\eYYNzbTU TX d3UPfT{ VX hTWUx+U RhT^T-TYWhb R=WTU RZa\VU6 +;&l f] RhT+Z=WP Vf]VXcfa\+P RZ]TX VP]T^T-P RWbP VfaV]Y\3Z=hRfP RU V ]dm ]TqWZVPj YUxqU Tah q + ; 3TbVP ReYrobVP VgTfRc"&I RhYX0TSP RTX!z UPdfTVX hTWUxqbP TWU Vrj V^T

YU VP RUYZ]T^T=Ra^TPYUXCR WTU RZa\VU6Z=gdfj VX Wadk RV- + zR=Z+WP Vf]VXB + $"z($&

OCT-T^Yg=bPX] RhUYkVWhY3ZRm ]` g+Wadk R\g-WgTf]`Y V!U TkhY+]V!\Za\[!UW\-UWRYWUYkVWhY6]V_RZYWYX ` X YNz

bPY6U TX {\+U Tkh RgTfYUW\+ZSaY-] R _Y ${rN&p!TU TX d3Z=h RkVWUV-]kax]T^TR -PUVd^Tax]Yh R+fa\=bTYWh R X Tm ]T-PSRUx=UP Vd^Tax]YhNz] Rr fV]]` r6P -a\=bPf Vf`!fd Vr;U TkhYN&IVX WRX ` X Y]T^fR-fRVUW\+fTWUYkxd ] RVhTU-] TP` g+ZY fRg3YWTf]` g3fR]]` g3UPdfTVX hTWUY6bTWUP TV]Y\3UPY R]^da\eYY3Z+WP Vf]VXc +;&

nIYW&N|O$ RPY R]U`oaTh RaY_ReYY6UP Vd^Tax]Yh R-UZ+YVP RUYZ]` g3Ra^TPYUXCRg

R RhUYhV!TS` k]T-WbTaxY_d[!UW\+WaVfd[! WbTWTS` bTYWh RP-UVd^Tax]Yh R bT=fR]]Tr+U TkhV!Z]d{ UPY6]V^T=Y6bT+]VhTU TP TX d=YWgTf]TX d+UP V^Tax]Yhd PYW&I|$&

$&p!P TZfYUW\=bPXCR\=kVP V-VhTU] TPd[cU Tkhd3Z]UPY3YWgTf]T^T=UP Vd^Tax]Yh R=Y3eVaVZd[QU Tkhd &wNR{ U VX bTYWh+TWd VWUZa\VUW\+ZfTax U Tr3bP\X Tr=h3eVaY;$"&p!PY+U TX ]VTSgTfYX TTPP-h VhU]T=TSP RSU` ZRUx WYUdReYYNzhT^fR-] R=bdUY6X T^dU3ZWP VUYUxW\+da`cY6hTaa]VRP]` VSP R&V

&I !ZY^RUxW\;bT Tf]TX d ^dj-zI]mR;h-TX#jfR^V6bP-R TZf\ bPX d[­VPk V eV]UP U Vhd V^T UP Vd^Tax{ ]Yh R!Y+eVaVZd[oU Tkhd zY+RU VX bVP VgTf\=h+WTVf]VX d=UP V^Tax]Yhd zWTTUZVUWUZd[! d=WU TP T]VzhTU TPd[ bVP VWh RVU;bTWUP TV]] R\+bPXCR\6$(&

|& !ZY^RUxW\+bT+Tf]TX d6j^d-]zR=hm-TXoYfR -TUh TP` g3] RfT+bVP VgTfYUx6kVP V=U RhTV-P VSP T3U V^T UP Vd^Tax]Yh RzkU T+eVaVZR\3U Tkh R=Y;ZVPj Y] R3U V^T3UP Vd^Tax]Yh RzbP TUYZTaVm-R-\+Z`R SYP RVX TX d3bV{ P VWh RVX TX d3SPd VzaVm-U3bT+PR]`R V TP T]`oTU3bP\X TrNzTbP Vfa\VX Tr;fR]]` XqSP TXcV(& U3WbTWTST TS` k]T fRVUqSTaVV6faY]]` rqbdUx fT eVaYNzI]T TqRa^TPYUX YkVWhYqbP T V6YqbTU TX d WUP V&C !a\;bP R{ ZYax]Tr+P RSTU` fR]]T^T=Ra^TPYUXCR!bTYWh Rd-WVWUZV]]` X \ZaVUW\-U T -PYZ=UR]^da\eYY+Z` bTa]\VUW\ dWaTZYV !VaT]& IWaY6dWaTZYV- !VaT] !] RPdj V]T zU T=Y]^fR-TZX Tm ]T+ReYhaYZR]YV-a^TPYUXCR&R

p!TWaV-U T^T=h6UPR VSdVX ` r;UP Vd^Tax]Yh6]rV]NzRf Z+]VXoWUP T\UW\3]TZ` V_a`-d-PzVSP R=Y;UP Vd^Tax]YhYNz R-RU VX bP TY_ZTfYUW\+aTh Rax]TV!bP VWUP TV]YV+UPY R]^da\eYYN&

" FF46 IsKI NvIH uIJ =KIvB+t N c6v;NK J 3 ( ( + '53 ' (F5F F1( ' .

]VCZ` bTa]\VUW\ ]Yh RYg-VPb VWUP TV]YrN&OCX T ^ !bPY+h-Tr=ZWUf RZhVC]TZT^T _daR=PYW&}$RNWP d=mR V dfRa\[!UW\ ZWV UP Vd^Tax]YhYNzd-TUh TP` g]dUPx-Z TbYWR]]` g+ThPdm ]TWU Vr+bT RfVU=]TZ` r+dVa3PYW&}IS$& p!PY-U TX ZWV dfRaV]]` VCUP Vd^Tax]YhY=]V\Z]T!TSP d[!URVhTU-] TP` rTaY^T]N&p!TWaVC-b U T^ !] R XV dfa]{ ]` g Vd^Tax]YhTZ!WUP TYUW\ RbTa]\[! \!UPY-R R]^da\eY\!bdU VX;WTVfY]V]Y\-TZT^T] _daR WCUYX bTaY^T]TXPYW&N}IZ$ &

nIYW&N}$&OCWU RZh R=U TkY6Z=YU VP RUYZ]TXoRa^TPYUX V>CfRa\r6Y3WUP T?

R]]` rqRa^TPYUXQWUP TYUqWP dqZWV6]TSgTfYXR ` V3UP Vd^Tax]YhYqZ TUakYV3TU TS` k]T^T;YU VP RUYZ{ ]T^T3Ra^TPYUXCRz^fV=bPY ZWU RZhV=Tf]T^T3daR3ZT_X Tm ]`QX ]T^ThP RU]` VVP-bVWUP TV]Y\ Tf]T^T+Y U T^T3m V UP Vd^Tax]Yh R&Il RhT fVWxq] R;bVPZ` rqbaR]qZ` gTfYUqbP TeVfdP R;Z`!fVaV]Y\ hT]UdP R;dfaV]]T^T;baY{ ^T] Rz TU;i i!VhUYZ]TWUYqP RSTU`#hTU TP T^ +RZYWYU TS -\6WhTPR TWUx Ra^TPYUXCR&O#eVaTX!zRZYWYX; TWUY TU YWbTax_dVX Tr WUPdhUdP` fR]]` gqUTUoRa^TPYUX#X VU UP RUYUxqZP VX V]YoX V]xj VzCkVX­a^TPYUX#WR bVP VWUP TV]Y\X YNz Y6]TUN&

IPdfTVX hTWUx6fR]]T^T3Ra^TPYUXCR=bTa]TWUx[yWTZb RfVU6W=TeV]h RX Y fa\3bP TWU T^ 3YU VP RUYZ]T^T3Ra{ ^TPYUXCR&

""FF=/= J KIvvIuCtvIKN uIvIsJH:¦IJGIvQ NK J© uIvIGNJ' (F5 721HI& O . &1 '+ 53%' 1&+ZWVCP R]V!bTWUP TV]]` V!UP Vd^Tax]YhY=R]TW\UW\-ZVhTU-] TPd[qWUPdhUdPd zW bTX T x[ hTU TP Tr X Tm ]T+fWU RU Tk]T=S` WUP T+] RgfYUx=UP Vd^Tax]YhY6Z+RfR]]Tr3U TkhV baTWhTWUYN&

""FFI46 NvIH uIJ=KIv NvIK# +vIuCtuIvIsJHQ NK J© uIvIGNJO' (F5 (HN& *1 . &1 '+ 5E( ' 8 &'+ fa\+ZWVg6bTWUP TV]]` g;UP Vd^Tax]YhTZ+Z` kYWa\VUW\3X Y]XCRax]` r TS VX a[! Yr3bP\X Td^Tax]Yh+WT=WU TP T] RX YNzb RP RaaVax]` X Y3TW\XqhTP fY] RUNzY6R]TWYUW\+ZfVP {VZT6$|& p!PYqdfRaV]YYqWU RP` g Vd^Tax]YhTZ;]VTSgTfYX T;Yg dfRa\Ux;Y fVP{VZRzIR;bPYqbTWUP TV]YY ]TZ` g0 _R]TWYUx &

!a\;Z` bTa]V]Y\ bTYWh R;UP Vd^Tax]Yh RzIZ hTU TP` r bTb RfVU U Vhd -\R ZWU RZa\VXCR\;Z UPY R]^da\eY[ U Tkh Rz ]VTSgTfYX T6Z` ba]YUx;WU R] fRP U]` r U TkVk]` rRbP_ TW3h fVP {VZd Y bTakYUx6WbYWThqUP Vd^Tax{ ]YhTZ z kxYoTS VX a[! YV;bP\X Td^Tax]YhYq] RgTf\UW\qZqfR]]TroU TkhV&CwNRU VXy] RfTqZ` SP RUx _Y;]Yg U T UP Vd^Tax]YhNzZ]dUPx=hTU TP T^ -Tb RfVU3U Tkh R&

l!UX VUYX!zkU T WPdhUdP RfVP {VZR!]V bTZTa\VU=] RrY=TS VhUNzSaYm-rjR Yr=h+RfR]]Tr=U TkhV& !X V]]T bTU TX d3fR]]` r Ra^TPYUXqUPY R]^da\eYY6WWbTax-Y _TZR]YVX fVP{VZR+WaVfdVU;bPYX V]\Ux+U Tah +WdbVP{-W WUPdhUdP TrNzkU TS`oYWha[!kYUx+bT Rf]YV TkP Vf]Tr6U TkhY6Z]V UPY R]^da\eYYN&