- •Ocular Blood Flow
- •Contents
- •1: Anatomy of the Ocular Vasculatures
- •Core Messages
- •1.1 Limbus and Conjunctiva
- •1.1.1 Cornea
- •1.1.2 Vasculature Distribution in the Anterior Segment
- •1.1.3 The Conjunctiva
- •1.1.3.1 The Conjunctival Arterial Supply
- •1.1.3.2 The Conjunctival Veins
- •1.2 Uveal Tract
- •1.2.1 The Iris
- •1.2.1.1 The Major Arterial Circle of the Iris
- •1.2.2 Ciliary Body and Processes
- •1.2.3 Choroid and Suprachoroid
- •1.2.3.1 Development of the Choroidal Vasculature
- •1.2.3.2 Arteries
- •1.2.3.3 Choroidal Veins (Vortex Veins)
- •1.2.3.4 Choriocapillaris
- •1.3 Optic Nerve Vasculature
- •1.4 Retina
- •1.4.1 Development of the Retinal Vasculature
- •1.4.2 Adult Retinal Vasculature
- •1.4.3 Nonprimate Adult Retinal Vasculatures
- •1.5 Conclusions
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •2.1 Introduction
- •2.3 Stochastic Error in the Entrapment of Microspheres
- •2.4 Methodological Errors and Practical Advice
- •2.4.1 Size of the Microspheres
- •2.4.2 Physical Characteristics of Microspheres
- •2.4.4 Dissection
- •2.4.5 Detection of RM and NAM
- •2.4.6 Detection of CM and FM
- •2.5 Biological Variation
- •2.5.1 Blood Pressure
- •2.5.3 Arterial Blood Gases
- •2.5.4 Other Possible Causes for Biological Variability
- •2.6 Summary for the Clinician
- •References
- •3: Laser Doppler Flowmetry in Animals
- •Core Messages
- •3.1 Introduction
- •3.2 History
- •3.3 Theory
- •3.4 Validation
- •3.5 Calibration
- •3.6 Zero Offset
- •3.7 Effects of Oxygen
- •3.9 Measurement Depth and Sampling Volume
- •3.10 Caveats
- •References
- •4: Oxygen Measurements in Animals
- •Core Messages
- •4.1 Introduction
- •4.2.1 Oxygen Electrodes
- •4.2.2 Hypoxyprobe
- •4.2.3 Magnetic Resonance Imaging
- •4.2.4 Phosphorescence Decay
- •4.2.5 Oximetry
- •4.3.1 Vitreal Oxygen
- •4.3.2 Intraretinal Oxygen
- •4.4 Oxygen in Avascular Retinas
- •4.5 Analysis of Retinal Oxygen Utilization
- •4.5.1 Fick Principle Analyses
- •4.5.4 Other Diffusion Models
- •4.6 Physiological Variations in Retinal Oxygen
- •4.6.1 Light
- •4.6.2 Hypoxia
- •4.6.3 Hyperoxia
- •4.6.4 Hypercapnia
- •4.7 Pathophysiology and Retinal Oxygen
- •4.7.1 Vascular Occlusion
- •4.7.2 Diabetes
- •4.7.3 Retinal Detachment
- •4.7.4 Retinal Degenerative Diseases
- •4.7.5 Retinopathy of Prematurity
- •4.8 Retinal Molecular Changes Related to Oxygen
- •4.9 Oxygen in the Optic Nerve Head
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •5.1 Measuring Technique
- •5.2 Normal Values
- •5.3 Retinal Pathologies
- •5.3.1 Diabetes Mellitus
- •5.3.2 Central Retinal Vein Occlusion
- •5.4 Summary
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •6.1 Introduction
- •6.1.1 Anatomy
- •6.3 Vessel Diameter Measurements Based on Photographic and Digitally Stored Images
- •6.3.1 Basics for Measurements on Stored Images
- •6.3.1.1 Measuring Principle
- •6.3.1.4 Problems and Measuring Errors
- •6.3.1.5 Physiological Variability of Vessel Diameter
- •6.3.2 Methods
- •6.3.2.2 Microdensitometry Based on Photographic Negatives
- •6.3.2.3 Measurements Based on Digital Images
- •6.4 Diameter Assessment for Blood Flow
- •6.4.1 Assessment of Flow by Use of Doppler Technique (CLBF)
- •6.5 Retinal Vessel Analysis
- •6.5.1 Basics of Retinal Vessel Analysis
- •6.5.2 Static Vessel Analysis
- •6.5.3 Results and Limits of Static Vessel Analysis
- •6.5.4 Results and Limits of Dynamic Vessel Analysis
- •6.5.4.1 Stimulation with Flicker Light
- •6.5.4.2 Other Provocation Tests
- •6.5.5 Systems Available for Dynamic Vessel Analysis
- •6.6 Further Perspectives
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •7.1 Introduction
- •7.2 Retinal Laser Doppler Velocimetry
- •7.2.1 The Doppler Effect
- •7.2.2 Electric Field Scattered by Singly Scattering Particles Moving in a Capillary Tube
- •7.2.5 Experimental Test of the Bidirectional LDV Technique
- •7.2.7 The DSPS for RBCs Moving in a Retinal Vessel
- •7.2.7.1 Multiple Scattering of Blood
- •7.2.7.2 DSPS from RBCs Flowing in a Glass Capillary Tube
- •7.2.7.3 DSPS from Human Retinal Vessels
- •7.2.7.4 Exploring the Scattering Process
- •7.2.9 Instrumentation
- •7.2.10 Blood Flow in Retinal Vessels
- •7.2.12 Limitations, Safety, and Future Directions of the LDV Technique
- •7.2.13 Physiologic and Clinical Applications (Brief Overview)
- •7.3.1 The DSPS for RBCs Moving in the Microvascular Bed of a Tissue
- •7.3.2 Hemodynamic Parameters Derived from the DSPS
- •7.3.3 Detection Scheme for Optic Nerve and Subfoveal Choroidal Blood Flow
- •7.3.4 Critical Questions Regarding the Application of LDF to Ocular Blood Flow
- •7.3.4.1 LDF Sample Volume
- •7.3.4.2 Linearity of LDF
- •7.3.4.3 Scattering Scheme
- •7.3.5 Reproducibility of LDF
- •7.3.6 Applications of LDF
- •7.4 Summary for the Clinician
- •References
- •8: Color Doppler Imaging
- •Core Messages
- •8.1 Principles
- •8.2 Instrumentation
- •8.3 Procedure
- •8.4 Outcome Variables
- •8.5 Reproducibility
- •8.6 Physiological and Pharmacological Stimuli
- •8.7 Results in Patients with Disease
- •8.8 Advantages and Limitations
- •References
- •9: Other Approaches
- •Core Messages
- •9.1 Blue Field Entoptic Technique
- •9.1.1 Laser Speckle Technique
- •9.1.2 Pulsatile Ocular Blood Flow
- •9.1.2.1 Laser Interferometry
- •References
- •10: Systemic Determinants
- •Core Messages
- •10.1 Introduction
- •10.1.1 Ocular and Systemic Blood Flow
- •10.2 Local Skin Cooling Effect
- •10.2.1 Choroidal Blood Flow
- •10.2.2 Retinal Blood Flow
- •10.3 Aerobic Exercise
- •10.3.1 Choroidal Blood Flow
- •10.3.2 Macular Blood Flow
- •10.3.3 Retinal Blood Flow
- •10.4 Neural Activation
- •10.4.1 Valsalva Maneuver
- •10.4.2 Nicotine
- •10.5 Blood Pressure Versus Ocular Perfusion Pressure
- •10.5.1 Increased Ocular Perfusion Pressure
- •10.5.1.1 Choroidal Blood Flow
- •10.5.2 Decreased Ocular Perfusion Pressure
- •10.5.2.1 Choroidal Blood Flow
- •10.5.2.2 Optic Nerve Head Blood Flow
- •10.5.3 Neural Retinal Function
- •10.6 Blood Gases
- •10.6.1 Hyperoxia and Blood Flow
- •10.6.3 Hypoxia and Pulsatile Choroidal Blood Flow
- •10.6.4 Hyperoxia, Hypercapnia, and Retinal Function
- •10.6.5 Hypoxia, Hyperoxia, and Retinal Function
- •10.7 Regional Choroidal Perfusion
- •10.7.1 Cones Versus Rods: Structure and Function
- •10.7.2 Choroidal Angioarchitecture
- •10.7.3 Dark Adaptation
- •10.7.4 Protracted Blue Flicker
- •10.8 Aging
- •10.8.1 Structure
- •10.8.2 Blood Flow
- •10.8.3 Retinal Function
- •References
- •11: Local Determinants
- •Core Messages
- •11.1 Introduction
- •11.2 Ocular Perfusion Pressure, IOP, and the Ocular Starling Resistor Effect
- •11.3 Types of Local Control
- •11.3.1 Myogenic Local Control
- •11.3.2 Metabolic Local Control
- •11.3.3 Flow-Mediated Vasodilation
- •11.3.4 Flow Control by Intercellular Conduction
- •11.4 Ocular Local Control
- •11.4.1 Optic Nerve Head (ONH)
- •11.4.2 Choroid
- •11.4.3 Retina
- •11.4.4 Ciliary Body
- •11.4.5 Iris
- •11.5 Caveats
- •11.6 Summary for the Clinician
- •References
- •12: Neural Control of Ocular Blood Flow
- •Core Messages
- •12.1 Overview of Ocular Blood Supplies and Their Neural Control
- •12.2 Neural Control of Optic Nerve and Retinal Blood Flow
- •12.3 Neural Control of Iridial and Ciliary Body Blood Flow
- •12.4 Neural Control of Blood Flow in Orbital Glands
- •12.5 Neural Control of Choroidal Blood Flow
- •12.5.1 Importance of the Choroid
- •12.5.2 Choroidal Innervation: Overview of Anatomy
- •12.5.3 Facial Nucleus Parasympathetic Input
- •12.5.3.4 Choroidal Autoregulation and the PPG Input to Choroid – Mammals
- •12.5.3.8 Choroidal Autoregulation and the PPG Input to Choroid – Birds
- •12.5.4 Oculomotor Nucleus Parasympathetic Input
- •12.5.4.1 Ciliary Ganglion Circuitry – Mammals
- •12.5.4.2 Function of the EW-Ciliary Ganglion Circuit – Mammals
- •12.5.4.3 Ciliary Ganglion Circuitry – Birds
- •12.5.4.4 Function of vSCN-EWM-Ciliary Ganglion Circuit – Birds
- •12.5.5 Sympathetic Superior Cervical Ganglion Input
- •12.5.6 Trigeminal Sensory Input
- •12.5.7 Intrinsic Choroidal Neurons
- •12.5.8 Disturbed Neural Control of Choroidal Blood Flow in Aging and Retinal Disease
- •12.5.8.1 Effect of Aging on Retina and Choroid
- •12.5.8.2 Effect of Disease on Retina and Choroid
- •References
- •13: Endothelial and Adrenergic Control
- •Core Messages
- •13.1 Nitric Oxide
- •13.2 Endothelins
- •13.3 Arachidonic Acid Metabolites
- •13.4 Adrenergic Control
- •13.5 Alpha Receptors
- •13.6 Topical Administration
- •13.6.1 Clonidine
- •13.6.2 Brimonidine
- •13.6.3 Beta Receptors
- •13.6.4 Timolol
- •13.6.5 Human Studies
- •13.6.6 Betaxolol
- •13.6.7 Human Studies
- •13.6.8 Levobunolol
- •13.6.9 Carteolol
- •13.6.10 Serotonin
- •13.7 Carbonic Anhydrase Inhibitors
- •13.8 Acetazolamide
- •13.9 Dorzolamide
- •13.10 Retrobulbar Blood Flow
- •13.11 Retinal Blood Flow
- •13.12 Choroidal and Optic Nerve Head Blood Flow
- •13.13 Brinzolamide
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •14.1 Introduction
- •14.2 Retinal Ischemia Basic Mechanisms
- •14.3 Oxidative Stress
- •14.6 Animal Studies Relating Ischemia, Glaucoma, and Neuroprotection
- •14.6.1 Retinal Ischemia
- •14.6.6 Role of Mitochondria (Fig. 14.6)
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •15.1 Introduction
- •15.2 Retinal Blood Flow in Diabetes
- •15.3 Retinal Hypoperfusion
- •15.3.1 Mechanisms of Hypoperfusion
- •15.3.1.1 Glycaemic Control
- •15.3.1.2 Protein Kinase C
- •15.3.1.3 Ion Channel Dysfunction
- •15.4 Retinal Hyperperfusion
- •15.4.1 Mechanisms of Hyperperfusion: A Link to Hypoperfusion, Tissue Hypoxia and Retinal Leukostasis?
- •15.4.2 Retinal Autoregulation in Diabetes
- •15.5.1 Basement Membrane Thickening
- •15.5.3 Microaneurysms
- •15.5.4 Capillary Acellularity
- •15.6 Retinal Blood Flow and Vision Loss in Diabetic Retinopathy
- •15.6.1 Diabetic Macular Oedema
- •15.6.2 Proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy
- •15.7 Conclusions
- •15.8 Summary for the Clinician
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •16.1 Introduction
- •16.2 Choroidal Blood Flow
- •16.3 Systemic Vascular Factors and AMD
- •16.5 Choroidal Hemodynamic Changes in AMD
- •16.5.1 Choroidal Histopathological Vascular Changes in AMD
- •16.5.1.1 Choriocapillaris and Bruch’s Membrane in Aging and AMD
- •16.5.2 Choroidal Microcirculation in AMD
- •16.5.2.2 Choroidal Watershed Zones and Neovascularization
- •16.5.2.3 Laser Doppler Flowmetry Evaluation
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •17.1 Introduction
- •17.2 Potential Mechanisms of Ischaemic Damage in Glaucoma
- •17.2.2 Autoregulatory Disturbances
- •17.2.3 Mechanical Compression or Collapse of Vessels
- •17.2.4 Atherosclerosis
- •17.2.5 Vascular Endothelial Factors
- •17.2.6 Barriers to Nutrient Delivery
- •17.2.7 Circulating Vasoconstrictors
- •17.3 Evidence Base Supporting the Importance of Ischaemia in Glaucoma
- •17.3.1 Association and Causality
- •17.3.1.1 Reduction in Optic Nerve Head Blood Flow
- •17.3.1.2 Blood Pressure, Intraocular Pressure and Perfusion Pressure
- •17.3.1.3 Nocturnal Hypotension
- •17.3.1.4 Vasospasm
- •17.3.1.5 Endothelin and Other Circulating Peptides
- •17.3.2 Effects of Treatment
- •17.3.2.1 Calcium Channel Blockers
- •17.3.2.2 Topical Adrenergic Antagonists
- •17.3.2.4 Prostaglandin Analogues
- •17.4 Experimental Models of Ischaemia Relating to Glaucoma
- •17.4.1 Acute Ischaemia
- •17.4.2 Chronic Ischaemia
- •17.5 Summary
- •17.5.1 Diversity of Evidence
- •17.5.2 Evidence Base Compared to Intraocular Pressure
- •17.5.3 Requirements to Strengthen Evidence Base
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •18.1 Retinal Diseases
- •18.2 Uveitis
- •18.3 Optic Nerve Disorders
- •18.4 Systemic Diseases
- •References
- •Core Messages
- •19.1 Atherosclerosis
- •19.1.1 Pathogenesis of Atherosclerosis
- •19.1.2 Internal Carotid Artery Disease (ICA)
- •19.1.3 Effects on the Ocular Circulation
- •19.1.3.1 Retinal Artery Occlusion
- •Clinical Characteristics
- •Diagnosis
- •Mortality/Morbidity
- •19.1.3.2 Retinal Vein Occlusion (RVO)
- •Clinical Characteristics
- •Pathogenesis
- •Diagnosis
- •19.1.3.3 Ischemic Optic Neuropathy
- •Clinical Characteristics
- •Mortality/Morbidity
- •19.1.3.4 Asymptomatic Retinal Emboli
- •Background
- •Pathophysiology
- •19.2 Vasculitis
- •19.2.1 Takayasu’s Arteritis (Aortic Arch Syndrome)
- •19.2.1.1 Pathophysiology
- •19.2.1.2 Clinical Characteristics
- •19.2.1.3 Epidemiology
- •19.2.2 Behcet’s Disease
- •19.2.2.1 Clinical Characteristics
- •19.2.2.2 Pathogenesis
- •19.2.2.3 Diagnosis
- •19.2.2.4 Epidemiology
- •19.2.3 Thromboangiitis Obliterans
- •19.2.3.1 Diagnosis and Clinical Characteristics
- •19.2.3.2 Treatment
- •19.2.4 Temporal Arteritis
- •19.2.4.1 Epidemiology
- •19.2.4.2 Pathogenesis
- •19.2.4.3 Ocular Manifestations
- •19.2.5 Wegener’s Granulomatosis
- •19.2.5.1 Pathogenesis
- •19.2.5.2 Ocular Manifestation
- •19.2.5.3 Diagnosis
- •19.2.6 Kawasaki Disease
- •19.2.6.1 Clinical Characteristics
- •19.2.6.2 Diagnosis
- •19.3 Vascular Malformations
- •19.3.1.1 Diagnosis
- •19.3.1.2 Pathophysiology
- •19.4 Systemic Hypertension and Treatment
- •19.4.1 Etiology
- •19.4.1.1 Primary Hypertension
- •19.4.1.2 Secondary Hypertension
- •19.4.2 Pathophysiology
- •19.4.3 Pathology and Complications
- •19.4.4 Symptoms and Signs
- •19.4.5 Diagnosis of Hypertension
- •19.4.5.1 History
- •19.4.5.2 Physical Examination
- •19.4.5.3 Testing
- •19.4.6 Prognosis
- •19.4.7 General Treatment
- •19.4.7.2 Drugs
- •19.5 Hypertensive Retinopathy
- •19.5.2 Pathophysiology
- •19.5.3 Blood Pressure
- •19.5.3.1 The Risk of Stroke
- •19.5.3.2 The Risk of Coronary Heart Disease
- •19.5.4 Treatment
- •19.5.4.1 ACE Inhibitors and the Eye
- •References
- •Index
Ocular Blood Flow in Diabetes: |
15 |
Contribution to the Microvascular |
Lesions of Diabetic Retinopathy
Tim M. Curtis and Tom A. Gardiner
Core Messages
¥Diabetic retinopathy is a leading cause of vision loss in the working population of developed countries.
¥Changes in retinal haemodynamics have been proposed to play a key role in the initiation and progression of diabetic retinopathy.
¥Substantial evidence suggests that there is an early reduction in retinal perfusion prior to the onset of diabetic retinopathy followed by a gradual increase in blood ßow as the disease progresses.
¥Twomajormechanismshavebeenproposed to explain how hyperglycaemia decreases retinal blood ßow in early diabetes, namely, protein kinase C (PKC) activation and ion channel dysfunction in the contractile mural cells of retinal microvessels.
¥The functional reduction in retinal blood ßow observed during early diabetic retin-
T.M. Curtis, Ph.D. ( )
Centre for Vision and Vascular Sciences School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences,
The QueenÕs University of Belfast, Institute of Clinical Science - Block A, Royal Victoria Hospital,
Grosvenor Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland BT12 6BA, UK e-mail: t.curtis@qub.ac.uk
T.A. Gardiner, Ph.D.
Centre for Biomedical Sciences Education, School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences, The QueenÕs University of Belfast, Whitla Medical Building, 97 Lisburn Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland BT9 7B, UK e-mail: t.gardiner@qub.ac.uk
opathy may be additive or synergistic to pro-inßammatory changes, leukostasis and vaso-occlusion and thus may be intimately linked to the progressive ischaemic hypoxia and increased blood ßow associated with later stages of the disease.
¥A unifying haemodynamic framework is presented that explains how changes in retinal perfusion may contribute to the microvascular lesions and vision loss in diabetic retinopathy.
¥Large-scale prospective studies are currently needed to determine whether retinal blood ßow measurements may be useful as a surrogate end point for clinical drug trials in diabetic retinopathy.
15.1Introduction
Diabetes mellitus is a condition of chronic hyperglycaemia and is currently classiÞed into two main forms. Type 1 diabetes is due primarily to autoimmune-mediated destruction of pancreatic- b-cell islets, resulting in absolute insulin deÞciency. People with type 1 diabetes are usually younger than 30 years old at diagnosis and are dependent on continuing supplemental insulin. Type 2 diabetes is a metabolic disorder normally of middle-life characterised by insulin resistance and/or abnormal insulin secretion, either of which may predominate. People with type 2 diabetes
L. Schmetterer, J.W. Kiel (eds.), Ocular Blood Flow, |
365 |
DOI 10.1007/978-3-540-69469-4_15, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012 |
|
366 |
T.M. Curtis and T.A. Gardiner |
|
|
are not usually dependent on exogenous insulin but may require it for control of blood glucose levels if this is not achieved with diet alone or with oral hypoglycaemic agents.
Diabetes is associated with a number of complications which share an aetiology that is, at least in part, vascular. As a consequence of microvascular pathology, diabetes is a leading cause of blindness, end-stage renal disease and a variety of debilitating neuropathies. Macrovascular complications manifest themselves as accelerated atherosclerosis resulting in an increased risk of myocardial infarction, stroke and limb amputation. Diabetes is increasing at a startling rate and consequently imposes an everincreasing burden on health-care authorities in both developed and developing countries. The global Þgure of people with diabetes is set to rise from the present estimate of 150Ð220 million in 2010 and 300 million in 2025 [13, 110]. Most cases will be of type 2 diabetes, which is strongly associated with sedentary lifestyle and obesity [199].
Retinopathy is one of the most common microvascular complications of diabetes [10]. After 20 years of diabetes, nearly all patients with type 1 diabetes will have at least some retinopathy. Approximately 80% of type 2 diabetic patients who require insulin and 50% type 2 diabetic patients who do not require insulin will have retinopathy after 20 years [111]. Although the pathogenic basis of diabetic retinopathy is not wholly understood at the cellular and molecular level, large-prospective clinical studies have demonstrated a strong relationship between time-averaged mean levels of glycaemia and the rate of development of retinopathy in both type 1 and type 2 diabetes [1, 3].
Diabetic retinopathy is traditionally regarded as disease of the intra-retinal microvessels and is generally classiÞed into two main clinical forms: non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy and proliferative diabetic retinopathy. Mild non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy (background retinopathy) and severe proliferative retinopathy represent different ends of a spectrum of the same disease process. Non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy is characterised by a complex array of vasodegenerative lesions within the retinal microvascular bed, including thickening of capillary basement membranes [77], pericyte and vascular smooth muscle cell dropout [81, 123], microaneurysms [34] and
capillary occlusion and acellularity [67]. Visual impairment normally occurs in the later stages of diabetic retinopathy with the development of macula oedema as a direct consequence of bloodretinal barrier breakdown. In the proliferative phase of the disease, there is an abnormal growth of new blood vessels (retinal neovascularisation) that give rise to sight-threatening complications such as vitreous haemorrhage and tractional retinal detachment [76]. Arguably, both macular oedema and retinal neovascularisation occur as a result of increasing inner retinal ischaemia and hypoxia-driven secretion of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). Sight-threatening diabetic retinopathy can be treated or contained to some extent by laser photocoagulation or vitreoretinal surgery, but this is often at the expense of functional retina and visual performance [79]. The use of VEGF-blocking agents has shown efÞcacy in both of these sight-threatening sequelae, but the underlying vascular insufÞciency may compromise retinal cell survival [148].
While there is no doubt that hyperglycaemia is the primary insult in the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy [1, 3], haemodynamic factors have also been implicated in the development of this condition. This chapter begins by providing an overview of the haemodyamic changes that occur in the retina during the development of diabetic retinopathy. Attention is also given to the pathophysiological mechanisms that have been proposed to underlie these alterations. The remainder of the chapter is then devoted to describing how retinal blood ßow changes in diabetes may contribute the sight-threatening lesions of diabetic retinopathy. From these discussions, it is clear that treatments designed to normalise retinal blood ßow during early and long-term diabetes may provide a novel means of delaying the onset and progression of this devastating condition.
15.2Retinal Blood Flow in Diabetes
The earliest suggestion that retinal blood ßow may be disrupted in diabetes came from studies performed over 60 years ago showing that dilation of retinal veins is common in persons
