
- •Acknowledgments
- •About the Authors
- •About the Technical Editors
- •Contents at a Glance
- •Contents
- •Foreword
- •Introduction
- •Overview of the CISSP Exam
- •The Elements of This Study Guide
- •Study Guide Exam Objectives
- •Objective Map
- •Reader Support for This Book
- •Security 101
- •Confidentiality
- •Integrity
- •Availability
- •Protection Mechanisms
- •Security Boundaries
- •Third-Party Governance
- •Documentation Review
- •Manage the Security Function
- •Alignment of Security Function to Business Strategy, Goals, Mission, and Objectives
- •Organizational Processes
- •Organizational Roles and Responsibilities
- •Security Control Frameworks
- •Due Diligence and Due Care
- •Security Policy, Standards, Procedures, and Guidelines
- •Security Policies
- •Security Standards, Baselines, and Guidelines
- •Security Procedures
- •Threat Modeling
- •Identifying Threats
- •Determining and Diagramming Potential Attacks
- •Performing Reduction Analysis
- •Prioritization and Response
- •Supply Chain Risk Management
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Job Descriptions and Responsibilities
- •Candidate Screening and Hiring
- •Onboarding: Employment Agreements and Policies
- •Employee Oversight
- •Compliance Policy Requirements
- •Privacy Policy Requirements
- •Understand and Apply Risk Management Concepts
- •Risk Terminology and Concepts
- •Asset Valuation
- •Identify Threats and Vulnerabilities
- •Risk Assessment/Analysis
- •Risk Responses
- •Cost vs. Benefit of Security Controls
- •Countermeasure Selection and Implementation
- •Applicable Types of Controls
- •Security Control Assessment
- •Monitoring and Measurement
- •Risk Reporting and Documentation
- •Continuous Improvement
- •Risk Frameworks
- •Social Engineering
- •Social Engineering Principles
- •Eliciting Information
- •Prepending
- •Phishing
- •Spear Phishing
- •Whaling
- •Smishing
- •Vishing
- •Spam
- •Shoulder Surfing
- •Invoice Scams
- •Hoax
- •Impersonation and Masquerading
- •Tailgating and Piggybacking
- •Dumpster Diving
- •Identity Fraud
- •Typo Squatting
- •Influence Campaigns
- •Awareness
- •Training
- •Education
- •Improvements
- •Effectiveness Evaluation
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Planning for Business Continuity
- •Project Scope and Planning
- •Organizational Review
- •BCP Team Selection
- •Resource Requirements
- •Legal and Regulatory Requirements
- •Business Impact Analysis
- •Identifying Priorities
- •Risk Identification
- •Likelihood Assessment
- •Impact Analysis
- •Resource Prioritization
- •Continuity Planning
- •Strategy Development
- •Provisions and Processes
- •Plan Approval and Implementation
- •Plan Approval
- •Plan Implementation
- •Training and Education
- •BCP Documentation
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Categories of Laws
- •Criminal Law
- •Civil Law
- •Administrative Law
- •Laws
- •Computer Crime
- •Intellectual Property (IP)
- •Licensing
- •Import/Export
- •Privacy
- •State Privacy Laws
- •Compliance
- •Contracting and Procurement
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Defining Sensitive Data
- •Defining Data Classifications
- •Defining Asset Classifications
- •Understanding Data States
- •Determining Compliance Requirements
- •Determining Data Security Controls
- •Data Maintenance
- •Data Loss Prevention
- •Marking Sensitive Data and Assets
- •Handling Sensitive Information and Assets
- •Data Collection Limitation
- •Data Location
- •Storing Sensitive Data
- •Data Destruction
- •Ensuring Appropriate Data and Asset Retention
- •Data Protection Methods
- •Digital Rights Management
- •Cloud Access Security Broker
- •Pseudonymization
- •Tokenization
- •Anonymization
- •Understanding Data Roles
- •Data Owners
- •Asset Owners
- •Business/Mission Owners
- •Data Processors and Data Controllers
- •Data Custodians
- •Administrators
- •Users and Subjects
- •Using Security Baselines
- •Comparing Tailoring and Scoping
- •Standards Selection
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Cryptographic Foundations
- •Goals of Cryptography
- •Cryptography Concepts
- •Cryptographic Mathematics
- •Ciphers
- •Modern Cryptography
- •Cryptographic Keys
- •Symmetric Key Algorithms
- •Asymmetric Key Algorithms
- •Hashing Algorithms
- •Symmetric Cryptography
- •Cryptographic Modes of Operation
- •Data Encryption Standard
- •Triple DES
- •International Data Encryption Algorithm
- •Blowfish
- •Skipjack
- •Rivest Ciphers
- •Advanced Encryption Standard
- •CAST
- •Comparison of Symmetric Encryption Algorithms
- •Symmetric Key Management
- •Cryptographic Lifecycle
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Asymmetric Cryptography
- •Public and Private Keys
- •ElGamal
- •Elliptic Curve
- •Diffie–Hellman Key Exchange
- •Quantum Cryptography
- •Hash Functions
- •RIPEMD
- •Comparison of Hash Algorithm Value Lengths
- •Digital Signatures
- •HMAC
- •Digital Signature Standard
- •Public Key Infrastructure
- •Certificates
- •Certificate Authorities
- •Certificate Lifecycle
- •Certificate Formats
- •Asymmetric Key Management
- •Hybrid Cryptography
- •Applied Cryptography
- •Portable Devices
- •Web Applications
- •Steganography and Watermarking
- •Networking
- •Emerging Applications
- •Cryptographic Attacks
- •Salting Saves Passwords
- •Ultra vs. Enigma
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Secure Design Principles
- •Objects and Subjects
- •Closed and Open Systems
- •Secure Defaults
- •Fail Securely
- •Keep It Simple
- •Zero Trust
- •Privacy by Design
- •Trust but Verify
- •Techniques for Ensuring CIA
- •Confinement
- •Bounds
- •Isolation
- •Access Controls
- •Trust and Assurance
- •Trusted Computing Base
- •State Machine Model
- •Information Flow Model
- •Noninterference Model
- •Take-Grant Model
- •Access Control Matrix
- •Bell–LaPadula Model
- •Biba Model
- •Clark–Wilson Model
- •Brewer and Nash Model
- •Goguen–Meseguer Model
- •Sutherland Model
- •Graham–Denning Model
- •Harrison–Ruzzo–Ullman Model
- •Select Controls Based on Systems Security Requirements
- •Common Criteria
- •Authorization to Operate
- •Understand Security Capabilities of Information Systems
- •Memory Protection
- •Virtualization
- •Trusted Platform Module
- •Interfaces
- •Fault Tolerance
- •Encryption/Decryption
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Shared Responsibility
- •Hardware
- •Firmware
- •Client-Based Systems
- •Mobile Code
- •Local Caches
- •Server-Based Systems
- •Large-Scale Parallel Data Systems
- •Grid Computing
- •Peer to Peer
- •Industrial Control Systems
- •Distributed Systems
- •Internet of Things
- •Edge and Fog Computing
- •Static Systems
- •Network-Enabled Devices
- •Cyber-Physical Systems
- •Elements Related to Embedded and Static Systems
- •Security Concerns of Embedded and Static Systems
- •Specialized Devices
- •Microservices
- •Infrastructure as Code
- •Virtualized Systems
- •Virtual Software
- •Virtualized Networking
- •Software-Defined Everything
- •Virtualization Security Management
- •Containerization
- •Serverless Architecture
- •Mobile Devices
- •Mobile Device Security Features
- •Mobile Device Deployment Policies
- •Process Isolation
- •Hardware Segmentation
- •System Security Policy
- •Covert Channels
- •Attacks Based on Design or Coding Flaws
- •Rootkits
- •Incremental Attacks
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Apply Security Principles to Site and Facility Design
- •Secure Facility Plan
- •Site Selection
- •Facility Design
- •Equipment Failure
- •Wiring Closets
- •Server Rooms/Data Centers
- •Intrusion Detection Systems
- •Cameras
- •Access Abuses
- •Media Storage Facilities
- •Evidence Storage
- •Restricted and Work Area Security
- •Utility Considerations
- •Fire Prevention, Detection, and Suppression
- •Perimeter Security Controls
- •Internal Security Controls
- •Key Performance Indicators of Physical Security
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •OSI Model
- •History of the OSI Model
- •OSI Functionality
- •Encapsulation/Deencapsulation
- •OSI Layers
- •TCP/IP Model
- •Common Application Layer Protocols
- •SNMPv3
- •Transport Layer Protocols
- •Domain Name System
- •DNS Poisoning
- •Domain Hijacking
- •Internet Protocol (IP) Networking
- •IP Classes
- •ICMP
- •IGMP
- •ARP Concerns
- •Secure Communication Protocols
- •Implications of Multilayer Protocols
- •Converged Protocols
- •Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP)
- •Software-Defined Networking
- •Microsegmentation
- •Wireless Networks
- •Securing the SSID
- •Wireless Channels
- •Conducting a Site Survey
- •Wireless Security
- •Wi-Fi Protected Setup (WPS)
- •Wireless MAC Filter
- •Wireless Antenna Management
- •Using Captive Portals
- •General Wi-Fi Security Procedure
- •Wireless Communications
- •Wireless Attacks
- •Other Communication Protocols
- •Cellular Networks
- •Content Distribution Networks (CDNs)
- •Secure Network Components
- •Secure Operation of Hardware
- •Common Network Equipment
- •Network Access Control
- •Firewalls
- •Endpoint Security
- •Transmission Media
- •Network Topologies
- •Ethernet
- •Sub-Technologies
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Protocol Security Mechanisms
- •Authentication Protocols
- •Port Security
- •Quality of Service (QoS)
- •Secure Voice Communications
- •Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP)
- •Vishing and Phreaking
- •PBX Fraud and Abuse
- •Remote Access Security Management
- •Remote Connection Security
- •Plan a Remote Access Security Policy
- •Multimedia Collaboration
- •Remote Meeting
- •Instant Messaging and Chat
- •Load Balancing
- •Virtual IPs and Load Persistence
- •Active-Active vs. Active-Passive
- •Manage Email Security
- •Email Security Goals
- •Understand Email Security Issues
- •Email Security Solutions
- •Virtual Private Network
- •Tunneling
- •How VPNs Work
- •Always-On
- •Common VPN Protocols
- •Switching and Virtual LANs
- •Switch Eavesdropping
- •Private IP Addresses
- •Stateful NAT
- •Automatic Private IP Addressing
- •Third-Party Connectivity
- •Circuit Switching
- •Packet Switching
- •Virtual Circuits
- •Fiber-Optic Links
- •Security Control Characteristics
- •Transparency
- •Transmission Management Mechanisms
- •Prevent or Mitigate Network Attacks
- •Eavesdropping
- •Modification Attacks
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Controlling Access to Assets
- •Controlling Physical and Logical Access
- •The CIA Triad and Access Controls
- •Managing Identification and Authentication
- •Comparing Subjects and Objects
- •Registration, Proofing, and Establishment of Identity
- •Authorization and Accountability
- •Authentication Factors Overview
- •Something You Know
- •Something You Have
- •Something You Are
- •Multifactor Authentication (MFA)
- •Two-Factor Authentication with Authenticator Apps
- •Passwordless Authentication
- •Device Authentication
- •Service Authentication
- •Mutual Authentication
- •Implementing Identity Management
- •Single Sign-On
- •SSO and Federated Identities
- •Credential Management Systems
- •Credential Manager Apps
- •Scripted Access
- •Session Management
- •Provisioning and Onboarding
- •Deprovisioning and Offboarding
- •Defining New Roles
- •Account Maintenance
- •Account Access Review
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Comparing Access Control Models
- •Comparing Permissions, Rights, and Privileges
- •Understanding Authorization Mechanisms
- •Defining Requirements with a Security Policy
- •Introducing Access Control Models
- •Discretionary Access Control
- •Nondiscretionary Access Control
- •Implementing Authentication Systems
- •Implementing SSO on the Internet
- •Implementing SSO on Internal Networks
- •Understanding Access Control Attacks
- •Crackers, Hackers, and Attackers
- •Risk Elements
- •Common Access Control Attacks
- •Core Protection Methods
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Security Testing
- •Security Assessments
- •Security Audits
- •Performing Vulnerability Assessments
- •Describing Vulnerabilities
- •Vulnerability Scans
- •Penetration Testing
- •Compliance Checks
- •Code Review and Testing
- •Interface Testing
- •Misuse Case Testing
- •Test Coverage Analysis
- •Website Monitoring
- •Implementing Security Management Processes
- •Log Reviews
- •Account Management
- •Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity
- •Training and Awareness
- •Key Performance and Risk Indicators
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Need to Know and Least Privilege
- •Separation of Duties (SoD) and Responsibilities
- •Two-Person Control
- •Job Rotation
- •Mandatory Vacations
- •Privileged Account Management
- •Service Level Agreements (SLAs)
- •Addressing Personnel Safety and Security
- •Duress
- •Travel
- •Emergency Management
- •Security Training and Awareness
- •Provision Resources Securely
- •Information and Asset Ownership
- •Asset Management
- •Apply Resource Protection
- •Media Management
- •Media Protection Techniques
- •Managed Services in the Cloud
- •Shared Responsibility with Cloud Service Models
- •Scalability and Elasticity
- •Provisioning
- •Baselining
- •Using Images for Baselining
- •Automation
- •Managing Change
- •Change Management
- •Versioning
- •Configuration Documentation
- •Managing Patches and Reducing Vulnerabilities
- •Systems to Manage
- •Patch Management
- •Vulnerability Management
- •Vulnerability Scans
- •Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Conducting Incident Management
- •Defining an Incident
- •Incident Management Steps
- •Basic Preventive Measures
- •Understanding Attacks
- •Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems
- •Specific Preventive Measures
- •Logging and Monitoring
- •The Role of Monitoring
- •Log Management
- •Egress Monitoring
- •Automating Incident Response
- •Understanding SOAR
- •Threat Intelligence
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •The Nature of Disaster
- •Natural Disasters
- •Human-Made Disasters
- •Protecting Hard Drives
- •Protecting Servers
- •Protecting Power Sources
- •Trusted Recovery
- •Quality of Service
- •Recovery Strategy
- •Business Unit and Functional Priorities
- •Crisis Management
- •Emergency Communications
- •Workgroup Recovery
- •Alternate Processing Sites
- •Database Recovery
- •Recovery Plan Development
- •Emergency Response
- •Personnel and Communications
- •Assessment
- •Backups and Off-site Storage
- •Software Escrow Arrangements
- •Utilities
- •Logistics and Supplies
- •Recovery vs. Restoration
- •Testing and Maintenance
- •Structured Walk-Through
- •Simulation Test
- •Parallel Test
- •Lessons Learned
- •Maintenance
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Investigations
- •Investigation Types
- •Evidence
- •Investigation Process
- •Major Categories of Computer Crime
- •Military and Intelligence Attacks
- •Business Attacks
- •Financial Attacks
- •Terrorist Attacks
- •Grudge Attacks
- •Thrill Attacks
- •Hacktivists
- •Ethics
- •Organizational Code of Ethics
- •(ISC)2 Code of Ethics
- •Ethics and the Internet
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Software Development
- •Systems Development Lifecycle
- •Lifecycle Models
- •Gantt Charts and PERT
- •Change and Configuration Management
- •The DevOps Approach
- •Application Programming Interfaces
- •Software Testing
- •Code Repositories
- •Service-Level Agreements
- •Third-Party Software Acquisition
- •Establishing Databases and Data Warehousing
- •Database Management System Architecture
- •Database Transactions
- •Security for Multilevel Databases
- •Open Database Connectivity
- •NoSQL
- •Expert Systems
- •Machine Learning
- •Neural Networks
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Malware
- •Sources of Malicious Code
- •Viruses
- •Logic Bombs
- •Trojan Horses
- •Worms
- •Spyware and Adware
- •Ransomware
- •Malicious Scripts
- •Zero-Day Attacks
- •Malware Prevention
- •Platforms Vulnerable to Malware
- •Antimalware Software
- •Integrity Monitoring
- •Advanced Threat Protection
- •Application Attacks
- •Buffer Overflows
- •Time of Check to Time of Use
- •Backdoors
- •Privilege Escalation and Rootkits
- •Injection Vulnerabilities
- •SQL Injection Attacks
- •Code Injection Attacks
- •Command Injection Attacks
- •Exploiting Authorization Vulnerabilities
- •Insecure Direct Object References
- •Directory Traversal
- •File Inclusion
- •Request Forgery
- •Session Hijacking
- •Application Security Controls
- •Input Validation
- •Web Application Firewalls
- •Database Security
- •Code Security
- •Secure Coding Practices
- •Source Code Comments
- •Error Handling
- •Hard-Coded Credentials
- •Memory Management
- •Summary
- •Exam Essentials
- •Written Lab
- •Review Questions
- •Chapter 2: Personnel Security and Risk Management Concepts
- •Chapter 3: Business Continuity Planning
- •Chapter 4: Laws, Regulations, and Compliance
- •Chapter 5: Protecting Security of Assets
- •Chapter 10: Physical Security Requirements
- •Chapter 11: Secure Network Architecture and Components
- •Chapter 12: Secure Communications and Network Attacks
- •Chapter 17: Preventing and Responding to Incidents
- •Chapter 18: Disaster Recovery Planning
- •Chapter 19: Investigations and Ethics
- •Chapter 20: Software Development Security
- •Chapter 21: Malicious Code and Application Attacks
- •Chapter 3: Business Continuity Planning
- •Chapter 5: Protecting Security of Assets
- •Chapter 6: Cryptography and Symmetric Key Algorithms
- •Chapter 12: Secure Communications and Network Attacks
- •Chapter 15: Security Assessment and Testing
- •Chapter 17: Preventing and Responding to Incidents
- •Chapter 18: Disaster Recovery Planning
- •Chapter 19: Investigations and Ethics
- •Chapter 21: Malicious Code and Application Attacks
- •Index
Implementing Security Management Processes |
753 |
These two techniques are often used in conjunction with each other because they achieve different results. Passive monitoring is only able to detect issues after they occur for a real user because it is monitoring real user activity. Passive monitoring is particularly useful for troubleshooting issues identified by users because it allows the capture of traffic related to that issue. Synthetic monitoring may miss issues experienced by real users if they are not included in the testing scripts, but it is capable of detecting issues before they actually occur.
Implementing Security
Management Processes
In addition to performing assessments and testing, sound information security programs also include a variety of management processes designed to oversee the effective operation of the information security program. These processes are a critical feedback loop in the security assessment process because they provide management oversight and have a deterrent effect against the threat of insider attacks.
The security management reviews that fill this need include log reviews, account management, backup verification, and key performance and risk indicators. Each of these reviews should follow a standardized process that includes management approval at the completion of the review.
Log Reviews
In Chapter 16, you will learn the importance of storing log data and conducting both automated and manual log reviews. Security information and event management (SIEM) packages play an important role in these processes, automating much of the routine work of log review. These devices collect information using the syslog functionality present in many devices, operating systems, and applications. Some devices, including Windows systems, may require third-party clients to add syslog support. Administrators may choose to deploy logging policies through Windows Group Policy Objects (GPOs) and other mechanisms that can deploy and enforce standard policies throughout the organization.
Logging systems should also make use of the Network Time Protocol (NTP) to ensure that clocks are synchronized on systems sending log entries to the SIEM as well as the SIEM itself. This ensures that information from multiple sources has a consistent timeline.
Information security managers should also periodically conduct log reviews, particularly for sensitive functions, to ensure that privileged users are not abusing their privileges. For example, if an information security team has access to eDiscovery tools that allow searching through the contents of individual user files, security managers should routinely review the logs of actions taken by those administrative users to ensure that their file access relates to legitimate eDiscovery initiatives and does not violate user privacy.

754 Chapter 15 ■ Security Assessment and Testing
Network flow (NetFlow) logs are particularly useful when investigating security incidents. These logs provide records of the connections between systems and the amount of data transferred.
Account Management
Account management reviews ensure that users only retain authorized permissions and that unauthorized modifications do not occur. Account management reviews may be a function of information security management personnel or internal auditors.
One way to perform account management is to conduct a full review of all accounts. This is typically done only for highly privileged accounts because of the amount of time consumed. The exact process may vary from organization to organization, but here’s one example:
1.Managers ask system administrators to provide a list of users with privileged access and the privileged access rights. They may monitor the administrator as they retrieve this list to avoid tampering.
2.Managers ask the privilege approval authority to provide a list of authorized users and the privileges they should be assigned.
3.The managers then compare the two lists to ensure that only authorized users retain access to the system and that the access of each user does not exceed their authorization.
This process may include many other checks, such as verifying that terminated users do not retain access to the system, checking the paper trail for specific accounts, or other tasks.
Organizations that do not have time to conduct this thorough process may use sampling instead. In this approach, managers pull a random sample of accounts and perform a full verification of the process used to grant permissions for those accounts. If no significant flaws are found in the sample, they make the assumption that this is representative of the entire population.
Sampling only works if it is random! Don’t allow system administrators to generate the sample or use nonrandom criteria to select accounts for review, or you may miss entire categories of users where errors may exist.
Organizations may also automate portions of their account review process. Many identity and access management (IAM) vendors provide account review workflows that prompt administrators to conduct reviews, maintain documentation for user accounts, and provide an audit trail demonstrating the completion of reviews.
Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity
In Chapter 3, “Business Continuity Planning,” you learned how organizations design continuity controls to maintain operations in the face of potential disruptions. In Chapter 18,
Implementing Security Management Processes |
755 |
“Disaster Recovery Planning,” you will learn the importance of supplementing those continuity controls with disaster recovery programs that help organizations resume operations quickly after a disruption.
Consistent backup programs are an extremely important component of these efforts. Managers should periodically inspect the results of backups to verify that the process functions effectively and meets the organization’s data protection needs. This may involve reviewing logs, inspecting hash values, or requesting an actual restore of a system or file.
Regular testing of disaster recovery and business continuity controls provides organizations with the assurance that they are effectively protected against disruptions to business operations.
Training and Awareness
Training and awareness programs play a crucial role in preparing an organization’s workforce to support information security programs. These efforts educate employees about current threats and advise them on best practices for protecting information and systems under their care from attack.
These programs should begin with initial training designed to provide foundational knowledge to employees who are either joining the organization for the first time or moving into a new role with different security responsibilities. This initial training should be tailored to an individual’s role, providing them with the specific, actionable information that they need to carry out their security responsibilities.
Recurring training and awareness efforts should take place throughout the year, reminding employees of their responsibilities and updating them on changes to the organization’s operating environment and the threat landscape.
Many organizations use phishing simulations to evaluate the effectiveness of their security awareness programs. These simulations use fake phishing messages to determine whether users are susceptible to phishing attacks. Users who click the link or otherwise respond to the simulated attacks are redirected to training resources to help them better identify suspicious activity.
You’ll find complete coverage of security training and awareness programs in Chapter 2, “Personnel Security and Risk Management Concepts.”
Key Performance and Risk Indicators
Security managers should also monitor key performance and risk indicators on an ongoing basis. The exact metrics they monitor will vary from organization to organization but may include the following:
■■
■■
■■
■■
Number of open vulnerabilities Time to resolve vulnerabilities Vulnerability/defect recurrence Number of compromised accounts