учебный год 2023 / Жуков. Государство. Право. Власть
.pdf
f[LёjJ RjvAfx f qvёUQx Gjv"gjA k A"J"L"[" ‘ё D"‘j q"UqJgj‘‘"x Uj>у ]ёL‘"qJf Lё>gfvёqE №qfM"№ёJf+ g D"LRj fqJjLffд H" q ]Lk["x qJ"у L"‘Q fqM"]+ f> Lёqqk<]j‘fx '‘[ё R"<‘" q]jvёJE gQg"] GJ" efJу vjL у gqjуJёAf Rё‘ёуvfG‘"qJE g">[vёgfgKё+ Rё‘ёу]gf<j‘fjд p" j[" q"UqJgj‘‘"Rk №Lf>‘ё‘f™ №"‘ёGёvk efJvjL №L"f>gjv ‘ё ‘j[" qfvE‘"j g№jGёJvj‘fjд p" R‘j‘f™ '‘[ё efJvjL у "Lk]fj qfv Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"у [" "‘ AёA gq+Afx №"]vf‘‘Qx g"<]E ‘j gj]jJ ё gj]"Rд efJvjL "vfTjу Jg"L+jJ q"U"x ?j‘E ‘jRjTA"x ‘ёTff ‘" g J" <j gLjR+ +gv+jJq+ qfRg"у v"R jj vkGKj[" Uk]kwj["Ж "‘ у >jLAёv" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" ‘jRTjg j[" Lk№"Lд ЭvёqJE efJvjLё ‘j №"vfJfGjqAё+ ё Rё[fGjqAё+ "‘ ‘j k№Lёgу v+jJ ejLRё‘fjx ё vfKE fqJ"vA"gQgёjJ "Uwjj ‘ё№Lёgvj‘fj q"UQJfx "‘ у №L"L"A A"J"L"[" JLk]‘" "URё‘kJE g №"vfJfAjд Э vfG‘"R №vё‘j efJvjL ‘jGjqJ"v™Ufg f ёqjAqkёvj‘д ЭQJjq‘j‘‘ё+ qjAqkёvE‘"qJE efJу vjLё №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A <j‘wf‘j "U"LёGfgёjJq+ v™U"gE™ A ejLRё‘ff A"J"Lё+ f +gv+jJq+ j[" j]f‘qJgj‘‘"x f №"]vf‘‘"x qJLёqJE™д ! ‘ёу A"‘jT '‘[ ]jvёjJ gQg"] gQ>Qgё™wfx AёA Rf‘fRkR ‘j]"kRj‘fjН №"qA"vEAk efJvjL gQLё<ёjJ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j ‘jRTjg "‘ f jqJE qёRё ejLRё‘f+ qёR ‘jRjTAfx ‘ёL"]д
p"qvj "A"‘Gё‘f+ g"x‘Q '‘[ UQv gjqERё "№Lj]jvj‘j‘ f AёJjу ["LfGj‘ g "Tj‘Aj s[jLRё‘qA"x AёJёqJL"DQyд r‘ №"vё[ёv GJ" M"J+ ‘jRTQ у §J" qA"Ljj U"vE‘Qj GjR №LjqJk№‘fAf "‘f gqj ]" "]‘"[" ‘jqkJ "JgjJqJgj‘‘"qJE >ё q"]j+‘‘"jд p"qA"vEAk A"vvjAJfg‘"j Ujqу q">‘ёJjvE‘"j "UYj]f‘+jJ ‘jRTjg g j]f‘"j Tjv"j "‘f ]"v<‘Q №Lfу >‘ёJE >ё q"U"x fRj‘‘" A"vvjAJfg‘k™ gf‘k ё ‘j J"vEA" gf‘k "J]jvEу ‘QM g"j‘‘QM №LjqJk№‘fA"gд Й™Uё+ №"№QJAё A"["уJ" №L"qJfJE fvf №LjkRj‘EKfJE >v"]j+‘fj ]"v<‘ё №Lf>‘ёgёJEq+ AёA <ё<]ё Ljgё‘Kёд pqfMfGjqA"j >]"L"gEj ‘jRTjg R"<jJ UQJE ]"qJf[‘kJ" J"vEA" №kJjR fqALj‘‘j[" №"Aё+‘f+д H" '‘[ ‘ё §J"R ‘j "qJё‘ёgvfgёjJq+Н JёA AёA ‘ёTf"‘ёvуq"Tfёvf>R jqJE №L"+gvj‘fj "UwjjgL"№jxqA"x U"vj>‘f gf‘k >ё qvkGfgKjjq+ ]"v<‘Q Lё>]jvfJE gqj ‘ёL"]Q hgL"№Qд
Э qg+>f q s‘jRjTAfR qvkGёjRy '‘[ gQqAё>QgёjJ ‘jA"J"LQj RQqvf " ‘ёTff A"J"LQj "ULёwё™J ‘ё qjU+ g‘fRё‘fjд Hё№k[ё‘‘Qx ]jxqJgfjR qfv A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" "‘ gf]fJ g Aё<]"x ‘ёTff №"Jj‘TfёvE‘Qx fqJ"G‘fA "№ёq‘"qJfд HёTf+ №" '‘[k §J" R"‘qJL A"J"LQx g qg"jR №"gj]j‘ff LkA"g"]qJgkjJq+ ‘f>KfRf <fу g"J‘QRf f‘qJf‘AJёRf "Uvё]ёjJ g‘kKёjR"qJE™ №jwjL‘"[" Gjv"gjAё №"]">LfJjvE‘"qJE™ f >v"U‘"qJE™ ]fAёL+д ” ‘ёTff ‘j R"<jJ UQJE GjqJf "‘ё ‘j g q"qJ"+‘ff ]jL<ёJE qv"gёд HLёgqJgj‘‘"qJE jj ["qk]ёLу qJgj‘‘QM ]j+Jjvjx ‘j №LjgQKёjJ в>ё Lj]AfR fqAv™Gj‘fjRи kL"g‘+ <fg"J‘"№"]"U‘"x ‘LёgqJgj‘‘"qJf Rёqqд p"qA"vEAk U"vEKfj ‘ёTff №Lj]№"vё[ё™J U"vEKfj AёJёqJL"DQ J" '‘[ >ё RёvQj ‘ёTffд
’ёA №"vё[ёjJ '‘[ q"TfёvE‘Qj AёJёAvf>RQ ьь gд №"]"Lgёvf ]"gjу Lfj >ё№ё]‘QM "UwjqJg A q№"q"U‘"qJf Gjv"gjAё qJL"fJE №"vfJfGjqAfj "J‘"Kj‘f+ ‘ё LёTf"‘ёvfqJfGjqA"x "q‘"gj f >ёqJёgfvf fM "ULёJfJEq+ A qg"jRk Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"Rkд p"§J"Rk '‘[ qGfJёjJ ‘j"UM"]fRQR fqу №"vE>"gёJE q">]ё‘‘k™ fR ё‘ёvfJfGjqAk™ №qfM"v"[f™ в"‘ ‘ё>QgёjJ
ныт
jj s>ё№ё]‘"x x"["xy sёvMfRfjx ьь gjAёyи g AёGjqJgj f]j"v"[fGjу qA"x Uё>Q q"TfёvE‘"[" LjD"LRёJ"LqJgёд H" №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ GJ" №Lf gqjx "Lf[f‘ёvE‘"qJf kGj‘f+ KgjxTёLqA"[" №qfM"v"[ё "‘" gQ[v+]fJ qvfKA"R RfD"v"[f>fL"gё‘‘QRд
Эf]‘QR №Lj]qJёgfJjvjR №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ё +gv+jJq+ ‘jRjTA"у ёRjLfAё‘qAfx q"Tf"v"[ Dfv"q"D f №qfM"v"[ 'Adp жAWKK врЛаау рЛВаид r‘ L"]fvq+ g Ljvf[f">‘"x qjREj j[" "JjT >ё‘fRёvq+ J"L["gvjx gf‘"R ё ]j] f №Lё]j] №" "JT"gqA"x vf‘ff UQvf Lёggf‘ёRfд „‘ёGёvё g" zLё‘ADkLJqA"R ё >ёJjR g ejx]jvEUjL[qA"R k‘fgjLqfJjJj zL"RR f>kGёv Dfv"q"Df™ f q"Tf"v"[f™д p"qJj№j‘‘" "‘ №Lf"UwёjJq+ A kGj‘f™ zLjx]ё №L"M"]fJ kGjU‘Qx AkLq №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ё f ‘ёGf‘ёjJ >ё‘fRёJEq+ vjGjU‘"x №LёAJfA"xд Э рЛеауj [[д zL"RR у q"JLk]‘fA f>gjqJ‘"[" !‘qJfJkJё q"TfёvE‘QM fqqvj]"gё‘fx g" zLё‘ADkLJjу ‘ёуЮёx‘j вq рЛее №" рЛнЛ [д f‘qJfJkJ ‘ёM"]fvq+ q‘ёGёvё g pёLfу <j >ёJjR g HE™у%"LAjи []j >ё‘fRёvq+ q"TfёvE‘"x №qfM"v"[fjxд „ рЛее [д zL"RR у g „iШН LёU"JёjJ g !‘qJfJkJj №qfMfёJLff fRд ”д ”ёxJё №Lj№"]ёjJ g ’"vkRUfxqA"R f %jvEqA"R k‘fgjLqfJjJёMд Э рЛырурЛм. [[д <fv g ЮjAqfAj g">[vёgv+v !‘qJfJkJ №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ё №Lf HёTf"‘ёvE‘"R k‘fgjLqfJjJj g ЮjMfA"д Э рЛ.н [д zL"RR №jLjу qjvfvq+ g igjxTёLf™д
zL"RR у "]f‘ f> ALk№‘jxKfM ‘j"DLjx]fqJ"g в‘ёL+]k q ’д “"Lу ‘f eд „д „ёvfgё‘"R Шд ’ёL]f‘jL"Rид h[" kGj‘fj sLё]fAёvE‘"[" [kу Rё‘f>Rёy №Lj]qJёgv+™wjj q"U"x q"j]f‘j‘fj f]jx zLjx]ё f ЮёLAqё вg §J"R qAё>ёv"qE gvf+‘fj DLё‘ADkLJqA"x Dfv"q"DqA"x KA"vQи KfL"A" f>gjqJ‘" f №"№kv+L‘" ‘ё oё№ё]jд !R ‘ё№fqё‘" U"vEK"j A"у vfGjqJg" A‘f[ f qJёJjx qLj]f A"J"LQM gQ]jv+™Jq+ sЩj[qJg" "J qg"у U"]Qy sckKё Gjv"gjAёy s’"‘Tj№Tf+ Gjv"gjAё k ЮёLAqёy sШ‘ёJ"у Rf+ Gjv"gjGjqA"x ]jqJLkAJfg‘"qJfy s!RjJE fvf UQJEyд
r]‘ё f> [vёg‘QM >ё]ёG zL"RRё вAёA f ]Lk[fM ‘j"DLjx]fqJ"gи у №"Aё>ёJE qg+>E "UwjqJgj‘‘QM f‘qJfJkJ"g f "J‘"Kj‘fx q Ujqq">‘ёу JjvE‘QR Gjv"gjAё LёqqR"JLjJE >ёgfqfR"qJE q"TfёvE‘"x f f‘]fу gf]kёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ffд zL"RR qJLjRfJq+ №"Aё>ёJE "UwjqJg" f j[" №L"+gvj‘f+ GjLj> №Lf>Rk №qfM"v"[ff "J]jvE‘"[" Gjv"gjAёд
rJ№Lёg‘"x J"GA"x g A"‘Tj№JkёvE‘QM №"qJL"j‘f+M zL"RRё +gv+jJq+ j[" №"‘fRё‘fj №LfL"]Q Gjv"gjAё ё >‘ёGfJ f "UwjqJgёд Э "JvfGfj "J zLjx]ё A"J"LQx gf]jv g Gjv"gjAj fqAv™GfJjvE‘" >v"j ‘ёGёv" вsGjv"gjA у №"Jj‘TfёvE‘Qx №LjqJk№‘fA gLё[ AkvEJkLQyи zL"RR №Lf]jL<fgёjJq+ U"vjj q№"A"x‘"x №">fTffд r‘ №"vё[ёjJ GJ" №"qA"vEAk Gjv"gjA "]‘"gLjRj‘‘" +gv+jJq+ Jjv"R f ]kK"x ё‘[jv"R f >gjLjR j[" qkw‘"qJE q"qJ"fJ g A"‘DvfAJj ]"ULё f >vё UjLkwjR qg"f fqJ"Af g q"TfёvE‘QM kqv"gf+Mд rJ]jvE‘Qx f‘]fgf] f Gjv"gjGjqJg" g Tjv"R №"Jj‘TfёvE‘" q"]jL<ёJ g qjUj ]gj Lёg‘"gjvfAfj ‘" g>ёfR"fу qAv™Gё™wfj Jj‘]j‘Tff у sqf‘]L"R Lёq№ё]ёy gj]kwfx A [fUjvf f sqf‘]L"R L"qJёy "Ujq№jGfgё™wfx №L"[Ljqqfg‘"j Lё>gfJfj <f>‘fд rJ J"[" AёAfR №kJjR №"x]jJ Gjv"gjGjqJg" AёAk™ №"Jj‘Tf™ Ljёvf>kу jJ >ёgfqfJ j[" Uk]kwjjд rGjgf]‘" GJ" sqf‘]L"R L"qJёy f sqf‘]L"R
ные
Lёq№ё]ёy ‘ё№"Rf‘ё™J mL"q f ?ё‘ёJ"q zLjx]ё ‘" RjMё‘f>R "ULё>"gёу ‘f+ §JfM qfv f №jLq№jAJfgQ fM U"LEUQ k ]gkM RQqvfJjvjx Lё>vfG‘Qд „""JgjJqJgj‘‘" gqj Jg"LGjqA"j ‘ёqvj]fj zL"RRё kqv"g‘" R"<у ‘" qgjqJf A ]gkR "q‘"g‘QR q"qJёgv+™wfRН ри ё‘ёvf> sqf‘]L"Rё
Lёq№ё]ёy LёqqR"JLj‘fj f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"x f q"TfёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ff g q"gLjRj‘‘QM qJLё‘ёM oё№ё]ё в"q"Uj‘‘" g ejLRё‘ff f „iШи f
ти A"‘qJLkfL"gё‘fj q"UqJgj‘‘"x f]jёvE‘"x q"TfёvE‘"x R"]jvf ]"у Aё>Qgё™wjx LjёvE‘"qJE №jLq№jAJfgQ sqf‘]L"Rё L"qJёyд
Щ"LEUk sqf‘]L"Rё L"qJёy f sqf‘]L"Rё Lёq№ё]ёy zL"RR №QJёjJq+ LёqqR"JLjJE fqJ"LfGjqAf "Jg"]+ №Lf §J"R "q‘"g‘k™ L"vE №L"Tjqqk f‘]fgf]kёvf>ёTff Gjv"gjAёд ’ёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ "A"v" GjJQLjM JQq+G vjJ ‘ё>ё] k Gjv"gjAё ‘ёGёv" №L"Uk<]ёJEq+ vfG‘"qJ‘"j q">‘ё‘fj "‘ qJё‘"gfJq+ ‘ё №kJE qёR"qJ"+JjvE‘"qJf f ‘j>ёgfqfR"qJf "J L"]ё gQ]jvj‘f+ qjU+ f> A"q‘"x f f‘jLJ‘"x RёqqQ qg"fM q"№vjRj‘‘fA"gд cё‘‘Qx №L"Tjqq Lё>gfgё+qE "q"Uj‘‘" UQqJL" ‘ё oё№ё]j g §№"Mk Э">у L"<]j‘f+ f g H"g"j gLjR+ ]"qJf[ёjJ qg"j[" №fAё g ьь gд !J"["R f‘]fgf]kёvf>ёTff qJёv" №Lf"ULjJj‘fj Gjv"gjA"R qg"U"]Q A"J"Lk™ f‘]fgf] q s№jwjL‘"xy №qfM"v"[fjx g"q№Lf‘+v AёA ‘jgQ‘"qfR"j ULjR+ №ёLёvf>"gёgKjj j[" q">‘ё‘fj f g"v™ f №"qJёgfgKjj №jLj] ‘fR ёvEJjL‘ёJfgkН vfU" f>UёgfJEq+ "J qg"U"]Q №kJjR ‘"g"x >ёgfqfR"qJf f №"]Gf‘j‘f+ vfU" ‘LёgqJgj‘‘" ]"LёqJf ]" №"v‘"x Ljёvf>ёTff qg"у U"]Qд Ш №"qA"vEAk f‘]fgf]kёvf>ёTf+ ‘j"ULёJfRё J" №jLgQx №kJE gj]jJ A [fUjvf Lёq№ё]k Gjv"gjAё f "UwjqJgё вLjёvf>ёTf+ sqf‘]L"Rё Lёq№ё]ёyи J"[]ё AёA gJ"L"x у A LёqTgjJk Gjv"gjGjqAfM qfv в"qkwjqJу gvj‘fj sqf‘]L"Rё L"qJёyид
rULёJfRq+ A sqf‘]L"Rk Lёq№ё]ёyд zL"RR №"vё[ёjJ GJ" q"gLjу Rj‘‘Qj "UwjqJgё oё№ё]ё f u"qqf+ qJLё]ё™J №ёJ"v"[fjx U"vE‘Q Jj‘]j‘Tf+ Lёq№ё]ё №Lf"ULjvё k ‘fM AёJёqJL"DfGjqAfx MёLёAJjLд pёу J"v"[f+ qJёvё k‘fgjLqёvE‘"x "‘ё "U‘ёLk<fgёjJ qjU+ AёA g D"LRj ]jу R"ALёJff JёA f g gf]j J"JёvfJёLf>Rёд cfAJёJkLQ „Jёvf‘ё f efJvjLё zL"RR "Tj‘fgёjJ AёA ALёx‘jj №L"+gvj‘fj ]j[Lё]ёTffд „ №">fTfx №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ё zL"RR gQ]jv+jJ qvj]k™wfj §vjRj‘JQ RjMё‘f>Rё "Uу Lё>"gё‘f+ q"TfёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ffН ри ‘ёLTfqqf>RЖ ти f‘TjqJkёvE‘Qj gvjGj‘f+Ж еи qё]"Rё>"Mf>RЖ ни ]jqJLkAJfg‘"qJEЖ ыи A"‘D"LRf>Rд
рд »ЗAydъъdoKl Э AvёqqfGjqA"R №qfM"ё‘ёvf>j №"] ‘ёLTfqqf>R" №"‘fRёjJq+ JёA"j q"qJ"+‘fj №Lf A"J"L"R Gjv"gjA №"LQgёjJ gqj qg+у
>f q g‘jK‘jx LjёvE‘"qJE™ f >ёRj‘+jJ jj q"UqJgj‘‘"x vfG‘"qJE™ "‘ gjqE №jLj№"v‘j‘ qёRfR q"U"x f №LjgLёJfv qjU+ g RfLд p" zL"RRk ‘ёLTfqqf>R вAёA f‘]fgf]kёvE‘Qx JёA f q"TfёvE‘Qxи ‘jk‘fGJ"<fR "‘ "]‘"gLjRj‘‘" ‘j"UM"]fR f "№ёqj‘ ]v+ <f>‘f q j[" [f№jLJL"DfL"у gё‘‘QRf D"LRёRf qvj]kjJ U"L"JEq+д
HёLTfqqf>R №"vё[ёjJ zL"RR f[LёjJ U"vEKk™ L"vE g g">‘fA‘"у gj‘ff Ljvf[f">‘"x Avёqq"g"x f ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘"x gLё<]Q g Lё>g+>Qgёу
й HёLTfqq у №jLq"‘ё< ]Ljg‘j[LjGjqA"[" RfDё A"J"LQx gv™Ufvq+ g qg"j "JLё<j‘fj g g"]j f kRjL "J v™Ugf A qjUjд
нын
‘ff g"x‘ Rj<]k ["qk]ёLqJgёRfд HёLTfqqf>R k Lё>vfG‘QM q"TfёvEу ‘QM [Lk№№ №"+gv+jJq+ AёA A"R№j‘qёTf+ >ё J+["JQ §A"‘"RfGjqA"[" f №"vfJfGjqA"[" UQJё AёA <jvё‘fj g"q№"v‘fJE qg"™ g‘jK‘™™ Uj]у ‘"qJE f ‘jkqJL"j‘‘"qJE §R"Tf"‘ёvE‘" ‘ё№"v‘j‘‘QR GkgqJg"R v™Ugf A qjUjд ?ёA"x RjMё‘f>R gQLё<ёjJq+ g J"R GJ" "]‘ё f> q"TfёvE‘QM [Lk№№ ‘ё]jv+jJ qjU+ №Ljg"qM"]‘QRf AёGjqJgёRf >ё qGjJ kRёvj‘f+ ]"qJ"f‘qJg ]Lk[fM [Lk№№д ЭjLё g qg"j №Ljg"qM"]qJg" q"qJёgv+jJ №"]у vf‘‘"j q"]jL<ё‘fj ‘ёLTfqqf>Rё f "q‘"gk gLё<]Q AёJ"vfA"g f №L"у JjqJё‘J"g DLё‘Tk>"g f ‘jRTjg UjvQM f GjL‘QM ёLfxTjg f ‘jёLfxу Tjg A"RRk‘fqJ"g f Aё№fJёvfqJ"g f Jд №д HёLTfqqf>R JLjUkjJ qg"j[" k]"gvjJg"Lj‘f+ №Ljg"qM"]qJg" ]"v<‘" №"]JgjL<]ёJEq+ ]jxqJgfjR №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A ]Lk[fR s‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘QRy [Lk№№ёR в‘ё№LfRjL k‘fу GJ"<j‘fj jgLjjg g ?LjJEjR LjxMjид hqvf g‘kJLf qJLё‘Q JёA"x [Lk№№Q ‘j ‘ёM"]fJq+ J" "UYjAJ"R ё[Ljqqff qJё‘"g+Jq+ ]Lk[fj ["qk]ёLqJgёд zL"RR "JRjGёjJ GJ" g ьь gд ‘ёUv™]ёjJq+ qRjwj‘fj "J Ljvf[f">‘"[" ‘ёLTfqqf>Rё g qJ"L"‘k ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘"[" Lёq"g"[" f №ёLJfx‘"["д ?ёA J"JёvfJёL‘Qx Lj<fR g ejLRё‘ff у +LA"j №L"+gvj‘fj ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘"у [" f №ёLJfx‘"[" ‘ёLTfqqf>Rё ё g u"qqff у №ёLJfx‘"[" f Avёqq"g"["д HёTf"‘ёvE‘Qx ‘ёLTfqqf>R ‘ёL"]"g oё№ё]ё qJёv №" zL"RRk "]‘fR f> fqJ"G‘fA"g "UjfM RfL"gQM g"x‘д
„"TfёvE‘Qx ‘ёLTfqqf>R "U+>ёJjvE‘" №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ g"<]+ q A"у J"LQR [Lk№№ё qjU+ f]j‘JfDfTfLkjJ ‘ё A"J"L"[" №jLj‘"qfJ qg"x ‘ёLу Tfqqf>Rд Э ёAJj №"]Gf‘j‘f+ qfvE‘"Rk g"<]™ [Lk№№ё "wkwёjJ qg"j R"[kwjqJg"д p"vfJfA №"]gjL<j‘‘Qx ‘ёLTfqqf>Rk "Uvё]ё™wfx "[L"R‘"x gvёqJE™ ‘ёGf‘ёjJ №Lf№fqQgёJE qjUj qgjLMGjv"gjGjqAfj qg"xqJgёд mJ" gj]jJ j[" A №"v‘"x f>"v+Tff в№Lj<]j gqj[" №qfM"v"у [fGjqA"xи "J g‘jK‘j[" RfLё GJ" L"<]ёjJ g ‘jR qJLёM f №"]">LfJjvEу ‘"qJE ё >‘ёGfJ f qJLjRvj‘fj kALj№fJE qg"™ gvёqJEд cё‘‘Qx №"L"Gу ‘Qx ALk[ g fJ"[j >ёAё‘GfgёjJq+ Rё‘fёAёvE‘QR №qfM">"R f AL"gёgQRf Lj№Ljqqf+Rfд HёLTfqqf>R №"vfJfGjqA"[" vf]jLё LkA"g"]fJjv+ ["qkу ]ёLqJgё №L"+gv+jJq+ JёA<j g №"№QJAёM №Lj"ULё>"gёJE g‘jK‘fx RfL g q""JgjJqJgff q" qg"fRf №Lj]qJёgvj‘f+Rf " ‘jRд p"qA"vEAk Gjv"gjAу ‘ёLTfqq ёUq"v™J‘" ‘jALfJfGj‘ "ULёwj‘ J"vEA" ‘ё qjU+ LёqM"<]j‘fj j[" №Lj]qJёgvj‘fx " RfLj q DёAJfGjqA"x ]jxqJgfJjvE‘"qJE™ L"<]ёjJ g ‘jR "wkwj‘fj ]fqA"RD"LJё ‘ёqJk№ё™wj[" Uj>kRf+д PJ"UQ №"A"‘у GfJE q §JfR U"vj>‘j‘‘QR GkgqJg"R №"vfJfAу‘ёLTfqq ‘ёGf‘ёjJ №jLjу ]jvQgёJE ]jxqJgfJjvE‘"qJE №"] qg"f f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘Qj Dё‘Jё>ffд Э §J"R qvkGёj GjR qfvE‘jj k ‘ёLTfqqё №qfM"> JjR kUj]fJjvE‘jj "‘ gQ[v+]fJ g [vё>ёM "UwjqJgё JjR U"vEKj Kё‘q"g k ‘j[" ‘ё kq№jMд
тд шЮyDъChЗm Ю D \mDnDЮd zL"RR qGfJёjJ f‘TjqJkёvE‘Qj gvjGjу ‘f+ "]‘fRf f> Dk‘]ёRj‘JёvE‘QM g Gjv"gjAj ‘" g "JvfGfj "J zLjx]ё
gf]fJ g ‘fM ‘jqjAqkёvE‘k™ №LfL"]kд Э "q‘"gj f‘TjqJkёvE‘QM gvjу Gj‘fx vj<fJ ёRUfgёvj‘J‘"j "J‘"Kj‘fj A RёJjLfН q "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q LjUj‘"A <]jJ "J RёJjLf v™Ugf f >ёwfJQ q ]Lk["x у fq№QJQgёjJ A ‘jx qJLёMд „JLjRvj‘fj LjUj‘Aё вRёvEGfAё fvf ]jg"GAfи A Uj>"№ёq‘"qJf L"<]ёjJ v™U"gE A RёJjLf ё qJLёM №"JjL+JE §Jk Uj>"№ёq‘"qJE у U"+>‘E
ныы
№"JjLf JёA AёA g jj gvёqJf vfKfJE qg"fM ]jJjx >ёKfJQд !‘TjqJkёvEу ‘Qj gvjGj‘f+ qJё‘"g+Jq+ №ёJ"v"[fjx g qvkGёj g">‘fA‘"gj‘f+ f‘Tjу qJkёvE‘"[" qfRUf">ё Jд jд JёA"x qg+>f q RёJjLE™ №Lf A"J"L"x Gjv"у gjA +gv+jJq+ jj ‘j"JYjRvjR"x GёqJE™ >ёgfqfJ "J ‘jj в‘j "U+>ёJjvE‘" Df>fGjqAf ‘" №qfM"v"[fGjqAf f f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘"и ‘j g q"qJ"+‘ff "q">‘ёJE qjU+ AёA qёR"qJ"+JjvE‘k™ vfG‘"qJEд pLf f‘TjqJkёvE‘"R qfRUf">j f‘]fgf] Lj[LjqqfLkjJ A qg"fR fqJ"AёRН "‘ kqJLjRv+jJq+ ‘ё>ё] g RёJjLf‘qA"j v"‘" №QJё+qE ‘ёxJf JёR >ёwfJk f №"A"x GJ" №qfM"v"[fGjqAf ">‘ёGёjJ <jvё‘fj kxJf "J <f>‘f №LjALёJfJE jjд
cё‘‘Qx RjMё‘f>R f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"x №qfM"№ёJ"v"[ff zL"RR №"v‘"qJE™ №jLj‘"qfJ ‘ё q"TfёvE‘Qj "J‘"Kj‘f+д ЮёJE №Lj]qJёgу v+jJ q"U"x J"vEA" №jLgk™ №jLq"‘fDfAёTf™ qfvQ A"J"Lё+ >ёу wfwёjJ f [ёLё‘JfLkjJ Uj>"№ёq‘"qJEд p">]‘jj g>L"qvQx Gjv"gjA №L"]"v<ё+ fq№QJQgёJE №"JLjU‘"qJE g >ёwfJj >ёRjwёjJ RёJE qjу REjx L"]"R ‘ёTfjx №ёLJfjx ["qk]ёLqJg"R U"["Rд ?ёA zL"RR №Lfg"]fJ №LfRjL qfTfvfxqA"x RёDff Gvj‘Q A"J"L"x ‘ё>Qgё™J qg"™ "L[ё‘f>ёTf™ sRёR"xyд pёJLf"Jf>R ‘ёTf"‘ёvf>R gjL‘"qJE №ёLJff ["qk]ёLqJgk fvf TjLAgf jqJE vfKE q"TfёvE‘Qj D"LRQ f‘у TjqJkёvE‘QM gvjGj‘fxд Pjv"gjA "J]ёjJ qg"™ qg"U"]k q"TfёvE‘QR f‘qJfJkJёR Lё]f №Lf"ULjJj‘f+ kgjLj‘‘"qJf g qjUj qJёUfvE‘"qJf f >ёwfJQд
zL"RR q U"vEKfR "№ёqj‘fjR "J‘"qfJq+ A q"TfёvE‘QR +gvj‘f+R gQL"qKfR ‘ё №"Ggj f‘TjqJkёvE‘QM gvjGj‘fx JёA AёA "Gj‘E GёqJ" g ‘fM №"Uj<]ёjJ sqf‘]L"R Lёq№ё]ёyд Hё qJё]ff q"TfёvE‘"[" f‘TjqJkу ёvE‘"[" qfRUf">ё g gf]j [f№jLJL"DfL"gё‘‘"[" №ёJLf"Jf>Rё ‘ёTf"у ‘ёvf>Rё Ljvf[f">‘"[" f №"vfJfGjqA"[" §AqJLjRf>Rё Gjv"gjA gqJk№ёу jJ g A"‘DvfAJ q Lё>kR"R f LjёvE‘"qJE™ "‘ qR"JLfJ ‘ё RfL [vё>ёRf ‘ёTff fvf №ёLJff qGfJёjJ fM gqj[]ё f g" gqjR ёUq"v™J‘" №LёgQRf ‘jg>fLё+ ‘ё kUj]fJjvE‘"qJE LёTf"‘ёvE‘QM ёL[kRj‘J"gд „vj]qJgfу jR f‘TjqJkёvE‘"[" qfRUf">ё +gv+jJq+ JёA<j J" GJ" ‘j fRj™wfx AL"g‘"[" L"]qJgё q sRёJjLE™y вJд jд №ёLJfjx ‘ёTfjx ["qk]ёLqJg"R TjLA"gE™и Gjv"gjA g"q№Lf‘fRёjJq+ AёA ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘Qxд !‘]fgf] qfRUf"JfGjqAf qg+>ё‘‘Qx q q"TfёvE‘"x [Lk№№"x ‘j q№"q"Uj‘ v™у UfJE A"["уvfU" AL"Rj qjU+ f ]ё‘‘"x [Lk№№Qд mJfR "UY+q‘+jJq+ №" zL"RRk fLLёTf"‘ёvE‘"qJE ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘"[" Lёq"g"[" Ljvf[f">‘"[" fvf №"vfJfGjqA"[" Dё‘ёJf>Rёд
ед *З;WKЗoWpdoK Юё>"Mf>Rй f qё]f>Rйй у gё<‘Qj №qfM"ё‘ёvfу JfGjqAfj №"‘+Jf+д hqvf Rё>"Mf>R ">‘ёGёjJ №"gj]j‘fj Gjv"gjAё "Lfу j‘JfL"gё‘‘"[" ‘ё №"vkGj‘fj qjAqkёvE‘"[" k]"g"vEqJgf+ №kJjR q"Uу qJgj‘‘QM k‘f<j‘fx f qJLё]ё‘fx J" qё]f>R №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ №"vkGj‘fj
й p"‘+Jfj |
Rё>"Mf>Rё |
qg+>ё‘" q fRj‘jR ёgqJLfxqA"[" №fqёJjv+ |
Йд oёMjLуЮё>"Mё |
врВемурВЛыи |
"№kUvfA"gёgKj[" qAё‘]ёvE‘Qx L"Rё‘ q""Jу |
gjJqJgk™wjx §L"JfGjqA"x "Lfj‘JёTffд
йй ?jLRf‘ №L"fqM"]fJ "J fRj‘f DLё‘Tk>qA"[" №fqёJjv+ RёLAf>ё ]j „ё]ё вр.наурВрни ёgJ"Lё L+]ё vfJjLёJkL‘QM №L"f>gj]j‘fx q "№fqё‘fjR qTj‘ qjAqkёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ffд
ным
k]"gvjJg"Lj‘f+ q №"R"wE™ ‘ёqfvf+ ‘ё] qjAqkёvE‘QR №ёLJ‘jL"Rд Юё>"MfqJqAfj f qё]fqJqAfj №"Uk<]j‘f+ +gv+™Jq+ ёRUfgёvj‘J‘"x ‘jLё>LQg‘"x №ёL"x №Lfqkwjx Aё<]"Rk Gjv"gjAkд p" zLjx]k jqvf f‘]fgf] g qg"jR №"gj]j‘ff №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A g‘jK‘jRk RfLk у qё]fqJ J" g "J‘"Kj‘ff qёR"[" qjU+ "‘ Rё>"MfqJ f ‘ё"U"L"Jд Э >ёgfqfR"qJf "J "UqJ"+JjvEqJg Rё>"MfqJqAfj f qё]fqJqAfj ‘ёAv"‘‘"qJf Gjv"gjAё R"[kJ Rj‘+JEq+ RjqJёRf ‘" ‘fA"[]ё ‘j fqGj>ё™Jд
zL"RR g "q‘"g‘"R №Lf]jL<fgёjJq+ §JfM <j №">fTfx ‘" "‘ №jLjу g"]fJ RjMё‘f>R qё]f>Rё f Rё>"Mf>Rё f> "UvёqJf qjAqkёvE‘"x g №"vfу JfGjqAk™ gQqJLёfgё+ JjR qёRQR qg"™ Jj"Lf™ sUj[qJgё "J qg"U"]Qyд „ j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ gqj Lё>‘""ULё>‘Qj D"LRQ Rё>"Mf>Rё "Ukqv"gу vj‘Q "]‘fRН qJLjRvj‘fjR f>UёgfJEq+ "J q"UqJgj‘‘"x vfG‘"qJf "J ULjRj‘f qg"U"]Qд „ё]f>R qg"]fJq+ A <jvё‘f™ "gvё]jJE ]Lk[fR Gjу v"gjA"R №LjgLёJfJE j[" g Ujq№"R"w‘Qx "UYjAJ qg"jx g"vf qJёJE j[" ёUq"v™J‘QR №"gjvfJjvjRд Эё<‘jxKfx №Lf>‘ёA qё]f>Rё у <ё<]ё gvёqJf q №"R"wE™ A"J"L"x R"<‘" №LfGf‘+JE qJLё]ё‘f+ f k‘f<ёJE ]Lk[fMд ЭvёqJ‘Qj "J‘"Kj‘f+ №Lj]qJёgv+™J q"U"x qfRUf"> qё]fqJ"g f Rё>"MfqJ"g A"J"LQj q ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE™ ‘k<]ё™Jq+ ]Lk[ g ]Lk[jд „ №">fTfx zL"RRё gvёqJE qJL"fJq+ ‘ё "q‘"gj №qfM"v"[fGjqA"x q"у j]f‘j‘‘"qJf ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘QM vfG‘"qJjxд ! qё]fqJQ f Rё>"MfqJQ у v™]f kwjLU‘Qj "‘f ‘j R"[kJ №L"Jfg"qJ"+JE "UqJ"+JjvEqJgёR g "]fу ‘"GAkЖ J"vEA" gvёqJE "UYj]f‘++ fM ]ёjJ fR qfvkд
?ёAё+ №L+R" qAё<jR Lё]fAёvE‘ё+ JLёAJ"gAё gvёqJf fqM"]fJ f> kUj<]j‘‘"qJf zL"RRё g J"R GJ" v™Uё+ gvёqJE JёfJ g qjUj №"Jj‘у TfёvE‘k™ №ёJ"v"[f™ q№"q"U‘k™ №Lf "№Lj]jvj‘‘QM kqv"gf+M qJёJE LjёvE‘"qJE™д hqvf qё]fqJqAfj f Rё>"MfqJqAfj ‘ёAv"‘‘"qJf v™]jx kLёg‘"gjKfgё™Jq+ "J‘"qfJjvE‘" [ёLR"‘fG‘" q"qkwjqJgk™J J" g "UwjqJgj ‘ёqJk№ёjJ №"vfJfGjqAё+ qJёUfvE‘"qJEд o‘ёGfJjvE‘Qj ]fqу №L"№"LTff qё]f>Rё f Rё>"Mf>Rё g Gjv"gjAj ‘ё№L"Jfg №L"g"TfLk™J q"TfёvE‘Qx §AqJLjRf>Rд
„g"j"ULё>‘QR g>LQg"R qё]"Rё>"MfqJqA"x №ёJ"v"[ff UQvё ]v+ zL"RRё [fJvjL"gqAё+ ejLRё‘f+ f qJёvf‘qAё+ u"qqf+д pLёg]ё "q‘"gу ‘"j g‘fRё‘fj "‘ gqjуJёAf k]jv+v №qfM"v"[ff ‘ёTf"‘ёvуq"Tfёvf>Rё gf]+ g ‘jRTёM Jf№fG‘QM qё]"Rё>"MfqJ"gд evёg‘Qx ‘"qfJjvE qё]"у Rё>"MfqJqA"x №qfM"v"[ff у RjvAё+ UkL<kё>f+д hj zL"RR qGfJёv "q‘"g‘QR fqJ"G‘fA"R №"vfJfGjqA"x ]jqJёUfvf>ёTff вf ‘j J"vEA" g ejLRё‘ffи f gqj[]ё "J‘"qfvq+ A ‘jx gLё<]jU‘"д
r‘ ]ёjJ +LAfx q"TfёvE‘"у№qfM"v"[fGjqAfx №"LJLjJ qё]"Rёу >"MfqJё №Lj]qJёgfJjv+ J"JёvfJёL‘"x qfqJjRQд „ё]"Rё>"MfqJqAё+ vfG‘"qJE Dё‘ёJfG‘" gjLfJ g" gvёqJE JёA AёA §J" A"R№j‘qfLkjJ jj q"UqJgj‘‘k™ ‘jkgjLj‘‘"qJE g qjUjЖ "‘ё g"qMfwёjJq+ gvёqJE™ M"GjJ №"]Gf‘fJEq+ jx ‘" g J" <j gLjR+ M"GjJ qёRё UQJE gvёqJE™д ” qё]"Rёу >"MfqJё qfvё gQ>QgёjJ v™U"gE f ["J"g‘"qJE №"]Gf‘fJEq+ ‘j>ёgfqfR" "J J"[" AJ" jj №L"+gfvд „fvё №LfgvjAёjJ j[" ‘j Lё]f JjM Tj‘‘"qJjx A"J"LQj >ё ‘j™ qJ"+J ё qёRё №" qjUj №"J"Rk GJ" "‘ё у qfvёд ! ‘ёу "U"L"J qё]"Rё>"MfqJ №Lf gf]j qvёU"[" f Uj>>ёwfJ‘"[" fq№QJQgёjJ
ны.
<jvё‘fj ‘ё№ёqJE ‘ё ‘j[" №"]ёgfJE k‘f>fJEд Hj]"qJёJ"A qfvQ qё]"у Rё>"MfqJ qGfJёjJ №Lf>‘ёA"R gf‘Q f ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJfЖ jqvf gvёqJE №L"+gv+jJ qvёU"qJE J" v™U"gE f kgё<j‘fj qё]"Rё>"MfqJё A ‘jx qRjу ‘+™Jq+ №Lj>Lj‘fjR f ‘j‘ёgfqJE™д cv+ qё]"Rё>"MfqJё ‘jJ №"‘+Jf+ Lёgj‘qJgё v™]f ]jv+Jq+ ‘ё gQqKfM f ‘f>KfMЖ v™UQj Lё>vfGf+ Uk]E J" №"v fvf Lёqё ]v+ ‘j[" "U+>ёJjvE‘" +gv+™Jq+ №Lf>‘ёAёRf №Ljg"qу M"]qJgё fvf ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJfд „ё]"Rё>"MfqJ gqj[]ё A"‘qjLgёJfgj‘ №LjAv"‘+jJq+ №jLj] №L"KvQR "‘ kUj<]j‘ GJ" <f>‘E "№Lj]jv+jJq+ qfvёRf vj<ёwfRf g‘j Gjv"gjAёд h]f‘qJgj‘‘" g">R"<‘"j qGёqJEj ]v+ ‘j[" у §J" №"]Gf‘fJEq+ §JfR qfvёRд ШAJfg‘"qJE qё]"Rё>"MfqJё R"<jJ UQJE J"vEA" g" fR+ ]"v[ё №L"Kv"[" gvёqJf ‘" ‘j g" fR+ <f>у ‘f AёA JёA"g"x ё gQqKё+ ]"UL"]jJjvE g j[" qfqJjRj Tj‘‘"qJjx у Uj>у L"№"J‘"j qJLё]ё‘fjд
нд ТDъCAhBCd\ЮWъC p"JLjU‘"qJE g Lё>LkKj‘ff ё[Ljqqf™ zL"RR qGfJёjJ "]‘fR f> gё<‘jxKfM qg"xqJg vfG‘"qJfд H" g "Jvfу Gfj "J zLjx]ё jRk №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ GJ" Gjv"gjGjqAё+ ]jqJLkAJfgу ‘"qJE fRjjJ g "q‘"g‘"R q"TfёvE‘k™ №LfL"]kд ?j"Lf+ " gL"<]j‘‘"x ё[Ljqqfg‘"qJf Gjv"gjAё zL"RRk №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ k№L"wj‘‘"x "]‘"у qJ"L"‘‘jx "‘ №Lj]vё[ёjJ qg"x g>[v+] ‘ё §Jk №L"UvjRkд pqfMfAё f‘у ]fgf]ё fRjjJ ]gj q"qJёgv+™wfj у f‘qJf‘AJ f qJLёqJfд hqvf f‘qJf‘у AJQ jqJE №L"+gvj‘fj Df>f"v"[fGjqAfM №"JLjU‘"qJjx в<ё<]ё ["v"] qjAqи J" qJLёqJf у §J" qvj]qJgfj №"JLjU‘"qJjx §A>fqJj‘TfёvE‘QM вqJLjRvj‘fj A v™Ugf ‘j<‘"qJf qg"U"]j №Lёg]j ё JёA<j A qё]f>Rk Rё>"Mf>Rk Lё>LkKj‘f™ gvёqJf f Jд №дид !‘qJf‘AJQ вё "JGёqJf f q"у TfёvE‘Qj kqv"gf+и vj<ёJ g "q‘"gj ]"UL"AёGjqJgj‘‘"x ё[Ljqqff ё qJLёqJf у >v"AёGjqJgj‘‘"xд
c"UL"AёGjqJgj‘‘k™ ё[Ljqqf™ вg "q‘"g‘"R g gf]j "U"L"‘Qи zL"RR qGfJёjJ >ёA"‘"R №LfL"]Q ‘ё№Lёgvj‘‘QR ‘ё >ёwfJk <f>‘f g" gqjM jj №L"+gvj‘f+M вUf"v"[fGjqA"R f q"TfёvE‘"Rид pёLё]"Aу qёvE‘" ‘" A ]"UL"AёGjqJgj‘‘QR gf]ёR ё[Ljqqff "‘ "J‘"qfJ g"x‘k в№Lj<]j gqj[" "U"L"‘fJjvE‘k™ид mJ" JjR U"vjj qJLё‘‘" fU" JёA"j qk<]j‘fj fqM"]fJ "J [kRё‘fqJё "J [vkU"A"[" f №L"‘fTёJjvE‘"[" fqqvj]"gёJjv+ q"TfёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ffд „ J"GAf >Lj‘f+ D"LRёvE‘"x v"[fAf fqM"]+ f> №"qQv"A qёR"[" zL"RRё g"x‘ё A"Lj‘fJq+ g f‘у qJf‘AJёM Gjv"gjAё f №"§J"Rk +gv+jJq+ ‘jf>Uj<‘"x ‘ё gqjR №L"J+у <j‘ff qkwjqJg"gё‘f+ Gjv"gjGjqJgёд H" zL"RR №L"g">[vёKёjJ AёA Lё> №L"Jfg"№"v"<‘Qx Jj>fqН №LfGf‘Q g"x‘ ‘j vj<ёJ g №LfL"]j Gjу v"gjAё f ‘j DёJёvE‘Q fM R"<‘" f>Uj<ёJEд ’L"Rj J"[" GJ" j[" ‘j "Gj‘E Ujq№"A"fJ §J" g‘kJLj‘‘jj №L"Jfg"LjGfj >]jqE №L"+gfvёqE ‘jу q№"q"U‘"qJE №qfM"v"[ё "UY+q‘fJE g>ёfR"]jxqJgfj Uf"v"[fGjqAfM f q"TfёvE‘QM DёAJ"L"gд
ov"AёGjqJgj‘‘ё+ ё[Ljqqf+ qg"xqJgj‘‘ё fqAv™GfJjvE‘" Gjv"gjAk "‘ё ‘j №"L"<]ёjJq+ <fg"J‘QRf f‘qJf‘AJёRfд ?"vEA" Gjv"gjA q№"q"у Uj‘ Lё>LkKёJE fqJ+>ёJE f kUQgёJE Uj> gq+A"x ]v+ qjU+ №"vE>Q fvf f> k]"g"vEqJgf+д !qJ"G‘fA"R >v"AёGjqJgj‘‘"x ё[Ljqqff +gv+jJq+ sULjу R+ qg"U"]Qy A"J"L"j q]jvёg vfG‘"qJE f>"vfL"gё‘‘"x >ёUL"Kj‘‘"x
ныВ
Ujq№"R"w‘"x №"qJёgfv" jj g kqv"gf+ §A>fqJj‘TfёvE‘"x qfJkёTffд !‘]fgf] "Aё>ёvq+ №jLj] gQU"L"RН fvf gqjqJ"L"‘‘jj Lё>gfJfj ‘ё "q‘"gj qg"U"]Q fvf sUj[qJg" "J qg"U"]Qy ‘ё D"‘j №ёJ"v"[fGjqA"x ё[Ljqqffд ov"AёGjqJgj‘‘ё+ ]jqJLkAJfg‘"qJE +gv+jJq+ qvj]qJgfjR ‘jу Ljёvf>"gё‘‘"x qg"U"]Q Lj>kvEJёJ"R ‘j№L"<fJ"x <f>‘fд Э‘kJLj‘у ‘++ qA"gё‘‘"qJE f qJjq‘j‘‘"qJE Gjv"gjAё Uj[kwj[" "J qg"U"]Q f <f>‘f "U"LёGfgёjJq+ ‘j‘ёgfqJE™ A RfLk <jvё‘fjR j[" Lё>LkKfJEд ! GjR U"vEKj JёAё+ qA"gё‘‘"qJE JjR U"vjj Lё>LkKfJjvE‘"x "Aё>Qу gёjJq+ ё[Ljqqf+д
ov"AёGjqJgj‘‘ё+ ]jqJLkAJfg‘"qJE №" zL"RRk §J" ёvEJjL‘ёJfgё <f>‘f №kJE A Lёq№ё]k f qRjLJfд ’Lёx‘++ qJj№j‘E >v"AёGjqJgj‘‘"x ё[Ljqqff у ‘jAL"Dfvf+д HjJL"Dfv GkgqJgkjJ gvjGj‘fj A" gqjRk ‘jу <fg"RkН JLk№ёR [‘fj‘f™ ‘jGfqJ"JёRЖ "‘ q "<fgvj‘fjR ["g"LfJ " U"vj>‘+M №"M"L"‘ёM qRjLJfд HjAL"Dfv ‘j v™UfJ <f>‘f №"§J"Rk "‘ M"v"]j‘ RёAqfRёvE‘" ]fqJё‘TfL"gё‘ "J v™]jxд Щ"+qE <f>‘f ‘jAL"у Dfv №"qJ"+‘‘" №QJёjJq+ №"qJёgfJE jj №"] A"‘JL"vE "‘ у qJ"L"‘‘fA s>ёA"‘ё f №"L+]Aёyд „ёRQx §DDjAJfg‘Qx q№"q"U >ёwfJQ "J "№ёqу ‘"qJf fqM"]+wjx "J <f>‘f у kRjLwgvj‘fj <f>‘fд p"§J"Rk ]v+ ‘jу AL"Dfvё MёLёAJjL‘ё kqJё‘"gAё ‘ё qfvk JёA AёA q jj №"R"wE™ <fg"j R"<‘" №LjgLёJfJE g RjLJg"jЖ qfvё №"A"fJq+ ‘ё gvёqJf kUfgёJEд Hjу AL"Dfv №"]Gf‘j‘ f‘TjqJkёvE‘QR gvjGj‘f+R у "‘ gqj[]ё qJLjRfJq+ g sv"‘" RёJjLfy A №L"Kv"Rk j[" Tj‘‘"qJf vfU" A"‘qjLgёJfg‘Q vfU" LjёATf"‘‘Qд
zL"RR №"vё[ёjJ GJ" ‘jAL"Dfvf+ g J"x fvf f‘"x RjLj №Lfqkу wё gqjR v™]+R ‘" g ‘ёqJ"+wjj gLjR+ "‘ё gqj U"vjj f U"vjj "gvёу ]jgёjJ RfL"Rд rq"Uj‘‘"qJE™ q"gLjRj‘‘"x §№"Mf +gv+jJq+ J" GJ" f‘]kqJLfёvE‘"уU™L"ALёJfGjqAё+ Tfgfvf>ёTf+ oё№ё]ё q">]ёvё ‘"gQx Jf№ Gjv"gjAё A"J"L"[" zL"RR ‘ё>QgёjJ ;хBх BГф;-NПфVэ Gjv"gjAу ёgJ"RёJ fq№QJQgё™wfx gvjGj‘fj A" gqjRk RjMё‘fGjqA"Rk f "JgLёу wj‘fj A" gqjRk <fg"Rkд Э f‘]kqJLfёvE‘"R "UwjqJgj []j <f>‘E qJёу ‘"gfJq+ gqj U"vjj RjMё‘fGjqA"x JjM‘fAё >ёqv"‘+jJ Gjv"gjAё f gjwf qJё‘"g+Jq+ AkvEJ"R vfG‘"qJE qёRё qJё‘"gfJq+ gjwE™ ]j№jLq"‘fDfу TfLkjJq+ №LjgLёwёjJq+ g ёUqJLёAJ‘k™ qJёJfqJfGjqAk™ j]f‘fTkд rUу wjqJg" LёqqRёJLfgёjJq+ AёA ‘jAfx RjMё‘fGjqAfx ё[Lj[ёJ kqv"gfjR Dk‘ATf"‘fL"gё‘f+ A"J"L"[" +gv+jJq+ ‘ёvfGfj Gjv"gjAёуёgJ"RёJё Uf"v"[fGjqA"[" L"U"Jёд !qAkqqJgj‘‘Qx RfL RfL JjM‘fAf JjM‘"v"у [fx f gjwjx "Aё>QgёjJq+ U"vjj A"RD"LJёUjvE‘QR f k№Lёgv+jRQR jRk "J]ёjJq+ №Lj]№"GJj‘fj №jLj] <f>‘E™д pLf JёA"R №"v"<j‘ff ]jv f ]jR"ALёJf+ f ]fAJёJkLё jqJE gqj[" vfKE qg"j[" L"]ё JjM‘"v"[f+ №" "L[ё‘f>ёTff "UwjqJgё №"v‘"qJE™ vfKj‘‘ё+ §JfGjqA"[" qRQqvёд HjAL"DfvE‘" "Lfj‘JfL"gё‘‘Qx Gjv"gjA №"]]jL<fJ v™Uk™ gvёqJE A"J"Lё+ №"R"<jJ k]"gvjJg"LfJE j[" v™U"gE A gjwёRд HёfU"vjj +LA"j №L"+gvj‘fj q"TfёvE‘"x ‘jAL"Dfvff у J"JёvfJёL‘Qj Lj<fRQ []j №Lёg+J >ёA"‘Gj‘‘Qj g"<]fу‘jAL"DfvQ вefJvjL „Jёvf‘и ё Gjv"gjA g UkAgёvE‘"R qRQqvj qJёv gjwE™ Jд jд kRjL AёA vfG‘"qJEд
ныЛ
ыд ЛWЮtWAKdoKl „"[vёq‘" №">fTff zL"RRё q"gLjRj‘‘Qx >ёу №ё]‘Qx Gjv"gjA GJ"UQ AёAуJ" kxJf "J GkgqJgё Ujq№"A"xqJgё f ‘jkgjу Lj‘‘"qJf gQ‘k<]j‘ "JAё>QgёJEq+ "J qg"j[" n f qJё‘"gfJEq+ JёAfR AёAfR j[" M"J+J gf]jJE ]Lk[fjд !‘]fgf] №LfUj[ё+ A q"TfёvE‘"x Rfу RfALff №LjgLёwёjJq+ g qg"j"ULё>‘Qx Dё‘J"R №"]Gf‘j‘‘Qx qJё‘у ]ёLJёR Rёqq"g"x AkvEJkLQд ЮQKvj‘fj A"‘D"LRfqJё ‘jALfJfG‘"д h[" §R"Tf"‘ёvE‘"qJE №"]ёgvj‘ё "‘ ‘j fRjjJ ]ё<j qg"fM <jvё‘fx M"GjJ J"[" GJ" +gv+jJq+ "Uwj№Lf‘+JQRд „"gLjRj‘‘"j >ё№ё]‘"j "UwjqJg" q">]ёv" "ULё> s‘"LRёvE‘"[" Gjv"gjAёy A"J"LQx ‘fA"[]ё ‘j UQgёjJ qvfKA"R [LkqJj‘ qvfKA"R qjL]fJ fvf qvfKA"R g>g"v‘"gё‘д
H" GjR U"vEKj Gjv"gjA №Lfq№"qёUvfgёjJq+ "JRjGёjJ zL"RR JjR Ujq№"R"w‘jj "‘ qjU+ GkgqJgkjJд „"gLjRj‘‘Qx Gjv"gjA "Ujqqfvjv у f §J" [vёg‘ё+ "№ёq‘"qJE §№"Mfд ’"‘D"LRfqJ qJLё]ё+ f>у>ё №"JjLf qg"jx vfG‘"qJf ["J"g №Lf‘+JE v™Uk™ f]j"v"[f™ f v™U"[" g"<]+ A"J"LQx №""UjwёjJ jRk g‘jqJf qRQqv g j[" <f>‘EЖ "‘ №ёqqfg‘" gqJLjJfJ v™у Uk™ q"TfёvE‘k™ AёJёqJL"Dkд srJGё+‘fj v™]jxуL"U"J"g у >ёAv™GёjJ zL"RR у №fJёJjvE‘ё+ qLj]ё ]v+ №"vfJfGjqAfM Tjvjx DёKf>Rёyд
’ёA k<j "JRjGёv"qE ёvEJjL‘ёJfg"x sqf‘]L"Rk Lёq№ё]ёy +gv+jJq+ sqf‘]L"R L"qJёy A"J"LQx gAv™GёjJ g qjU+ v™U"gE A <f>‘f вUf"Dfу vf+и qJLjRvj‘fj A qg"U"]j ‘j>ёgfqfR"qJf №"v‘"x Ljёvf>ёTff gqjM qfv Gjv"gjAё ё JёA<j U"LEUk q" gqjRf №L"+gvj‘f+Rf q"TfёvE‘"x №ёу J"v"[ffд Hё "q‘"gj Jj‘]j‘Tff L"qJё Gjv"gjA №" zL"RRk qR"<jJ gQу xJf f> q"qJ"+‘f+ №"]ёgvj‘‘"qJf f "ULjqJf ‘"gk™ gQqKk™ [ёLR"‘f™ q №LfL"]"x f v™]ERf q">]ёJE q"gjLKj‘‘Qj q"TfёvE‘Qj f‘qJfJkJQд
PJ"UQ ]"Aё>ёJE LjёvfqJfG‘"qJE JёA"x ёvEJjL‘ёJfgQ zL"RR ёAJfg‘" №LfgvjAёjJ f]jf ЮёLAqё f zLjx]ёд ’ёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ "Uё RQqvfJjv+ №L"]"v<ё+ fk]j"MLfqJfё‘qAk™ f [LjA"уL"Rё‘qAk™ [kRёу ‘fqJfGjqAk™ JLё]fTf™ UQvf j]f‘Q g "]‘"RН Gjv"gjA <fgjJ g RfLj fvv™>fx вJд jд ‘jqg"U"]Qи №"R"[ё™wfM jRk №jLj‘"qfJE J+["JQ <f>у ‘f j[" ‘j"UM"]fR" "qg"U"]fJE "J "A"g qёR""URё‘ё gjL‘kJE A LjёvEу ‘"qJf f JjR qёRQR q]jvёJE vfG‘"qJE №"]vf‘‘" qg"U"]‘"xд ”Gj‘fj ЮёLAqё zL"RR №Lf‘fRёjJ g"qJ"L<j‘‘"д p">fJfg‘QR +]L"R RёLAу qf>Rё "‘ qGfJёjJ [kRё‘fqJfGjqAk™ A"‘Tj№Tf™ Gjv"gjAё ‘ёKj]Kk™ №" j[" R‘j‘f™ qg"j "JLё<j‘fj g smA"‘"RfGjqA"уDfv"q"DqAfM LkA"у №fq+M рВнн ["]ёy f sHjRjTA"x f]j"v"[ffyд
ЭRjqJj q JjR zL"RR №"vё[ёjJ GJ" ЮёLAq q"gjLKfv sJLё[fGjqAk™ "KfUAky f>ULёg qLj]qJg"R ]"qJf<j‘f+ q"Tfёvf>Rё Ljg"v™Tf™ f ‘ёу qfvfjд Э qJLjRvj‘ff ЮёLAqё f>Rj‘fJE q"TfёvE‘Qx RfL Ljg"v™Tf"‘у ‘QR №kJjR №Lf "U+>ёJjvE‘"R >ёMgёJj ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"x gvёqJf zL"RR kqRёJLfgёjJ gvf+‘fj UkL<kё>‘QM Ljg"v™Tfx g M"]j A"J"LQM №" j[" R‘j‘f™ №"vfJfAё f[Lёvё [vёgj‘qJgk™wk™ L"vEд p"vfJfGjqAё+ Jj"Lf+ ЮёLAqё AёA "‘ qGfJёjJ №" qkJf qg"jx UkL<kё>‘ё f +gv+jJq+ Kё["R ‘ё>ё] №" qLёg‘j‘f™ q pLk]"‘"R ЩёAk‘f‘QR ’L"№"JAf‘QR
й rJ vёJд фхNжхBПэ у №"]"U‘Qx q""ULё>‘Qxд r>‘ёGёjJ №Lfq№"q"Uvj‘у GjqJg" №ёqqfg‘"j №Lf‘+Jfj qkwjqJgk™wj[" №"L+]Aёд
нма
A"J"LQj "JgjL[ёvf ["qk]ёLqJg" g AёGjqJgj "Lk]f+ q"TfёvfqJfGjqAfM №Lj"ULё>"gё‘fxд Йj‘f‘ f „Jёvf‘ Lё>gfg f]j™ " Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"R ‘ёу qfvff DёAJfGjqAf Lj[LjqqfL"gёvf A UkL<kё>‘"Rk №Lёg"q">‘ё‘f™ GJ" f qJёv" №" j[" R‘j‘f™ №LfGf‘"x ‘jk]ёG‘"[" "№QJё №"qJL"j‘f+ q"Tfёvf>Rё g u"qqffд „JёgAё ‘ё kALj№vj‘fj q"gjJqA"[" ["qk]ёLqJgё №"gQKj‘fj j[" L"vf g ]jvj q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"[" qJL"fJjvEqJgё ]jvёjJ "‘ gQg"] >ёA"‘GfvёqE kqJё‘"gvj‘fjR J"JёvfJёLf>Rёд
zL"RR gQq"A" "Tj‘fgёjJ "JALQJ"j ЮёLAq"R f m‘[jvEq"R RёJjу LfёvfqJfGjqA"j №"‘fRё‘fj fqJ"Lff ‘" "‘f q j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ ‘j №"Aё>ёvf RjMё‘f>R q"j]f‘+™wfx Uё>fq q ‘ё]qJL"xA"xд mJk >ё]ёGk №" zL"RRk q№"q"Uj‘ LjKfJE №qfM"ё‘ёvf>д
zL"RR gQ]jv+jJ ]gё §vjRj‘Jё JёA"[" RjMё‘f>RёН q"TfёvE‘"j Ujqу q">‘ёJjvE‘"j f q"TfёvE‘Qx MёLёAJjLд
p" zL"RRk q"TfёvE‘"j Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j вGёqJE ‘ё]qJL"xAfи g">‘fAёjJ g v™U"R ‘j>]"L"g"R "UwjqJgj AёA q№"q"U kxJf "J LjёvEу ‘QM №L"UvjR g RfL fvv™>fxд ЭRjqJ" J"[" GJ"UQ kvkGKёJE kqv"gf+ qg"jx <f>‘f v™]f №Lj]№"GfJё™J ‘j >ёRjGёJE ‘j[ёJfg‘Qj DёAJQ ]jxqJgfJjvE‘"qJf f №jLjg"]fJE fM g №"]q">‘ё‘fjд Э Lj>kvEJёJj Gjv"у gjA "Aё>QgёjJq+ g ‘jgL"JfGjqA"R q"qJ"+‘ff gAv™Gё™wjR RjMё‘f>R sUj[qJgё "J qg"U"]Qyд Э s>]"L"g"R "UwjqJgjy в№"] ‘fR №"‘fRёjJq+ [kRё‘f>fL"gё‘‘Qx q"Tfёvf>Rи №"vё[ёjJ zL"RR ]"v<‘Q UQJE fqу Av™Gj‘Q kqv"gf+ №"]ёgv+™wfj Gjv"gjAё ё >‘ёGfJ f k№Lё>]‘j‘ё qёRё "q‘"gё >ёqJёgv+™wё+ v™]jx "JAё>QgёJEq+ "J qg"U"]Q f kM"]fJE g RfL fvv™>fxд ekRё‘f>fL"gё‘‘Qx q"Tfёvf>R Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j ]jvёу jJ "q">‘ё‘‘QR Jд jд g">gLёwёjJ Gjv"gjAё A LjёvE‘"qJf g"qqJё‘ёgvfу gёjJ j[" ]kM"g‘k™ Tjv"qJ‘"qJEд
p"] q"TfёvE‘QR MёLёAJjL"R zL"RR №"‘fRёjJ q"g"Ak№‘"qJE №qfM"v"[fGjqAfM GjLJ №LfqkwfM "UwjqJgk вfvf q"TfёvE‘"x [Lk№№jи ‘ё J"R fvf f‘"R §Jё№j j[" Lё>gfJf+д „"TfёvE‘Qx MёLёAJjL у §J" Ljу >kvEJёJ ё]ё№JёTff Gjv"gjAё A "UwjqJgj‘‘"Rk qJL"™ "‘ №Lj"ULё>kjJ g‘jK‘™™ ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE g" g‘kJLj‘‘™™ №"JLjU‘"qJE f‘]fgf]"g f JjR qёRQR R"Ufvf>kjJ Gjv"gjGjqAk™ §‘jL[f™ ‘ё gQ№"v‘j‘fj >ё]ёG ]ё‘‘"x §A"‘"RfGjqA"x qfqJjRQд !‘ёGj ["g"L+ q"TfёvE‘Qx MёLёAJjL D"LRfLkjJ №"JLjU‘"qJf Gjv"gjAё №Lfg"]fJ fM g q""JgjJqJgfj q kL"gу ‘jR Lё>gfJf+ №L"f>g"]fJjvE‘QM qfv q">]ёjJ ‘j"UM"]fRk™ f‘]fgf]k qJLkAJkLk ‘ё]qJL"xAf вf]j"v"[f™ ["qk]ёLqJg" №Lёg"ид p"Aё Gjv"у gjA q№"q"Uj‘ k]"gvjJg"L+JE qg"f №"JLjU‘"qJf q"TfёvE‘Qx MёLёAJjL qg+>QgёjJ g"j]f‘" Uё>fq f ‘ё]qJL"xAkд H" №" RjLj §A"‘"RfGjqA"[" Lё>gfJf+ Rj<]k q"TfёvE‘QR MёLёAJjL"R f Uё>fq"R "ULё>kjJq+ Lё>у LQg qJёLQj №qfM"v"[fGjqAfj qJjLj"Jf№Q "Aё>Qgё™Jq+ ‘jq№"q"U‘Qу Rf "Uqvk<fgёJE ‘"gQj №L"f>g"]qJgj‘‘Qj "J‘"Kj‘f+д PJ"UQ g"qqJёу ‘"gfJE Lёg‘"gjqfj "UwjqJgj‘‘"x qfqJjRQ ‘j"UM"]fR ё]ё№Jfg‘Qx qAёG"A g A"L‘j Rj‘+™wfx q"TfёvE‘Qx MёLёAJjL f kqJё‘ёgvfgё™wfx ё]jAgёJ‘Qj №"JLjU‘"qJfд
ЭRjqJj q JjR zL"RR kAё>QgёjJ GJ" ё]ё№JёTf+ R"<jJ UQJE AёA №L"[Ljqqfg‘"x JёA f Lj[Ljqqfg‘"xд ?ёA ‘ё№LfRjL "‘ №"vё[ёjJ GJ"
нмр