учебный год 2023 / Жуков. Государство. Право. Власть
.pdf
q ]"[RёJfGjqAfRf D"LRkvёRf qg"fM fqAё‘fx gjLQ gqj[]ё ‘ё№L+<j‘у ‘QM f g>g"v‘"gё‘‘QMyйд
„vj]kjJ q"[vёqfJEq+ q ЩjL]+jgQR g J"R GJ" ЮjLj<A"gqAfx №Lfу ‘ё]vj<fJ A L+]k RQqvfJjvjx k A"J"LQM qJfRkv"R Ljvf[f">‘"[" Dfv"у q"DqJg"gё‘f+ +gv+jJq+ fM R+Jkwё+q+ Rj<]k gjL"x f Uj>gjLfjR ]kKё "qJL"j f <kJA"j "wkwj‘fj ‘j"JgLёJfR"qJf qRjLJf qJLёqJ‘"j <jvё‘fj q№ёqj‘f+ "J ‘jj вA fM Gfqvk ‘ё ‘ёK g>[v+] R"<‘" "J‘jqJf JёAfM №fу qёJjvjx f RQqvfJjvjx AёA pёqAёvE ’EjLAj["L c"qJ"jgqAfx ’ёDAё qJ"+wfM k fqJ"A"g §A>fqJj‘TfёvE‘"x Dfv"q"Dffид Э §J"R A"‘JjAqJj s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x ‘jAk™ qkUvfRёTf™ §A>fу qJj‘TfёvE‘QM №jLj<fgё‘fx ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" №"№QJAk jwj Lё> вUjqA"у ‘jG‘k™ k<j №" qGjJk g fqJ"Lffи kUj]fJE qjU+ f ]Lk[fM g №"]vf‘‘"qJf !fqkqё “LfqJё №"v‘"Jj j[" U"<jqJgj‘‘"x R"wfд
Эё<‘QR DёAJ"L"R "Ukqv"gfgKfR q">]ё‘fj s!fqkqё Hjf>gjqJ‘"у ["y вAёA g№L"GjR gqjx JLfv"[ffи qJёvf Uj>kqv"g‘" JLё[fGjqAfj Aёу JёAvf>RQ g u"qqff f hgL"№jН №jLgё+ RfL"gё+ g"x‘ё Ljg"v™Tf+ §Rfу [LёTf+ q"TfёvE‘"у№"vfJfGjqAё+ ‘jqJёUfvE‘"qJE g hgL"№j f "<f]ё‘fj gJ"L"x RfL"g"x g"x‘Q ‘ёGёv" A"J"L"x ЮjLj<A"gqAfx qg+>Qgёv q ‘ёqJk№vj‘fjR A"‘Tё RfLёд pfqёJjvE qLёg‘fgёjJ qjU+ q Gjv"gjA"R A"у J"LQx ‘ёM"]+qE ‘ё J"‘kwjR gqjRfL‘"R A"LёUvj в"ULё> [fU‘kwj[" Gjу v"gjGjqJgё у qAg">‘"x g JLfv"[ffи Af]ёjJ g R"Lj UkJQvAk q №fqER"R g ‘ё]j<]j ‘ё j[" №L"GJj‘fj g Uk]kwjRд s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy JёAfR "ULё>"R qJё‘"gfJq+ AёA UQ ]kM"g‘QR >ёgjwё‘fjR RQqvfJjv+ RfLk ‘ёqJ"+wjRk f g"qALjqKjRk №"qvj qg"jx [fUjvfд
’ёA k<j UQv" qAё>ё‘" s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy у >ёAv™GfJjvEу ‘ё+ GёqJE JLfv"[ff вM"J+ A‘f[ё №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x U"vEK"x f qёу R"qJ"+JjvE‘Qx f‘JjLjq Uj>"J‘"qfJjvE‘" A "qJёvE‘QR jj GёqJ+Rид Э №jLgQM ]gkM №L"f>gj]j‘f+M ЮjLj<A"gqAfx "ULёwёjJq+ A №L"Kv"у Rk Gjv"gjGjqJgё qJLjRfJq+ "JQqAёJE f №"‘+JE AkvEJkL‘"уfqJ"Lfу GjqAfj fqJ"Af Э"qJ"Aё вh[f№jJ Эёgfv"‘и f oё№ё]ё вШJvё‘Jf]ё !>у LёfvE [LjA"уLfRqAё+ Tfgfvf>ёTf+и "U">‘ёGfJE q"j]f‘fJjvE‘k™ vf‘f™ gqALQJE g‘kJLj‘‘™™ qg+>E ‘ёGёvё gqjRfL‘"x fqJ"Lff f jj A"‘Tёд Pjv"gjGjqAk™ fqJ"Lf™ ЮjLj<A"gqAfx №"‘fRёjJ f g"q№Lf‘fу RёjJ №Lj<]j gqj[" AёA q"Tf"AkvEJkL‘Qx RfD "‘ q">]ёjJ qg"j"ULё>у ‘k™ RfD"fqJ"LfGjqAk™ LjёvE‘"qJE g "q‘"gj A"J"L"x vj<fJ qёR"Lё>у gfJfj f]jf Щ"[ёд HёGёv"R f A"‘T"R JёA"x fqJ"Lff jj "qE™ gQqJk№ёjJ !fqkq “LfqJ"qд p" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk „Lj]f>jR‘"j R"Lj qg+>Qgё™у wjj JLf GёqJf qgjJё вhgL"№k Ш>f™ f ШDLfAkи №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x qjL]Tj >jRvf ё ]gj vf‘ff №L"gj]j‘‘Qj "J ЮjRDfqё в"]f‘ f> gj]kу wfM ["L"]"g Hf<‘j[" h[f№Jёи ]" ’"‘qJё‘Jf‘"№"v+ f "J Эёgfv"‘ё ]" ufRё "ULё>k™J ALjqJ у №L""ULё> ["v["DqA"[" ALjqJё №"] A"J"LQR f q"gjLKёjJq+ gqjRfL‘ё+ fqJ"Lf+д ”<j g ]Ljg‘fM +>QGjqAfM Ljvfу [f+M JёfJq+ “LfqJ"q MLfqJfё‘qJg" jqJE rJAL"gj‘fj Ш№"Aёvf№qfq +>QGjqJgёд s„"]jL<ё‘fj gqjRfL‘"x RfqJjLff у RfDё " qJLё]ё™wjR Щ"[j у ["g"LfJ ЮjLj<A"gqAfx у jqJE q"UQJfj ‘j "]‘ё<]Q №L"fqу
й уDA; D\ » ь zfv"q"Df+ Jg"LGjqJgё AkvEJkLQ f fqAkqqJgёд „д еВВд нар
Kj]Kjj ё gqj[]ё №L"fqM"]+wjj gqj g‘"gE f g‘"gE №jLj<fgёjR"j g <f>‘f RfLё f Gjv"gjGjqJgёдддyй ййд
rUY+q‘++ №"qvj]"gёJjvE‘"qJE ‘ё№fqё‘f+ A‘f[ JLfv"[ff RQqvfу JjvE "JRjGёjJ GJ" s?ёx‘ё Э"qJ"Aёy вJёx‘ё ‘ёGёvёи №Lfgjvё j[" A s?ёxу ‘j oё№ё]ёy вJёx‘j ’"‘Tёид Ш JёA AёA !fqkq “LfqJ"q sjqRE ШvEDё f rRj[ё ‘ёGёv" f A"‘jTy J" Jёx‘ё Э"qJ"Aё f oё№ё]ё qg"]fJq+ ЮjLj<у A"gqAfR A Jёx‘j “LfqJё Lё>[ё]ёg A"J"Lk™ qJё‘jJ №"‘+Jj‘ qRQqv Gjv"у gjGjqA"x fqJ"Lffд
Э A‘f[j s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy ЮjLj<A"gqAfx qJёgfJ №jLj] q"у U"x >ё]ёGk +gfJE ‘jf>gjqJ‘"[" RfLk “LfqJё "JALQJE ‘jf>gjqJ‘"j Gjу v"gjGjqJgk hgё‘[jvfj вhgё‘[jvfj "J !fqkqё “LfqJёид !q№"vE>"gё‘fj fR "№Lj]jvj‘fx s‘jf>gjqJ‘Qxy s‘jf>gjqJ‘"jy g q"GjJё‘ff q JёAfRf qvfKA"R f>gjqJ‘QRf >ё ]gj JQq+Gf vjJ qkwjqJg"gё‘f+ qv"gёRf AёA !fqkq “LfqJ"q f hgё‘[jvfj qLё>k gg"]fJ GfJёJjv+ g №L"qJLё‘qJg" №ёLё]"AqёvE‘"x RQqvf []j №LfGk]vfgQR "ULё>"R q"j]f‘+™Jq+ fqJ"у LfGjqAё+ LjёvE‘"qJE f RfD >‘ё‘fj f gjLёд „JLjRvj‘fj Gjv"gjGjqJgё g‘fRёJjvE‘" LёqqR"JLjJE vfT" “LfqJё g fqJ"Lff f hgё‘[jvff q]jvёJE Hjf>gjqJ‘"[" ]" A"‘Tё f>gjqJ‘QR "ULjGj‘ё №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk ‘ё ‘jk]ёGk JёA AёA +LAfx "ULё> Щ"["Gjv"gjAё №"]"U‘" q"v‘Tk "qvj№v+у jJ qR"JL+wfMд Э §J"R qRQqvj Jёx‘ё “LfqJё AёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ ‘ёgqj[]ё "qJё‘jJq+ ‘jLё>[ё]ё‘‘"xд
ЮjLj<A"gqAfx qJLjRfJq+ fq№LёgfJE "ULё> „№ёqfJjv+ fqAё<j‘у ‘Qx g fqJ"LfGjqA"R MLfqJfё‘qJgj qJёgKfx №" j[" qv"gёR v"<‘QR g LjёvE‘"R MLfqJfё‘qA"R RfLjд r‘ A"‘qJёJfLkjJ g MLfqJfё‘qJgj ‘ёу vfGfj sgjG‘"x U"vj>‘f Gjv"gjGjqA"[" kRё f g"vfy JёA ‘ё>QgёjR"[" sAё<j‘f+y в"J qv"gё sAё>ёJEq+yи №Lj]№"vё[ё™wj[" >‘ё‘fj “LfqJё AёA sJj‘f f №Lf>LёAёy ‘" ‘j AёA <fg"x f LjёvE‘"x №v"JfЖ q"gLjRj‘у ‘QR v™]+R “LfqJ"q №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ sAё<kwfRq+y R‘fR"x №v"JE™д rJq™]ё №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk D"LRёvE‘"j "J‘"Kj‘fj A >ё№"gj]+R hgё‘[jvf+ A"J"LQj №"‘fRё™Jq+ q"gLjRj‘‘QR Gjv"gjA"R AёA g‘jKу ‘++ "UL+]‘"qJE kqv"g‘"qJE MLfqJfё‘qA"[" q"TfёvE‘"[" UQJёд Юjу Lj<A"gqAfx kUj<]j‘ GJ" s‘jvE>+ №L"GjqJE hgё‘[jvfj ‘j ]jvё+ J"[" GJ" g ‘jR qAё>ё‘"ддд Э"J №"GjRk §J" qёRё+ ‘jGfJёjRё+ f> A‘f[ qёRё+
‘jf>gjqJ‘ё+y й йд pL"GjqJE hgё‘[jvfj ">‘ёGёjJ q j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ kgfу ]jJE g ‘jR ‘j J"vEA" HjUjq‘"[" “LfqJё ‘" f ojR‘"[" !fqkqё k>‘ёJE j[" ‘ёA"‘jT g" №v"Jf J" jqJE №"gjLfJE g Щ"["Gjv"gjAё ‘ёGёJE <fJE №" “LfqJkд ?ёAfR "ULё>"R ЮjLj<A"gqAfx qJLjR+qE №"gjL‘kJE Gjу v"gjGjqJg" A qg"jRk !fqkqk Hjf>gjqJ‘"Rk №Lj]№Lf‘fRёjJ AёA jRk
№Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ [Lё‘]f">‘k™ №"№QJAk q№ёqJf MLfqJfё‘qJg" ё q ‘fR gjqE RfLд
Э A‘f[j s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy ёgJ"L qkRjv ‘ёfU"vjj №"v‘" "JLё>у fJE f]jx‘"j q"]jL<ё‘fj f v"[fGjqAk™ D"LRk qg"jx A"‘Tj№Tff ?Ljу JEj[" oёgjJёд
й)DADbBW\ъBdG Т ?ёx‘ё ?LjMН h[f№jJ f Эёgfv"‘д pLё[ё рЛтыд „д тВд
йй)DADbBW\ъBdG Т „"ULд q"Gд !fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxд ЮдН ujq№kUvfAё рЛЛмд „д .д
нат
’"‘Tj№Tf+ ?LjJEj[" oёgjJё вg"qM"]+wё+ A kGj‘f™ !"ёMfRё zv"LqA"["й йй f "J]jvE‘QR №"v"<j‘f+R qLj]‘jgjA"g"x №ёJLfqJfAfи R‘"["ёq№jAJ‘ё №" qg"jRk q"]jL<ё‘f™д ЮjLj<A"gqAfx Lё>gfgёjJ qg"™ Jj"Lf™ "JJёvAfgё+qE "J ALfJfAf fqJ"LfGjqA"[" MLfqJfё‘qJgё g "q‘"у gk A"J"L"[" №" j[" R‘j‘f™ >ёv"<j‘ ]kёvf>R ]kMё f №v"Jf ]"ULё f >vё qgjJv"[" f JjR‘"[" AёA Lёg‘QM f №L"Jfg"№"v"<‘QM ‘ёGёv RfL"у >]ё‘f+д Й"[fAё ]kёvf>Rё fqJ"LfGjqA"[" MLfqJfё‘qJgё №Lfg"]fJ AёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ A №Lf]ё‘f™ >vk qkUqJё‘TfёvE‘"[" MёLёAJjLё [kUfJjvE‘ё+ R"wE A"J"L"[" ‘ёGf‘ёjJ "[Lё‘fGfgёJE qfvk Щ"[ёд p"‘+J‘" GJ" g §J"R qvkGёj s"№Lёg]ё‘fjy ?g"LTё g AёGjqJgj s‘ёGёvё f A"‘Tё RfLёy []j >v" jqJE vfKE GёqJ‘Qx qvkGёx ]"ULё ‘j R"<jJ q"qJ"+JEq+д
?ёA"j "[Lё‘fGfJjvE‘"j №"‘fRё‘fj R"[kwjqJgё Щ"[ё AL"jJq+ №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk ‘j g "‘J"v"[fGjqA"x ]g"xqJgj‘‘"qJf Gjv"gjGjqA"x №LfL"]Q JёA<j Lёq№"vё[ё™wjx A ]kёvfqJfGjqA"Rk g"q№Lf+Jf™ RfLё ё №Lj<]j gqj[" g J"R GJ" №jLg"‘ёGёvE‘" Gjv"gjGjqJgk UQvf ]"qJk№‘Q vfKE ]gё ЙfAё Щ"[ёд pLj"]"vj‘fj JёA"[" RjJёDf>fGjqA"[" ]kёvf>Rё ЮjLj<A"gqAfx kqRёJLfgёjJ g RfqJfGjqA"R LёqALQJff kGj‘f+ " Щ"<jу qJgj‘‘"x ?L"fTjд Э JL"fG‘"qJf №" j[" R‘j‘f™ ‘j J"vEA" >ёRfL+jJq+ ]g"xqJgj‘‘"qJE g JLjJEjR ЙfAj Щ"[ё ‘" DёAJfGjqAf +gv+jJq+ h]f‘"j g cgkM cgё qJё‘"g+Jq+ h]f‘QR f g MLfqJfё‘qA"x Ljvf[ff g‘"gE "Uу LjJёjJq+ ёUq"v™J‘ё+ R"wE ?g"LTёд
p"уqg"jRk "qRQqvfgё+ kGj‘fj " Щ"<jqJgj‘‘"x ?L"fTj вsJёx‘Q ?LjMyи qJLjR+qE "JALQJE Gjv"gjGjqJgk №"]vf‘‘" Ljvf[f">‘Qx qRQqv Щ"[ё RfLё f Gjv"gjAё ЮjLj<A"gqAfx ‘ёM"]fJ №kJE A q№ёqj‘f™ g fqу №"v‘j‘ff JLjM oёgjJ"g вJ" jqJE JjM "J‘"Kj‘fx Rj<]k Щ"["R f Gjv"gjу A"R A"J"LQj >ёAv™Gё™Jq+ g №"№jGj‘ff Щ"[ё " Gjv"gjAj f g "U+>ё‘‘"у qJ+M №"qvj]‘j[" №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A Щ"[kид
uёqALQgё+ ]fёvjAJfGjqAk™ g>ёfR"qg+>E oёgjJ"g f "№Lj]jv++ fM AёA v™U"gE >ёMgёJQgё™wk™ RfL RQqvfJjvE gf]fJ g fM №"qvj]"gёу JjvE‘"x qRj‘j ]Lk[ ]Lk["R LjёvE‘" "qkwjqJgv+™wk™q+ ‘" gqj <j №"у Jj‘TfёvE‘" qALQJk™ g">R"<‘"qJE q№ёqj‘f+Н sддд[vkU"Aё v™U"gE rJTё ё v™U"gE „Q‘ё [vkU<jЖ [vkU"Aё v™U"gE „Q‘ё ё jwj [vkU<j v™U"gE ЮёJjLfд rJjT ‘j q№ёq „Q‘ ‘j q№ёqjJ у q№ёqjJ ЮёJEyййд ’ёA №"vё[ёjJ ЮjLj<A"gqAfx oёgjJ „Q‘ё вH"gQx oёgjJи №L"Jfg"LjGё f №L"Jfg"у U"LqJgk+ oёgjJk rJTё вЭjJM"Rk oёgjJkи ‘j "JRj‘+jJ №"qvj]‘j[" ё №ёLё]"AqёvE‘QR "ULё>"R Lё>gfgёjJ j["д pL"Jfg"LjGfg"j j]f‘qJg" oёу
gjJ"g fRjjJ qg"fR qvj]qJgfjR ]gё Lj>kvEJёJёд „ "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q fM №L"у Jfg"U"LqJg" gj]jJ A k‘fGJ"<j‘f™ ]Lk[ ]Lk[ё f kqJё‘"gvj‘f™ CёLqJgё Ш‘JfMLfqJёд r]‘ёA" q ]Lk["x у Rj<]k rJGfR f „Q‘"g‘fR oёgjJёRf gQ+gv+jJq+ [vkUf‘‘ё+ "‘J"v"[fGjqAё+ qg+>E ]jvё™wё+ g">R"<‘QR f ‘j"UM"]fRQR kqJё‘"gvj‘fj ?LjJEj[" oёgjJё у ckMёуЮёJjLf []j ]gё №jLgQM q"[vёqk™Jq+ f CёLqJg" Щ"<fj qJё‘"gfJq+ LjёvE‘QR DёAJ"Rд
й „"[vёq‘" j[" kGj‘f™ JLjR vfTёR MLfqJfё‘qA"x ?L"fTQ q""JgjJу qJgk™J JLf §LQ №"qvj]‘++ f> A"J"LQM Uk]jJ TёLqJg"R „g+J"[" ckMё Jд jд gjG‘"x q№Lёgj]vfg"qJf RfLё f №Lёg]Qд
йй )DADbBW\ъBdG Т ?ёx‘ё ?LjMН h[f№jJ f Эёgfv"‘д „д емнд
нае
„ №">fTfx ?Lfj]f‘qJgё ЮjLj<A"gqAfx "U"q‘"gQgёjJ g">R"<у ‘"qJE f ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE qkwjqJg"gё‘f+ Щ"<jqJgj‘‘"[" rUwjqJgё GJ" ‘ёM"]fJ qg"j qfRg"vfGjqA"j g"№v"wj‘fj g LёqALQgёjR"x fR sJёx‘j ?LjMyд r]f‘ ЙfA ?Lfj]f‘qJgё q""JgjJqJgkjJ №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk U"<jqJgj‘‘"x Gjv"gjGjqA"x vfG‘"qJf у №jLgfG‘"x j]f‘fTj CёLqJgё Щ"<f+д HёvfGfj ]gkM ЙfA"g Щ"<jqJgё "JLё<ёjJq+ g sRfqJfAj p"vёy []j №"v"gQj "J‘"Kj‘f+ №"‘fRё™Jq+ fR AёA Gjv"gjA"у f U"["№">‘ёу ‘fj вsqg+J"j qvё]"qJLёqJfjyид p"+gvj‘fj U"<jqJgj‘‘"x Gjv"gjGjqA"x vfG‘"qJf вfq№"v‘j‘fj Jёx‘Q r]‘"["и >‘ёRj‘k™wjj q"U"x kJgjL<]jу ‘fj s„g+J"x pv"Jfy "qg+wj‘‘"qJf №"v"gQM "J‘"Kj‘fx вfq№"v‘j‘fj Jёx‘Q cgkMи gj]jJ A fq№"v‘j‘f™ Jёx‘Q ?LjM у kqJё‘"gvj‘f™ Щ"<jу qJgj‘‘"[" rUwjqJgё CёLqJgё Щ"<f+д rL[ё‘fGjqAё+ q"j]f‘j‘‘"qJE „g+J"[" ckMё f „g+J"x pv"Jf №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk g"qу №Lf+Jfj JLjJEj[" ЙfAё Щ"[ё AёA ckMуЮёJjLE GJ" №">g"v+jJ №jLjxJf AёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ "J sRjLJg"[" ]"[RёJёy fqJ"LfGjqA"[" MLfqJfё‘qJgё []j g JLff№"qJёq‘"qJf "JqkJqJgkjJ ЮёJE f „Q‘ L"<]ё+qE Uj> ЮёJjLf AёA UQ g"gqj ‘j L"<]ёjJq+ A <fg"Rk "JAL"gj‘f™д ?ёAfR "ULё>"R g q"у "JgjJqJgff q №"‘fRё‘fjR ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" JLf ЙfAё Щ"[ё вrJjT „Q‘ ckMуЮёJjLEи +gv+™Jq+ "q‘"g"x [L+]kwj[" CёLqJgё Щ"<f+ g A"J"L"R pv"JE kLёg‘fgёjJq+ g №LёgёM q ckM"R kqJLё‘++ JjR qёRQR f>gjG‘Qx fM ]kёvf>Rд
Cj‘JLёvE‘QR f]jx‘QR A"R№"‘j‘J"R №qfM"v"[fGjqAfR qJjL<‘jR f ‘jLg"R A"‘Tj№Tff ?LjJEj[" oёgjJё +gv+jJq+ §qMёJ"v"[f>R ЮjLj<у A"gqA"[" j[" Dfv"q"Df+ ’"‘Tёд ’ёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ §qMёJ"v"[f+ g">gjу ]j‘‘ё+ fR g Lё‘[ RjJ"]ё Ljvf[f">‘"уfqJ"LfGjqA"[" №">‘ё‘f+ gg"]fJ gqjRfL‘k™ fqJ"Lf™ g qDjLk gjG‘"qJf ё ‘j gLjRj‘f GJ" №">g"v+jJ gQ+gfJE [Lё‘fTQ jj qkwjqJg"gё‘f+д Э §J"x qg+>f "‘ Lj>A" ALfJfAkу jJ Jj"Lf™ №L"[Ljqqё g "q‘"gj A"J"L"x №" j[" R‘j‘f™ vj<fJ v"<‘ё+ ёAqf"Rё Uvё["x UjqA"‘jG‘"qJf UQJf+ RfLё f A"J"Lё+ >ё №"qvj]‘fj №+JE у KjqJE gjA"g ⧹"Mё Э">L"<]j‘f+ ujD"LRёTff Ljg"v™Tfxи qkу Rjvё №"[ёqfJE fqM"]+wfx "J “LfqJё Ljvf[f">‘Qx qgjJд
uёqqRёJLfgё+ Lё>gfJfj fqJ"Lff q №">fTff qg"j[" §qMёJ"v"[f>Rё ЮjLj<A"gqAfx ]jvfJ jj ‘ё JLf §Jё№ё qg+>Qgё+ fM q qkwjqJg"gё‘fjR JLjM Gjv"gjGjqJgН №jLg"[" в]"№"J"№‘"["и №"[fUKj[" "J Э"]Q gJ"L"у [" в№"qvj№"J"№‘"["и A"J"L"j №"[fU‘jJ "J r[‘+ f JLjJEj[" f]kwj[" gqvj] >ё gJ"LQR A"J"L"j g">L"]fJq+ g ckMjд „"gLjRj‘‘Qx RfL №"
ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk ‘fA"[]ё jwj g fqJ"Lff gJ"L"[" Gjv"gjGjqJgё ‘j qJ"+v JёA Uvf>A" A ’"‘Tk AёA qjxGёqЖ №Lj]qAё>QgёjRё+ fR qA"Lё+ [fUjvE hgу L"№Q вsMLfqJfё‘qA"x gqjRfL‘"qJfyи jqvf f ‘j Uk]jJ A"‘T"R Gjv"gjGjу qJgё J" qJё‘jJ >‘ёRj‘fjR ’"‘Tёд Щj>Ljvf[f">‘"qJE >f+™wё+ №kqJ"Jё sqvfKA"R Uvё["№"vkG‘"[" MLfqJfё‘qJgёy +gv++qE q "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q ‘f>Kjx J"GA"x №ё]j‘f+ gJ"L"[" Gjv"gjGjqJgё q ]Lk["x у jqJE ‘j"UM"у ]fR"j kqv"gfj j[" Uk]kwj[" g"qALjqj‘f+д Э §J"R qRQqvj kJgjL<]ёjJ ЮjLj<A"gqAfx q"gLjRj‘‘Qj v™]f v™]f ’"‘Tё AёA ‘fA"[]ё Uvf>A" ‘ёM"]+Jq+ A №"‘fRё‘f™ !fqkqё Hjf>gjqJ‘"["д
efUjvE Gjv"gjGjqJgё №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk ‘j№"qLj]qJgj‘‘QR "Uу Lё>"R qg+>ё‘ё q gvf+‘fjR ]E+g"vё gqjRfL‘"x fqJ"Lff Ш‘JfMLfqJ"Rд
нан
cE+g"v у Gjv"gjA g" №v"Jf f AL"gf JёA"j <j fqJ"LfGjqA"j vfT" AёA f “LfqJ"q "JLё<ё+ g v"<‘"R №"]"Uff qkwjqJg" f ?L"fG‘"qJE Щ"<jу qA"[" vfTё f "qkwjqJgv++ JjR qёRQR gjvfGёxKfx q"Uvё>‘ qJLjRfJу q+ LёqA"v"JE f k]g"fJE Щ"<jqJgj‘‘"j h]f‘qJg" ?L"fTQ q]jvёJE qjU+ Lёg‘QR Щ"[k вs]gё Щ"[ёyи g‘jqJf g RfL UjqA"‘jG‘"qJE ]kёvf>Rёд „"у gLjRj‘‘"j Gjv"gjGjqJg" №" ЮjLj<A"gqA"Rk "Aё>ёv"qE g" gvёqJf ]E+у g"vEqA"[" №LjvEwj‘f+ fRj‘‘" №"J"Rk GJ" gf]jv" g Ш‘JfMLfqJj vfKE vj[j‘]k №L"KvQM gjA"g ё ‘j LjёvE‘k™ [L">‘k™ ]jxqJgfJjvE‘"qJEд r]‘ёA" AёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ LёqA"v"JE RfL f №L"Jfg"№"qJёgfJE “LfqJk >ёUvk]Kjj Gjv"gjGjqJg" ]E+g"vk k]ёjJq+ vfKE g" gLjRj‘f ‘" ‘j g gjGу ‘"qJf JёA AёA v™]f ’"‘Tё AёA ‘fAJ" >ё ]gj JQq+Gf vjJ MLfqJfё‘qJgё R"[kJ f ]"v<‘Q "JGjJvfg" kgf]jJE vfT" ЭLё[ёд
rq‘"g‘"j №L"Jfg"LjGfj Rj<]k “LfqJ"R f MLfqJfё‘qJg"R ЮjLj<у A"gqAfx kqRёJLfgёjJ g №"‘fRё‘ff TёLqJgё Щ"<f+д ”UQvE §qMёJ"v"у [ff g MLfqJfё‘qJgj U"vj>‘E sAё<j‘f+y вg"q№Lf+Jfj Щ"[ё f ]E+g"vё AёA RfDи №Lfgjvf №" j[" R‘j‘f™ A №"JjLj fR Ljvf[f">‘"[" "№QJё " ‘jLёqJ"L<fR"R j]f‘qJgj Щ"[ё f RfLё A Lё>]jvj‘f™ >jR‘"[" f ‘jу Ujq‘"[" №v"JqA"[" f ]kM"g‘"[" rJGj[" f „Q‘"g‘j["Ж TёLqJg" Щ"<fj qJёv" g"q№Lf‘fRёJEq+ ‘j Df>fGjqAfу№v"JqAf ё RjJёDf>fGjqAf fqу Av™GfJjvE‘" AёA TёLqJg" ‘jUjq‘"j GJ" ">‘ёGёv" kRjLJgvj‘fj hgё‘у [jvf+ f ‘"g"j Lёq№+Jfj “LfqJёд H" ]v+ ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" fqJ"LfGjqA"j MLfqJfё‘qJg" jqJE JёA<j ‘j"UM"]fRQx §Jё№ g №jLjM"]j A MLfqJfё‘qJgk ё№"Aёvf№qfGjqA"Rkд CёLqJg" Щ"<fj q j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ qkwjqJgk+ g gjG‘"qJf q"gjLKёjJq+ JёA<j g" gLjRj‘f f fqJ"Lff g ‘jR №L"fqM"]fJ g>ёfR"]jxqJgfj ]gkM qfv у Gjv"gjGjqA"x №"qJj№j‘‘"x f Щ"<jqA"x g‘j>ё№‘"xд CjLA"gE gJ"L"[" №LfKjqJgf+ Gk]jq‘QR "ULё>"R q"j]f‘jу ‘ё q TjLA"gE™ №jLg"[" №LfKjqJgf+ ё№"Aёvf№qfGjqA"j MLfqJfё‘qJg" №LfRjJ gqj №Lj]ё‘f+ Jёf‘qJgё f "JAL"gj‘f+ fqJ"LfGjqA"[" MLfqJfу ё‘qJgёд ?ёAfR "ULё>"R ?LjJfx oёgjJ ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" fq№"v‘+jJq+ g fqJ"LfGjqAfуLjёvE‘"R ‘jUjq‘"у>jR‘"R f ]kM"g‘"у№v"JqA"R TёLqJgj Щ"<EjR у g"№v"wj‘ff ?LjJEjx Щ"<jqA"x !№"qJёqf в„g+J"[" ckMёу ЮёJjLfид mJ" Uk]jJ ">‘ёGёJE JёA<j "ULё>"gё‘fj ‘ё §Jё№j ?LjJEj[" oёgjJё j]f‘"x Эqjvj‘qA"x CjLAgf Щ"["Gjv"gjGjqJgё []j №" kUj<]jу ‘f™ ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" q"gjLKfJq+ ‘jf>gjqJ‘ё+ hgMёLfqJf+ !fqkqё Hjу f>gjqJ‘"[" f Aё<]ё+ "J]jvE‘ё+ vfG‘"qJE qJё‘jJ LjёvE‘" GёqJE™ Jjvё “LfqJ"gё f №"Uj]fJ qRjLJE Df>fGjqAfд
’‘f[k s!fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qxy R"<‘" "J‘jqJf A "q"U"x Lё>‘"gf]у ‘"qJf MLfqJ"v"[fGjqA"x vfJjLёJkLQ ]"qJf[Kjx [f[ё‘JqAfM "UYjR"g A" gLjRj‘f ‘ё№fqё‘f+ §J"[" №L"f>gj]j‘f+д o]jqE ЮjLj<A"gqAfx вg qg"xqJgj‘‘"x jRk Rё‘jLjи "UfvE‘" TfJfLkjJ Lё>‘""ULё>‘Qj fqJ"G‘fу Af вё№"ALfDQ q"Gf‘j‘f+ "JT"g Э"qJ"G‘"x f oё№ё]‘"x TjLAgjx U"["qу v"g"g Dfv"q"D"gи q"№"qJёgv+jJ R‘j‘f+ Lё>vfG‘QM ёgJ"L"g ёAJfg‘" ALfJfAkjJ ёJjfqJfGjqAk™ JLё]fTf™ вg GёqJ‘"qJf gjLqff " <f>‘f “LfqJё Щд Щёk§Lё mд uj‘ё‘ё cд iJLёkqёид
ЭQM"] s!fqkqё Hjf>gjqJ‘"["y в№jLg"j f>]ё‘fj "qkwjqJgvjу ‘" g Щjv[Lё]j g рЛет [ди UQv gqJLjGj‘ ‘j"]‘">‘ёG‘"Н q№jAJL R‘j‘fx Lёq№Lj]jvfvq+ "J gQq"AfM №">fJfg‘QM "Tj‘"A вЩдpд ЭQKjqvёgTjg
наы
Щд’д oёxTjg Шд!д ’k№Lf‘ 'д’д ?jLё№fё‘" f ]Lди ]" ‘j["]"gё‘f+ q" qJ"L"‘Q Dfv"q"D"gуJLё]fTf"‘ёvfqJ"g f U"["qv"g"gд ?ёA Dfv"q"D f vfJjLёJkL‘Qx ALfJfA Щдpд ЭQKjqvёgTjg №fqёvН sevёg‘"j ]"qJ"f‘у qJg" A‘f[f ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" g ёUq"v™J‘"x "Lf[f‘ёvE‘"qJf j[" RjJ"]ёН §J" ‘j svfJjLёJkLёy вvfJjLёJkLё " “LfqJj у ‘jgQ‘"qfRёи ‘j ]"[RёJfу GjqA"j U"["qv"gfj в‘fA"Rk AL"Rj U"["qv"g"g ‘j№"‘+J‘"jиЖ §J" f ‘j Ljvf[f">‘"уDfv"q"DqA"j Lёqqk<]j‘fj у ‘jJ §J" f‘JkfJfg‘"j №"qJfу <j‘fj qALQJ"[" qRQqvё Lё>[ё]Qgё‘fj Jёf‘qJgj‘‘"[" s„fRg"vёy gjLQ GJj‘fj RjJёDf>fGjqA"[" KfDLё Lё>[ё]Qgё‘fj jgё‘[jvEqAfM №LfJG Aёу A"gQRf g A"‘Tj A"‘T"g +gv+™Jq+ gqj qv"gё f ]j+‘f+ “LfqJёyйд
!Rj+ KfL"Ak™ f>gjqJ‘"qJE g u"qqff f ‘ё oё№ё]j вg№L"GjR >ёRjJу ‘" k№ёgKk™ A A"‘Tk j[" <f>‘fи ЮjLj<A"gqAfx GёqJ" <ёv"gёvq+ ‘ё ‘j№"‘fRё‘fj qg"fM f]jx q" qJ"L"‘Q "UwjqJgj‘‘"qJfН sЭ u"qqff Rj‘+ ‘j v™Ufvf f ULё‘fvfЖ >ё [Lё‘fTjx Rj‘+ v™Ufvf f MgёvfvfЖ ‘" >]jqE f JёR "]f‘ёA"g" ‘j №"‘fRёvf R"j["д n fq№QJёv Rf‘kJQ JёA"[" "]fу ‘"GjqJgё GJ" qJё‘"gfv"qE <kJA"Ж f‘"[]ё Aё>ёv"qE GJ" fvf + ‘jR fvf
gqj [vkMfдддyйй Hj№"‘fRё‘f™ f ALfJfAj ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" q" qJ"L"‘Q j[" q"gLjRj‘‘fA"g вHдШд ЩjL]+jgё „дHд Щkv[ёA"gё ЭдЭд u">ё‘"gё Шд Щjу v"[" !дШд !vEf‘ё f ]Lди ‘ёL+]k q ]Lk[fRf №LfGf‘ёRf №"уgf]fR"Rk q№"q"UqJg"gёv" A"‘JLёqJ‘"j q"j]f‘j‘fj g j[" Jg"LGjqJgj [vkUf‘‘QM №L"UvjR Ljvf[f">‘"x "‘J"v"[ff f ё‘JL"№"v"[ff q №"№QJA"x Lё>Ljу KfJE fM q №"R"wE™ qkM"[" qMjRёJf>Rё f RjJёD"LfGjqA"[" +>QAёд
ukqqAfx Ljvf[f">‘Qx Dfv"q"D !дШд !vEf‘ "JRjGё+ GJ" A‘f[ё ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" "U !fqkqj “LfqJj s№"v‘ё ]kM"g‘"[" q"Uvё>‘ёy JёA MёLёAJjLf>"gёv j[" Ljvf[f">‘Qj f]jfН sCjvQx L+] vjJ ЮjLj<A"gу qAfx ‘"qfvq+ q RQqvE™ q">]ёJE ‘jA"j ‘j"MLfqJfё‘qJg" №LfGjR "‘ №"у gf]fR"Rk q"gjLKj‘‘" ‘j >ёRjGёv GJ" q"]jL<ё‘fj §J"x f]jf kALQgёjJ g ‘jA"jR gjvjLjGfg"R JkRё‘jЖ GJ" JjR№jLёRj‘J‘"qJE f ё[Ljqqfg‘"qJE j[" №L"№"gj]f q""JgjJqJgkjJ GLj>gQGёx‘" qRkJ‘"Rk f gjG‘" Rj‘+™у wjRkq+ q"]jL<ё‘f™Ж GJ" qJL"[" ["g"L+ "‘ gL+] vf f qёR >‘ёjJ Gj[" "‘ q"UqJgj‘‘" M"GjJ у GJ" "UYjR j[" f]jf kALQgёjJ g qjUj ‘j <fgk™ [vkUf‘k ё RjLJgj‘‘"уLёqqk]"G‘k™ №kqJ"Jkyйййд
mJё ALfJfAё q №">fTfx JLё]fTf"‘‘"[" №Lёg"qvёgf+ >ёJLё[fgёjJ qkJE U"["fqAёJjvEqJgё ЮjLj<A"gqA"["д Э №jLjv"R‘Qx ALf>fq‘Qx №jу Lf"] Lё>gfJf+ L"qqfxqA"[" "UwjqJgё ‘ёGёvё ‘ёKj[" qJ"vjJf+ A"[]ё LkKfvfqE ‘j J"vEA" №LfgQG‘Qj §A"‘"RfGjqAfj f №"vfJfGjqAfj D"LRQ UQJf+ ‘" f qёRf RfL"g">>Lj‘GjqAfj "q‘"gQ <f>‘f q" gqjx "qJL"J"x gqJёvё №L"UvjRё №"fqAё ‘"gQM ]kM"g‘QM "Lfj‘JfL"gд Щ"["fqAёJjvEqJg" ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" +gfv"qE Lё>‘"gf]‘"qJE™ ]kM"g‘"[" qJLё‘‘fGjqJgё A"J"L"j №QJёv"qE "ULjqJf JgjL]k™ №"Ggk №"] ‘"[ёRf gQxJf A s>jRvj "UjJ"gё‘‘"xyд p"§J"Rk ‘j>ёgfqfR" "J ‘ёKfM RfL"g">>Lj‘GjqAfM №Lfу
й Х gDъmЗ\yD\ у б cд ЮjLj<A"gqAfxд !fqkq Hjf>gjqJ‘Qx „"gLjу Rj‘‘Qj >ё№fqAfд рЛенд ыыд „д неаунерд
йй )DADbBW\ъBdG Т * p"vfд q"ULд q"Gд „№Uд Юд рЛррурЛрнд ?д !д „д рытд
ййй шm dЮ ш ь ?g"LGjqJg" ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" !vEf‘ !д Шд r]f‘"Afx Mk]"<‘fAд Юд рЛЛед „д рнед
нам
qJLёqJfx №"уqg"jRk k‘fAёvE‘Qx f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘"у‘LёgqJgj‘‘Qx f Ljу vf[f">‘Qx "№QJ sU"["fqAёJjvEqJgёуqJLё‘‘fGjqJgёy ЮjLj<A"gqA"[" R"<jJ UQJE f‘JjLjqj‘ q"gLjRj‘‘"Rk GfJёJjv™ f>kGё™wjRk fqJ"Lf™ LkqqA"x ]kM"g‘"x AkvEJkLQ №jLg"x №"v"gf‘Q ьь gд
НIжш •шжш ш •эШь IЭ7ш Ч•э э Э7 ш•э 3 у Dfv"q"DqA"j №L"f>gj]j‘fj „д Hд Щkv[ёA"gёд uёU"Jё q">]ёgёvёqE ‘ё №L"J+<j‘ff ‘jу qA"vEAfM vjJ врЛррурЛрми jj "J]jvE‘Qj DLё[Rj‘JQ №kUvfA"gёvfqE g №jLf"]fAj врЛрнурЛрмид rJ]jvE‘"x A‘f["x gQKvё g f>]ёJjvEqJgj spkJEy врЛр.ид p" qv"gёR oj‘EA"gqA"[" s„gjJ ‘jgjGjL‘fxy >ёgjLKёjJ Ljvf[f">‘"уDfv"q"DqAfx №jLf"] Jg"LGjqJgё Щkv[ёA"gё A"J"LQx №Lf‘+g g рЛрВ [д qg+wj‘qJg" g ]ёvE‘jxKjR ‘j №"LQgё+ g‘kJLj‘‘jx qg+>f q Dfv"q"DqA"x №L"UvjRёJfA"x №jLjM"]fJ A fqqvj]"gё‘f™ g "q‘"g‘"R U"["qv"gqAfM g"№L"q"gд ’‘f[ё ‘j J"vEA" №"]g"]fJ "№Lj]jу vj‘‘Qx fJ"[ ]kM"g‘"x §g"v™Tff Щkv[ёA"gё "J svj[ёvE‘"[" RёLAqf>у Rёy A f]jёvf>Rk f №Lёg"qvёgf™ вqёR ёgJ"L ‘ё>QgёjJ jj fq№"gj]E™и ‘" JёA<j [vkU"A" f LjvEjD‘" "JLё<ёjJ qRQqv f qkwjqJg" №"fqAё sLjvf[fу ">‘"[" j]f‘qJgё <f>‘fy >‘ёGfJjvE‘"x GёqJf LkqqA"x f‘Jjvvf[j‘Tff ‘ёGёvё ьь gд Э ‘jx Lё>gfgёjJq+ MLfqJfё‘qAё+ Dfv"q"Df+ Щ"[ё f RfLё f vj<ёwё+ g jj "q‘"gj f]j+ „"Dff вgqvj] >ё Эд „д „"v"gEjgQR f pд Шд zv"Lj‘qAfRид Э" ggj]j‘ff вspLfL"]ё Ljvf[f">‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+yи ё‘ёvf>fLkjJq+ JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘ё+ №LfL"]ё Ljvf[ff "q‘"gQ f №Lj]№"у qQvAf g">‘fA‘"gj‘f+ Ljvf[f">‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+д p" Щkv[ёA"gk <fgё+ Ljvf[f">‘"qJE gjLё "q‘"gё‘ё ‘ё ‘ё№L+<j‘‘"R GkgqJgj №L"Jfg"№"v"<у ‘"qJf fRRё‘j‘J‘"[" f JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘"[" №"v+Lf>ёTff RfL"q">‘ё‘f+ f U"["q">‘ё‘f+д ujvf[f+ >‘ёRj‘kjJ q"U"x ‘j J"vEA" qg+>E q Щ"["R ‘" JёA<j f [LjM"g‘"j "J№ё]j‘fj RfLё "J ‘j[" kqJё‘"gvj‘fj ёUq"v™J‘"[" ‘j№Lj"]"vfR"[" ]v+ RfLё LёqqJ"+‘f+ №Lj"]"vjgёjR"[" vfKE g Ljу >kvEJёJj Gk]ё Rfv"qJf f v™Ugf Щ"<jqJgёд ШAJ gjLQ "Uvё]ё™wfx Aёу GjqJg"R "UYjAJfg‘"qJf f JLё‘qqkUYjAJfg‘"qJf №Lfg"]fJ A L"<]j‘f™ ]"[RёJё f]jj AёD"vfG‘"qJf вk‘fgjLqёvE‘"qJf f gqjGjv"gjG‘"qJf fqу Jf‘Q Щ"<Ejxи f TjLA"g‘"qJfд ujvf[f">‘"j q">‘ё‘fj ‘ёM"]fJ qg"j g"у №v"wj‘fj g RfDj f AkvEJj у A"‘ALjJ‘"x "ULё>‘"x D"LRj "JAL"gj‘f+ JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘"[" gQqKj[" RfLёд r]‘fR f> fqJ"G‘fA"g Ljvf[f">‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+ +gv+jJq+ Dfv"q"Df+ №"qJ"+‘‘" qJLjR+wё+q+ gQxJf >ё №Ljу ]jvQ RfL"№">‘ё‘f+ ‘jqkwё+ g qjUj sv™U"gE A „"Dffyд p"qA"vEAk Dfv"q"Df+ AёA №"vё[ёjJ Щkv[ёA"g g qg"jx "q‘"gj RfDfG‘ё fvf ]"[у RёJfG‘ё jRk №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ "UYjAJfg‘QR f >ёA"‘"RjL‘QR qkwjqJg"у gё‘fj Ljvf[f">‘"x Dfv"q"Dff "L[ё‘fG‘" q"GjJё™wjx g qjUj qg"U"]k RQqvf f ]"[RёJ gjLQд Э №jLg"R "J]jvj вsЩ"<jqJgj‘‘"j ‘fGJ"yи ]ёjJq+ A"‘Tj№Tf+ "JLfTёJjvE‘"[" U"["q">‘ё‘f+ LёqqRёJLfgё™Jq+ kGj‘f+ №Lj]qJёgfJjvjx ё№"DёJfGjqA"[" U"["qv"gf+ в’vfRj‘J ШvjAqё‘]Lfxу qAfx rLf[j‘ Эёqfvfx ЭjvfAfx eLf["Lfx Щ"["qv"g eLf["Lfx Hfqу qAfx !"ё‘‘ cёRёqAf‘ eLf["Lfx pёvёRё f ]Lдид p" Щkv[ёA"gk Tj‘у JLёvE‘"x №L"UvjR"x Ljvf[f">‘"x Dfv"q"Dff +gv+jJq+ "qRQqvj‘fj U"<jqJgj‘‘"[" HfGJ"д uё>vfGё+ JёAfj №L"+gvj‘f+ q">‘ё‘f+ AёA №L"у Jfg"LjGfj вv"[fGjqA"j f ]fёvjAJfGjqA"jи f ё‘Jf‘"Rf™ в‘jg">R"<у
на.
‘"qJE №">‘ёJE JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘Qx U"<jqJgj‘‘Qx RfL f "]‘"gLjRj‘‘"j №LfqkJqJgfj §J"[" RfLё g Ljvf[f">‘"R №jLj<fgё‘ffи "‘ kqRёJLfgёjJ q""JgjJqJgj‘‘" ]gё №"]M"]ё g Ljvf[f">‘"x Dfv"q"DffН §g"v™Tf"‘‘"у ]fёvjAJfGjqAfx f ё‘Jf‘"RfGjqAfxд Э №jLg"R qvkGёj №Lj]№"vё[ё™wjR qfqJjRk Ljvf[f">‘"[" R"‘f>Rё gqj"Uwj[" k‘fgjLqёvE‘"[" J"<]jqJgё вUk]]f>R №ё‘Jjf>R pv"Jf‘ё Щд „№f‘">Q Шд i"№j‘[ёk§Lё mд eёLJRёу ‘ёи Щ"[ f RfL qJё‘"g+Jq+ "]‘"№"L+]A"gQRf R"Rj‘JёRf ]fёvjAJfGjу qA"[" Lё>gfJf+ UQJf+ fjLёLMfGjqAfRf qJk№j‘+Rf qёR""JAL"gj‘f+ HfGJ"д Эq+A"j ‘jGJ" вЩ"[ Gjv"gjA ‘jU" ё] ё‘[jvQ ]jR"‘Qи fRj+ j]f‘k™ №LfL"]k +gv+jJq+ R"]kq"R f№"qJёqJE™ ёUq"v™J‘"[" HfGJ" №Lf"ULjJёjJ MёLёAJjL A"‘jG‘"[" f "J‘"qfJjvE‘"[" GJ" [L">fJ Gjv"gjу Ak ]kM"g‘"x [fUjvE™д pLf ё‘Jf‘"RfGjqA"R №"‘fRё‘ff Ljvf[f">‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+ ‘ё№L"Jfg Щ"[ g qg"jx JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘"qJf UjqA"‘jG‘" k]ёvj‘ "J Gjv"gjAё kM"]fJ "J ‘j[" sg >ё№Lj]jvE‘k™ Jёx‘kyд Щkv[ёA"g qGfJёjJ GJ" "JLfTёJjvE‘"j U"["qv"gfj ‘j ]ёjJ v"[fGjqA"[" №jLjM"]ё A №"v"<fу JjvE‘"Rk kGj‘f™ " Щ"[j f RfLj fM ‘j№"qJf<fR"qJE "JGёqJf Lё>LjKёу jJq+ vfKE №"]gfJ"R gjLQд r]‘ёA" q"Jg"Lj‘fj RfLё L"<]ёjJ g">R"<у ‘"qJE "№Lj]jvfJE Щ"[ё AёA ‘jA"j fRRё‘j‘J‘"уJLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘"j ]kёvfqJfGjqA"j ‘ёGёv" №Lfg"]fJ A №"+gvj‘f™ U"["№">‘ё‘f+ f U"["у "Uwj‘f+ ]"[RёJё f RfDё f ‘ёA"‘jT A №"v"<fJjvE‘"Rk вAёJёDёJfGjу qA"Rkи U"["qv"gf™ f Ljvf[f">‘"уDfv"q"DqA"Rk "qRQqvj‘f™ Щ"[ёд ?ёAfR "ULё>"R ё‘Jf‘"Rf+ ‘j ‘ёM"]+ qg"j[" v"[fGjqA"[" Lё>LjKj‘f+ "Aё>QgёjJq+ Lё>LjKfR"x g Ljvf[f">‘"x <f>‘f ‘j U"+wjxq+ Lёqqk]"Gу ‘"[" ёUqkL]ёд ЭJ"L"x "J]jv вsЮfLyи №"qg+wj‘ k+q‘j‘f™ qRQqvё Ljу vf[f">‘QM "q‘"g UQJf+д „"[vёq‘" Щkv[ёA"gk Jg"Lj‘fj RfLё Щ"["R jqJE qёR"Lё>gfJfj ШUq"v™J‘"[" j[" Jg"LGjqAё+ <jLJgё v™Ugf Lё]f "Jу ‘"qfJjvE‘"["д Э §J"R qRQqvj Jg"Lj‘fj №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x ёUq"v™J‘" qg"U"]‘Qx f qёR"UQJ‘Qx g qjUj qёR"R fRj™wfx qRQqv f "q‘"gk Rjу JёDf>fGjqAfx f fLLёTf"‘ёvE‘Qx ёAJд r‘J"v"[fGjqAk™ "q‘"gk Jg"Ljу ‘f+ q"qJёgv+jJ Uj>RjL‘"j qRfLj‘fj ШUq"v™J‘"[" у №Lj]jvE‘ё+ f k‘fу gjLqёvE‘ё+ ]"UL"]jJjvE MLfqJfё‘qJgёд Щkv[ёA"g Lё>vfGё+ ‘fGJ" в№"v‘"j "JLfTё‘fj UQJf+ у kA"‘и f ‘jGJ" в‘jgQ+gvj‘‘"j №"Jj‘TfёvEу ‘"j UQJfj у Rj"‘и №"‘fRёjJ q">]ё‘fj "Uwjx RёJjLff JgёL‘"qJf вЭjу vfAё+ ЮёJjLE №LfL"]‘"[" RfLёи AёA Lj>kvEJёJ №LjgLёwj‘f+ kA"‘ё g Rj"‘д Юj"‘ gQ+gv++ qg"™ №"Jj‘TfёvE‘"qJE f "qg"U"<]ё+qE "J g‘jKу ‘jx №kqJ"JQ gQqJk№ёjJ g AёGjqJgj §Jё№ё ‘ё №kJf "J ‘jUQJf+ в‘fGJ"и A UQJf™ вGJ"ид ?ёf‘qJgj‘‘Qx Jg"LGjqAfx qf‘Jj> UQJf+ f ‘jUQJf+ gQу Lё<ё™wfxq+ g UQgё‘ff jqJE fqJf‘‘ё+ qkw‘"qJE JgёL‘"qJf gqj[" "Jу ‘"qfJjvE‘"["д p"qA"vEAk ШUq"v™J‘"j "U‘ёLk<fgёjJ qjU+ AёA ?g"LjT "qkwjqJgv+jJq+ g UQJff RfL №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ Щkv[ёA"gk qJё‘"g+wfRу q+ Щ"["Rд ?g"L+ RfL Щ"[ JjR qёRQR f qjU+ ggjL[ёjJ g Jg"Lj‘fj fqJ"у wёjJq+ g ‘fGJ" №LjgLёwёjJ j[" g RёJjLfёv ]v+ qg"j[" "ULё>ё f №"]"у Uf+д ?ёx‘ё JgёL‘"qJf №L"+gv+jJq+ JёA<j g №L"Jfg"LjGfg"R "q">‘ё‘ff JgёLE™ gLjRj‘‘"qJf qg"j[" UQJf+ f gjG‘"qJfд ЭLjR+ вёAJkёvE‘Qx qf‘у Jj> UQJf+ f ‘jUQJf+и №"[v"wj‘‘"j №L"KvQR f kqJLjRvj‘‘"j g Uk]kу wjj jqJE AёA UQ ‘j fRj™wё+ f>RjLj‘f+ J"GAё ]gf<kwё+q+ g "Ajё‘j Rj"‘ёvE‘"[" UQJf+у№"vkUQJf+ №L"Kj]Kj[" f Uk]kwj[" вk<jу‘jуUQJfj
наВ
f jwjу‘jуUQJfjид rUwё+ ё‘Jf‘"Rf+ JgёL‘"qJf gQLё<ёjJq+ g ё‘Jf‘"у Rff qg"U"]Q f ‘j"UM"]fR"qJf №Lfqkwjx JgёLf f>у>ё jj "J‘"qfJjvEу ‘"qJf f "[Lё‘fGj‘‘"qJfд p"qA"vEAk RfL UQJfx‘QRf A"L‘+Rf kM"]fJ g Щ"[ё "‘ Gk<] qg"U"]Q f ‘j"UM"]fR"qJf ‘" №"qA"vEAk "‘ JgёLj‘ f №"[Lk<j‘ g ‘fGJ" jRk qg"xqJgj‘‘ё g">R"<‘"qJE gQU"Lёд „">‘ёgёjRё+ JgёLE™ >ё]ёGё Jg"LGjqJgё №" Щkv[ёA"gk k<j №Lj]gjG‘" Lё>LjKj‘ё Щ"у ["R ‘" "‘ё ]"v<‘ё UQJE Lё>LjKёjRё g" gLjRj‘fд rU"q‘"gё‘fj Ljvf[fу ">‘QM "q‘"g RfL">]ё‘f+ №"vkGёjJ qg"j ]ёvE‘jxKjj Lё>gfJfj g "Lf[fу ‘ёvE‘"x RfD"v"[jRj „"Dffд p" Щkv[ёA"gk „"Df+ ‘ёM"]+qE g‘j qёR">ёRA‘kJ"x ёUq"v™J‘"x №"v‘"JQ Щ"<jqJgj‘‘"[" RfLё JjR ‘j Rjу ‘jj ]"№kqAёjJq+ g ‘j[" №" ‘jf>LjGj‘‘"Rk q‘fqM"<]j‘f™ v™Ugf Щ"у <Ejx "JALQgёjJ Jёx‘Q f [vkUf‘Q Щ"<jqJgёд Э "JvfGfj "J Щ"<jqJу gj‘‘QM f№"qJёqjx A"J"LQj ‘jf>Rj‘‘" №LjUQgё™J j]f‘"qkw‘QR Щ"<jqJg"R ‘ё№"v‘+™J qjU+ fR f j[" q"U"™ „"Df+ vfKE q"]jL<fJ J" GJ" №"vkGfvё "J Щ"[ё вg §J"R qRQqvj "‘ё у sЭjG‘ё+ <j‘qJgj‘‘"qJEyи Щkv[ёA"g kqRёJLfgёjJ g <j‘qJgj‘‘"qJf Jёx‘k RfLё №"qA"vEAk ]" j[" q"Jg"Lj‘f+ "‘ k<j UQv >ёL"<]j‘ g qg"jR <j‘qJgj‘‘"R v"‘jд cjxqJgfj gqjx „gд ?L"fTQ g Aё<]"x f> jj f№"qJёqjx №Lfg"]fJ A >ёL"<]j‘f™ RfLё g „"Dff qJё‘"g+wjxq+ g Lj>kvEJёJj ‘ёGёv"R JgёL‘"qJfд „"Df+ №LjUQgё+ Rj<]k RfL"R f Щ"["R UQJfjR f qgjLMUQJfjR gLjRj‘jR f gjG‘"qJE™ g‘"qfJ g RfL GjLj> qjU+ f ]v+ qjU+ №"L+]"A f g‘kJLj‘‘™™ №"qvj]"gёJjvE‘"qJE Щ"<jqJgj‘‘"[" ?Lfj]f‘qJgёд ”R"№"qJf[ёjRQj gjG‘Qj f]jf ёAJkёvE‘" q"]jL<ёwfjq+ g „"Dff vj<ёJ g "q‘"gj JgёLу ‘"[" RfLё ]jvё™J j[" q"Dfx‘QR ‘ё]jv+™J Aё<]"j qkwjqJg" qg"jx f]jjxу‘"LR"x ]ёgё+ JjR qёRQR jRk №"]vf‘‘"j UQJfjд Э §J"R qRQqvj RfL jqJE „"Df+ g qg"jx "q‘"gj f ‘j jqJE „"Df+ g qg"jR q"qJ"+‘ffд ЮёJjLf™ Щkv[ёA"g "№Lj]jv+jJ AёA ‘f>Kk™ №"]"q‘"gk RfLё Lёq№ёgу
Kk™q+ R‘"<jqJgj‘‘"qJE ‘ёM"]+wk™ qg"j j]f‘qJg" vfKE g" gLjRj‘‘"у №L"qJLё‘qJgj‘‘"R №L"Tjqqj qJё‘"gvj‘ff UQJffу‘jUQJffд Э "JvfGfj "J RёJjLff Jjvk №Lf]ёjJq+ №"v"<fJjvE‘"j f Uj>kqv"g‘"j >‘ёGj‘fjЖ "‘" jqJE ‘j J"vEA" qvj]qJgfj [LjMё ‘" +gv+jJq+ JёA<j №jLg">]ё‘‘"x qkw‘"qJE™ ‘jA"jx kR"№"qJf[ёjR"x RёJjLfjx "ULё>k™wjx "q‘"gk Jjу vjq‘"qJf g qёR"x „"Dffд rJgjL[ё+ ]kёvfqJfGjqA"j RfL"№"‘fRё‘fj в]"UL" f >v" AёA ‘ёGёvё RfLёи Щkv[ёA"g №"vё[ёjJ GJ" №jLg"L"]‘Qx [LjM №Lf‘jq q q"U"x ‘j qkUqJё‘TfёvE‘k™ ё Dk‘ATf"‘ёvE‘k™ №"LGk RfLёЖ RfL vj<fJ g" >vj ‘" ‘j jqJE >v" A"J"L"j jqJE j[" q"qJ"+‘fj ё ‘j qkw‘"qJEд oёAv™Gj‘‘"j g ‘j№L"‘fTёjRk™ "U"v"GAk ‘fGJ" >v" gqj[]ё "JJ"L<j‘" "J gqjj]f‘qJgё g‘jq"Dfx‘" f ё‘Jfq"Dfx‘"д Э JLjJEjR "Jу ]jvj вsPjv"gjAyи №Lj]qJёgvj‘ё Ljvf[f">‘ё+ ё‘JL"№"v"[f+ f fqJ"Lf"у q"Df+ Щkv[ёA"gёд p" j[" R‘j‘f™ Gjv"gjA g"№v"wё+ g qjUj "ULё> f №"у ]"Ufj Щ"<Ej jqJE "]‘"gLjRj‘‘" JgёLE f ‘j JgёLE "J‘"qfJjvE‘"j f ёUq"v™J‘"jЖ "‘ JLё‘qTj‘]j‘J‘" №L"Jfg"qJ"fJ ‘j J"vEA" RfLk ‘" f qjUj AёA §R№fLfGjqA"x f №qfM"v"[fGjqA"x ]ё‘‘"qJfд Щk]kGf RjJёDfу >fGjqAfR Tj‘JL"R RfL">]ё‘f+ Gjv"gjA q"]jL<fJ g qjUj gq™ №"v‘"Jk JgёL‘"[" RfLё AёA UQ №"v‘k™ №L"[LёRRk Jg"Lj‘f+д p"v‘"Jё "ULё>ё Щ"<Ej[" №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ ]kM"g‘k™ ]gk№"v"qJE Gjv"gjAё gQLё<ё™wk™у q+ g §L"JfGjqA"x ‘ё№L+<j‘‘"qJf у [vkU"GёxKjx "q‘"gj Jg"Lj‘f+ f
наЛ
Jg"LGjqJgё g qJLjRvj‘ff A ]kM"g‘"уTjv"qJ‘"Rk ULёAkд p"qA"vEAk №" Щkv[ёA"gk qёJё‘ё R"<jJ g‘jqJf q"Uvё>‘ g RfL J"vEA" GjLj> Gjv"gjAё j[" [LjM"№ё]j‘fj +gv+jJq+ №"Uj]"x ‘ё] gqjx JgёLE™д rJgLёwё+qE "J Щ"[ё Gjv"gjA <ё<]jJ k<j J"vEA" RfLё g№ё]ёjJ g "]‘"U"Afx A"qRf>R вfRRё‘j‘Jf>RиЖ qRjLJE qJё‘"gfJq+ Uvё["]j+‘fjR q№ёqj‘fjR "J <f>‘f ‘ё >ёGkRvj‘‘"x >jRvjд Э Lj>kvEJёJj JёA"x RjJёDf>fGjqA"x AёJёqJL"у DQ ‘j№"qLj]qJgj‘‘"j U"[""Uwj‘fj qRj‘+jJq+ ‘ё]j<]"x ‘ё g"qq"j]fу ‘j‘fj q Щ"["R f]jjx q№ёqj‘f+ Ljvf[f">‘QR U"[""JAL"gj‘fjR f U"["у ]jxqJgfjRд Э GёqJ‘"qJf +LAfx №LfRjL sfqAё‘f+y Щ"[ё Щkv[ёA"g kqRёJLfgёjJ g +>QGjqJgj A"J"L"j g R"Rj‘JQ qg"j[" Ljvf[f">‘"[" №"]YjRё №L"+gv+jJ №Lj]jvE‘Qx k<ёq U"[""qJёgvj‘‘"qJfд p" Щkv[ёA"у gk RfL UQv J"vEA" №Lj]q"Jg"Lj‘ g Gjv"gjAj A"J"LQx ]"v<j‘ UQv q" qg"jx qJ"L"‘Q q"Jg"LfJE qёR"[" qjU+ q"UqJgj‘‘"x qg"U"]"xд r]‘ёA" "U‘ёLk<fgKё+q+ ‘jq"qJ"+JjvE‘"qJE Gjv"gjAё ‘ё §J"R №kJf j[" [LjM"у №ё]j‘fj №"JLjU"gёv" "J Щ"[ё ‘"g"[" ёAJё Jg"Lj‘f+ у U"["g"№v"wj‘f+Ж “LfqJ"q вs‘"gQx Ш]ёRyи >ёRjqJfg q"U"x sgjJM"[" Ш]ёRёy qJёv fRRёу ‘j‘Jj‘ Gjv"gjAk f RfLk +gfvq+ j]f‘QR f k‘fgjLqёvE‘QR gqjGjv"gjу A"R q"U"L‘QR Gjv"gjGjqJg"R qёR"x TjLA"gE™д Ш‘Jf‘"Rf+ q№ёqj‘f+ №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE q"MLё‘fJE Lё> №Lf>gё‘‘"[" A UQJf™ Gjу v"gjAё f ‘jg">R"<‘"qJE q№ёqJf j[" JёAfR AёA"g "‘ jqJEЖ Uvё["]ёL+ e"v["DqA"x <jLJgj sgjJMfxy Gjv"gjA q">]ёjJq+ >ё‘"g" qJё‘"gfJq+ vkGKj №" qkwjqJgk "qJёgё+qE №"qvj g"qALjqj‘f+ qёRfR q"U"x s№" q"у qJ"+‘f™yд !qJ"Lf+ №" Щkv[ёA"gk №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x "qkwjqJgvj‘fj №jLg"‘ёGёvE‘"[" Jg"LGjqA"[" >ёRQqvё ‘jAk™ >ёgjLKj‘‘"qJE №"qvjу ]"gёJjvE‘" LёqALQgё™wk™q+ g" gLjRj‘fд !Rj+ qg"j ‘ёGёv" g LёxqA"R Gjv"gjGjqA"R UQJff fqJ"Lf+ ‘j№"]gvёqJ‘ё gvf+‘f™ №jLg"L"]‘"[" [LjMё A"J"LQx JjR ‘j Rj‘jj g‘"qfJ g ‘jj JLё[f>R f ё‘Jf‘"Rf™д r]‘fR f> fqJ"G‘fA"g RkGfJjvE‘"[" f №L"Jfg"LjGfg"[" qkwjqJg"gё‘f+ Gjv"у gjGjqJgё +gv+jJq+ №" Щkv[ёA"gk qJfMf+ M">+xqJg"gё‘f+ вёAJfg‘"у JLk]"g"j g">]jxqJgfj Gjv"gjAё ‘ё №LfL"]kи q"Dfx‘ё+ №" qg"jRk A"Lу ‘™ вAёA gq+A"j Jg"LGjqA"j ]jvё‘fjи f ё‘Jfq"Dfx‘ё+ g qg"jR UQJff вLёUqJg" ‘j"UM"]fR"qJfид Э M">+xqJgj f GjLj> M">+xqJg" Gjv"gjGjqJg" q">]ёjJ qg"j fqJ"LfGjqA"j Jjv" Ljёvf>kjJ ]v+ qjU+ RfL "qkwjqJgv+jJ gvёqJE ‘ё] ‘fRд Эё<‘"j >‘ёGj‘fj g fqJ"Lff Щkv[ёA"g №Lf]ёjJ JjkL[fу GjqAfR f q"DfkL[fGjqAfR >ё]ёGёR fqAkqqJgё ‘ёM"]+wj["q+ ‘ё [Lё‘f ]gkM RfL"gд Э §J"x qg+>f "‘ "JRjGёjJ GJ" fqAkqqJg" Jjq‘" qg+>ё‘" q Ljvf[f">‘QR AkvEJ"RЖ "‘" q A"vQUjvf №"gfJ" R"vfJg"x f Uvё["["gjу ‘fjRН ‘ё >ёLj AkvEJkL‘"x fqJ"Lff Gjv"gjGjqJg" vkGKfj qg"f g]"M‘"у gj‘f+ №Lf‘"qfJ A ёvJёL™ f №"qg+wёjJ Щ"[kд !qJ"LfGjqAё+ <f>‘E Gjv"у gjGjqJgё №L"JjAёjJ g D"LRj "UwjqJgj‘‘"qJf A"J"Lё+ №" Щkv[ёA"gk qALj№v+jJq+ gvёqJE™д rwkwё+ RfqJfGjqAfx f fLLёTf"‘ёvE‘Qx MёLёAу JjL gvёqJf jj U"[""JGk<]j‘‘"qJE Gjv"gjA qJLjRfJq+ №Lj"]"vjJE gvёqJE f №LfxJf A U"["gvёqJf™ вJj"ALёJffид „ J"GAf >Lj‘f+ Щkv[ёA"у gё fqJ"Lf™ R"<‘" qGfJёJE k]ёgKjxq+ jqvf "‘ё №"]["J"gfvё qg"x >ёу A"‘"RjL‘Qx A"‘jT f gQM"] >ё fqJ"Lf™ A s<f>‘f Uk]kwj[" gjAёyЖ A"у ‘jT fqJ"Lff jqJE ё№"Dj"> <f>‘f f jj "№Lёg]ё‘fjд „">Ljgё+ g ёAJёM U"[""JAL"gj‘f+ f U"["g"№v"wj‘f+ fqJ"Lf+ №L+R" fvf A"qgj‘‘" "№Ljу
нра