Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Скачиваний:
88
Добавлен:
21.12.2022
Размер:
2 Мб
Скачать
☆

 

Paragraph

Page

Elements to be taken into account in assessing indemnity

10.41

236

General

10.41

236

Valuing the loss of an estate, interest or charge

10.42

236

Interest

10.44

237

Costs

10.45

238

Factors that will bar a claim for indemnity or reduce the amount that

 

can be recovered

10.47

239

When a claim will be barred

10.47

239

When a claim will be reduced

10.48

240

The mechanism for determining indemnity

10.49

240

Rights of recourse

10.51

241

PART XI: SPECIAL CASES

 

243

INTRODUCTION

11.1

243

THE CROWN

11.2

243

Acknowledgements

11.2

243

Crown land

11.3

243

The issues addressed by the Bill

11.4

244

Registration of land held in demesne

11.5

245

The present law

11.5

245

Voluntary registration under the Bill

11.11

247

Compulsory registration under the Bill

11.13

247

Cautions against the first registration of demesne land

11.17

248

Escheat

11.20

250

The nature of escheat

11.20

250

The circumstances in which escheat occurs

11.23

252

The treatment of escheat in the Bill

11.26

255

Crown and Duchy land: representation

11.31

257

The disapplication of certain requirements in relation to Duchy land 11.33

257

Introduction

11.33

257

The present law

11.34

258

The Duchy of Cornwall

11.34

258

The Duchy of Lancaster

11.36

259

The provisions of the Bill

11.37

259

Matters for which the Bill makes no provision

11.38

260

BANKRUPTCY

11.39

260

Introduction

11.39

260

Procedure in relation to bankruptcy petitions

11.40

261

Procedure in relation to bankruptcy orders

11.41

261

Protection for disponees in good faith

11.42

262

SETTLEMENTS

11.45

263

PART XII: CONVEYANCING 1: GENERAL PROVISIONS

264

INTRODUCTION

12.1

264

PROOF OF TITLE

12.2

264

Introduction

12.2

264

What proof of title must a seller deduce?

12.4

265

xi

 

Paragraph

Page

What title is a buyer entitled to see?

12.9

267

COVENANTS FOR TITLE

12.14

269

Introduction

12.14

269

No liability for matters on the register

12.16

270

Rules

12.20

271

Covenants implied on the assignment of a lease prior to 1996

12.21

272

PART XIII: CONVEYANCING 2: ELECTRONIC

 

CONVEYANCING

 

273

INTRODUCTION

13.1

273

FORMAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ELECTRONIC DISPOSITIONS 13.5

274

Introduction

13.5

274

THE DRAFT LAW OF PROPERTY (ELECTRONIC

 

 

COMMUNICATIONS) ORDER

13.7

275

THE PROVISIONS OF THE BILL

13.11

277

Introduction

13.11

277

The applicability of Clause 91

13.12

277

The four conditions

13.13

278

Deemed execution

13.18

281

Deeds

13.19

281

Execution by agents

13.20

282

Notice of assignments

13.22

282

Execution by corporations

13.24

283

Execution by corporations which are companies for the purposes of the

13.25

283

Companies Act 1985

Execution by other corporations

13.30

285

Rights of a purchaser as to execution

13.31

286

Supplementary rule-making powers

13.32

286

PROVISIONS GOVERNING THE LAND REGISTRY NETWORK 13.34

286

Introduction

13.34

286

Access to the network

13.36

287

Network access agreements

13.36

287

The level of access will be variable

13.38

288

Authority may be given to perform registrar’s functions

13.39

288

Criteria for entry into a network access agreement

13.40

289

Terms of access

13.47

291

The purposes for which the power to authorise may be used

13.48

291

To require transactions to be conducted electronically

13.49

292

To regulate ancillary purposes

13.50

292

To enable transactions to be monitored

13.51

292

The obligation to comply with network transaction rules

13.52

292

The power to regulate terms of access by rules

13.54

293

Termination of access

13.55

293

Appeals

13.57

294

Overriding nature of network access obligations

13.58

295

Presumption of authority

13.60

295

xii

 

Paragraph

Page

Managing network transactions

13.63

296

Rules

13.66

298

Introduction

13.66

298

Why a rules-based approach is necessary

13.67

298

Safeguards

13.70

298

Do-it-yourself conveyancing

13.72

299

THE POWER TO MAKE ELECTRONIC CONVEYANCING

 

 

COMPULSORY AND TO REQUIRE THAT ELECTRONIC

 

 

DISPOSITIONS SHOULD BE SIMULTANEOUSLY REGISTERED 13.74

300

The objective of the power

13.74

300

The application of the power

13.80

302

Registration requirements

13.84

303

Rules

13.85

303

PART XIV: ADVERSE POSSESSION

 

305

INTRODUCTION

14.1

305

THE EFFECT OF THE BILL

14.9

311

Adverse possession shall not extinguish the title to a registered estate

14.9

311

The governing principle

14.9

311

The principle applies only in relation to registered estates andrentcharges

14.10

311

Provisions of the Limitation Act 1980 which depend on the accrual of

 

a cause of action or the limitation period will not apply

14.11

312

Mortgagors in possession

14.12

313

Mortgagees in possession

14.15

314

The right to apply for registration after ten years’ adverse possession

14.19

316

The prerequisites for an application: the general position

14.19

316

Where no valid application to be registered can be made

14.24

319

Where there are possession proceedings against the squatter

 

 

that are still current

14.25

319

Where the proprietor is an enemy or held in enemy territory14.28

320

Where the proprietor is suffering from mental disability or

 

 

physical impairment

14.29

320

Notification of the registered proprietor and others

14.32

322

Registration where no counter-notice is served

14.34

324

No registration where a counter-notice is served

14.35

324

Special case: registration even where a counter-notice is served

14.36

325

General summary

14.36

325

Estoppel

14.39

326

The principle

14.39

326

Examples

14.42

327

Some other right to the land

14.43

328

Reasonable mistake as to boundary

14.44

328

The principle

14.44

328

When will this exception be invoked?

14.46

330

What has to be established to fall within the exception ¾

 

factual elements

14.48

331

What has to be established to fall within the exception ¾

 

the mental element

14.50

331

xiii

Paragraph

Page

The right to make a further application for registration after two

 

 

more years’ adverse possession

14.53

332

Introduction

14.53

332

The right to make a further application to be registered

14.57

334

Where the squatter remains in adverse possession two years

 

 

after the rejection of his application to be registered

14.58

334

Where the proprietor obtains a judgment against the squatter

 

but fails to enforce it within two years

14.59

335

Where proceedings are discontinued or struck out more than

 

two years after the squatter’s application was rejected

14.61

336

The status of a right to be registered

14.63

336

The effect of registration

14.65

337

Introduction

14.65

337

The legal background

14.66

338

The recommendations in the Consultative Document and the response

 

on consultation

14.68

339

The provisions in the Bill

14.70

340

No trust

14.70

340

The squatter is successor in title to the previous proprietor

14.71

341

Registration of the squatter and the effect on registered charges

14.74

342

Where the squatter will be bound by charges

14.76

343

Apportionment

14.77

343

Possession proceedings

14.82

345

Introduction

14.82

345

The general rule: the registered proprietor is entitled to possession as

14.83

345

against the squatter

Exceptions: defences to possession proceedings

14.84

345

Defences which are unconnected with the squatter’s adverse

 

possession

14.84

345

Other defences

14.85

345

Reasonable mistake as to boundary

14.86

346

Where the squatter has become entitled to be registered

 

even though his or her application to be registered was

 

 

rejected

14.87

346

Special cases

14.88

347

Rentcharges

14.89

347

Trusts

14.91

347

Adverse possession by a stranger of land held in trust

14.91

347

Adverse possession by a trustee or beneficiary of land held

 

 

in trust

14.95

349

Crown foreshore

14.97

350

Transitional provisions

14.101

351

Introducing the new system

14.102

352

Preserving vested rights

14.104

352

PART XV: THE LAND REGISTRY

 

354

INTRODUCTION

15.1

354

THE LAND REGISTRY

15.2

354

CONDUCT OF BUSINESS

15.5

355

xiv

 

Paragraph

Page

ANNUAL REPORT

15.8

355

FEES

15.9

356

MISCELLANEOUS FUNCTIONS

15.11

356

Power to publish information about land

15.11

356

Consultancy and advisory services

15.12

356

PART XVI: JUDICIAL PROVISIONS

 

358

INTRODUCTION

16.1

358

THE ADJUDICATOR

16.3

359

The office of Adjudicator

16.3

359

Jurisdiction

16.6

360

The general right to object an application to the registrar and the

16.6

360

registrar’s duty to refer to contested applications to the Adjudicator

Other matters

16.8

361

PROCEEDINGS

16.11

362

Proceedings before the registrar

16.11

362

Proceedings before the Adjudicator

16.15

364

Power for the Adjudicator to direct a hearing before the court

16.20

365

Right of appeal

16.23

367

THE ROLE OF THE COURT

16.24

367

OFFENCES

16.26

368

The present law

16.26

368

The offences under the Bill

16.28

369

Suppression of information

16.28

369

Improper alteration of the registers

16.29

369

Dishonestly inducing another to change or authorise

 

 

a change to the register

16.30

369

Intentionally or recklessly making an unauthorised

 

 

change in the register

16.32

370

Privilege against self-incrimination

16.33

370

PART XVII: RULES AND ORDERS

 

372

INTRODUCTION

17.1

372

RULES

17.2

372

The present law

17.2

372

The approach to rule-making powers adopted in the Bill

17.4

373

The rule-making powers under the Bill

17.5

373

Land registration rules

17.5

373

Other rules and regulations

17.10

376

ORDERS

17.12

377

APPENDIX A: DRAFT LAND REGISTRATION BILL

379

APPENDIX B: LIST OF RESPONDENTS TO

 

 

CONSULTATIVE DOCUMENT LAW COM NO 254

602

xv

THE LAW COMMISSION AND

HM LAND REGISTRY

Item 5(a) of the Law Commission’s Seventh Programme of Law Reform

To the Right Honourable the Lord Irvine of Lairg, Lord High Chancellor of Great Britain

PART I

THE LAND REGISTRATION BILL AND ITS OBJECTIVES

INTRODUCTION

1.1The Land Registration Bill is the final outcome of six years’ joint work by the Law Commission and HM Land Registry.1 The purpose of the Bill is a bold and striking one. It is to create the necessary legal framework in which registered conveyancing can be conducted electronically. The move from a paper-based system of conveyancing to one that is entirely electronic is a very major one and it will transform fundamentally the manner in which the process is conducted. The Bill will bring about an unprecedented conveyancing revolution within a comparatively short time. It will also make other profound changes to the substantive law that governs registered land. These changes, taken together, are likely to be even more far-reaching than the great reforms of property law that were made by the 1925 property legislation. Not only will the Bill introduce a wholly different method of conveyancing, but, as we explain below, it will also alter the way in which title to land is perceived.2 The Land Registration Bill is the largest single law reform Bill and project that has been undertaken in the Law Commission since its foundation in 1965.

1.2When the Law Commission and HM Land Registry first began planning the Bill, the possibility that conveyancing might be conducted electronically had scarcely been mooted. The Consultative Document from which the Bill derives, “Land Registration for the Twenty-First Century”, which the Law Commission and HM Land Registry published in 1998,3 set the agenda for the development of dematerialised conveyancing and stimulated a good deal of public debate. There is now wide support, both within the property industry and from many legal practitioners, for the introduction of a system of dealing with land in

dematerialised form. Indeed, such a system has come to be regarded as

1The collaboration has already resulted in Land Registration Act 1997, which (amongst other things) extended the triggers to compulsory first registration and recast the provisions on indemnity.

2See below, para 1.10.

3(1998) Law Com No 254, referred to throughout this Report as “the Consultative Document”. See below, para 1.15.

1

inevitable. The Bill provides the necessary changes to the law at precisely the time when they are needed. It will enable those who deal with property to take full advantage of the developments in information technology unconstrained by out- of-date legislation.

1.3In this Part we explain¾

(1)the objectives of the Bill and the thinking behind them;

(2)some key features of the Bill; and

(3)the background to the Bill and how it has come about.

THE OBJECTIVES OF THE BILL

1.4We have explained above that a system of conveyancing conducted in dematerialised form is now regarded as inevitable.4 Dealings with land cannot remain unaffected by the general development of electronic commerce. Nevertheless, however inevitable it may now seem, there is a legitimate public expectation that the change to an electronically based system for dealings with land will produce clear and demonstrable benefits. The public rightly seeks a more expeditious and much less stressful system of dealing with land. It also wants to see better protection for title to land and for the rights and interests that exist in land. The Bill attempts to meet these expectations.

1.5The fundamental objective of the Bill is that, under the system of electronic dealing with land that it seeks to create, the register should be a complete and accurate reflection of the state of the title of the land at any given time, so that it is possible to investigate title to land on line, with the absolute minimum of additional enquiries and inspections.

1.6Although that ultimate objective5 may seem an obvious one, its implications are considerable, and virtually all the changes that the Bill makes to the present law flow directly from it. The Bill is necessarily limited in its scope to registered land or to dealings with unregistered land in England and Wales that will trigger first registration. Although the great majority of titles are in fact now registered, there are still substantial amounts of land (particularly in rural areas) that are unregistered. However, as we explain in Part II, unregistered land has had its day.6 In the comparatively near future, it will be necessary to take steps to bring what is left of it on to the register.7

1.7The process of registration of title is conducted by the State through the agency of HM Land Registry. Indeed, the State guarantees the title to registered land.

4

5

6

7

See above, para 1.2.

It will not be achieved at once. See below, para 2.9.

See below, para 2.13.

2

If, therefore, any person suffers loss as a result of some mistake or omission in the register of title, he or she is entitled to be indemnified for that loss. At present, there is no requirement that a disposition of registered land has to be entered in the register if it is to be effective. Even without registration, dispositions are valid not only between the parties to them, but as against many but not necessarily all third parties who subsequently acquire an interest in the same registered land. This is a necessity under the present law because there is a hiatus ¾ called the “registration gap” ¾ between the making of any disposition and its subsequent registration. The transfer or grant has to be submitted to the Land Registry for registration, which inevitably takes some time.8 It would be wholly unacceptable for the transfer or grant to have no legal effect in that interim period. It should be noted that there are some interests in registered land, presently known as overriding interests, which are not protected in the register at all but which nonetheless bind any person who subsequently acquires an interest in the land affected. This is so whether or not that person knew of, or could readily have discovered, the existence of these interests.

1.8If it is to be possible to achieve the fundamental objective of the Bill mentioned in paragraph 1.5 above¾

(1)all express dispositions of registered land will have to be appropriately protected on the register unless there are very good reasons for no doing so;

(2)the categories of overriding interests will have to be very significantly reduced in scope; and

(3)dispositions of registered land will have to be registered simultaneously, so that it becomes impossible to make most dispositions of registered land except by registering them.

The aim stated in (3) will be possible only if conveyancing practitioners are authorised to initiate the process of registration when dispositions of registered land are made by their clients. This is a very significant departure from present practice.

1.9To achieve the goals stated in paragraph 1.8 will also require a change in attitude. There is a widely-held perception that it is unreasonable to expect people to register their rights over land. We find this puzzling given the overwhelming prevalence of registered title. Furthermore, the law has long required compliance with certain formal requirements for the transfer of interests in land and for contracts to sell or dispose of such interests. The wisdom of these requirements is not seriously questioned. We cannot see why the further step of registration should be regarded as so onerous. In any event, under the system of electronic conveyancing that we envisage (and for which the Bill makes provision), not only

8Registration is effective from the time when an application is taken to have been received in the Registry.

3

will the process of registration become very much easier, but the execution of the transaction in electronic form and its simultaneous registration will be inextricably linked.

1.10These changes will necessarily alter the perception of title to land. It will be the fact of registration and registration alone that confers title. This is entirely in accordance with the fundamental principle of a conclusive register which underpins the Bill.9

SOME KEY FEATURES OF THE BILL

1.11It may be helpful to list some of the most striking changes that the Bill will either introduce as soon as it is brought into force or allow to be introduced subsequently. Two of the main changes¾in relation to the introduction of electronic conveyancing and the recasting of the law on adverse possession¾call for specific comment.

Electronic conveyancing

1.12The Bill will create a framework in which it will be possible to transfer and create interests in registered land by electronic means. It is envisaged that, within a comparatively short time, it will it will be the only method of conducting registered conveyancing. As we have indicated above,10 an essential feature of the electronic system when it is fully operational is that it will be impossible to create or transfer many rights in or over registered land expressly except by registering them. Investigation of title will be almost entirely online. It is intended that the secure electronic communications network on which the system will be based, will be used to provide information about properties for intending buyers. It will also provide a means of managing a chain of transactions by monitoring them electronically. This will enable the cause of delays in any chain to be identified and remedial action encouraged. It is anticipated that far fewer chains will break in consequence and that transactions will be considerably expedited. Faster conveyancing is also likely to provide the most effective way of curbing gazumping. The process of registration under the electronic system will be initiated by solicitors and licensed conveyancers, though the Land Registry will exercise control over the changes that can be made to the register. Electronic conveyancing will not come into being as soon as the Bill is brought into force. It will be introduced over a number of years, and there will be a time when both the paper and electronic systems co-exist.

Adverse possession

1.13The Bill abandons the notion that a squatter acquires title once he or she has been in adverse possession for 12 years. It creates new rules in relation to registered land that will confer greater protection against the acquisition of title

9See above, para 1.5.

10See para 1.8.

4

by persons in adverse possession. This is consistent with one of the objectives of the Bill¾that it is registration alone that should confer title.11 The essence of the new scheme is that a squatter will be able to apply to be registered as proprietor after 10 years’ adverse possession. However, the registered proprietor will be notified of that application and will, in most cases, be able to object to it.12 If he or she does, the application will be rejected. However, the proprietor will then have to take steps to evict the squatter or otherwise regularise his or her position within two years. If the squatter is still in adverse possession after two years, he or she will be entitled to be registered as proprietor. We consider that this new scheme strikes a fairer balance between landowner and squatter than does the present law. It also reflects the fact that the basis of title to registered land is the fact of registration, not (as is the case with unregistered land) possession.

Other changes

1.14Some of the other striking changes that the Bill makes can be summarised as follows¾

¨the requirement of compulsory registration of title is to be extended to leases granted for more than 7 years, with power to reduce the length of registrable leases still further;

¨in favour of those dealing with them, owners of registered land will be presumed to have unrestricted powers of disposition in the absence of any entry on the register;

¨the rules as to the competing priority of interests in registered land will be clarified and simplified;

¨the protection for rights in or over registered land will be simplified and improved by the extension of notices and restrictions and the prospective abolition of cautions and inhibitions;

¨the range of overriding interests will be significantly restricted in their scope: the ambit of particular categories of overriding interests will be narrowed, some categories will be abolished altogether and others will be phased out after 10 years;

¨it will become possible to access the history of a registered title (to the extent that the Registry has it) if there is a reason to see it;

¨charge certificates will be abolished and land certificates will have a much less important role;

¨Crown land, including much of the foreshore around England and Wales, that is not presently registrable will become so; and

11See above, para 1.10.

12If there is no objection to the application, the squatter will be registered.

5