Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Экзамен зачет учебный год 2023 / [Andreas_Fllesdal,_Birgit_Peters,_Geir_Ulfstein]-1

.pdf
Скачиваний:
1
Добавлен:
20.12.2022
Размер:
2.22 Mб
Скачать

bibliography

427

Thallinger, G. Sense and Sensibility of the Human Rights Obligations of the United Nations Security Council, Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 67 (2007) 101540

Tomuschat, C. Case Law Comment, Common Market Law Review 43 (2006) 53751

Die staatsrechtliche Entscheidung für die internationale Offenheit, J. Isensee and P. Kirchhoff (eds.), Handbuch des Staatsrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Vol. VII (Heidelberg: C. F. Müller, 1992) 483524

Human Rights Between Idealism and Realism, 2nd edn (Oxford University Press, 2008)

Human Rights in a Multi-Level System of Governance and the Internment of Suspected Terrorists, Melbourne Journal of International Law 9 (2008) 391404

The Effects of the Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights According to the German Constitutional Court, German Law Journal 11 (2006) 51326 The Kadi Case: What Relationship is there between the Universal Legal Order under the Auspices of the United Nations and the EU Legal Order?,

Yearbook of European Law 28 (2009) 65463

Torres Pérez, A. Conicts of Rights in the European Union: A Theory of Supranational Adjudication (Oxford University Press, 2009)

Tridimas, T. and Gutierrez-Fons, J.A. EU Law, International Law, and Economic Sanctions against Terrorism: The Judiciary in Distress?, Fordham International Law Journal 32 (20089) 660730

Tsakyrakis, S. Proportionality: An Assault on Human Rights?, International Journal of Constitutional Law 7:3 (2009) 46893

Proportionality: An Assault on Human Rights?: A Rejoinder to Madhav Khosla, International Journal of Constitutional Law 8:2 (2010) 30710

Tulkens, F. The European Convention on Human Rights between International Law and Constitutional Law, in ECtHR (ed.), Dialogue between Judges (Strassbourg: Council of Europe, 2007) 815

and Donnay L. Lusage de la marge dappréciation par la Cour européenne des droits de lhomme. Paravent juridique superu ou mécanisme indispensable par nature?, Revue de science criminelle et de droit pénal comparé 1 (2006) 323

Tzanakopoulos, A. United Nations in Domestic Courts: From Interpretation to Deance in Abdelrazik v. Canada, Journal of International Criminal Justice

8 (2010) 24967

Tzevelekos, V.P. The Use of Article 31(3)(c) of the VCLT in the Case Law of the ECtHR: An Effective Anti-Fragmentation Tool for the Reinforcement of Human Rights Teleology? Between Evolution and Systemic Integration,

Michigan Journal of International Law 31 (2010) 62190

Ulfstein, G. International Constitutionalization: A Research Agenda, Guest Editorial, ESIL Newsletter (2010)

428

bibliography

The International Judiciary, in J. Klabbers, G. Ulfstein and A. Peters (eds.),

The Constitutionalization of International Law (Oxford University Press, 2009) 12652

van Drooghenbroeck, S. La proportionnalité dans le droit de la Convention européenne des droits de lhomme Prendre lidée simple au sérieux (Brussels: Bruylant, 2001)

Vitruk, N.V. O nekotorykh osobennostyakh ispolzovaniya resheniy Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka v. pratike Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Fedreratsii i inykh sudov, Sravnitelnoe konsituttsionnoe obozrenie, 1 (2006)

Voeten, E. Politics, Judicial Behavior, and Institutional Design, in Christoffersen and Madsen (eds.), The European Court of Human Rights between Law and Politics, 6176

The Impartiality of International Judges: Evidence from the European Court of Human Rights, American Political Science Review 102:4 (2008) 41733

von Bernstorff, J. Kerngehalte im Grundund Menschenrechtsschutz (Berlin: Duncker und Humboldt, 2012)

von Bogdandy, A. On the Democratic Legitimation of International Judicial Lawmaking, German Law Journal 12 (2011) 134170

Pluralism, Direct Effect, and the Ultimate Say: On the Relationship between International and Domestic Constitutional Law, International Journal of Constitutional Law 6 (2008) 397413

Prinzipien der Rechtsfortbildung im europäischen Rechtsraum: Überlegungen zum Lissabon-Urteil des BVerfGE, Neue Juristische Wochenzeitung 63:1 (2010) 15

and Venzke, I. International Judicial Institutions as Lawmakers, German Law Journal 12:5 (2011) 9791004

von Staden, A. The Democratic Legitimacy of Judicial Review Beyond the State: Normative Subsidiarity and Judicial Standards of Review, Jean-Monnet Working Paper 10/11 (2011)

Voßkuhle, A. Europa als Gegenstand wissenschaftlicher Reexion eine thematische Annäherung in 12 Thesen, C. Franzius et al. (eds.), Strukturfragen der Europäischen Union (Baden-Baden: Nomos 2011) 3745

Multilevel Cooperation of the European Constitutional Courts: Der Europäische Verfassungsgerichtsverbund, European Constitutional Law Review 6 (2010) 17598

Voyiakis, A. International Law and the Objectivity of Value, Leiden Journal of International Law 22:1 (2009) 5178

Wagner, A. Bill of Rights Commission publishes advice (and squabbles) on European Court of Human Rights reform, UK Human Rights Blog (9 September 2011)

Waldock, H. The Effectiveness of the System set up by the European Convention on Human Rights, Human Rights Law Journal 1 (1980) 112

bibliography

429

Waldron, J. Judges as Moral Reasoners, International Journal of Constitutional Law 7 (2009) 224

The Core of the Case against Judicial Review, Yale Law Journal 115 (2006) 13461406

Weiler, J.H.H. UnEuropa Cristiana: Un saggio esplorativo (Saggi: BUR, 2003) Editorial, European Journal of International Law 21:1 (2010) 16

Wheatley, S. Minorities under the ECHR and the Construction of a Democratic Society, Public Law (2007) 77092

White, R. and Ovey, R. The European Convention on Human Rights, 5th edn (Oxford University Press, 2010)

Wieacker, F. Geschichtliche Wurzeln des Prinzips der verhältnismäßigen Anwendung, M. Lutter, W. Simpel and H. Wiedemann (eds.), Festschrift für Robert Fischer (Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter, 1997) 86781

Wildhaber, L. A Constitutional Future for the European Court of Human Rights?, Human Rights Law Journal 23:5/7 (2002) [N.P. Engel] 1615

Europäischer Grundrechtsschutz aus der Sicht des Europäischen Gerichtshofs für Menschenrechte, Europäische Grundrechtezeitschrift (2005) 68992

Rethinking the European Court of Human Rights, in Christoffersen and Madsen (eds.), The European Court of Human Rights between Law and Politics, 20429

The European Court of Human Rights in Action, Ritsumeikan Law Review 83 (2004) 8392

Winkler, S. Der Beitritt der Europäischen Gemeinschaften zur Europäischen Menschenrechtskonvention (Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2000)

Worster, W.T. Competition and Comity in the Fragmentation of International Law, Brooklyn Journal of International Law 34:1 (2008) 11949

Young, K.A. The Law and Process of the U.N. Human Rights Committee (The Procedural Aspects of International Law Monograph Series) (Ardsley, New York: Transnational Publishers, 2002)

Yourow, H.C. The Margin of Appreciation Doctrine in the Dynamics of European Human Rights Jurisprudence (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1996)

Zappalà, S. Reviewing Security Council Measures in the Light of International Human Rights Principles, in Fassbender (ed.), Securing Human Rights? Achievements and Challenges of the UN Security Council, 17294

Zaum, D., The Security Council, the General Assembly, and War: The Uniting for Peace Resolution, in V. Lowe et al. (eds.), The United Nations Security Council and War (Oxford University Press, 2008) 15474

Zimnenko, B.L. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo in pravovaya sistema Rossiyskoy Federatsii

(Moscow: Statut, 2006)

INDEX

accession of EU to ECHR, 89, 23, 30133, 398

Bosphorus doctrine and, 31012, 332 co-respondent mechanism and,

32531, 398

current suspension of negotiations, 31920

Discussion Documenton (ECJ), 31516, 321

European Commission and, 313, 315, 322

new issues raised by, xi, 4 point or purpose of, 3303

prior involvement mechanism and, 31317, 320, 328, 3312, 398

procedural issues and, 58 relationship between ECJ and

ECtHR prior to, 3018 role of European courts in

negotiations, 31218 administration and budget of ECtHR,

2918

administrative discretion, origins in concept of margin of appreciation in, 645

Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organisation (ILOAT), 337

admissibility criteria, 368, 513, 559, 391

advisory opinion of ECtHR on election of judges, 26871

advisory opinions, 4850 Albania

legal representation in, 48 remedies in unfair domestic legal

proceedings, 152

Alexy, Robert, 75, 82

Andenas, Mads, vii, 22, 181, 392, 3978, 401

Andorra

legal representation in, 48 responsibility for administration of

justice in, 351

Arai-Takahashi, Yutaka, vii, 21, 62, 397, 399

Armenia, legal representation in, 48 Article 46 judgments, 161, 16671 asymmetrical relationship between ECJ

and ECtHR, 3023 Austria

court fees in, 46

legal representation in, 48 authority-based legitimacy, 12635 autonomous concepts doctrine, 113,

122, 124, 18990

Azerbaijan, legal representation in, 48

Bandinter, Robert, 236 Barkhuysen, T., 55 Belgium

judges, nomination of, 267 legal representation in, 48

national implementation of ECHR rights in, 2046, 260

Bernhardt, Rudolf, 1 Bernstorff, Jochen von, 234

Besselink, Leonard, vii, 23, 301, 392, 398, 4001

Bingham, Lord, 2034

Bjorge, Eirik, vii, 22, 181, 392, 3979, 401

blacklists, UN, 338 Bogdandy, Armin von, 183

430

index

431

Bosnia and Herzegovina

pilot judgment procedures involving, 1634

remedies in unfair domestic legal proceedings, 152

UN peacekeepers and military operations in, 344, 356

Bosphorus doctrine, 31012, 332, 3803, 400

Bratza, Sir Nicholas, 213 Brauch, J. A., 81 Breyer, S., 42

Brighton Declaration (2012), 3, 6, 8, 4354, 178, 299

budget and administration of ECtHR, 2918

Bulgaria, pilot judgment procedures involving, 162

Cameron, Iain, vii, 201, 25, 390, 3947 Canada, on travel bans, 371

Carozza, Paolo G., 91 Cassese, Antonio, 352, 356

CDDH (Steering Committee for Human Rights), 447, 501, 279

Centre for Advanced Study, Norway, xi Chechnya, 171, 174

Christoffersen, Jonas, 2, 4 CJEU. See Court of Justice of the

European Union (CJEU) and ECtHR

Clarke, Kenneth, 166 coordination-based legitimacy, 1335 co-respondent mechanism, 32531, 398 Cohen-Eliya, Moshe, 94, 104

CoM. See Committee of Ministers comity, principle of, 1516, 401 commitment-based legitimacy, 126,

13641

committee form, decision of cases in, 53 Committee of Ministers (CoM)

advisory opinion of ECtHR on election of judges and, 26871

budget of ECtHR and, 2914 expert panel to advise on election of

judges, 2725

implementation of Court judgments by, 27591, 398

judges, involvement in election of, 264, 266, 26875, 2968

Liaison Committee, 295 relationship with ECtHR and

PACE, 264, 288, 299300, 395, 397

remedies used by ECtHR and, 152, 161, 176, 179

Resolution (97)9 on status and conditions of service of ECtHR judges, 2968

unfair domestic legal proceedings, re-opening of, 152

voting rights, 31920

common law, development of rights in, 2034

competing rights and freedoms, balancing, 778

consistency issues case law, 534, 60

margin of appreciation doctrine, 7980

principles, Court obligation of consistency of, 140 constitutional issues, 11, 106, 332,

3901, 394, 402

Costa, Jean-Paul, 186, 272, 2945 Council of Europe institutions and ECtHR, 8, 223, 263300.

See also Committee of Ministers; Parliamentary Assembly of Council of Europe

autonomy of ECtHR, 2948 budget and administration, 2918

implementation of Court judgments, 27591, 398

judges, election of, 26475

judicial role of Court, expansion of, 2634

relationship between PACE, CoM, and ECtHR, 264, 288, 299300, 3945

court fees, proposal to introduce, 467

Court of First Instance of the European Union (CFI; now General Court), on freezing orders,

3746

432

index

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and ECtHR.

See also European Court of Justice CFI (now General Court) on freezing

orders, 3746

EU and ECtHR, relationship between, 89, 23

general interpretative guidelines for national courts, CJEUs efforts to create, 49

prior review by CJEU, 392 proportionality, use of principle

of, 19

relationship between, xi, 4 subsidiarity principle and, 400

CPT (European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment), 207

Crawford, James, 181, 190 Croatia, legal representation in, 48

cultural values, recognition/rejection of, 97103

Czech Republic

legal representation in, 48 national implementation of

ECHR rights in, 1845, 192, 2023, 260

damages, pecuniary and nonpecuniary, 1478

de minimis rule, 391, 396

democratic control and independence of Court, balancing, 14

detainees, release of, 15760 Directorate General for Human Rights,

265

Dublin Regulation, 333

Dworkin, Ronald, 76, 823, 86, 124, 140

dynamic interpretation doctrine, 2, 21, 10641, 397

after reform of Protocol 11 (1998), 11522

autonomous concepts doctrine and, 113, 122, 124

before reform of Protocol 11 (1998), 10915

common or shared standards as factor, 108

constitutions and, 106 emergent consensus or common

value, reliance on, 11622 human rights law and, 1078 legitimacy of moral reading of

ECHR, 1256.

See also legitimacy of ECtHR margin of appreciation versus, 89,

11315, 121, 125, 188

moral reading of ECHR, 1225, 397 national implementation of ECHR

rights and, 1856, 188, 1902, 259

present-day standards as factor, 108 respondent states standards,

decisive importance not assigned to, 109

ECHR. See European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms

ECJ. See European Court of Justice ECSC (European Coal and Steel

Community) protections regarding international organisations, 334

ECtHR. See European Court of Human Rights

effective control doctrine, 3507 effectiveness, principle of, 1012, 1719, 263, 278, 3968

efciency of ECtHR system, 3956 Eisenhower, Dwight, 42

enforced disappearance cases, 171 erga omnes, 3, 53

Estonia, legal representation in, 48 EULEX, 359

European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) protections regarding international organisations, 334

European Commission, on accession of EU to ECHR, 313, 315, 322

European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT), 207

index

433

European consensus

dynamic interpretation doctrine and, 10915

margin of appreciation doctrine and, 879, 99100

European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR). See also accession of EU to ECHR; dynamic interpretation doctrine; national implementation of ECHR rights

effectiveness, principle of, 1719 effectuation of, ECtHRs focus on, 2 extra-territorial jurisdiction under

Article 1 ECHR, 3616, 392, 398

immunity of EU action under (Bosphorus doctrine), 31012, 332

moral reading of, 1225

procedural statute, creation of, 446 European Court of Human Rights

(ECtHR), xi

accession of EU to ECHR and, 89, 23, 30133, 398.

See also accession of EU to ECHR

advisory opinions on election of judges, 26871

autonomy of, 2948

budget and administration, 2918 changing circumstances and

institutional setting, in 16 CJEU and, xi, 4. See also Court of

Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and ECtHR

common legal principles guiding analysis of, xii, 1012

Council of Europe institutions and, 8, 223, 263300. See also Council of Europe institutions and ECtHR

democratic control and independence of Court, balancing, 14

dynamic interpretation doctrine, 2, 21, 10641, 397.

See also dynamic interpretation doctrine

ECJ, relationship to, 3018, 317 efciency of, 3956

EU and, 89, 23, 30133.

See also European Union and ECtHR

expert panel to advise on election of judges, 2725

extra-territiorial jurisdiction, 3616, 392, 398

implementation of judgments, role in, 276, 291

importance of decisions for fundamental rights conceptions, 391

international organisations and, 910, 3345

judges, Court involvement in election of, 26875

judicial cooperation and interaction, principles governing, 1517

judicial role, expansion of, 2634 jus dicere role of, 263

legitimacy issues, 1215, 38994. See also legitimacy of ECtHR

margin of appreciation doctrine, 21, 62105. See also margin of appreciation doctrine

member states and, 68, 201 national courts and, 22, 181262,

3978. See also national implementation of ECHR rights

procedural issues, 201, 2561. See also procedural issues

remedies, 22, 14280, 397. See also remedies

success rates of applicants, 391 UN and, 4, 24, 33488, 392.

See also United Nations and ECtHR

European Court of Justice (ECJ) accession negotiations, role in,

31218

autonomy and uniqueness, efforts to protect, 331

co-respondent mechanism and, 329, 331

434

index

European Court of Justice (ECJ) (cont.) Discussion Documenton accession negotiations, 31516, 321 exhaustion of domestic remedies,

332

freezing orders, on 37287

Joint Communication with ECtHR on accession, 317

national enforcement of international directions or orders, on 3678

prior involvement mechanism, 31317, 320, 328, 3312, 398

relationship between ECtHR and ECJ prior to EU accession to ECHR, 3018

standard of scrutiny for claims regarding fundamental rights, 303

European Union and ECtHR, 89, 23, 30133. See also accession of EU to ECHR

Bosphorus doctrine, 31012, 332 co-respondent mechanism, 32531,

398

ECJ and ECtHR, 3018

Foreign and Security Policy of EU, 31920

national enforcement of international directions or orders, 3678

evolutive interpretation. See dynamic interpretation

exhaustion of domestic remedies, 53, 332

expert panel to advise on election of judges, 2725

expertise-based legitimacy, 12933 extra-territorial jurisdiction of ECtHR,

3616, 392, 398

FAO (Food and Agriculture

Organisation), 337

fees, proposal to introduce, 467 ltering, 335, 501, 57 Føllesdal, Andreas, viii, 1, 389

Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), 337

Foreign and Security Policy, EU, 31920

France

accession of EU to ECHR, objections to, 319

administrative discretion in, 65 Andorra, responsibility for

administration of justice in, 351 appeals accepted by Cours de

Cassation, 56

legal representation in, 48 national implementation of ECHR

rights in, 1947, 217, 219, 236, 260

Franck, Thomas, 14 freezing orders, 37287 FREMP (Working Party on

Fundamental Rights, Citizens Rights and Free Movement of Persons), 318, 320

Gaja, Giorgio, 346

General Court (formerly Court of First Instance of the European Union or CFI), on freezing orders, 3746

Georgia, legal representation in, 48 Germany

administrative discretion in, 65 federal responsibility for interests of

Länder in, 341

national implementation of ECHR rights in, 183, 21837, 239, 2601

pilot judgment procedures involving, 163

Giegerich, Thomas, 219

good faith, obligation of ECtHR to reason in, 140

Grant, Ruth W., 276

Greece, pilot judgment procedures involving, 163

Greer, Stephen, 74, 845

Group of Wise Persons Report (2007), 302, 57, 295

Guyomar, Mattias, 195, 217

Habermas, Jürgen, 1045

Hale, Lady, 193, 2034

index

435

Hart, H. L. A., 723

Hölderlin, Friedrich, 233

HRC (Human Rights Committee),

UN, 339

Huber, Max, 192

Human Rights Committee (HRC),

UN, 339

Hungary, legal representation in, 48

IACtHR. See Inter-American Court of Human Rights

ICCPR. See International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights

ICESCR (International Covenant on Social, Economic and Cultural Rights), no withdrawal from ratication of, 107

ICJ (International Court of Justice), responsibility doctrine of, 353, 3556

ICTY (International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia), 336, 352

ILC (International Law Commission), 346, 34950

ILOAT (Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organisation), 337

immunity of EU action under ECHR (Bosphorus doctrine), 31012, 332

implementation of ECHR rights Court judgments, CoM

implementation of, 27591, 398

national implementation.

See national implementation of ECHR rights

implied powers doctrine, 1012, 15, 263, 278, 3945

inadmissibility criteria, 368, 513, 559, 391

inconsistency. See consistency issues independence of the Court and

democratic control, balancing, 14

individual rights and public interests, balancing, 747

institutional/structural dimension of subsidiarity and margin of appreciation, 923

Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR)

budget of, 293 remedies of, 22, 1727

interim measures, requests for, 52 Interlaken Declaration (2010), 6, 35,

4354, 178

International Court of Justice (ICJ), responsibility doctrine of, 353, 3556

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)

ECHR and, 339

no withdrawal from ratication of, 107

International Covenant on Social, Economic and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), no withdrawal from ratication of, 107

International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), 336, 352

international directions or orders, national enforcement of. See national enforcement

of international directions or orders

International Law Commission (ILC), 346, 34950

international organisations.

See also specic institutions

ECSC and, 334

ECtHR and, 910, 3345 legitimacy of, 11

interpretation of ECHR. See dynamic interpretation doctrine, margin of appreciation doctrine

Iraq, international military operations in, 347, 359, 3646

Italy

legal representation in, 48 national implementation of ECHR

rights in, 2379, 260 repetitive cases, 41

Izmir Declaration (2011), 6, 4354

436

index

Joint Communication of ECJ and ECtHR on accession, 317

judges

advisory opinion of ECtHR on election of, 26871

CoM involvement in election of, 264, 266, 26875, 2968

Court involvement in election of, 26875

election to ECtHR by PACE, 26475 expert panel to advise on election of,

2725

member states, nomination by, 2667, 3023

national implementation of ECHR rights and, 259

procedural issues and, 335, 38 Resolution (97)9 on status and

conditions of service of, 2968 judicial cooperation and interaction,

principles governing, 1517 judicial deference and judicial restraint,

65

judicial dialogue between ECtHR and ECJ, 3068

jus cogens, 137

jus dicere role of ECtHR, 263

Keller, Helen, 182, 206, 259, 389 Keohane, Robert O., 276 Khodorkovsky, Mihail, 158, 184, 261 Korean War, 358

Koskenniemi, Martii, 91 Kosovo, international military

operations in, 348, 3513, 358, 360, 365

Kumm, Mathias, 17

Kuwait, international military operations in, 347

Lambert-Abdelgawad, Elisabeth, viii, 223, 3945, 3978

Latvia, legal representation in, 48 Leach, Philip, viii, 22, 142, 391, 398 legal representation before ECtHR, 478 legitimacy, national. See national

sovereignty

legitimacy of ECtHR, 1215, 38994

authority-based legitimacy, 12635 causes of and explanations for crisis

regarding, 3934 coordination-based legitimacy,

1335

commitment-based legitimacy, 126, 13641

continuing scepticism about and rejection of, 38990, 3923

expertise-based legitimacy, 12933 good faith application of consistent

principles, as 140

moral reading of ECHR, justication for, 1256

procedural issues and, 5461 legitimacy of international institutions

generally, 11

Letsas, George, viii, 21, 74, 93, 106, 1234, 391, 393, 397

Liaison Committee between CoM and ECtHR, 295

Libya, international military operations in, 349, 359

Liechtenstein, legal representation in, 48 Lisbon Treaty, 910, 309, 311, 316 Lithuania, Article 46 judgments against,

170

living instrument, ECHR as. See dynamic interpretation doctrine

London, Treaty of (1949), 1 Luxembourg, legal representation

in, 48

Maastricht Treaty, 303 Macdonald, Ronald. St. J., 63

Macedonia, former Yugoslav Republic of, legal representation in, 48

Madsen, Mikael Rask, 2, 4 Mahoney, Paul, 1

majoritarian preferences, 967, 101, 123, 397

Manneken Pis (Petit Julien), 304 Marchenko, Mihail N., 240

margin of appreciation doctrine, 21, 62105

administrative discretion, origins in concept of, 645