
ИГПЗС учебный год 2023 / Dynastic Right
.pdf42 |
GIESEY: DYNASTIC RIGHT TO THE FRENCH THRONE [TRANS. AMER. PHIL. SOC. |
sistently connected the present king's status with an ancient act of the Estates, or the "Mystical Body of the Realm"; the idea of the Princes of the Blood nowhere suggests any such relationship between the crown and the people. Indeed, when the birth of Louis XIV was celebrated on a medal as the Ortus Solis Gallici, "the
rising of the Gallic sun," and the babe Louis pictured as a young Apollo rising in his chariot, we have so far lost the constitutional bearings of royal legitimacy that it seems to issue from the will of the Almighty.'59 The quantity of artistic and literary propaganda in the reign of Louis XIV that branded men's minds with this kind of thought will be found to outweigh by far the kind of legal-juristic speculation which still had predominated in the sixteenth century.
159 Medailles sur |
Ics |
principaux evenements du regne de |
Louis le Grand, 2, |
Paris, |
1702, in 4?. |
conceited act of Louis XIV to bring the hearts of deceased members of the royal family together in a royal shrine at Val-de-Gracel60 indicates that the Sun-King had deceived himself about the existence of a mystique
de sang royal.
Without accusing Prince Sixte de Bourbon of har- boring such feelings as these in the twentieth century, we may still wonder whether he would not have found, had he looked deeper into his heritage, that the progres- sive exaltation of the Princes of the Blood-as if they were called at the moment of birth to greatness and distinction, instead of merely enjoying the chance that the law some day would call them to a great duty-was a kind of self-centeredness that led the Capetian dynasty away from the vital juristic basis of the fundamental law.
160See J.-J.-J. Servier, Le Val-de-Grace,35-41, Paris, 1888.
REFERENCES
D'ANGLEBERME,JEAN PYRRHUS. 1584. De suitate et haereditate per fictionem transmittenda. Ed. Tractatus Uni-
versi Juris [below] 8(2). |
|
|
|
Paris. |
||
1517. |
Index Opusculorum |
Pyrrhi Anglebermei. |
||||
AQUINAS, THOMAS.1947-1948. Summa |
Theologica. 3 v. |
|||||
New York, Benziger Bros. |
|
in |
|
|
||
BALDUS DE UBALDUS. 1576. Commentaria |
primam |
Digesti |
||||
Veteris |
partem. |
Turin. |
|
|
|
|
. 1580. |
In feudorum usus commentaria. |
Venice. |
|
|||
.1589. |
Consilia. |
Frankfort. |
|
Gulielmi Benedicti |
||
BENEDICTI, GUILLAUME. |
1575. |
Repetitio |
. . . in cap. Raynutius de testamentis. 4 v. in 1. Lyon. BIGNON,JEROME.1610. De l'Excellence des rois et du royaume
de France. Paris.
ETIENNE. 1902. igtude sur Francois Hotman. BLOCAILLE,
Dijon.
BLOCH,MARC. 1924. Les rois thaumaturges. Strasbourg.
BODIN, JEAN. 1590. Lettre de M. Bodin, officer a Laon, a
|
l'un de ses amis tres meschant du temps. Paris. |
|||||
. |
1593. Les six livres de la Republique. Lyon. |
|
||||
-. |
1945. Method for |
the easy comprehensionof |
history. |
|||
|
Transl. Beatrice Reynolds. New York. |
|
||||
BOHIER,NICHOLAS. 1543. |
Consuetudines |
Bituricenses. |
Paris. |
|||
. 1579. D. N. Boerii Decisiones Burdegalenses. Lyon. |
||||||
BONAUD DE SAUSET, JACQUES. |
1526. |
Panegyricus. |
Lyon. |
|||
|
(Appendix to 1526 edition of Terre Rouge-see below.) |
|||||
|
DOMMARTIN. |
(Ed.) |
1827-1871. Recueil des his- |
|||
BOUQUET, |
|
|
|
|
||
|
toriens des Gaules et de la France. 19 v. Paris. |
|
||||
BOURBON DE PARME, Prince |
Sixte |
de. |
1914. Le |
traite |
||
|
d'Utrecht et les lois fondamentalesdu royaume. Paris. |
|||||
BUCKLAND,W. W., and A. D. McNAIR. |
1936. Roman law |
and common law. Cambridge.
CENIVAL,P. DE. 1911. Un documentrelatif a la succession de Charles IX. Bibl. de l'tc. des Chartes 72: 222-225.
CHAUVIRE,ROGER.1914. Jean Bodin, auteur de la "Republique." Paris.
CHENON, EMILE. 1926-1929. Histoire generale du droit fran- cais. 2 v. Paris.
Chronographiaregum francorum. 1891-1897. Ed. H. Moranville. 3 v. Paris.
CHURCH, WILLIAM F. 1941. Constitutional thought in six- teenth-century France. Cambridge, Harvard Univ.
Press.
COQUILLE,GUY. 1607. Institution du droict des Francois. Paris.
Corpus Iuris Canonici. 1879-1881. Ed. Emil Friedberg. 2 v.
Leipzig.
1559. Decretales Gregorii Noni Pontificis. Lyon.
1559. Decretum D. Gratiani. Lyon.
1586. Liber Sextus . . . cum Clementinis et Extrava- gantibus. Frankfort.
Corpus Iuris Civilis. 1562. 5 v. Lyon.
. 1915. Ed. Th. Mommsenand P. Kreuger. 3 v. Berlin.
Le Debat des herauts d'armesde France et d'Angleterre. 1877. Ed. Leopold Pannier. Paris.
DEL GIUDICE,P. 1892-1893. La storia di una frase. Commento all' articolo 2 dello Statuto del Regno. Rendiconti del Reale Istituto Lombardodi scienze e littere, 2d ser., 25: 428-443; 26: 304-319.
Du MOULIN,CHARLES. 1624. Opera. 3 v. Paris.
DUPUY, PIERRE. 1670. Traitez touchant les droits du roy tres chrestien. Rouen.
DU TILLET, JEAN. 1607. Recueil des roys de France . . .
ensemble,le rang des grands de France. Paris.
Les Etablissementsde saint Louis. 1881-1886. Ed. Paul Viollet. 4 v. Paris.
FERRAULT,JEAN. 1545. Tractatus iura seu privilegia aliqua regni Franciae continens. Paris.
FEU, JEAN. 1539-1541. Prima [et secunda] pars commentariorum Joannis Ignei. 2 v. Lyon.
FIGGIS,JOHN N. 1914. The divine right of kings. Cambridge. FORTESCUE,SIR JOHN. 1885. The governance of England.
Ed. Charles Plummer. Oxford.
FRANTZ. 1912. L'Ancienne France: le roi. FUNCK-BRETANO,
Paris.
GALEN. 1542. De naturalibus facultatibus. Ed. Opera Galeni 1. Basel.
GERSON,JEAN. 1706. Opera Omnia. Ed. Ellies du Pin. 5 v.
Antwerp.
GIESEY,RALPH E. 1960. The French Estates and the Corpus
Mysticum Regni. Album Helen Maud Cam [=Etudes presenteesa la CommissionInternationalepour l'Histoire
des Assemblees d'Etats 23:] 153-171.
.1960. The royal funeral ceremonyin renaissanceFrance.
[= Travaux d'humanisme et Renaissance 37.] Geneva,
Librairie Droz.
GLASSON,E. 1892. Le Droit de succession au moyen age. Nouvelle revue historique de droit francais et etranger,
3rd ser., 16: 555-591.
.1887-1903. Histoire du droit et des institutions de la France. 8 v. Paris.
GODEFROY,THEODORE1649. . Le ceremonial francois. 2 v.
Paris.
GRASSAILLE, CHARLES DE. 1545. Regalium franciae libri duo. Paris.
HALL,EDWARD1809. . Hall's Chronicle. London.
ROBERT. 1910. FranzSsische VerfassungsgeschHOLTZMANN,
ichte. Munich and Berlin.
HOTMAN,FRANCOIS. 1573. Francogallia. Geneva.
1585. Disputatio de controversia successionis regiae inter patruumet fratris praemortuifilium. Frankfort. 1586. Idem. Geneva.
1588. De Jure successionis regiae in regno Francorum.
N.p.
.1599-1600. Operum tomus primus [-tertius]. Ed. Jacques Lect. 3 v. Geneva.
ISAMBERT,FRANCOIS-A. (Ed.) 1821-1833. Recueil generaI des anciennes lois francaises depuis l'an 420 jusqu'a la revolution de 1789. 29 v. Paris.
JACOBI,PIERRE. 1575. Aurea practica libellorum Petri Jacobi. Cologne.
JUVENAL DES URSINS, |
JEAN. |
1653. Histoire de Charles |
VI. |
||||
Ed. Denys Godefroy. |
Paris. |
|
|
|
|
||
KANTOROWICZ,ERNST H. |
1955. |
Mysteries |
of state: |
an |
ab- |
||
solutist concept |
and |
its |
late |
medieval |
origins. |
Harvard |
|
Theological Review 47: |
65-91. |
|
|
|
|||
. 1957. The king's two |
bodies. Princeton, Univ. Press. |
KEEN, ALAN, and ROGERLUBBOCK. 1954. The Annotator.
London.
KERN, FRITZ. 1939. Kingship and law in the middle ages.
Oxford.
LAMBERT, J. N. 1955. Le patronat et la succession romaine.
Revue historique de droit francais et etranger, 4th ser., 33: 479-512.
LANGLOIS, CHARLES-V. 1887. Le Regne de Philippe le Hardi.
|
Paris. |
|
LA |
HENRI DE. 1908. |
Du Droit de succession a la |
|
PERRIERE, |
|
Couronnede France dans la dynastie capetienne. Paris.
. 1910. Le Roi legitime. Paris.
Layettes du Tresor des chartes. 1902. Ed. E. Berger. 4 v.
Paris.
LEBER,Ch. 1825. Les ceremonies du sacre. Paris.
43
44 |
GIESEY: DYNASTIC RIGHT TO THE FRENCH THRONE |
[TRANSAMER.PHIL.SOC. . |
LE CARON,Louis CHARONDAS. 1637. Pandectes ou Digestes du droict francois. Paris.
LE GRAND, JOACHIM. 1728. Traite de la succession a la couronne, ou la Couronne de France toujours successive lineale agnatique. Paris.
ANDRE. 1907. Les Lois fondamentales de la monLEMAIRE,
archie francaise. Paris.
LESCOT, RICHARD. 1896. |
Chronique de |
Richard Lescot, re- |
||
ligieux de Saint-Denis (1328-1344). Ed. Jean Lemoine. |
||||
Paris. |
|
|
|
|
Lex Salica. 1874. Ed. J. Fr. Behrend. Berlin. |
|
|
||
.1953. Ed. K. A. Eckhardt. Weimar. |
|
|
||
LOT, FERDINAND. 1891. |
Les Derniers |
Carolingiens. |
[= |
Bib. |
de l'ec. des hautes etudes, fasc. 87.] |
Paris. |
|
|
|
LOT, FERDINAND and R. FAWTIER. 1958. Histoire |
des |
insti- |
tutions francaises au moyen age: Tome II, Institutions
royales. Paris.
La Loy salique, premiere loy des francois. 1557. Combined with Claude de Seyssel: La Grand'monarchiede France. Paris.
LOYSEAU,CHARLES. 1666. Les Oeuvres de maistre Charles Loyseau. Paris.
LUCHAIRE, ACHILLE. 1883. |
Histoire |
des institutions |
mon- |
|
archiques de la France |
sous les |
premiers Capetiens |
(987- |
|
1180). |
2 v. Paris. |
|
|
|
1892. |
Manuel des institutions francaises, periode des |
Capetiensdirects. Paris.
MALINGRE,CLAUDE. 1614. Traicte de la loy salique. Paris.
MATHEW,A. H. 1910. The Life and Times of Hildebrand, Pope Gregory VII. London.
MCLAREN,MORAY. 1949. "By Me .. ." a report upon the apparent discovery of some working notes of William Shakespeare in a sixteenth-centurybook. London.
Medailles sur les principaux evenementsdu regne de Louis le
Grand. 1702. Paris, in 4?.
MONOD, GABRIEL. 1892. Le legende de la Loi Salique et la succession au tr6ne de France. Revue critique,n.s., 34:
515-520.
Oldradus de Ponte. 1576. Consilia. Frankfort.
1951. Histoire du droit francais.
Paris.
Ordonnancesdes rois de France de la troisieme race. 17231849. Ed. Eusebe de Lauriere et al. 21 v. Paris.
PANGE, J. DE. 1949. Le roi tres chretien. Paris.
PERE, GEORGES.1921. Le Sacre et le couronnement des rois de France dans leurs rapportsavec les lois fondamentales.
Bagneres-de-Bigorre.
PERILLI, ANGELO. 1584. De suitate. Ed. Tractatus Universi
Juris [below] 8(2). Venice.
PETRUS DE VINEA. 1740. Petri de Vineis Epistolarum. 2 v.
Basel.
PLANCHER, DOM URBAIN. |
|
1739-1781. |
Histoire |
generale |
et |
||||
particuliere de Bourgogne. 4 v. |
Dijon. |
|
|
||||||
POCOCK,J. G. A. 1957. |
The |
ancient constitution and the |
|||||||
feudal law. |
Cambridge,Univ. Press. |
|
|
||||||
POTTER, JOHN. 1937. |
The |
development |
and significance |
of |
|||||
the Salic Law of the French. Eng. Hist. Rev. 52: 235- |
|||||||||
253. |
1619. |
Petri |
Rebuffi . . . Tractatus varii. |
||||||
REBUFFI, PIERRE. |
|||||||||
Lyon. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Rec. hist. de Fr. See Bouquet. |
|
|
|
|
|
||||
REGNAUD, JEAN. |
1584. |
De |
|
suitate et |
extraneitate. |
Ed. Trac- |
|||
tatus Universi Juris [below] 8(2). |
Venice. |
|
|||||||
SALMON, J. H. |
M. |
1959. |
The French religious wars |
in |
English political thought. Oxford.
SAN GEORGIO,CARDINALGIOVANNIANTONIODA. 1629. Com- mentaria in feudorum libros III. Frankfort.
SCHRAMM, PERCY ERNST. 1939. Der K6nig von Frankreich. Weimar.
Scriptores historiae augustae. 1865. Ed. H. Peter. Leipzig. SERVIER, J.-J. 1888. Le Val de Grace. Paris.
SEYSSEL,CLAUDEDE. 1557. La Grand'monarchie de France.
Paris.
SHAKESPEARE, WILLIAM. 1880. The life of Henry the Fift.
Ed. W. G. Stone. [= New Shakspere Society, Ser. II, no. 10.] London.
Le Songe du vergier. 1731. Ed. J. L. Brunet, Traitez des droits et libertez de l'Eglise gallicane. 1st v. (of 2). N. p.
TERREROUGE,JEAN DE. 1526. |
Contra rebelles |
suorum |
regum. |
Ed. J. Bonaud de Sauset. Lyon. |
|
|
|
. 1586. Idem. Printed with Francois Hotman, Consilia. |
|||
Arras. |
|
|
|
TIRAQUEAU, ANDRE. 1587. Le |
mort saisit le |
vif. Ed. |
Trac- |
tatus varii. Lyon. |
|
|
|
[Primum (-decimum septimum) volumen] Tractatum ex variis iuris interpretibuscollectorum. 1549. 18 v. Lyon.
Tractatus Universi Juris. 1584. Ed. F. Zilettus. 18 v. in 25. Venice.
ULLMAN, WALTER. 1955. |
The growth of papal government |
in the middle ages. |
London. |
VILLARI, PASQUALE. 1905. The two first centuries of floren- tine history. Transl. Linda Villari. London.
VIOLLET, PAUL. 1890-1903. Histoire des institutions politiques et administrativesde la France. 3 v. Paris.
.1893. Histoire du droit civil francais. Paris.
- 1895. Commentles femmes ont ete exclues, en France, de la successiona la Couronne. Memoires de l'Academie
des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 34(2): 125-178.
WERNER, KARL. 1952. Die Legitimit der Kapetinger und die
Entstehung des "Reditus regni Francorum ad stirpem Karoli." Die Welt als Geschichte 12: 203-225.
INDEX
Adoption of heir, in Roman empire, 34; in France, 12, 34 Agnatic succession, in feudal law, 9 (& n. 24), 32, 33; sub-
sumed in Princes of the Blood, 37, 40
Alencon, John II Duke of, treason trial (1457), 27, 28 n. 96 Andreas of Isernia (d. 1316), on primogeniture,34 n. 127 d'Angleberme,Jean Pyrrhus (fl. 1500), on Salic Law, 20; on
representation,25 n. 86
Anjou, Francis Duke of (d. 1584), 30, 31
Antoine of Bourbon,King of Navarre (d. 1562), 25, 31 Aquinas, St. Thomas, as source for Terre Rouge, 12, 15 (&
n. 47), 35 n. 137
Aragon, succession to throne of, 13, 27
Aristotle, as source for Terre Rouge, 12, 15 (& n. 47); on society, 24
Aubain, and royal family, 40
Baldus de Ubaldus (d. 1400), on feudal succession,9-11, 29, 35, 38; on right of first-born, 10, 27 n. 91; hypothesizes Bourbon
succession,10, 32; alleged by others, 12, 23, 26 n. 90, 27 n. 95, 30 n. 107
Bartolus of Sassoferrato (d. 1357), 12, 23
Belloy, Pierre de (fl. 1585), on simple succession, 17 Benedicti, Guillaume (fl. 1500), on suitas, 24; on father-son
continuity, 15 n. 47, 38 n. 146; on simple succession, 17; on le mort saisit le vif, 11 (& n. 29)
Bignon, Jerome (fl. 1600), on relations of French dynasties, 37 n. 142
Blood right, of Princes of the Blood (q.v.), 38-40, 41, 42; Merovingianand Carolingian,38; of "Jean I" of France, 41;
of Duke of Alenqon (1457), 27; of Bourbon dynasty, 9 |
(& |
|
n. 24), 10, 40; distinct from patria potestas, 36; in |
Terre |
|
Rouge's thought, 15, 39; in Du Moulin's thought, 27; |
in |
|
Loyseau's thought, 37; in Hotman's thought, 36, |
39; |
in |
popular thought, 36 |
|
|
Bodin, Jean (d. 1596), theory of royal succession,29-30; change in views, 31; on le mort saisit le vif, 11 (& n. 29); on simple
succession, 17
Bohier, Nicholas (d. 1539), on primogenitary right, 9 n. 22, 25 n. 85
Bonaud de Sauset, Jacques de (fl. 1525), on hereditary royal powers, 38 n. 145; editor of Terre Rouge, 12 n. 34
Bourbon de Parme, Prince Sixte de, on founding of Spanish Bourbondynasty, 3 (& n. 1), 4, 41, 42
Bourbon dynasty in France, accession hypothesizedby Baldus, 9, 10, 32; accession to throne, 22, 25, 30-31, 36, 37; blood mysticism and absolutism,4, 40; ranks altered by Louis XIV, 3, 41; see also Huguenots, Antoine of Bourbon,CharlesCardi-
nal of Bourbon, Henry IV
Bourbondynasty in Spain, accession, 3, 36 n. 138, 41; claimants to French throne, 3 n. 2; see also Bourbonde Parme, Jaime,
Philip V
Canon law, general effect on laws of succession, 6-7; use by Terre Rouge, 12; avoided by Hotman, 32.
Decretum: alius (c. 3, C. XV, qu. 6), 7 n. 13, 16 n. 51, 28
n. 101; videntes (c. 16, C. XII, |
qu. 1), |
22 n. 79; |
coepit |
|||
Ermigildus |
rex juvenis |
(c. 42, C. XXIV, |
qu. 1), 6; |
quam |
||
periculosum (c. 8, C. VII, |
qu. 1), |
8 n. 19 |
|
|||
Decretales: |
venerabilem |
(I, |
6, 34), |
6; licet universis |
(III, |
|
34, 6), 6, 13 n. 36; per venerabilem (IV, |
17, 13), 20 n. 71, |
|||||
41 n. 158 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Clementines: de aetate & qualitate (I, 6), 22 n. 79
Capetiandynasty (direct line, 987-1328), connectionto Saxons, 37 n. 142; advent and legitimacy, 5-7, 29; system of rex designatus,6, 8; use of conceptdignitas, 7 (& n. 14); hereditary principle and primogeniture,7, 8 (& notes 17, 20); as feudal monarchs, 10-12, 38; dependence upon coronation-
consecration (q.v.), 5, 7 (& n. 14), 38; end of direct line, 11; see also Hugh Capet, Valois, Bourbons, Princes of the Blood
Carolingian dynasty, initiates royal consecration,4-5; regards realm as patrimony,5; link to Capetiandynasty, 7 n. 14, 37,
38; rise of hereditary feudality, 8; link to Merovingians, 37 n. 142, 38
Catherinede' Medici, and Princes of the Blood, 39 Charlemagne,and Roman Law, 19
Charles of Bourbon, Cardinal and so-called "Charles X" (d. 1590), 25, 30 n. 110, 31
Charles Martel, "legitimization"of, 41 n. 158
Charles IV, King of France, last of direct Capetians, 19, 33 n. 120
Charles VI, King of France, crisis at his death, 12, 14; royal descent from him, 34-35 and fig. 2.
Charles VII, King of France, right to regency powers and
throne, 12-16 passiin; lit de justice in 1457, 27-28; family tree from Charles VI, 34-35 and fig. 2; and Princes of the
Blood, 39
Charles VIII, King of France, coronation entry in 1484, 18 n. 63, 20; descent from Charles VI, 34-35 and fig. 2
Charles IX, King of France, and Princes of the Blood, 39-40 (& n. 154)
Christ as antitype of rulers, unigenitus and primogenitus, 8
(& n. 21); consanguineouswith kings, 38 n. 145
Clovis, baptism,4, 5, 20; legend of, 5 (& n. 8), 6, 20; initiator of Frankish kingdom, 37, 38
Collateral heirs, in feudal law, 8-10 passim, 35; by representa- tion (q.v.) in Roman law, 24-25; in Aragon and Majorca, 27; see also Agnatic succession,Suitas
Coquille, Guy (d. 1603), on simple succession, 17; legend of Frankish kings, 37 n. 142
Coronation-consecration,of Clovis, 4, 5, 20, 37, 38; basis of Carolingian legitimacy, 4-5 (& note 4), 38, 40; in Capetian dynasty, 6 (& n. 12), 10, 40; of Charles VIII, 20; of Henry IV, 31 n. 114; see also Holy Balm, King's Evil
Corpus luris Canonici, see Canon law Corpus Iuris Civilis, see Roman law
Customarylaw, influenceon law of successionvia Terre Rouge, 12-17 passim, 27, 31; in thought of Du Moulin, 26-29; in
thought of Hotman, 32-34; expressed in cout,umiiers,7, 8, 26, 29, 33; on droit d'ainesse,8 n. 20; and blood right, 40-41
Le Debat des herauts d'armes de France et d'Angleterre
(1458/1459), 18
Decius, Philip (d. 1536), on primogeniture,34 n. 127
Dignity, crown or royal office as, 5, 7, 40; concept dignitas in canon law, 7 (& n. 14), 32; great fiefs as, 10 (& n. 25), 29; primogenituralright as, 8 n. 19; 26-27 (& n. 90); suitas as,
35 n. 135; le mort saisit le vif inapplicable to, 11 n. 29; dig- nitas basically anti-dynastic, 11 n. 29, 27, 32
Divine law, 4-6; approves primogeniture,26; see also Corona- tion-consecration
Droit d'ainesse,correspondencewith primogeniture(q.v.), 8-9; in representation,25, 35; in Du Moulin's thought, 26; in Hotman's thought, 33, 35
Du Moulin, Charles (d. 1566), views on royal succession, 17,
26-29; on customarylaw, 32
Dupuy, Pierre (d. 1651), on simple succession, 17; criticizes Salic Law, 21 n. 75
Du Tillet, Jean (fl. 1550), on Princes of the Blood, 39 notes 148-150; on Jean I, 41 n. 157
Edward III, King of England, claims French throne, 18 (& n. 57), 19 n. 64
Egidius Romanus (d. 1316), 12
45
46 |
GIESEY: DYNASTIC RIGHT TO THE FRENCH THRONE |
[TRANS. AMER. PHIL. Soc. |
Elective principle,disallowed in France, 6, 7 n. 13, 8 n. 17, 11, 29; upheldby Hotman, 30; necessary if royal line expires, 27
Estates (in France), approved original law of succession, 13, 21, 37, 42; cannot alter establishedsuccession, 16; empowered if dynasty expires, 11, 27, 28; Hotman's view of, 30-31; Estates of 1328, 19; Estates of 1577, 30 n. 110; Estates of 1588, 31 n. 114
8tablissements de St. Louis, on seizin, 10, 11 n. 29
Ferrault, Jean (fl. 1510), on Salic Law, 21 n. 73
Feu, Jean de (fl. 1510), on primogenitaryright, 28 (& n. 100) Feudal law and fiefs, laws of succession generally, 7-12, 29, 37, 38, 40; relation to Salic Law, 18, 32; representationin feudal succession, 24, 33; Du Moulin on De feudis, 26-29; see also
Primogeniture, Droit d'ainesse, Libri feudorlum Filiational right, see under Patria potestas
Fisc, of realm, 9, 10
Fortescue, Sir John (d. 1479), on English royal succession, 18 n. 57
Francis I, King of France, title to throne and accession, 25, 34-35 and fig. 2
Francis II, King of France, coronationof, 39 Frederick II, Holy Roman Emperor, on
(& n. 127)
Fundamentallaw (regarding succession), in sixteenth century, 25-38 passim; in Bourbontimes, 3-4, 37; of Du Moulin, 26-
29; of Bodin, 29-30; of Hotman, 30-37; of Loyseau, 37-38; and Princes of the Blood, 40, 42
Galen (fl. A.D.200), on genetics, 15 n. 47
Gerson,Jean (d. 1428), on hereditarysuccession,11; on father- son continuity,38 n. 146
Golein, Jean (fl. 1375), on "sacred line" of kings, 5 n. 10, 38 n. 145
Grassaille, Charles de (fl. 1540), on simple succession, 17; on Salic Law, 21 n. 73
Guise family, opposes Bourbons,9 n. 24; see also Ligue
Hall, Edward (fl. 1545), on Salic Law, 21 n. 76
Henry I, King of France, 7 n. 14
Henry II, King of France, on Princes of the Blood, 39
Henry III, King of France, end of Valois dynasty, 25, 30, 36; on Princes of the Blood, 39, 40
Henry IV, King of France and Navarre, right to throne and accession, 25, 30, 31-32; strengthens dynastic theory, 36, 37,
40; see also Huguenots
Henry V, King of England, adoptedas heir to French king, 12 Henry VI, King of England, "inherits"French crown, 12
Hereditary succession,does not apply in France, 6, 7 n. 13, 13, 29, 36, 37; does apply in France, 11, 37; applies in Hungary, 6, 13; applies in Aragon and Majorca, 27; distinct from "simple succession" (q.v.), 12-13, 17, 29, 30, 36; in feudal law, 8-9, 27; heirs in Roman law (q.v.), 22-25; see also
Primogeniture, Droit d'ainesse
Hincmar, Archbishop of Rheims (d. 882), and myth of corona- tion-consecration, 4
Holinshed, Raphael (fl. 1570), on Salic Law, 21 n. 76
Holy Balm, myth of, 4, 5, 6 n. 12, 15 n. 48, 37, 38; see also
King's Evil
Holy RomanEmpire, elective principlein, 6; as a Dignity, 7, 16
Hotman, Frangois (d. 1590), theory of royal succession,30-37; on seizin, 11 (& n. 29); editor of Terre Rouge, 12 n. 34, 31 n. 115; on simple succession, 17; attacks Salic Law, 21, 32;
on suitas, 32-35, 39
Hugh Capet, accession, 5; genearch of Capetians (q.v.), 36, 37
Huguenots, and Canon law, 7; and Salic Law, 31 n. 114; and Bourbonline, 9 n. 24; position upheld by Hotman, 30, 31, 32
Hungary, royal succession in, 6, 13
Inalienability |
of crown, 13, 15, 29 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
Italian law, |
embodies Salic |
Law, |
18 n. 58 |
|
|
|
|
||||||
Iuts formatum, |
in Terre Rouge, |
16; in Du |
Moulin, 27 |
|
|
||||||||
Jacobi, Pierre |
(mid-16th |
cent.), |
on |
representation, |
33 |
n. 120; |
|||||||
acknowledges "Jean I," 41 n. |
157 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
Jaime, of Spanish Bourbon line, 3 n. 2 |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
John I, King of France, |
|
enrolled in |
list |
of French kings, |
41 |
||||||||
(& n. 157) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
John the |
Fearless, Duke |
of Burgundy, |
and French |
regency, |
12 |
||||||||
Joly, Claude |
(fl. 1660), on simple succession, 17 |
|
|
|
|||||||||
Juvenal des |
Ursins, Jean |
(d. 1473), on "necessary heir," 16-17 |
|||||||||||
(& n. 53); |
|
and Salic Law, 18 (& notes, 59, 60), |
19 |
|
|
||||||||
King's Evil, |
curing of, 6 n. 12, 37 n. 142, 38 n. 145; see Corona- |
||||||||||||
tion-consecration, Holy Balm |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
Kin-right, |
in |
Merovingian |
dynasty, |
4, |
38, 40; see |
also |
Blood- |
||||||
right |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
La Perriere, |
Henri de, on royal succession, 3 |
|
|
|
|||||||||
Le Bret, Cardin (d. 1655), |
on |
simple |
succession, 17 |
|
|
||||||||
Le Caron, Louis Charondas (d. 1617), |
on Salic |
Law, 20-21 |
|||||||||||
(& n. 73); |
|
on Princes |
of the |
Blood, |
40 n. 155, 41 |
|
|
|
|||||
Lescot, Richard (fl. 1360), |
on |
Salic |
Law, |
17 n. 56 |
|
|
|
||||||
Lex animata, king as, 28 |
(& n. 97) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
Lex regia, analogous to Salic Law, |
16, 20-21 (& n. 73) |
|
|
||||||||||
L'Hommeau, |
Pierre de (fl. 1600), on simple succession, |
17 |
|
||||||||||
L'Hospital, |
Michel de (d. |
1573), |
on simple succession, |
17 |
|
Libri feudorum, on succession to fiefs, 7-8, 9, 11, 18; cited by
Terre Rouge, 15 n. 44; |
cited by Hotman, 33 n. 120 |
|||||||
Ligue |
(in |
French |
religious |
wars), |
and religious test |
for crown, |
||
30 n. 110, 31 n. 114; Bodin as ligueur, 31 (& n. 111) |
||||||||
Lit de justice, |
of |
Charles VII in |
1457, 27 |
|
||||
Lombard |
law, |
on |
guardianship, 15 n. 46; and Libri |
feudorum |
||||
(q.v.), |
18 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Louis |
VII, King of France, realm as Dignity, 7 n. 14 |
|||||||
Louis |
VIII, |
King |
of France, dynastic mysticism, 5; |
coronation |
||||
of, |
6; uses |
title |
primogenitus, 8 n. 20 |
|
Louis IX, King of France, canonization enhances dynasty, 5-6;
coronation,6; son's primogenituralright, 25 n. 85; genearch of French dynasty, 36-37
Louis X, King of France, 11, 41
Louis XI, King of France, descent from Charles VI, 34-35 and
fig. |
|
2 |
|
King of |
|
|
|
|
|
25 (& n. 85); |
de- |
||
Louis |
|
XII, |
France, representation, |
||||||||||
scent from Charles VI, 34-35 and fig. 2 |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
Louis |
|
XIV, |
King of France, alters ranks |
of Bourbon |
princes, |
||||||||
3, 41; |
as roi soleil, 42; makes mausoleum |
of Val-de-Grace, |
41 |
||||||||||
La Loy |
salique, premiere loy des francois, |
18-19 (& |
notes |
61, |
|||||||||
65-67), |
20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||
Loyseau, |
Charles (fl. 1600), theory of |
royal succession, |
37-38; |
||||||||||
on |
|
seizin, |
11; on |
simple succession, |
17; |
on Princes |
of |
the |
|||||
Blood, |
37, 39 n. 149, 40 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
Majorca, as hereditary monarchy, 27 |
|
21 n. 75; |
|
|
|
||||||||
Malingre, Claude (fl. 1600), on Salic Law, |
geneology |
||||||||||||
of French kings, 36 n. 141 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
Mantuan |
law, on family |
succession, 10 n. 27 |
|
|
|
||||||||
Matthaeus de Afflictis (d. 1523), |
on primogeniture, 34 n. 127 |
||||||||||||
Maxims: |
|
saisit le |
|
|
to |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
Le |
|
mort |
vif, |
applied |
royal succession, |
10-11 |
(& |
||||||
n. 29) |
|
|
le roil, |
11 n. 29 |
|
|
|
|
|||||
Le |
roi |
est mort! |
Vive |
|
|
|
|
||||||
Le |
roi ne meurt jamais, 11 n. 29 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
Rex |
est imperator |
in suo regno, |
20 |
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
Rex |
non recognoscit superiorem, |
20 |
|
|
|
|
|
Merovingiandynasty,basis of legitimacy,4, 6, 38, 40; deposition of, 7 n. 13, 28 n. 101; Capetianslinked to, 37 (& n. 142); see
also |
Clovis, Salic |
Law |
Montreuil, Jean de |
(fl. 1410), and Salic Law, 18 n. 60 |
|
Le |
1mortsaisit le vif, see under Maxims |
VOL. 51, PT. 5, 1961] |
INDEX |
47 |
Mystical body of the realm, 13 (& n. 39), 16 (& n. 51), 42 Nature and natural law, in Terre Rouge's thought, 14, 15; in
Hotman'sthought, 32, 33, 36; and Princes of the Blood, 40, 41
Oldradusde Ponte (d. 1335), on representation,25 n. 85
Parlement of Paris, registers Treaty of Troyes, 12; lit de justice of 1457, 27-28; and Princes of the Blood, 39, 40
Patria potestas, traditional Roman law view of, 13, 14, 27, 39; affected by doctrine of suitas, 22-24; condominionof father and son, 14, 15, 27, 38; ius filiationis, 14, 15, 16, 39; limited in French royal succession, 13, 14 (& n. 43)
Peers of the realm, and lit de justice of 1457, 28; relation to Princes of the Blood, 39, 40
Pepin, King of the Franks, consecrationof, 4
Perilli, Angelo (d. 1446), on suitas, 22-23 (& notes 79-81) Petrus de Vinea (d. 1249), letter regarding primogeniture,33
(& n. 127)
Pharamond, legendary king of the Franks, 5, 20 n. 69; and Salic Law, 18-20 (& n. 65), 37
Philip II, King of France, as rex designatus, 6, 13; weds
Carolingianprincess, 38; and Peers of the realm, 39
Philip III, King of France, acclaimed king before coronation, 6, 7, 25 n. 85
Philip IV, King of France, adopts title primogenitus,8 n. 20; ancestor of English kings, 18 n. 57
Philip V, King of Spain, 3
Philip VI, King of France, first of Valois kings, 11, 18, 33 n. 120; supposedlyalleges Salic Law, 18-19 (& notes 64, 66)
Popes and papal authority, influence on royal succession, 6, 7 n. 13, 16 (& n. 51); as a Dignity itself, 7; Pope Zacharias
on Carolingian dynasty, 5, 7 n. 13; Popes Symmachus and Gregory VII on papal merits, 6 n. 11; Gregory the Great on rex juvenis [see Canonlaw], 6; Alexander III on Hungarian and French crowns, 6, 7 n. 14; Innocent III on Imperial suc- cession, 6; Benedict XII on exclusion of women from French throne, 11 n. 30
Prescription, cannot affect primogeniture,28 |
|
|
Presles, Raoul de (d. 1382), on Salic Law, 17 n. 56 |
as peculiar |
|
Primogeniture, in feudal law, 7-12 (esp. |
8-9); |
|
French principle, 8, 33; as title of king's son, 8 |
(& n. 20), |
|
13; approvedby Estates, 16; in Scriptures,8 n. 19, 26 n. 90; |
||
in Roman law representation, 24, 25; |
in Terre Rouge's |
|
thought, 13, 14-15, 16, 36 n. 138; in Du |
Moulin's thought, |
26-28; in Hotman's thought, 33-34, 37; subsumedin Princes
of the Blood, 37, 40; see Hereditary succession, Droit d'ainesse
Princeps iuventutis,34 (& n. 130) Princes of the Blood, 36, 37, 38-40, 41, 42
Rebuffi,Pierre (fl. 1550), stresses Roman law, 29 n. 104; con- sanguinity of French king with Christ, 38 n. 145
Regnaud, Jean (end 15th cent.), on suitas, 23-24
Remi (St.), Bishop of Rheims, baptism of Clovis, 4 Representation (in legal successions), in Roman civil law, 24-
25, 27, 32; in French royal succession,25, 32-33, 35, 37
Rex designatus,in early Capetiandynasty, 5-6, 8 (& n. 20), 13 Rex juvenis, son of king as, 6, 26
Roman Law, heirs and inheritance in, 22-25, 33, 35, 39, 40;
guardianship in, 15 n. 46; in Carolingian times, 19; in Terre Rouge's thought, 12; in Hotman's thought, 32; rela-
tion to French law, 26, 34; see Hereditary succession, Patria potestas, Representation,Suitas
Corpus luris Civilis, and Libri feudorum,7; and patria potestas, 14; lex regia in, 20; general influenceof, 22; disparaged by Hotman, 32; in Renaissancethought, 36
Digest 1, 1, 1, 13 n. 35; 1, 1, 5, 26 n. 90; 1, 3, 32 & 33, 13 n. 37; 1, 7, 22, 14 n. 42; 6, 1, 1, 20 n. 71; 11, 7, 6, 14 n. 42;
28, 2, 11, 6, 7 n. 13, 14 n. 41, 23 n. 81; 28, 2, 29, 14; 28, 5, 58, 35 n. 138; 33, 4, 4, 20 n. 71; 37, 8, 1, 34 n. 130; 38, 1, 29, 14 n. 42; 38, 2, 1 & 2, 14; 38, 2, 5, 14; 38, 9, 1, 23 n. 80; 38,
16, 1, 34 n. 130, 35 n. 137; 48, 20, 6, 34 n. 130; 50, 16, 220, 35 n. 137
Codex 6, 55, 12, 14; 6, 58, 15, 14; 1, 3, 33, 22 n. 79; 6, 55, 8, 22 n. 79; 1, 3, 54, 23 n. 79; 6, 9, 4, 23 n. 80
Institutes 1, 2, 13 n. 35; 2, 19, 2, 23 n. 80; 3, 2 and 3, 3, 13 n. 37
Novels, extend principle of representation,24; Nov. 118, 1, 14 n. 43; Nov. 81, 22 n. 79.
Sacral kingship, see Coronation-consecration
Salic Law, applied to French royal succession, 17-22, 39; Pharamond the supposed law-giver, 18-20, 37; accession of
Bourbondynasty, 21-22; supposedallegation at Valois acces- sion, 11, 18-19; mentionedby Bodin, 29, 30; by Du Moulin, 28; by Hotman, 21, 32, 36; by CharondasLe Caron, 20-21;
by Pyrrhus d'Angleberme, 20; |
by Hall, Holinshed |
and |
Shakespeare, 21 (& n. 76); by |
Malingre, 21 (& n. |
75); |
appliedto Italian royal succession, 18 n. 58; see also Women (exclusion of)
San Georgio, CardinalGiovanni Antonio da, on primogeniture, 25 notes 85, 87
Scriptores historiae augustae, on princeps inventutis, 34 n. 130
Scriptures, as source of primogenitaryrights (Gen. 25, Exod. 11, Deut. 21, Ps. 109), 8 n. 19, 26 n. 90
Seizin, see under Maxims: Le mort saisit le vif
Seyssel, Claudede (d. 1520), treatise on French monarchy,26; name associatedwith tract La Loy salique, 18 n. 61, 26
Shakespeare,on Salic Law in Henry V, 21 (& n. 76)
Simple succession (or "successive right"), developed by Terre Rouge, 12-17 passim; in Bodin and Hotman, 29, 30
Songe du vergier (ca. 1376), on magical powers of the king, 6 n. 12; on le mort saisit le vif, 10, 11 n. 29; on election of
kings, 11 (& n. 32)
Spanish succession,see Bourbondynasty in Spain
Suitas, meaning, origin and history, 22-25; applied to French royal succession by Hotman, 31, 32, 33-35, 39; subsumedin Princes of the Blood, 37
Terre Rouge, Jean de (fl. 1420), theory of succession, 7 n. 13, 12-17; career and nature of treatise, 12, 26; publication of treatise, 12 (& n. 34), 21, 31 (& n. 115); on simple succes-
sion and primogeniture,8 n. 21, 12-17 passim; on blood right, 15, 39; on father-son continuity, 23; cited by Du Moulin, 27, 28, 29; utilized and publishedby Hotman, 31, 32, 34, 36; ideas reflectedin Loyseau, 37; influenceof ideas, 17
Testamentary succession, in Aragon, 13, 27; not in French royal succession, 13 (& n. 37), 14, 37
Tiraqueau,Andre (d. 1558), on le mort saisit le vif, 11 n. 29 Treaty of Troyes (1420), 12
Val-de-Grace,as royal family shrine, 42
Valois dynasty, beginningof, 11, 33 n. 120; as feudal monarchy, 11; expiration of, 32, 40; link to Bourbon dynasty (q.v.),
10, 36, 37
Women, exclusion from succession,in feudal law, 8; in French royal succession, 11, 29; subsumedin Princes of the Blood, 37-38; see Salic Law