TABLE OF CASES

GERMAN

AcP

AcP 1965, 311

451

AcP 1967, 290

449

BAG

BAG 1, 51=AP no 1

155

BAG 13, 1=AP no 19 (Grand Senate 16 31962)

145, 149, 151

BAG 26 10 1978

155

BAnz (FA)

BAnz no 45 of 6.3.1958=BGB1 III 7831–1–1

455

BayObLG

BayObLG Cr 1958, 34

721

BayObLG NstZ 1983, 126

719

BayObLG NstZ 1983, 265

719

[1974] 2 CMLR 540 Solange I=BVerfGE 37, 271

15

[1987] 3 CMLR 225 Solange II=BVerfGE 52, 178

15, 97

BB

BB 1959, 1186=VersR 1960, 342

405

BB 1964, 319

453

BB 1965, 439

455

BB 1979, 477=AP no 27

145, 155

Baden-Württemberg StGH, VerwRspr 4, 1

213

BGB1

BGB1 1954 II 14

667

BGB1 1973 II 421

631

BGB1 1973 II 1534

649

BGB1 III 7831

455

BGHSt

BGHSt 2, 38

721

BGHSt 2, 194

689

BGHSt 2, 196

691

BGHSt 2, 201

697

BGHSt 2, 203

695

BGHSt 2, 209

697

BGHSt 2, 234

627, 647

BGHSt 3, 132 base motive case

733

BGHSt 4, 1

689

BGHSt 6, 186

725

BGHSt 11, 207

719, 721

BGHSt 18, 87

675

BGHSt 21, 371

719, 725

BGHSt 23, 46

489, 493

BGHSt 25, 277 rough ill-treatment case

741

BGHSt 26, 99

657

BGHSt 30, 1

631, 633

BGHSt 32, 293

631, 633

BGHSt 32, 310

719, 725

BGHSt 33, 97

629

BGHSt 35, 379

657, 673

BGHSt 36, 83 insult of soldiers case

715

BGHSt 37, 320

631

BGHSt 38, 1

631

BGHSt 38, 18

631

BGHSt 38, 88

631

BGHSt 39, 1 shootings at the Berlin wall case

109, 621

BGHZ

BGHZ 6, 330

383, 385

BGHZ 7, 338

605

BGHZ 9, 373=NJW 53, 1297

567

BGHZ 11, 192

589

BGHZ 13, 334 publication of a letter case

469

BGHZ 15, 224

443

BGHZ 16, 54

265, 279

BGHZ 16, 111

595

BGHZ 21, 102

251, 255

BGHZ 22, 383

589

BGHZ 23, 36

595

BGHZ 24, 21

461

BGHZ 25, 250

443

BGHZ 29, 65

489, 597

BGHZ 33, 247

447

BGHZ 34, 32

261

BGHZ 34, 375

603

BGHZ 36, 252

489, 597

BGHZ 38, 200

597

BGHZ 40, 91

443, 453

BGHZ 40, 99

445

BGHZ 40, 101

443

BGHZ 40, 104

445

BGHZ 42, 176

583

BGHZ 45, 296

489, 493, 597, 599

BGHZ 47, 207=NJW 1967, 1022

291

BGHZ 48, 118

451, 453

BGHZ 48, 310

465

BGHZ 49, 350

387, 447

BGHZ 51, 91 fowl pest case

387, 389, 439

BGHZ 56, 40

593

BGHZ 56, 296

387

BGHZ 59, 30 newspaper delivery obstruction case

481, 597

BGHZ 59, 172

405

BGHZ 60, 221=NJW 1973, 752

395

BGHZ 61, 118

409

BGHZ 61, 227

387, 389

BGHZ 63, 35

593

BGHZ 64, 46 allergy to hair tonic case

399

BGHZ 65, 196

593

BGHZ 66, 51 fall in the supermarket case

377

BGHZ 69, 297

315

BGHZ 69, 128 air traffic controllers strike case

579

BGHZ 70, 337=NJW 1978, 1374

291

BGHZ 71, 262

259

BGHZ 72, 382=NJW 1979, 718

291

BVerfGE

BVerfGE [1994] NJ 46

107

BVerfGE 2 BvE 1/90

57

BVerfGE 2 BvQ 17/93 [1993] EuGRZ 326

19

BVerfGE 1, 14

215

BVerfGE 1, 144

221

BVerfGE 1, 264

201

BVerfGE 1, 208

61, 69

BVerfGE 2, 1 Socialist Reich Party

515

BVerfGE 2, 266

211, 217

BVerfGE 2, 307

215

BVerfGE 3, 19

211, 221

BVerfGE 3, 34

199

BVerfGE 3, 58

211

BVerfGE 3, 225

149, 647, 665

BVerfGE 3, 288

211

BVerfGE 3, 359

199

BVerfGE 3, 383

199

BVerfGE 3, 407

203

BVerfGE 4, 7 investment aid act case

193

BVerfGE 4, 31=NJW 1954, 1601

81

BVerfGE 5, 9

149, 151

BVerfGE 5, 85 Communist Party

515, 521

BVerfGE 6, 32

515, 543

BVerfGE 6, 55

515

BVerfGE 6, 84=NJW 1957, 377

61, 69, 515

BVerfGE 6, 132

647

BVerfGE 7, 198 film director case

505

BVerfGE 7, 377 Chemists

185

BVerfGE 8, 1

599

BVerfGE 8, 85=NJW 1964, 1715

179

BVerfGE 10, 59

91, 149

BVerfGE 12, 113

493

BVerfGE 14, 121=NJW 1962, 1493

63

BVerfGE 15, 337

149

BVerfGE 18, 85, 92

91

BVerfGE 19, 342 arrested admiral case

111

BVerfGE 20, 162

493

BVerfGE 21, 329

149

BVerfGE 22, 349

157

BVerfGE 24, 278

493, 719

BVerfGE 25, 236

157

BVerfGE 25, 256 Blinkfüer

495

BVerfGE 25, 269

665

BVerfGE 30, 173 Mephisto case

129, 173

BVerfGE 31, 1

149

BVerfGE 32, 98=NJW 1972, 327

165

BVerfGE 36, 1

655

BVerfGE 37, 217

149, 151

BVerfGE 37, 271 Solange I=[1974] 2 CMLR 540

15

BVerfGE 42, 163

719

BVerfGE 43, 213

149

BVerfGE 44, 125=NJW 1977, 1054

59

BVerfGE 51, 222=NJW 1979, 2463

59, 61

BVerfGE 51, 252

61

BVerfGE 52, 178 Solange II=[1987] 3 CMLR 225

15, 97

BVerfGE 52, 223=NJW 1980, 575

165

BVerfGE 52, 369 housework day case

143

BVerfGE 53, 135

109

BVerfGE 55, 159

109

BVerfGE 58, 300 Gravel

191

BVerfGE 69, 315 Brokdorf

183

BVerfGE 73, 1=NJW 1986, 2492

59

BVerfGE 73, 40=NJW 1986, 2487

59

BVerfGE 73, 206 Mutlangen

183

BVerfGE 74, 264 Boxberg

191

BVerfGE 78, 350=NJW 1989, 285

59

BVerfGE 90, 145=NJW 1994, 1577

165, 167, 169

BVerfGE 96, 375 [399]=NJW 1998, 519

135

BVerfGE 97, 125=NJW 1998, 1381

177, 179

BVerfGE 101, 1 [37]=NJW 1999, 3523

129

BVerfGE 101, 361=NJW 2000, 1021

179

BVerwG

BVerfG 3 C 20/00, 21.12.2000

159

BVerfG 1 BvQ 35/01, 24.8.2001

175

BVerfG 1 BvQ 36/01, 30.8.2001

179

DB

DB 1971, 2302

257

DB 1973, 1129 (BAG)

251

DB 1975, 2075

257

DB 1976, 1018 (BAG)=NJW 1976, 1284

309

DB 2000, 666 Wilkens

347, 349, 355, 357

DRiZ

DRiZ 1941, 637=HRR 1941, 225

443

DRiZ 1968, 266

453

DVBl

DVBl 1974, 820=ZBR 1974, 369=NJW 1975, 1905

595

HRR

HRR 1931 no 376

743

HRR 1935 no 1276

745

HRR 1941, 225=GJJ 1941, 637

443

JR

JR 1968, 287

455

Table of Cases

JuS

JuS 1968, 347

451

JuS 1978, 674

721

JZ

JZ 1960, 470

729

JZ 1962, 553

387

JZ 1965, 475

387

JZ 1968, 494

455

JZ 1968, 497

449

JZ 1968, 714

449

JZ 1971, 73

599

JZ 1984, 948

633

JZ 1992, 665

633

JZ 1992, 990

667

LM

LM 254 E no 2

389

LM 276 Fa no 1

395

LM 459 BGB no 4

265

MDR

MDR 1953, 401

725

MDR 1954, 515

383

MDR 1966, 491

463

MDR 1974, 921

597

NJW

NJW 1953, 58

249

NJW 1953, 1297

567

NJW 1954, 913 (BGH) fallen telegraph pole case

565

NJW 1954, 1601=BVerfGE 4, 31

81

NJW 1956, 1193

389

NJW 1957, 377=FCCD 6, 84

61, 69, 515

NJW 1957, 746 (BGH)=LM

395

NJW 1957, 1688 (BAG)

515

NJW 1959, 670

597

NJW 1959, 1676

387

NJW 1960, 77

387

NJW 1960, 720=WM 1960, 582

383

NJW 1961, 868

409

NJW 1962, 31

379, 463

NJW 1962, 1493=BVerfGE 14, 121

63

NJW 1964, 33=WM 1963, 1327

387, 389

NJW 1964, 34

465

NJW 1964, 272

637

NJW 1964, 811

291

NJW 1965, 965 (BGH)

309

NJW 1965, 1757=WM 1965, 871

387

NJW 1967, 2199

395

NJW 1968, 247

465

NJW 1968, 1279

459, 603

Sourcebook on German Law

NJW 1968, 1323

447

NJW 1968, 1593

449

NJW 1968, 1597

451

NJW 1968, 1598

449

NJW 1968, 1929

447

NJW 1968, 2102

249

NJW 1968, 2240 (BGH)

465

NJW 1969, 41=WM 1968, 1354

389

NJW 1969, 1207

597

NJW 1970, 38=WM 1969, 1358

389

NJW 1970, 653

291

NJW 1970, 1840

395

NJW 1971, 886

597

NJW 1971, 1422

251

NJW 1971, 1795=WM 1971 749

291

NJW 1972, 2217=WM 1972, 1124

405

NJW 1973, 752=BGHZ 60, 221

395

NJW 1974, 1503=Betr 1974, 1427

295

NJW 1974, 1641

409

NJW 1974, 1762 (BGHZ))

719

NJW 1975, 43

395

NJW 1975, 1774 termination of negotiations case

393

NJW 1975, 1905

595

NJW 1976, 103 (BGH)

593

NJW 1976, 1284 L

309

NJW 1977, 22

637, 649

NJW 1977, 626 (BGHZ)

719

NJW 1977, 1054=BVerfGE 44, 125

59

NJW 1979, 1101

629

NJW 1979, 2032 misdirected withdrawal declaration case

301

NJW 1979, 2463=BVerfGE 51, 222

59, 61

NJW 1981, 1522

719

NJW 1981, 2050=LM 276 Fc BGB no 12=WM 1981, 689

291

NJW 1981, 2117 (BGHZ)

719

NJW 1986, 1262

719

NJW 1986, 2492=BVerfGE 73, 1

59

NJW 1986 2487=BVerfGE 74, 40

59

NJW 1989, 285=BVerfGE 78, 350

59

NJW 1997, 165

339, 341

NJW 2000, 94

347

NJW 2000, 167

339

NJW 2000, 3216

161

NJW 2002, 363

333

NJW 53, 1297=BGHZ 9, 373

567

NStZ

NStZ BUSC 1983, 126

719

NStZ BUSC 1983, 265

719

NStZ 1987, 224

675

NStZ 1987, 554

725

NStZ 1997, 498

167

Table of Cases

OHGSt

OHGSt 2, 231

665

OHG JR 1978, 422

719

OLG

OLG of Cologne, NJW 1950, 702

307

OLG of Düsseldorf, NJW 1979, 59

633

OLG of Düsseldorf (C), NJW 1981, 1522

719

OLG of Düsseldorf, NJW 1983, 1277

633

OLGof Düsseldorf (C), NJW 1986, 1262

719

OLG of Hamburg, 7 U 75/01, 15.8.2001

177

OLG of Hamburg 7 U 77/01

181

OLG of Hamburg NZWehrr 77/70

725

RFH

RFH 27, 321

213

RG

RG GRUR 1940, 375

295

RG Recht 1912 no 1273

279

RG Recht 1912 no 2797

279

RG WarnRspr 1911 no 192

279

RG WarnRspr 1911 no 368

279

RG WarnRspr 1912 no 205

279

RG case law 1, 292

719

RG

RG DR 1940, 26

745

RG DR 1941, 492

745

RG DR 1943, 993

607

RG DR 1944, 330

745

RG LZ 1915, 60

719

RG JW 1912, 461=SeuffArch 67 no 198

267

RG JW 1917, 236

275

RG JW 1925, 2752

273, 275

RG JW 1931, 865

607

RG JW 1932, 31

719

RG JW 1938, 1879

745

RG JW 1938, 2808

745

RGSt

RGSt 19, 136

743

RGSt 31, 185

721

RGSt 32, 113

743

RGSt 33, 46

719, 721

RGSt 62, 160

745

RGZ

RGZ 21, 308

279

RGZ 41, 43

475

RGZ 50, 191

309

RGZ 51, 1

279

RGZ 57, 358

273

Sourcebook on German Law

RGZ 59, 240

279

RGZ 61, 84

279

RGZ 61, 171

265

RGZ 64, 266

279

RGZ 69, 242

477

RGZ 69, 401

475

RGZ 72, 175

475

RGZ 78, 239

381

RGZ 79, 397

475, 477

RGZ 82, 333

475

RGZ 85, 343

475

RGZ 87, 1

451

RGZ 94, 1

475

RGZ 96, 148

591

RGZ 99, 148

363

RGZ 99, 214

279

RGZ 100, 205

273, 275

RGZ 104, 257

589

RGZ 107, 277

475

RGZ 111, 233

291

RGZ 113, 414

475

RGZ 115, 416

475

RGZ 116, 287

565

RGZ 123, 312

475

RGZ 127, 31

567

RGZ 135, 339

265

RGZ 138, 254

265

RGZ 138, 354

265

RGZ 142, 116

497

RGZ 151, 50

477

RGZ 154, 117

595

RGZ 155, 257

531

RGZ 157, 228

569

RGZ 158, 83

595

RGZ 161, 193

277

RGZ 162, 7

475

RGZ 170, 155

459

RGZ 170, 246

445

RGZ 170, 380

307

SJZ

SJZ 1946, 105

647

SJZ 1947, 642

475

VersR

VersR 1956, 410

449

VersR 1956, 765

405

VersR 1960, 217

585

VersR 1960, 342=BB 1959, 1186

405

VersR 1961, 231

459

VersR 1963, 339

603

VersR 1966, 875

603

Table of Cases

VersR 1967, 69, 352

489

VersR 1967, 69, 851

489

VersR 1967, 685

459

VersR 1973, 443

603

VG

VG Frankfurt aM Decision of 1.3.2001–1 G 429/01 (V)

131

VkBl

VkBl 1954, 26

585

WM

WM 1960, 582=NJW 1960, 720

383

WM 1963, 1327=NJW 1964, 33

387, 389

WM 1965, 871=NJW 1965, 1757

387

WM 1968, 300=LM

387

WM 1968, 1354=NJW 1969, 41

389, 447

WM 1969, 1358=NJW 1970, 38

389

WM 1972, 1124=NJW 1972, 2217

405

WM 1975, 157

291

WM 1976, 448

251

WM 1977, 394

291

WM 1998, 1949

357

ZBR

ZBR 1974, 369

595

ZHR

ZHR 1965, 269

445

ZHR 1967, 173

451

ZHR 1967, 176

455

ZHR 1967, 179

449

ZHR 1967, 180

453

ZR

BGH, judgment of 20.5.1952—I StR 490/51

695

BGH, judgment of 10.7.1952—IV StR 73/52

697

BGH, judgment of 31.3.1953—I ZR 584/52

725

BGH, judgment of 14.1.1954—III ZR 221/52 (Frankfurt/M)

565

BGH, judgment of 5.11.1955—VI ZR 199/54=VersR 1956, 765

405

BGH, judgment of 25.4.1956—VI ZR 34/35=NJW 1956, 1193

389

BGH, judgment of 15.5.1959—VI ZR 109/58=NJW 1959, 1676

387

BGH, judgment of 20.10.1959—VI ZR 152/58

=VersR 1960, 342=BB 1959, 1186

405

BGH, judgment of 30.1.1961—III ZR 225/59=NLW 1961, 868

409

BGH, judgment of 26.9.1961—VI ZR 92/61

383

BGH, judgment of 8.5.1965—VI ZR 58/65=LM

389

BGH, judgment of 9.10.1968—VIII ZR 173/66=WM 1968, 1354

447

BGH, judgment of 14.1.1969—VI ZR 196/67=VersR 69, 352

489

BGH, judgment of 20.6.1969—VI ZR 234/67=VersR 69, 851

489

BGH, judgment of 30.9.1969—VI ZR 254/67=WM 1972/1124

=NJW 1972, 2217

389

BGH, judgment of 11.7.1972—VI ZR 194/70=VersR 1956, 765

405

BGH, judgment of 12.6.1975—X ZR 25/73 (Hamm)

393

BGH, judgment of 27.7.1978—V ZR 180/77 (Frankfurt)

321

BGH, judgment of 13.7.1983—VIII ZR 142/82 (Düsseldorf)

283

BGH, judgment of 24.1.1984—V ZR 866/83

725

Civil Senate, judgment of 23.10.1952, VEW (defendant) v E

(claimant)—III ZR 364/51

605

Civil Senate, judgment of 25.5.1954 Dr M (plaintiff) v

D W Publishers Ltd (defendant)—I ZR 211/53

469

Civil Senate, judgment of 14.12.1960, P (defendant) v D (claimant)

—V ZR 40/60

261

Civil Senate, judgment of 13.7.1963=BGHZ 40, 91

453

Civil Senate, judgment of 26.11.1968, V Ltd (defendant) v

B (plaintiff), VI ZR 212/66

439

Civil Senate, judgment of 30.5.1972, A (defendant) v FS (plaintiff)

—VI ZR 6/71

481

Civil Senate, judgment of 19.2.1975, FL (plaintiff) v

Fa O (defendant)—VIII ZR 144/73

399

Civil Senate, judgment of 28.1.1976, D (defendant) v

L (plaintiff)—VIII ZR 246/74

377

Civil Senate, judgment of 16.6.1977, FRG (defendant) v

Fa N (plaintiff)—III ZR 179/75

579

Criminal Senate, judgment of 23.12.1952, against Z and

B—II StR 612/52

689

Criminal Senate (3rd), judgment of 23.1.1974, v W—III ZR 324/73

741

Criminal Senate (1st), judgment of 9.1.1989, v P—I ZR 641/88

715

Criminal Senate, judgment of 3.11.1992, v W and H—V ZR 370/92

621

Vacational Criminal Senate (1st), judgment of 25.7.1952, v

Sch—I ZR 272/52

733

BAG, judgment of 10.5.1957=NJW 1957, 1688

515

BGH, judgment of 26.9.1961—VI ZR 92/61=NLW 1962, 31=LM

379

BGH, judgment of 11.5.1979—V ZR 177/77 (Düsseldorf)

301

Great Senate for criminal cases, judgment of 18.3.1952—GSSt 2/51

689, 691

Senate judgment of 1.4.1953—VI ZR 77/52

465

Senate judgment of 21.4.1956—VI ZR 36/55=VersR 1956, 410

449

Senate judgment of 15.1.1958–1 BvR 400/51

505

Senate, judgment of 5.1.1960—VII ZR 1/59=NJW 1960, 720

=WM 1960, 582

383

Senate, judgment of 3.1.1961—VI ZR 67/60=VersR 1961, 231

459

Senate, judgment of 26.9.1961—VI ZR 922/61

463

Senate, judgment of 16.10.1963—VIII ZR 28/62

=WM 1963, 1327=NJW 1964, 33

387, 389

Senate, judgment of 23.6.1965—VIII ZR 201/63

=WM 1965, 871=NJW 1965, 1757

387

Senate judgment 18.1.1966—VI ZR 184/64=MDR 1966, 491

463

Senate, judgment of 21.3.1967—VI ZR 164/65

455

Senate, judgment of 4.4.1967—VI ZR 98/65=VersR 1967, 685

459

Senate, judgment of 17.10.1967—VI ZR 70/66=NJW 1968 247

465

Senate, judgment of 10.1.1968—VIII ZR 104/65

=WM 1968, 300=LM

387

Senate, judgment of 12.3.1968—VI ZR 178/66=NJW 1968, 1279

459

Senate, judgment of 30.4.1968—VI ZR 29/67=NJW 1968 1323

447

Senate, judgment of 18.6.1968—VI ZR 120/67=NJW 1968 1929

447

Senate, judgment of 9.10.1968—VIII ZR 173/66=WM 1968, 1354 =NJW 19679, 41

389

EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE

Harz v Deutsche Tradex GmbH (case 79/83) [1986] 2 CMLR 430

107

Internationale Handelsgesellschaft GmbH v EV St (Case 11/70)

[1972] CMLR 55

108

Rewe-Zentral AG v Bundesmonopolverwaltung für Branntwein

(Cassis de Dijon) (Case 120/78) [1979] 3 CMLR 494

109

Von Colson v Land Nordrhein Westfalen (Case 14/83)

[1986] 2 CMLR 430

107

UNITED KINGDOM

Bebee v Sales (1916) 32 TLR 413

573

Buron v Denman (1848) 2 Exch 167

629

Byrne v Boadle (1863) 2 H & C 722

435

Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256

241

Council for Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service

[1984] 3 All ER 935 HL

108

Derbyshire County Council v Times Newspapers

[1992] 3 All ER 65

715

Fairline Shipping Corporation v Adamson [1974] 2 All ER 967

241

Felthouse v Bindley (1862) 11 CB (NS) 869

241

Gorris v Scott (1874) LR 9 Exch 125

437

Jones v Padavatton [1969] 2 All ER 616

241

Jones v Vernon’s Pool Ltd [1938] 2 All ER 626

241

Limpus v London General Omnibus Co (1862) 1 H & C 526

563

Moorcock, The (1889) 14 PD 64

371

Musgrave v Pulido (1897) 5 App Cas 102

629

Pharmaceutical Society v Boots Cash Chemist (Southern) Ltd

[1952] 2 All ER 456; [1953] 1 All ER 482

333

R v Desmond, Barrett and Others, The Times, 28 April 1868

637

R v Secretary of State for Employment ex p Equal Opportunities

Commission and Another, The Times, 4 March 1994

141

R v Secretary of State for the Home Department ex p Brind

[1991] 1All ER 720 HL

108

Rose v Plenty [1976] 1 All ER 97

563

Saunders v Anglia Building Society [1970] 3 All ER 961

259

Ward v Tesco Stores Ltd [1976] 2 All ER 219

435

USA

Tennessee v Garner, 1985 US Supreme Court 471 US 1

655