Novak_D_V_Neosnovatelnoe_obogaschenie_v_grazhdanskom_prave_2010
.pdf(mistake of law).
1802
Bible v. Lumley <1>.
<2>.
<3>.
-------------------------------- <1> Bible v. Lumley (1802) East 469, 102 Eng. Rep. 448. <2> ., 2. 323. <3> 409 412.
45 46
Bible v. Lumley <1>.
-------------------------------- <1> ., 2. 324.
<1>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: 324; Friedmann D., Cohen N. Payment of Another's Debt // International Encyclopedia of Comparative Law. Vol. X. Restitution
Unjust Enrichment and Negotiorum Gestio. Tubingen, 1991. Ch. 10. P. 49.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
Holman v. Johnson <1>
<2>.
-------------------------------- <1> Holman v. Johnson (1775) cowp. 341, 98 Eng. Rep. 1120. <2> ., 2. 334.
818 ).
(has so changed his position),
Lipkin Gorman v. Karpnale Ltd <1>:
".
(change of position),
<2>.
-------------------------------- <1> Lipkin Gorman v. Karpnale Ltd. (1991) 548, 579. <2> ., 2. 346.
),
),
(natural justice and equity), 1875., Mayer v. New York <1>
".
-------------------------------- <1> Mayer v. New York N.Y. 455 (1875).
142
(change of circumstances) <1>.
(" ")
<2>.
-------------------------------- <1> .: ., 2. 348. <2>
in personam
(constructive trust).
(in rem)
in personam
1)
2)
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
3)
<1>.
-------------------------------- <1> Gallo P. Op. cit. P. 444.
in rem,
(constructive trust).
(trustee)
(beneficiary)
(equitable lien)
(tracing) <1>
tracing
<2>.
<3>. (in rem)
(in personam)
") <4>.
-------------------------------- <1> Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 49 56; 424 425. <2> Gallo P. Op. cit. P. 445.
Ames J.B. Following Misappropriated Property into its Product // 19 Harv. L. R. 511 (1906).
<3> Gallo P. Op. cit. P. 445. <4> ., 2. 316.
(fiduciary relationship).
(constructive trustee)
160
<1>.
-------------------------------- <1> ., 314 315.
-
).
<1>.
-------------------------------- <1> .: 81.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
(restitution subserves property rights)".
<1>.
-------------------------------- <1> 81, 95.
(1)
(benefit) (2) (3)
<1>.
--------------------------------
<1> Goff R., Jones G. Op. Cit. P. 11 26; .,
2. 306 307.
XIV XVII
(institutional writers)
<1>,
<2>.
-------------------------------- <1> 1681 .,
.: ., 1. 305). <2> Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 1.
1707
<1>.
),
1680 1870
-------------------------------- <1>
., 1.
305).
<1>.
-------------------------------- <1>
117; .,
1. 306 307.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
<1>.
<2>,
-------------------------------- <1> (Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 3). <2> ., 1. 307.
80-
XX
(Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 10).
R" (the Rs) repetition ), restitution recompense
). 1681
<1>.
R"
-------------------------------- <1> Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 11.
repetition,
"restitution",
"restitution"
-
"restitution" "unjust (unjustified) enrichment"
recompense
repetition) restitution).
(quantum lucratus) <1>.
-------------------------------- <1> Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 38.
recompense
<1>,
). action de in rem verso,
<2>.
recompense,
(Nichtleistungskondiktionen) ).
-------------------------------- <1>
6:212 (Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 27).
<2> Ibid. Text after note 98.
<1>.
(repetition restitution)
(recompense) <2>.
--------------------------------
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
<1> Morgan Garanty Trust Co of New York v. Lothian Regional Council (1995) SLT 299, 309L; Shilliday v. Smith (1998) SC 725, 728.
<2> Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 13.
condictiones sine causa
repetition restitution
recompense <1>).
Shilliday v. Smith, 1998 <2>.
"condictio causa data causa non secuta"
(ground of action),
"repetition"
(remedy) <3>.
repetition restitution
(solutio indebiti),
condictio indebiti, condictio causa data causa non secuta, condictio ob turpem vel iniustam causam
--------------------------------
<1> (Hogg M.A. Op. cit. Text after note 19).
<2> Shilliday v. Smith (1998) SC 725, 728. <3> Hogg M.A. Op. cit. (note 19).
(mistake of law) <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> Morgan Garanty Trust Co of New York v. Lothian Regional Council (1995) SC 151, (1995) SLT 299.
(change of position).