Стояюнин В.Я.. Мысли о наших экзаменах

B. .SI. CTOIOHHH

HHIO K MOJIO~bIM JllO]VIM H BeJIH~rnH:wee 3JIO no OTHOWeHHIO K rocyAapCTBY H o6~eCT.ay?

HaM KIDKeTcSI, lITO 3K3aMeHLI, 3aBepwa10~He o6~ee 06pa3oeaHHe, Heo6XOAHMO OTAeJIHTb OT rHMHa3HH. ,Il;JISI HHX CJieAOBaJIO 6LI Ha3Ha'IHTb

OAHY noCTOSIHHYIO H c n bl T a T e JI b H y IO K 0 M H c c H IO'pa3AeJIHB ee Ha CTOJibKO OTAeJIOB , CKOJibKO cy~ecTeyeT yqe6HbIX rHMHa3HtieCKHX npeAMeTOB. B Ka~LIH OTAen Ha ABa HJIH Ha TPH roAa BL16upaT1> no TPH 3K3aMe-

HaTopa-cneQHaJIHCTa H3 neAaroroB onLITHLIX, ycneewHX qeM-JIH6o xopo-

WHM 3aSIBHTL ce6SI B ceoeH: neAaromqecKoii AeSITeJILHOCTH. Ha HHX ecerAa 6yAeT yKa3LIBaTL KaK ronoc caMHX neAaroroB , TaK H ronoc o6~eCTBeHHLIH

BMeCTe c JIHTepaTypnLIM. KouelJHO, 3AeCL He CJieAyeT CTecHSITLCSI OAHHM BeAOMCTBOM MHHHCTepCTBa uapoAHoro npocBe~eHHSI; ualfAeTcSI H no APY-

rHM BeAOMCTBaM AOBOJibHO onbITHbIX H nOlJTeHHbIX neAaroroB. IlpH

Ka~OM OTAeJie AOJI)KHO 6bITb no OAHOMY HJIH no ABa KaUAHAaTa, KOTOpbie 6L1 3aMeHSIJIH 3K3aMenaTopa B cnyqae ero 6one3HH H OTCYTCTBHSI no APYrHM npHlIHHaM. KOMHCCHSI AOJI)KHa 6bITb B AeHCTBHH KpyrJILIH yqe6HbIH roA, H HCnbITaHHe no Ka~OMY npeAMeTy MO)KeT npoH3BOAHTbCSI He HHalJe, KaK B npHcyTcTBHH TPex 3K3aMenaTopoB-cnelJ)faJIHCTOB B OTAeJILHOH KOMHaTe , KyAa AOCTYn BceM npolIHM JIHQaM AOJI)KeH 6LITL 3anpeI.QeH. l1cKJ110qeeHe MO)KffO CAeJiaTb AJISI YlJHTeJISI HJIH BOCDHTaTeJISI Toro MOJIOAOro qeJIOBeKa, KOTOpbIH SIBJISieTCSI ea 3K3aMeH; eMy Aa)Ke MOA<:HO AaTb npaBO npeABapHTeJILHO o6"bSICHHTb, KaK OH BeJI AeJIO c MOJIOALIM qenoBeKOM, ea KaKHe qaCTH HJIH nOAp06HOCTH npH ero o6yqeuHH o6paI.QeHO 6oJiee BHHMaHHSI

H T . n.; HO BMeWHBaTbCSI B 3K3aMeH OH He AOJI)Keff H HMeTh npaBa ronoca npH OKOHtiaTeJILHOM coBe~aHHH OH ue MO)KeT. Me~y 3K3aMenaTopaMH

3AeCb AOJI)KHO 6LITb DOJIHOe paeeHCTBO; npHCYTCTBHe KaKoro-JIH60 Ha'laJibCTBa, AYMalO , 6Lmo 6LI TaK)Ke H3JIHWee ; TaK KaK 3AeCL npeAnonaraeTCSI DOJIHOe AOBepHe K BbI6paHHbIM 3K3aMeHaTopaM , H , CJieACTBeHHO , HaA30pa HaA HHMH He ffY)KHO'a BO ecex APYrHX cnyqaSJX HalJaJibCTBO HMeeT CBOHCTBO CTeCHSITb, npHBOAHTb B CMyI.QeHHe H coo6I.QaTb npOCTOMY AeJiy TOp)KeCTBeHHOCTb. MLI XJIODOlJeM 0 3aMKHYTOCTH OTAeJIOB HCnhITaTeJibHOH

KOMHCCHH , HMeSI B BHAY HHTepecbl 3K3aMeHylOLQHXCSI, HO 3aMKHYTOCTb 3Ta 6yAeT TOJibKO Ka~I.QaSICSI, MHHMaSI, TaK KaK Ka~bIH neAaror 6yAeT HMeTh

HeCKOJibKO cnyqaeB npHCYTCTBOBaTb 3AeCh npH HCnbITaHHH CBOHX yqeHHKOB , . CJieAOBaTeJILHO , AeSITeJibHOCTb KOMHCCHH ue 6yAeT coeepweHHO

CKpbITa H neAaroraM BcerAa 6yAeT B03M0)Kff0CTb COCTaBHTb 0 eeH: MHeHHe H Aa)Ke JIHTepa1J'PHO BhipIDKaTh ero .nm1 o6~ecTBennoro o6cy~eHHSI.

TaKHM o6pa30M, MewalOI.QaSI Aeny ny6JIHtIHOCTL 6yAeT ycTPaHeHa, a caMoe

AeJIO ue OCTaHeTCSI BHe rJiaCHOCTH. l1MeTh oco6oro HalJaJibCTBa HaA KOMHCCHelO TaIOKe HeT H~06HoCTH; AOCTaTOlJHO Ha3HalJHTb OAHOro ceKpeTapSI

HJIH 3K3eKyTopa, KOTop1>1H: 6L1 YAOBJieTBOpSIJI pa3HLIM noTPe6HOCTSIM 3K3aMeua~oHHLIX OTAeJIOB , npHKJiaALIBaJI 6LI neqaTH K CBlfAeTeJILCTBaM HT. n.

Ka~blH OTAeJI AeHCTByeT COBepweHHO He3aBHCHMO; qJieHLI ero npH caMOM CBOeM H36paHHH HJIH ua3uaqenHH HMelOT 803MO)Kff0CTb corJiaCH'rhCSI

Me~y co6010, KaK BeCTH AeJIO, H uepaeeHCTBO Ami 3K3aMeffYIOLQHXCSI 6yAeT YCTPaueuo. BL16op epeMeHH, KOrAa Aep)KaTL 3K3aMeu , AOJI)KeH

B. SI. CTOIOHHH. MbICJIH o HarnHx 3K3aMeHax

61>1TL npe;n;oCTaBJieH caMHM Mono;n;1>IM nio;n;Dt. K~1>1i Mo:xceT 3aIIHCaTbCjf ;n;m1 HCIIhlTaHHSI B JIIOOOM OT;n;eJie KOMHCCHH, Ha JIIOOOH 3K33MeH~OHHbm

;n;eHh ( eCJIH 3K3aMeHarop1>1 6y;n;yr co6HpaT1>CJ1 He e:xce;n;HeBHO). OrpamReHHe MO:XCeT OhlTb c;n;eJiaHO TOJibKO B O;D;HOM: qT061>1 Bee 3K33MeHbl BMecTe O;n;HHM JllfqOM 61>mH HenpeMeHHO OKOH'leHblB reqeHHe ro;n;a HJIH H3BeCTHOro 'IHCJia Mec~eB. Ho HeT Heo6xo;n;HMOCTH CJIHillKOM orpaHH'IHBaT1> BpeMJI 3K33MCHOB. IlpoTHB 3TOro nono:xceHHJI HeKOTOp1>1e HaM 6y;n;yr CHJibHO B03pa:xcaTb: OHH 6y;n;yT BH;n;eTb B 3TOM HeYMeCTHoe nocna6JieHHe MOJIO;D;bIM JIIOAJIM, KOTOpbIM 6y;n;eT ;n;aea B03MO:xcHOCTb ;D;JIJI DpHrOTOBJICHHJI K K~OMY 3K3aMeey H33HaqHTb ce6e CTOJlbKO BpeMeHH, CKOJlbKO HM ey:xc-

HO, 'IT061>1HaCKOpo 3ayqHTb Beeb yqe6Hbm npe;n;MeT'c ycnexoM Bbt;n;ep- :XC8Tb 3K33MeH H DOTOM TaK :xce 6bICTpo 3aOblTb BbiyqeHllOe; CJie;D;OB8TeJibHO, npH TaKOM cnoco6e DpHrOTO&neHHJI ;n;on:xcua HenpeMeHHO nOCTpa;n;aTb OCHOBaTCJibHOCTb caMOro yqeHHJI. ,Il;eHCTBHTeJibHO, eCJIH 61>1 Mbl npe;n;nonaraJIH npoH3BO;D;HTb 3K33MCHbl no 061>1qHOMY cnoco6y'TO, MO:XCeT 6bITb, Mbl H 3arrpy;n;HHJIHCb Obi OTBe'laTbHa 3TO B03pa:xceHHe, a CKOpee Bcero, ;n;a:xce H He·BblCTaBHJIH 61>1 CBoero nono:xceHHJI: .K HbIHeDIHeMY 3K3aMeey CKOJibKOHH6y;n;1> ;n;apoBHTOMY H CMeJIOMY IOHOWe JierKO DpHroTOBHTbCJI B HCCKOJlbKO He;n;eJib H BnOJIHe y;D;OBJICTBOpHTb CBOBX 3K33MeHaTOpoB. 3TO ;D;OK33bmaIOT H ymmepcHTeTCKHe 3K3aMeH1>1, ea KOTop1>IX "'Mllomecry;n;eHT1>1 noJI}"laIOT xopomue 6aJIJibl, B reqeHHe ro;n;a He 33HHM3JICb HaYKOIO H nOCBJITHB e:H TOJlbKO HeCKOJlbKO ee;n;eJib nepe;n; 3K33MeHaMH.

,Il;ae MOJIO;D;blM JIIO;D;JIM npaeo JIBIDITbCJI Ha 3K3aMeH B JIIOOoe BpeMJI B reqeHHe ro;n;a, TeM CaMblM Mbl ;n;aeM H 3K3aMeHaTOp3M ;D;OCTaTO'IHOBpeMeHH 3aHJITbCSI c K~bIM MOJIO;D;bIM qenoBeKOM, nocBJl~rur eMY He HeCKOJlbKO MllH}'T'a eCJIH ey:xcHO - HCCKOJibKO qacoB. OHH 3;D;eCb He 6y;n;yr orpaHH11eHbI O;D;HHM ;n;HeM'B KOTOpbIH ;D;OJI:xcHbl nepecnpocHTb HCCKOJibKO

;n;eCSITKOB IOHOmei, He 6y;n;yT }'TOMJieHLInoqTH ;n;o 6e3;n;eHCTBHSI M03ra, CJie- ;D;OB8TeJibHO, H 3K33MeffYIO~eMYCS1 6e3 OCHOBaTCJibHblX n03Hamui, C

MaJibIMH cHJiaMH, 6y;n;eT Bec1>Ma -rpy;n;Ho cqaCTnHBo npocKOJib3H}'TbMe:xc;n;y HX pyK. OHH MOryT KOCHyrbCSI BCCX qaCTei yqe6Horo npe;n;MeTa, MOryT c TOqHOCTbIO coo6pa3HTb CTeneHh npoqHOCTH no3Hamui Mono;n;oro qenoBeKa, MOryT BH;D;eTb ero pa3BHTHe H np. ,Il;JISI TaKoro HCilbITaHHJI ey:xcHO H

DpHrOTOBJieHHe oqeHb npoqHoe, ;D;JIJI KOToporo MaJIO He TOJlbKO HCCKOJibKHX ee;n;eJib, HOH HeCKOJibKHX Mec.su~eB. ECJIH :xce H Hai;n;yrcsr TaKHe ;n;apoBH-

Tble JIIO;D;H, KOTOpble B TeqeHHe HeCKOJlbKHX He;n;enb ycnelOT TaK OBJI3;D;eTb npe;n;MeTOM, tfTO 6y;n;yr B CHJiax BLt;n;ep:xcaTb no;n;o6HblH .3K3aMeH, TO HeT HHKaKOH ~eJIH ;n;enaTb HM npemrrCTBHSI'3a;n;ep:xcuBaTb HX HJIH MemaTb HM. qTO KOMY 3a ;n;eno, BO CKOJibKO BpeMeHH npuo6peTeHbl n03H3HllJI, JIHlllb 61>1 OHH 61>mH OCHOBaTCJibHbl H IlpO'IHbl.P33Be MHOme He I'OTOBSITCSIK 3K33MeHaM no HeCKOJILKY JieT H '1epe3ro;n; noCJie 3K33MeHa y:xce HH'leroHJIH O'leHb HeMHoro noMIDIT?

CB06o;n;H1>1:A B1>16op ;D;JIJI 3K3aMeHa YCTJ>aHHT H 6eccoHH1>1e HO'IH,KOTOp1>1e Tenepb o6blKHOBeHHO npe;n;meCTBYJOT 3K3aMeey H qaCTO HMCIOT Ha Hcxo;n; ero caMoe He6naronpmrrHoe BJIWIHHe. Mono;n;oit qenoBeK, H3 6naropa3}'MWI,no~eT Ha 3K3aMeH ror;n;a, Kor;n;a 6y;n;eT 'ly&CTBoeaT1>ce6J1 coeep-

B . }I . CTOIOHHH

meHHO roTOBhIM, eMy He HY)K}IO 6yAeT pa6oTaTb Ha epoK, cneAoBaTeJibHO, 3aHHMaTb speWI y cHa. OH 6yAeT S1BJIS1ThCS1 Ha 3K3aMeH co eBe)KHMH, 60ApbIMH, H 0 p Ma JI b H bl M H eHJiaMH H, KOHe1IHO, AaeT 60Jibllle epeACTB sepHo OQeHHTh ee6SI. CTPax ero He 6yAeT HMeTb orropbI B TOM 6eeeHJIHH Ayxa, c KaKHM OH S1BJIS1eTcS1 Terrepb rrepeA CBOHMH 3K3aMeHaTopaMH. C APYroli CTOpOHbl'eMY He IIpffAeTeSI eJ..Qe 6onee OCJia6JISITb eBOH eHJibl AOJirHM o~aHHeM, KOrAa ero BhI30BYT K HCIIhITaHHJO, HHOrAa CHAeHHeM c YTPa AO II03AHero se11epa.

CpeAH . 3K3aMeHaTopoB MOJIOAOH 11enoBeK AOJI)KeH 6hITh 060ApS1eM TaKHM o6paJ..QeHHeM, KaKoe O)KHAaeTeSI Me)l{Ay rropSIA01IHhIMH H rrpHTOM He3HaKOMblMH JIIOAhMH. 3AeCb 6yAeT COBepmeHHO HeyMeCTHblM Bbipa- )KeHHe HeTeprreHHSI HJIH AOCaAhI, HH CTPOrHH y11HTenbeKHH TOH, HH B03BbImeHHe ronoca, TeM 6onee HacMeunrn HJIH rnyMJieHHe co cTopoHhI 3K3aMeHaTopoB. IlpOHHKHYTbie CBOeH Ba)K}IOIO 06S13aHHOCTblO, OHH, KOHe1IHO, 6YAYT CTeCHSITb H OCTaHaBJIHBaTb Apyr Apyra B HerrpHJIH1IHblX BbIXOAKax.

IIporpaMMa 3K3aMeHa AOJI)Kffa 6hITh orrpeAeneHa 11pe3Bhl11a8Ho T011Ho, 3aTeM 1ITO K<UKAhIH HAYl..QHH Ha 3K3aMeH AOJI)KeH rrpeASapHTeJihHO 3HaTL, KaKHX no3HaHHH MoryT OT Hero IIOTPe6osaTb. CTPax ero 11acTo rrpoHcxoAHT OT He3HaHHSI, 1ITO MoryT ero crrpoeHTb, a 3TO He3HaHHe BbITeKaeT H3 HeonpeAeJieHHOH rrporpaMMbl'KOTopy10 MO)K}IO paCTSirHBaTb AO 6eeKOHe1IHOCTH. Y Hae 06b1KH0BeHHo yrroTPe6nS110T OAHY H TY )Ke rrporpaMMY AJISI npenoAaBaHHSI H AJISI 3K3aMeHa, 1ITO, no HallleMy MHeHHIO, KpaHHe OllIHtloq-

HO. B npeIIOAaBaHHH HMeeTeSI B BRAY He TOJibKO rrepeAaqa Il03HaHHH, HOH pa3BHTHe erroeo6Hocre8 y11~eroeS1, CJieAOBaTeJibHO, TYT MO)KeT 6bITh

MHOro oco6eHHblX eoo6pa)KeHHH'no KOTOpbIM BBOASITCSI B npeAMeT y11eHHS1 pa3Hble II0Ap06HOCTH H MeJI01IH, He HMeJO~e eyi.u;eCTBeHHoro 3Ha1IeHHSI KaK He06XOAHMOe 3HaHHe. y KIDJCAOrO 'npeIIOAaBaTeJISI 6hIBaJOT CBOH eoo6pa)KeHHSI, CJieAOBaTeJibHO, K~blH H rrpHBS13aH K H3BeCTHblM Il0Ap06HOCTSIM, e11HTaSI HX 011eHb Ba)KffblMH B CBOeM AeJie: OHH AeHeTBHTeJibHO AeJiaJOT 3TO AeJIO H AOCTHraJOT esoeH QeJIH, HO OHH )Ke HMeJOT eBOHeTBa 6bICTPO 3a6bIBaTbCSI, He eBSl3aHHbie TeCHO c eyll\ffOCTblO Beero rrpeAMeTa.

A Me)l{Ay TeM y Hae Ha HHbIX 3K3aMeHax TOJibKO H 3aHHMalOTCSI BblIIblTbIBaHHeM pa3HblX nOAp06HOCTeH, KOTOpbie .Bee BMeCTe YAep)KaTb B rraWITH MO)K}IO TOJibKO Ha caMoe KOpOTKOe BpeMSI H KOTOpbie qepe3 HeCKOJibKO HeAeJib nocne 3K3aMeHa HcrrapS110TCS1 Aa)Ke y caMoro rraMSITJIHBoro H AapoBHToro JOHOllIH. HeK0Topb1e npenoAaBaTenH Aa)Ke nw6SIT ce6SI BbIKa3bIBaTL nepe~ HallanhCTBOM TaKHMH, no HX MHeHHIO, HHTepeCHhIMH no~po6-

HOCTSIMH, ropASITCSI TeMH yt1eHHKaMH, KOTOpbie 6e3 3aIIHHKH BbIKJiaAblBalOT HX rrepeA rrpHCYTCTBYIOl..QHMH, H HHKTO rrpH 3TOM He rrpeABffAHT'llTO qepe3 MeCSIQ TOT )Ke caMbIH IOHOllla IIOTPe6yeT BpeMeHH AJISI noBTopeHHSI' ecnH B3AYMalOT eMy npeAJIO)KHTb Te )Ke caMhie eonpocb1. CnpaUIHBaeM, 11To )Ke 3TO 3a 3HaHHSI H CTOHT JIH o HHX TaK xnorroTaTb Ha 3K3aMeHax? A

Me)l{Ay TeM OHH-TO, no 60JibllleH llaCTH, H 3aCTaBJISllOT yt1eHHKOB rrpOCIDKHBaTb HOllH nepeA 3K3aMeHaMH, llT06bI Ha KOpoTKoe RpeMJI ea6HTb HMH ronoay HAO Toro OAypeTb OT HHX, 1ITO eAeJiaTbCSI He cnoco6HbIM OTBet.IaTb H Ha caMbie cyJ..QeCTBeHHhie aonpocbI HayKH. Oco6eHHO qacro cnyt1aeTcS1

B. 51 . CTOtOHHH . M blCJIH o HawHx 3KJaMeHax

3TO Ha 3K3aMeHax H3 3aKOHa 60)l(IDI, HCTOpHH, CJIOBeCHOCTH, reorpacpHH: 3,((ecL ronoBa xopomo 3K3aMeHyioI.Qeroc.si 6L1BaeT HanoJIHeHa }')KacaJOI.QHMH IlO,((p06HOCTSIMH'H3 KOTOpbIX He ,((eJiaeTCSI pelllHTeJILHO HHKaKHX BbIBO,((OB H KOTOpbie, CJie,((OBaTeJibHO, o6peKalOTCSI caMH co6oio Ha 3a6BeHHe. 3K3a.MeHaTop ,((OJI)l(eH . CTpeMHTbCSI BepHO onpe,((eJIHTb, BMeCTe c Il03HaHIDIMH, H CTeneHL pa3BHTIDI MOJIO,((Oro 'lCJIOBeKa,HO eMy HeT HHKaKOro ,((eJia, KaK.HMH nyTSIMH TOT pa3BHBaJICSI, KaKHe IlO,((p06HOCTH 6bIJIH BbI)::(eJieHbl H3 uayKH HCKJIIO'lHTeJILHOB BH)::(aX ero pa3BHTHSI. ECJIH MOJIO,((OH 11enoBeK OKa)l(eTCSI pa3BHTLIM, CCJIH Bee BbIBO,((bl HayKH, o603Ha'1eHHLieB nporpaMMe, OH MO)l(CT ,((OKa3aTb HJIH IlO,((TBep,((HTb cpaKTaMH, TO 3TOro H ,((OCTaTO'lHO.Ilp011HOCTb TaKHX 3HaHHH HCCOMHeHHa; HX He HY)l(HO Ka)l()::(blH MeCSIQ IlO,((Y'lHBaTb,'1T06bIC'lllTaTbCSIo6pa30BaHHbIM qenoeeKOM.

B nporpaMMe 3K3aMeHa ,((OJI)l(ffhI 6LITL TO'lHO060JHa11eHLI Te cy~e­

CTBeHHLie Il03HaHIDI, KOTOpbie Be,((yT K onpe,((eJieHHbIM BbIBO,((aM HayKH H KOTOpbie, CJie,((OBaTeJihHO, COCTaBJISllOT ,((eHCTBHTeJihHYIO Ba)l(HOCTb B 061.QeM o6pa3oBaHHH. TaKHe noJHaHIDI 6epyTcSI o6LIKHOBeHHO He naM.sIThJO, a coo6pa)l(eHID1MH yMa; Ha HHX yM y6e)l()::(aeTCSI B TOH HJIH ApyroH: HCTHHe;. HMH 3K3aMeHyJOI.QHHCSI ,((OKa3bIBaeT''1TOOH ,((eHCTBHTeJibHO H3Yqan npe,((MeT. qTo ,((06L1To TPYAOM yMa, To naM.sITh nerKo H Ha,((onro y):'(ep- )l(HBaeT, CJie,((CTBeHHO, TYT HeJib3SI onacaTLCSI 3a Henpo11HOCTL 3HaHHH.

KaKHe HMeHHO no3HaHIDI, BhIBO,((LI H cpaKThI ,((OJI)l(HbI BORTH B npo-

rpaMMLI 3K3aMeHOB, pa3pemHTb 3TOT BOnpoc CJie,((yeT npe)l()::(e BCero nopy- 'lHTbcne~aJIHCTaM no Ka)l()::(oMy y11e6H0My npe,((Mery. He c-recHSISI npo-

rpaMMhI npeno,((aBaHHSI, KOTOpaSI B qacTHOCT.SIX MHOro 3aBHCHT OT JIH'IHOCTH npeno,((aBaTeJISI, '1TO YHH'lTO)KaTb 6bIJIO 6bI KpaHHe Bpe,((HO, OHH ,((OJl)l(Hbl CTeCHHTb nporpaMMY 3K3aMeHa, TaK KaK OHa 6y,((eT CJl}')KHTb pe3yJILTaTOM npeno,((aBaHHSI Bcex 6e3 BCSIKOro OTHOllleHHSI K KaKOH-JIH60 OT,((eJibHOH JIH'lHOCTH. Ho Ha onpe,((eJieHHH O,((HHX cneQHaJIHCTOB OCTaHOBHTbCSI. HeJIL3SI: B HX HaType yBJieKaTbCSI IlO,((p06HOCTSIMH H C'lHTaTb 3a O'leHbBa)l(HOe ,((JISI acex TO, '1TOHa caMOM ,((ene Ba)l(HO TOJlbKO ,((JISI 3allHC-

HblX cneQHaJIHCTOB. Bee HX nporpaMMbl He06XO,((HMO nopyqHTb Ha OKOH'laTeJibHbIH npOCMOTp COBeTy'COCTaBneHHOMY H3 rre,((arorOB'3aHHMalO~HXCSI

061.QeJO ne,((arorHeio. 0HH ,((OJI)l(Hbl .onpe,((eJIHTL HaCTOSll.QHH o6neM nporpa.MM, TPe6yeMLIH o6ll.\HM o6pa3oBaHHeM. MLI He ocTaHaBnHBaeMCSI 3,((ecb Ha qaCTHOCTSIX no Ka)l()::(OMY npe,((MeTy' nOTOMY '1TO 3TO 3aBeJIO 61>1 Hae CJIHlllKOM ,((aJieKO. 3THX qaCTHOCTeH MO)l(eT 6bITb O'leHbMHOro; HeMaJIO OKa>KeTCSI H cnopHblX nyHKTOB B BOnpoce 0 TOM, '1TOBa)l(HO B Macce 003HaHHH aoceMHa,((QaTHJieTHero JOHOlllH, BcrynaioIQero B PSIALI rpruKAaH cBoero 0Te11ecTBa. Ho MLI He AYMaeM, 11To6L1 B rnaBHhIX ocHoBaHHSIX Morno BLIHTH 6onLmoe pa3HornacHe . HHKTO, HanpHMep, He 6y,((eT cnopHTh, '1TO pycCKOMY IOHOllle c o6IQHM o6pa30BaHHeM He06XO,((HMO 3HaTb 0 ,((CSITeJibHOCTH JloMoHocoBa, KapaM3HHa H Apyrux nyqUIHX HaUIHX nHCaTene:H npe)l(Hero epeMCHH; HHKTO He 6y,((eT OTPHQaTb, '1TO3HaKOMCTBO c HHMH 6y,((eT BbITeKaTb H3 OCHOBaTeJILHOrO H3y11eHHSI HeKOTOpbIX HX C0'1HHeHHH,'1TOTaKoe H3y11eHHe He MO)l(eT 6bITb OTHeceHO K pa3pSl,((y o6peMeHSllOIQHX Il03HaHHH' KOTOpbie He ,((alOT HHKaKHx BbIBO,((OB H 6LICTPO 3a6LIBalOTCSI. Cnop MO)l(eT

B. 51 . CTOIOHHH

6bITb 0 TOM, KaKHe HMeHHO H3 CO'IHHeHHHCJieAyeT npeAilO'lleCTbAJUI H3}"1eHHSI. Ho KaKne 6bl OHH HH 6blJIH, a 3K3aMeffYIO~HHCSI AOn)KeH AOKa3aTb,

'ITOOH H3yqan HX, AOKa3afb OTBeTaMH Ha eonpOCbl 0 pa3BHTHH rnaBHOH H,n;eH BO ecex qaCTSIX npoH3BeAeHHSI, 0 CSSI 3H ero c coepeMeHHOCTblO, 0 npH3HaKax'no KOTopbl\.{ ero OTHOCSIT K 'TOMY HJIH APyroMY poAy H BK~Y

CO'IHHeHHHHT. n. 06 3THX Ba)KffbIX TPe0osaHHSIX, KOHe'IHO,TaIOKe HHKTO He 6yAeT cnopHTb. Ilo HaweMy MHeHHro, e~e He ·6onbWaSI 6eAa, eCJIH IOHOWa o6'bSIBHT''ITOOH He 3HaKOM c K3KHM-JIH6o AIDKe 83)KffbIM npOH3SeAeHHeM OTe'lleCTBeHHOHnHTeparypbI, eCJIH OH MO)KeT AOKa3aTb, 'ITOOCHOBaTenbHO H3}"1an Apyrne H3 HHX H DOHSIJI rnaBHble qepTbl xapaKTepa IIHCaTensr. X~e, ecnH OH 060S1BHT, 'ITO'IHTansee 3aMe'laTeJibHbienpoH3SeAeHHSI'A3)Ke paCCKIDKeT HX COAep)KaHHe'HO 6onee 3TOro HH'lleroHe CKa)KeT. OH TOnbKO AOKa)KeT CBOH 6eCllJIOAHble 3aHSITHSI'Ha KOTOpbIX He Mor pa3BHsaTbCSI; OH AOKIDKeT CHJIY ceoeit. naMSITH, HO OHa oco6eHHO He QeHHTCSI npli

oQeHKe yMcreeHHoro pa3SHTHSI. 3K3aMeHaTopbI AOn)Kffbl y6eAHTbCS1, 'ITO 3K3aMeHylO~HCSI Hay'IHJICSI'IHTaTbc TOnKOM, paccy:>KAaTb HaA npo'llHTaH-

HblM'33Me'llaTbnHTeparypHbie npHeMbl IlHCaTeJISI - Bee 3TO MO)KeT 6b1Tb

sepHbIM pY'JaTeJILCTBOMu AanLHeimero ero pa3SHTHSI npH noMO~H 'ITe- HHSI. Pa3s~TbIH MonoAOH qenoseK 6LICTJ'OAOnOJIHHT TO, qero eMy HeAo-

CTaeT, H CTaSHTb eMy HeyAOBJieTBOpHTenbHbIH 6ann 3a TO, 'ITOOH HC 3HaKOM c TeM HJIH APYrHM npoH3SeAeHHeM, xoTsr 6b1 Aa)Ke H 03Ha'lleHHLIMe nporpaMMe'ecnH OCHOSaTenbHO H3}"1aJI Apyme npoH3BeAeHHSI Toro )Ke DHCaTensr, 6blno 6bl Kpafme HecnpaBeAJIHBO, 'IT06blHe CKa3aTb AHKO.

Toqeo TO )Ke MO)KffO cKa3aTb Ho APYrHX npeAMeTax. B nporpaMMbI cneAYeT sHeCTH TOJILKO TO, 'ITO3K3aMeHyro~Hicsr AOJI)KeH 6Lm He 3a}"IHBaTL,

a H3}"1aTb, H Mbl ysepeHbl, 'ITOc HHMH CaMbie 3K3aMeHbl AeHCTBHTeJlbHO 6YAYT AOCTHraTb Tex QeJieH, KaKHe HM Ha3Ha'llalOTCSI. IlOA06Hbie npo-

rpaMMbl HenpeMeHHO npHHecyT e~e u ry nonL3Y, 'ITOyn}"lwaT caMoe npenoAaeaHHe, TaK KaK o6paTSIT BHHMaHHe Ha rnaBHOe H c~eCTBeHHOe HOTS-

JieKyT OT Toro, 'ITOHCCTapu Ha3MSaeTCSI K 0 H b K 0 M npenoAaSaTeJISI. 3K3aMeHbl AOJl)Kffbl 6b1Tb DHCbMeHHbie H CJIOBeCHbie, nepsble e~e SIDK-

Hee BTOpbIX H HenpeMeHHO AOJl)Kffbl HM npeAmeCTBOS3Tb; HO Mbl HHKaK He AOfiYCKaeM HX B TaKOH Macce's KaKOH OHH npOH3BOASITCSI s HaCTOSl~ee epe-

MSI. Ecnu qenoseKy 3aAaeTCSI cepbe3HbIH YMCTBeHHbIH TPYA, TO ffY)KffO no3a60THTLCS1 H 06 o6CTaHosKe, KOTopasi 6b1 TOMY 6naronpHS1TCTsosana. Hy)Kffo OT Hero YAaJIHTb see TO, 'ITOMO)KeT ero pa3BJieKaTb HJIH oTBJieKaTb OT Tpy~a 1'pe6oBaHHeMBHHMaHHSI K IlOCTOpoHHHM JI~aM. Kpalrne mIOXH Te neAarom, KOTOpble, HBHSWHCb s Macey MOJIOAbIX JllOAeH, AYMalOT Y3H3Tb 06 HX D03HaHHSIX H pa3BHTHH, JaAaS HM KaKylO-HH6YAb HH'ITO)KffYIO TeMy's KOTOpOH Heqero H pa3BHBaTb, H, Ha3Ha'IHScpoK, c qacaMH B pyKax :>KAYT IlOCJieAHeH ero MHHYTbl H JaTeM 6bICTpO co6uparoT HCDHCaHHbie HJIH HeAonucaHHbie nHCTO'l{KH. OHH Aa)f(e He nOA03pesaroT, 'ITO ceoei co6CTSeHHOH oco6oi MemalOT TPYAY, H MemaroT TeM 6onLwe, 'leMCHJILHee y HHX crpaCTb pa3blrpb183Tb reHepanbCKYIO pOJib. IlHCbMeHHblH 3K3aMeH s

Macce so36y)l{AaeT co cropoHbI 3K3aMeHaTopos onaceHHe, 'IT06LI3K3aMeHyro~11ecsr He DOJlb30SanHCb B3aHMHOIO IlOMO~blO HJIH He npn6eranH 6bl K

B. SI . CTOIOHHH. MMC.11H o HaWHX 3K3aMeHax

nOMOIIUf KHHr H Terrpa,o;e:H: OTClOJ:{a SIBJUleTCSI HenpHSITHbIH Ha,D;30p HJIH OCKOp6nTeJibHOe JarJISl,D;bIBaHHe B Sll.QHKH CTOJIOB, pa3BJieKalOI..Qee xo~e­

HHe Ha6JIIO,D;aTeJISI Me)K,ll;y CTOJiaMH, He,o;eJIHKaTHOe COBaHHe CBOero HOca B rrpy,o; nnIIIyI..Qero n np. Bee 3TO HHYIO MOJI0,o;y10 HaTypy ,o;o Toro pa3BJieKaeT, CM-yI..QaeT H BOJIHyeT''llTOOH He B CHJiax cocpe,o;oTOt{HTb MbICJieH H no,o;aeT CBOH rrpy,o;, caM KpaHHe HM He,o;oBOJibHbIH.

,[(JISI nHCbMeHHOro 3K3aMeHa ,D;OJI)({Hbl Ha3HaqaTbCSI TaKHe TeMbl, KOTOpbie 6bI He MOrJIH B036y,o;HTb onaceHHSI, t{TO 3K3aMeHylOI..QHHCSI BblilHIIIeT HX pa3BHTHe H3 KaKoro-Jin6o yqe6HHKa HJIH H3 CBOeH yqe6HOH TeTpa,o;n, cne,o;oBaTeJibHO, He 6y,o;eT OKa3bIBaTbCSI H Ha,D;06HOCTH B Ha,D;30pe 3a nHIIIY-

1.QHM. IlycKaH OH ,o;IDKe 3arJISl,D;bIBaeT B CBOH yqe6HHK, HJIH B JieKCHKOH, HJIH

,o;a:>Ke B npOH3Be,o;eHHe OHCaTeJISI, eCJIH eMy HY:>KHO c,o;eJiaTb KaKylO-JIH60 cnpaBKy; TeMa ,D;OJI)l(Ha 6bITb TaKoro po,o;a, 'llT06bI3K3aMeHylO~HHCSI, 6e3

co6CTBeHHoro 3anaca no3HaHHH, 6e3 npe,o;BapnTeJibHbIX rrpy,o;oB no BCeMy

npe,o;Mery, 6e3 co6CTBeHHbIX coo6pa)KeHHH n paccy)K,ll;eHHH He Mor c HelO Hnqero c,o;eJiaTb, ecnn ·6b1 y Hero 6bIJIH no,o; pyKaMn pa3Hbie cnpaBO'llHbie KHHI'H. Hx ,o;IDKe cJie,o;yeT ,o;aBaTb no HHbIM TeMaM, qT06b1 sn,o;eTb, KaK

MOJio,o;o:H qeJIOBeK MO)KeT cnpaBJISITbCSI c HHMH n H3BJieKaTb HY)({Hbie MaTepnanbI H3 Toro, 'llTOy Hero ecTb. KoHe'llHO,3TH TeMbI ,o;oJI)({HbI 6bITb BceTaKH coo6pruKeHbl c CHJiaMH IOHOIIIH H c TeMH Il03HaHHSIMH, KaKHX no nporpaMMe MO)KHO OT Hero Tpe6oBaTb. Ilpn 3TOM ero CJie,o;yeT ye,o;HHHTb eCJIH He B oco6o:H KOMHaTe, TO 33 oco6bIM CTOJIOM, t{T06bI HHKTO He MOr MeIIIaTb et.ty HJIH pa3BJieKaTb ero. Pa6oTa ero ,o;oJI)({Ha 6bITb o6cy)K,ll;eHa BceMH 3K3aMeHaTopaMH coo6i.qa, H OHa-TO )l;OJI:>KHa CJIY:>KHTb HCXO,D;HbIM nyHKTOM ,D;JISI CJIOBecHoro 3K3aMeHa, a He K3KOH-HH6y,o;b cnyqa:ffHo nonaBIIIHHCSI 6HJieT. Ilo 3TOH pa6oTe y)Ke MO)KHO OCHOBaTeJibHO cy,o;HTb 0 pa3BHTHH MOJIO,o;oro qeJIOBeKa; CJIOBeCHbIH )Ke 3K3aMeH 6y,o;eT TOJibKO ,D;ODOJIHHTeJibHblM ,D;JISI Y3HaHHSI KOJinqecTBeHHOH CTOpOHbl OCHOBaTeJibHblX n03HaHHH no eceM 'llaCTstMyqe6Horo npe,o;MeTa.

0KOH'llaTeJibHastOQeHKa ,D;OJI)l(Ha 6bITb c,o;eJiaua T o T q a c )Ke nocne CJIOBeCHOro 3K3aMeHa K a 0 r 0 3K3aMeHyioi.qerocSI H HenpeMeHHO o6~HM COBeTOM 3K3aMeHaTopoB, a He DOCJie HCnbITaHHSI HeCKOJibKHX MOJIO,IJ;blX JIIO,D;eH, t{T06bl OTBeTbl O,D;Horo He MorJIH CMeIIIHB3TbCSI B naMSITH 3K3aMeHaTopoB c OTBeTaMH ,o;pyroro; 1IT06bI HM npHIIIJIOCb cy,o;HTb no CBe- :>KHM Bne'llaTJieHHSIM,npHHHMaSI BO BHHMaHne Bee o6CTOSITeJibCTBa, a He no MepTBbIM QHQ>paM, 6e3yqacTHO npOH3BO)l;SI ,o;eHCTBHSI CJIO:>KeHHSI H ,o;eJieHIDI .

T3KOMY-TO npe,o;Mery, T. e. Mor JIH OH no HHM pa3BHBaTb CBOH nOHSITHSI HJIH HeT, Mor JIH OH nOJib30BaTbCJI HJIH HeT TeM, t{TO ,o;aeT TaKaSl-TO HayKa B H3BeCTHOM o6'beMe.Ecnn :>Ke OH 3a6bm HeK0Topb1e Q>aKTbI, HJIH HaJBaHHSI HHblX ropo,o;oB H MeCT, HJIH HeKOTOpbie t{HCJia H ro,o;bl, HJIH KOH-KaKHe Q>opMYJibl, TO, npaBo, B 3TOM eI..Qe He60JibIIIaS1 6e,o;a, 3a6b1Ba10T nx ,o;IDKe cne- l\ffaJIHCTbI, )l;JISI KOTOpbIX COCTaBJIJllOTCJI pa3Hble cnpaBOt{Hbie KHHrH. JinIIIaTb MOJIO,o;oro qeJIOBeKa npaB, napaJIH30B3Tb ero CHJibl, BHOCHTb rope H CJIC3bl B QeJioe ceMeHCTBO H3-3a Toro TOJibKO, 'llTOOH c6HJICJI B ,D;OKa3a-

B . ~. CTOIOHHH

TeJibCTBax TaKOrO-TO cpH3WleCKoro JaKOHa, HJIH He paccKa3aJI pa3HblX noApo6HocreH: QapcrsosaHIDI JlJOAOBHKa XIV, HJIH cnyTaJICSI B rpaMMaTH11ecKoH: cxonacTHKe, HJIH Ja TO, 1.JTO nony'IHJIABe ABOHKH no ABYM 'laCTSIM pa3HblX npeAMeTOB, XOTSI no BCeM npO'IHM11aCTSIM Bcex npeAMeTOB 0 T T p ex A 0 n SITH 6aJIJIOB, 3TOro, KOHe'IHO, onbITHbie 3K3aMeHaTOpbIneAarorH AOnycKaTb He 6YAYT. CosepweHHO OT HX BOJIH HJIH COBeTa AOJI)KHO JaBHCeTb H pa3peweHHe nepe3K3aMeHOBKH. OHH MOrYT BffAeTL, CKOJibKO H KaKHX n03HaHHH HeAOCTaeT IOHOIIIe, MOryT coo6pa3HTb KOJIH'leCTBO BpeMeHH, HYXHOe AJISI OCHOBaTeJibHOro HX npHo6peTeHIDI, MoryT, CJieAOBaTeJibHO, Ha3H3'1HTbcpoK, noCJie KOTOporo OH HMeeT npaeo CHOBa SIBHTbCSI Ha 3K3aMeH. B 3TOM Mbl He BHAHM HHKaKoro 3Jia, a, HanpOTHB, BffAHM ycTPaHeHHe npH'IHHhIToro ropsi H crpaAaHHH, KaKHe TepilSIT 6eAHLie JIIOAH OT HeyAaBWerOCSI 3K3aMeHa IOHOro 'IJieHaceMbH.

McnblTaTeJibHble KOMHCCHH MOryT 6bITb COCTaBJieHbl BO Bcex yHHBepcHTeTCKHX ropOAax, rAe ecerAa H3HACTCSI AOBOJibHO neAaroroB, H3 cpe]J,"bl KOTOpLIX 6yAeT B03MO)KHO AeJiaTb yAa1lHLie BL16opL1. 3a mMHa3HSIMH xe Tex ropOAOB, rAe He 6yAeT HCilbITaTeJibHblX KOMHCCHH, MO)KHO OCTaBHTb npaBO no 06.IQHM nporpaMMaM 3K3aMeHOBaTb )KeJiaJOIQHX, KOTOpbie, B cny- ':laeHeyAal.JH, BcerAa MOryT nepe3K3aMeHOBaTbCSI B TOH HJIH ApyroH: HCilblTaTeJibHOH KOMHCCHH. ATTeCTaTbl 3THX rHMHa3HH AOJI)Kffbl HMeTb CHJIY aTTeCTaTOB, BhIAaBaeMLIX OT KOMHCCHH, H nosepo11HL1e HCnL1TaHHS1 B yHHsepcHTeTax MoryT coxpaHHTLCSI AJISI nocrynaJOIQHX TYAa c mMHaJwiecKHMH aTTeCTaTaMH; HO y)Ke He CJieAyeT nOABepraTb HM nocrynaJO.IQHX c aTTeCTaTaMH OT KOMHCCHH. rHMHa3HH AOJI)Kffbl OK3H'IHBaTb Kypc B IlOCJieAHeM KJiacce B IlOJIOBHHe MapTa H 3aTeM npeAOCTaBIDITb CBOHM y'leHHKaMnonHYIO CB060AY pacnopSl)KaTbCSI BpeMeHeM AJISI HCnbITaHHSI B KOMHCCHH. BpeMeHH AO Ha':laJiaKypca B BblCWHX HJIH cneQHaJibHblX y'le6HblX3aBeAeHH11X HM OCTaeTCSI AOBOJlbHO'H'KOHel.JHO'Ka)K)l;bIH BOCnOJlb3yeTCSI HM no CBOeMY ycMOTPeHHIO H no CBOHM cHJiaM. HaM Ka)KeTCSI, 'ITOH YffHBepcHTeTaM HeT Heo6xOAHMOCTH OTKaJ:bmaTL B npueMe HOBLIX CTYAeHTOB AO nonoBHHbI OKTS16pS1 HJIH Aa)Ke HOS16pst, oco6eHHO Tex, KOTOpbIM He ffY)KHO AeJiaTb noeepO-'IHblXHCilbITaHHH.

CaMo co6010 pa3yMeeTCSI, 'ITO3K3aMeHaTOpbI KOMHCCHH AOJI:>KHhI nony11aTL 3a csou TPYALI oco6oe B03Harpa)K)l;eHue, u, npH6aenio, B03Harp3)1(AeHHe He Konee'!Hoe.K 3TOH pa6oTe ffYXHO npHBJieKaTb ny11wHX ne.QaroroB, KOTopb1e 6L1 c Reio He TOJibKO HH'leroHe TepS1JIH, iio e.IQe 6bI BLIHrpbIBaJIH

H KOTOpLie, CJieACTBeHHO, OXOTHO 61>1 6paJIHCb 3a eee H AOPO)KHJIH 61>1 el-0. Tor.Qa, KOHe11Ho, MO)KHO pacc11HTLIBaTb, ':ITO .Qeno noH:.QeT xopowo. Ho ecnH CMOTPeTb Ha npeno,QaBaTeneH:, KaK Ha cy.IQeCTBa, KOTOpbie 06S13aHbl HeCTH Ha nneqax BCe, .1.JTO Ha'laJibCTBYB3AyMaeTCSI Ha HHX HaBblO'IHTb,H HeCTH 6e3 BCSIKOro B03Harp3)1(AeHHSI, XOTSI 6hI 3TO H He B"°AHJIO B Kpyr HX o6si3aHHOCTeH, onpe]J,eneHHblX ycTaBOM, TO, pa3yMeeTCSI, He11ero H rOBOpHTb o KaKHX-nH6o ynyqweHHSIX. qT06L1 ]J;enaTJ> ]J;eno, HY)KHO AaTh H Heo6XOAHMLie AJISI Toro cpeACTBa. CTPaHHO TPe6oeaTh OT OAHHX H Tex )Ke JIHQ nocTOSIHHbIX no)KepTBOBaHHH H TPYAOM, H speMeHeM noA TeM npeAnoroM, 'ITO6yATO 6bl nnaTHTb ue11eM. Mb1 3HaeM, 'ITOnnaTstT xopomo Aa)Ke so

B. ~. CTotoHHH. MbtCJIH o HalllHX JK3aMeHax

BeeM o6eeneqeHHbIM COJIAaTaM, eCJIH HX Ha3HaqaioT Ha KaKylO-JIH60 oeo6yio pa6ory'TCM 6onee BnpaBe TPe6oBaTb 3TOro JIIOAH'KOTOphle TSl)KeJlbIM TPYAOM caMH AOJI}f{Hhl o6eeneqHsaTL ce6S1. Hae cnpocRT: rAe )Ke B3SlTL ,a;eHer? KoHeqHo , ene,a;yeT 6paTL e Tex, Ha Koro 6y,a;yT pa60TaT1>. qaCTL

,IJ;OJI}f{HO rmaTHTL roey,a;apcrso, qaCTL - }"IHJIH~e H qaCTL - OTAeJILHLie JiffqHOeTH. YqHJIH~a, ,a;aio~He esoHM yqeHHKaM o6~ee o6pa30BaHHe H

6epy~He e HHX rmaTy' JierKO MOryT BbIHeCTH HC3HaqHTeJibHbIH HaJIOr'

TOqHo TaK, KaK H ymrnepeHTCThl , H ,a;pyme eneJ.UlaJibHble 3aBe,a;eHIDI, KOTOpbie TPe6yioT OT nocrynaio~Hx mMHa3HqeeKoro aTTeCTaTa. 113 3K3aMeHY-

IO~HXeSl JIIO,IJ;H He,a;oCTaToqHble ,IJ;OJI}f{Hbl 6b1Tb ysoJieHbl OT BeSlKOro B3HOea, ,IJ;JISl qero OHH AOJI)f(Hbl TOJibKO npe,a;eTaBHTb eBHACTCJibCTBa 0 esoe:H HeeoCTOSlTeJihHOeTH HJIH OT rHMHa3HH, r,a;e OHH }"IHJIHeb, HJIH ,a;o6b1Tb me ,a;pyrHMH 3aKOHHhlMH IlYTSlMH, KaK ACJiaeTeSl 3TO H Tenepb. nJISl JIIO,IJ;eH )Ke eoCTOSlTCJibHblX Huqero He 6y,a;eT 3HaqHTb BHeeTH HeeKOJibKO py6ne:H. MbI yKa3blBaeM TOJibKO Ha HeToqHHKH ,a;oxo,a;a, HO He BXO,IJ;HM B no,a;po6Hble HeqHCJICHHSl, ,IJ;JISl KOTOpbIX y Hae HeT Beex HY)f(HbIX ,a;aHHbIX, no3TOMY He

MO)f(eM eKaJaTL, KaKaR ,a;oJISl nJiaTLI Morna 61>1 npHHTHCL Ha roeyAapcTBO. B HaCTOSl~ee BpeMSl ey~eeTBYIOT oeo61>1e KOMHCeHH ,IJ;JISl HenblTaHHSl

)f(CJialO~ nOJI}"IHTb npaBO 6LITb ,IJ;OMamHHMH HaCTaBHHKaMH H uacTaBHH-

QaMH, ye3AHhlMH H npHXO,IJ;CKHMH }"IHTeJISlMH, 3JieMeHTapHblMH yqHTeJihHffQaMH. Ha HX noJIO)f(eHHe TaIOKe ene,a;osano 6LI o6paTHTL BHHMaHue, TaK

KaK OHO e~e HeB1>1ro,a;Hee nOJIO)f(CHHSl 3K3aMeffYIO~eSl B rHMHa3HSIX. 3aMeTHM, qTo B 3TH KOMHCCHH SlBJISllOTeSl no 60Jihme:H qaCTH MOJIO,IJ;ble ,a;esymKH, nonyqHBmue naHeHOHCKoe HJIH ,a;oMamHee soenHTaHne. CeML BOCbMbIX H3 HHX npHHa,a;Jie)f(aT He,IJ;OCTaToqHhIM ceMhSlM, KOTOpble paecquTbIBalOT Ha HX TPYALI, npe,a;HaJHaqaR me B rysepHaHTKH HJIH yqHTeJILHHQLI. ECJIH pe,a;KH:H IOHoma He qyseTsyeT eep,a;eqHoro TPCneTa, SlBJISISICL Ha uenLITaHHe K COBepmeHHO HC3HaKOMblM JIHQaM, TO qTo )KC ,IJ;OJI)f(ffa 'l)'BCTBOBaTb MOJIO,IJ;aSl ,a;esymKa, no.a; KaKHM rHeTOM CTPaxa AOJI)f(Ha oHa IlPHAYMLIBaTL OTBeTbl Ha BOnpocbJ 3K3aMeHaTopa. 11 3aMeTHM, qTo OHa He MO)f(eT npeA-

BapHTCJibHO nOJI}"IHTb HHKaKOH onpeAeJieHHOH H eKOJibKO-HH6y,a;L IlOAp06HOH nporpaMMbl'KOTOpo:H B KOMHCeHH noKa e~e He cy~eCTByeT. 3K3aMe- ffYIO~e:HcSl H3BeCTHO TOJibKO'qTo OT Hee noTPe6yioT 3HaHHSl mMHaJuqec-

KOro Kypea; HO e:H H3BeeTHO H TO, qTo B Ka)f(,IJ;OH mMHa3HH npenoAaBaTeJIH BBOASIT B Kype eBOH qaCTHOCTH H nOAp06HOCTH''lJTOy Ka)f(,ll;Oro eCTL CBOH Ko H L K H. Ha qTo e:H o6paTHTL oeo6eHHoe BHHMa,1rne? •. B AYMax 06 3TOM OHa Tep.sreTCSI eme no 3K33MeHa, H eii KIDKeTC.sr, 'lJTOOHa HH'lJeroHe 3HaeT.

B TaKOM cocTOSlHHH Ayxa OHa OTAaeTCSl so BJJaCTL He Qenoro neAaroruqecKoro eoBeTa, He HeCKO:JlbKHX 3K3aMeHaTopoB c aCCHCTeHTaMH, a OJJ;Horo qeJIOBeKa, KOTOpbIH H pemaeT cyn;i,6y ee, B TO BpeMSl KaK y ee eeMbH u,a;eT

peqi,, MO)f(eT 6LITb, 0 KYCKe XJie6a ..•

HaM Ka)f(eTeSl, qTo npeAJiaraeMaR HaMH HcnLITaTeJibHaSl KOMHCCHSI

Morna 61>1 JaHSlTbCSl H 3THM Tpyn;oM - 3K3aMeHoBaTb Ha pa3Hhle neAarom-

qecKHe 3BaHHSl, TeM 6onee, qTo 3TOT 3K3aMeH OTJIHqaeTCSl OT rHMHaJuqecKOro pa3Be TOJibKO npo6HblMH ypoKaMH. Ho 3TH ypoKH 6bIBalOT BCern;a TaK KapHKaTYPHLI, qTo TepS110T BCSlKoe nen;aroruqecKoe JHaqeHHe. 0HH

B. .SI. CTOl-OHHH

noXO)KH mrBL1yqeHHLIH ypoK , KOTOpLIH yqeHHK HacKopo, APO:>Ka.ll.VIM ronocoM OTBeqaeT CBOeMY yqHTemo. ffHqero Apyroro HHKOrAa He MO:>KeT H BbIHTH H3 TaKHX npo6HbIX ypoKOB. Mo:>KHO JIH ·rpe6oBaTb OT MOJIOAOH AeByIIIKH npo6LI, KaK OHa 6yAeT yqHTb, ecJIH OHa e~e H caMa He COIIIJia c yqe6HOH CKaMeHKH, HHKOrAa HHKOro He yqHJia H HHKTO He IlOK33bIBaJI ei, KaK CJieAyeT npHHHMaTbCjf 33 3TO AeJIO; Aa:>Ke CaMoyqKOH ee HeKOrAa 6LIJIO eI.Qe CAenaTLcsr. Ha HeOA06peHHe npo6Horo ee ypoKa ee ocTaeTcsr JIHIIIL noBTOpHTb cnoea IlpocraKOBCKoro TpHmKH: «Aa nepBLIH-TO nopmoe IIIHJI, MO)KeT 6bITb, XY:>Ke MOero».

3K3aMeH Ha 3BaHHe·ryeepHaHTOK B HCilbITaTeJibHOH KOMHCCHH npHHec 6L1 H TY ea)l(Hyro noJIL3Y, qTo HenpeMeHHO ynyqmHJI 6L1 caMo npenoAaBaHHe B HallIHX qaCTHbIX :>KeHCKHX yqHJIHI.Qax CBOHMH IlOAp06HbIMH nporpaMMaMH, c KOTOpbIMH CTaJIH 6bI coo6pa:>KaTbCSI npenOAaBaTeJIH H BOCDHTaTeJibHHQbl. Tenepb :>Ke B Il0Jlb3Y IlaHCHOHCKoro o6yqeHHSI MO:>KHO CK333Tb

oqeHb HeMHOroe.

Mhl He 6yAeM roeopHTh 06 3K3aMeHax B cne~aJILHhIX yqHJim.qax - BLICIIIHX H cpeAHHX, MY:>KCKHX H :>KeHCKHX, no:>KenaeM TOJILKO, qT06L1 H TaM Il03a6oTHJIHCb o6pa6oTaTb nporpaMMbl HCilbITaHHSI H qT06bI caMbie 3K3aMeHbl IlOTepSIJIH TOT JIOTepeHHblH xapaKTep, KaKHM MHOme H3 HHX Bee e~e

OTJIH"llaIOTCSI.

qTO KacaeTCSI AO nepeBOAHbIX 3K3aMeHOB, TO HX Mbl cqHTaeM AOMaIIIHHM AeJIOM Ka)f(,IJ;oro yqHJIH~a, HO yeepeHbI, qTo H Ha HHX OKa:>KeT A06poe

BJIHSIHHe HOBCUI CHCTeMa OKOH"llaTeJibHOro HCilbITaHH·SI' TaK KaK OHH AOJI)KHbl 6YAYT IlOArOTOBJISITb yqeHHKOB K 3TOMY noCJieAHeMY H, KOHeqHo, 6YAYT npHHOpOBmITbCSI H K ero npHeMaM.

HaM OCTaeTCSI eI.Qe CKa3aTb 06 3K3aMeHax COBepIIIeHHO oco6oro pOAa, He HMeIO~HX HHKaKoro neAarorHqecKoro -3HaqeHHSI H SIBJISllOl.QHXCSI KaKHMTO CTpaHHhlM, nopa:>KaIOI.QHM aHaxpoHH3MOM. MM pa3yMeeM 3K3aMeH crapHKaM, BbICJIY)KHBIIIHM nepBbIH qffH rOAaMH AOJiroH: CJiy:>K6bI. qTO -Bbl CKa- )f(eTe 0 TaKOH CQeHe: nepeA BaMH CeAOH CTapHK, 3aAYMaBIIIHHCSI HaA BOnpoCOM, rAe HaXOASITCSI IIHpeHeH, KTO 6Lm Kapn BenHKHH, KOrAa :>KHJI BopHc roAyHOB, HJIH He CJiaAHBIIIHH C npoCTOH apHcl>MeTH"l!eCKOH 3aAaqee, HJIH HaAeJiaBIIIHH AOBOJlbHO op<l>orpacl>H"lleCKHX OIIIH60K B 3aAaHHOM eMY IlHCbMe. OH npeABHAHT, KaKOH pe3yJibTaT BbiffAeT H3 ero MOJiqaHHSI HJIH HeyAaqHbIX OTBeTOB'H HaqHHaeT ysepSITb Bae, qTo OH HeCKOJlbKO MeCSIQCB roTOBHJICSI K 3K3aMeHy H no TaKHM-TO 3JieMeHTapHbIM yqe6HHKaM, HO qTo naMSITb H3MerureT eMY'tfTO OH He B CHJiax 3aOOMHHTL Bcex 3THX HMe Ii H qHcen; OH HaqHHaeT YMOJISITL eac aTTecroeaTL ero YAOBJieTBopHTeJibHOIO

OTMeTKOIO, TaK KaK eMy He06XOAHM qffH, c KOTOpbIM y Hero CBSl3bIBaeTCSI eonpoc o KYCKe xne6a AJISI Bcee ero ceMLH; HaKoHe~ OH HaqHHaeT pbJAaTL

H c 6e3HaAe:>KHbIM BOOJieM OCTaBJISleT poKOBYIO AJISI Hero KOMHary. HY:>KffO HMeTb CJIHIIIKOM 3arpy6eJILie HepBbl, qTo6bI TaKHe CJie3bl CTapHKa He noeepHyJIH eamero cepAQa, TeM 6onee, qTo Bbl He MO:>KeTe OTKa3aTb ero paccy:>KAeHIHIM B OCHOBaTeJibHOCTH: 3aqeM, rOBOpHT OH, MHe 3HaTb Ha CTapoCTH neT, rAe IIHpeHeH, KTO 6LIJI Kapn BeJIHKHH, KOrAa :>KHJI fOAYffOB, eCJIH MOSI CJiy)K6a AO CHX nop He TPe6oBaJia 3TOro Aa He IlO'rpe6yeTH

B. }{. CTOJ-OHHH. MbtCJIH o Ha11rnx JKJaMeHax

BnepeA? 3aqeM MHe 3TH BbllJHCJieHWI, 6e3 KOTOpbIX SI npo)KHJI BelO CBOIO :>KH3Hh; 3aqeM 3TH rpaMMaTHlleCKHe npasHJia, eCJIH H 6e3 HHX HallaJihCTBO npH3HaJIO MOIO eJI}')K6yIlOJie3HOIO H xoqeT uarpaAHTb MeHSI'e'IHTaSIODbITHblM CJ1y)f(aK010? Bbl cKa}KeTe eMy, llTO no 3aKouy qeu MO}KeT nonyqHTh T0:11hKO qenoseK c HJBeCTHhIM 06pa3osauueM. Ou, sepo}{THO, HH'leroue OTBeTHT Ha 3TO JaMe11auue, TaK KaK Ami Hero oeTaHeTeSI 3araAKOIO, OT'lero 11enoseK, TOJihKO llTO y3uaswult o IlHpeueS1x, o KaKOM-TO Kapne, o foAyuose, BApyr CTaJI 06pa3osauuee ero; 11eM on suuosaT, llTO ea CTapoCTH neT CTana ryneTh er<;> naMS1Th, M OTllero }Ke ero no3uauuS1, .npuo6peTeHHhle AOJirHM OilbITOM'npHTOM B TaKOH ecpepe'rAe OHH-TO HMeHHO H HMelOT 3Haqeuue, OT'leroOHH ellHTalOTCSI HH 3a lJTO, a lJHH AaJOT 3a IlupeueH Aa 3a Kapna e fOAYHOBhIM? B eaMOM Aene, uey}KeJIH B 3THX WKOJihHhIX aneMeHTapHbIX Il03HaHWIX AOJI}KHO eOCTOSITb o6pa30BaHHe lJHKOBHHKa, Bbieny- :>KHBWero ee6e 'IHHAOJiro10 CJ1y}K6010? Pa3se B ecpepe ero AeSITeJihHOCTH ue DOJie3Hee BO eTO pa3 ero OilbITHOCTh, xopowee 3HaHHe Tex AeJI'KaKHe TaM npOH3BOASITeSI'ea 3HaKOMCTBO e KOTOpbIMH OH OTAaBaJI see esoe speMSI' Bee eBOH eHnhl, H pa3Be see 3TO He eoeTaBnSleT ero HaCTOSl~ero AOCTOHHCTBa H ero AeHCTBHTeJihHOfO o6pa30BaHHSI? M pa3Be CAenaeTeSI OH XOTh HaeKOJibKO-HH6yAh o6pa30Bauuee, eeJIH 3ayqHT no WKOJibHbIM yqe6HHKaM eoTHH HMeH Aa ueeKOJihKO AeeSITKOB rpaMMaTH'leeKHXnpasHJI? M AJISI 'lero }Ke uaeunosaTh ero CTap11eeKy10 uarypy, JaCTasnu pa6oTaTh u yM, u naMS1Th HaA TeM, AJISI qero ouu y}Ke AaBHO eAenaJIHeh cosepweuuo ueenoco6nhIMH? .[Vlsr qero yuH}KaTb ero AOCTOHHeTBO, 3aCTaBJISISI pa3hlrpbIBaTL ponb WKOJlbHHKa, a HHOfAa AOBOASI AO OT'laSIHHOfOIlOJIO}KeHHSI? Bee 3TO SIBHnOeb y nae B CTapoe speMSI H BhITeKaJIO H3 JIO}KHOro B3fJISIAa Ha o6pa30BaHHe, KOTOpoe orpaHH'IHBaJIOebKOe-KaKHM 3HaHHCM, XOTSI 6bI Aa}KC 6eeeMbieJieHHbIM, HeeKOJibKHX yqe6HHKOB.

IlpaKTH'leeKHeIl03HaHWI BO BeSIKOH CJiy)K6e HMelOT eBOIO Qeuy'H Mbl He BRAHM npH'IHHbl, IlO'leMY qeJIOBeKa e TaKHMH Il03HaHHSIMH CTaBHTh

HH}Ke Toro, KOMV YAaJIOCh 3ayqHTb ueeKOJibKO WKOJihHhIX aneMeHTapHbIX noJHaHHH. Y}K eCJIH HY}KHO no}KHBWeMy H noCJI~BWeMY qenoseKy

AeJiaTb HeilbITaHHe, lJT06bl AaTb llHH, TO y}K, KOHequo, HeilbITaHHe B TOM, lJTO ueo6XOAHMO H Ba}KHO B H3BeeTHOH ecpepe AeSITeJibHOCTH, a He B TOM, llTO CJIY:>KHT epeACTBOM AJISI pa3BHTWI AeTe:H.

0TeJOAa B03HHKaeT sonpoe 06 3K3aMeHax He Ha nepBblH KJiaeeHblH lJHH' a B006~e Ha AOJI}KHOCTHhle MeCTa, sonpoc, OT KOTOporo B HaCTOSlll~ee

speMSI MbI yAep}KHMesr, TaK KaK OH 3aBJieK 6b1 Hae eJIHWKOM AaJieKo. HeeoCTOSITeJihHOeTb }Ke 3K3aMeHOB Ha lJHH eJIHlllKOM OlleBHAHa, 'IT06hlrosopHTb 0 uei 'ITO-HH6YAh6onee.