Research part. Surveys.
The
aims of different schools are the same: to bring up literate people
who will be able to find their way and be useful for the country. We
have conducted the survey among the British, Russian and Japanese. We
succeeded in getting answers from the Russian a lot. All in all we
have asked more than 300 people. We have divided the respondents into
three groups:
Students
(11-15 years old):
Graduates
(16-25 years old):
Teachers
and parents (older than 26 years old).
This
division is aimed at objective view of modern schools of different
categories of people.
We
gave some answers for the test part:
Yes;
No;
Does
not matter.
The
last answer was mentioned only in Russian survey because more and
more people (mainly young) are becoming less interested in social
life of our country and do not take an active life position.
System of education in secondary school. Students.
O
Picture
1 Is the education in Russian secondary school effective?
nly the Russian answered this question. We can see that nearly
half of them think that modern secondary education is effective (see
picture 1). This survey confirmed our hypothesis that the school
needs to be reorganized. Moreover, we found out the number of
students who are indifferent to their school life and country. If the
methods of education are changed, the students will be interested in
studying at school more. Indifferent attitude to school leads to
apathetic life position. Those who support the passive position in
life cannot become personalities and patriots. This point contradicts
school and life demands.
We
also asked the respondents’ opinion what they would love to change
in schools. The answers are in the table below (see table 1).
Table 1
11-15
years
|
16-25
years
|
Older
26
|
To
improve the discipline;
To
have more festivals and school holidays;
To
study subjects that student really needs;
To
have less stressful timetable.
|
To
change the assessment system;
To
lessen PE lessons from 3 to 2;
To
cut down the secondary education;
To
organise more interesting lessons.
|
To
improve the timetable;
To
adapt the volume of information for higher school;
To
improve good skills in writing (to express the thoughts clearly),
reading (to read fast and get the information), counting;
To
simplify the programme so that the students were not afraid of
the subject;
To
cancel lessons on Saturday;
To
lessen the burden of homework on students;
To
improve (pre-) profile system of education.
|
Moreover,
the question of online-survey about practical works refers to this
subject too. We should mention that practical works mean not only
some experiments in Chemistry or Physics, but also some activities
that differ from the usual ones (like doing written exercises from
the student’s book). We decided to ask this question because
practical exercises at lessons are extremely interesting and useful.
The ideal number of such tasks is one in two weeks.
O
Picture
2 Are you satisfied with the list of school subjects?
ur next question was about the list of school subjects. A lot
of Russian students mentioned that they would love to get rid of
World Art Culture (or Art), the second foreign language. The majority
of graduates, parents and teachers claimed, that Life Safety, the
third PE lesson in a week are not needed, because children lose their
time and cannot concentrate on really important subjects such as
Russian and Mathematics. The results of the survey, which you can see
on the diagram (see picture 3), show that the list of school subjects
should be renewed. It is important to provide more time for basic
subjects by reducing unnecessary subjects or increasing the
length/amount of lessons.
W
Picture
3 Were you satisfied with the list of school subjects? (Japan)
Picture
4 Do we really need 5 years to get secondary education?
e also asked this question to Japanese students. You can see
the results on the diagram (see picture 2). The students are
satisfied with the subjects they study at school. The half of the
Japanese respondents mentioned, that English in schools is studied at
a very low level. This is a very actual problem in Russia too. It is
very important to know English well because it is an international
language. Unfortunately we can hardly see the opinion of British
students because only one student from Northern Ireland answered our
questions. However she said that she really likes the school
subjects. We also should mention that the British can choose the
subjects they want to study in secondary school (except the basic,
such as the Native language, Mathematics and Science). We suppose
this is the reason why nearly every British student would answer the
same.
We
should pay attention to the period of secondary education. Nearly 30%
of teachers and parents do not agree that we need five years to get
secondary education (see picture 4). Some of them mentioned that this
amount should be cut down.
O
Picture
5 Do you think school uniform is very important? (Russia)
Picture
6 Do you think school uniform is very important? (Japan)
ur next question refers to the obligatory school uniform.
Although most of the students and graduates are against it, school
cannot exist without a uniform (see picture 6). A student should be
concentrated on the learning process during the lesson. Bright and
flashy clothes do not contribute to the learning process. Moreover,
some “trendies” are always late to school because they are not
able to choose the attire. We know exactly that a school uniform is
obligatory in the UK and Japan. We asked the same question to foreign
students. Our only British respondent said “I think wearing a
uniform is very important because it helps people identify what
school you attend and also you don’t have to worry about what you
are going to wear every day!” There is a rather strange situation
in Japan at this point (see picture 5). One half of the respondents
are “for” and the other is “against” the obligatory uniform.
However, nearly every student who is against mentioned that he/she
likes the uniform. We also got some comments like “Of course,
because we wear the same clothes whether poor or rich. If we wear
clothes what we want, it becomes the reason for bulling. We can see
who's poor.”
W
Picture
7 How should the school uniform like?
e decided to ask the Russian students which type of school
uniform they like most of all. We mentioned four variants of answers
(Russian type, English type, Japanese type, it is not needed/your
variant). We found out a rather interesting fact – the amount of
respondents who chose the variant “it is not needed” is lower
three or two times in comparison to the answer “Japanese type”
(see picture 7).
There
are two variants of Japanese uniform. The first one is called sailor
fuku (sailor outfits). It is modelled on British type naval uniform
of the XIX century. The girls’ variant usually consists of pleated
skirt, a blouse with a sailor-style collar and the ribbon, which is
tied under the collar. The length of the blouse sleeves depends on
the season (short for summer, long for winter). The boys’ uniform
is called gakuran. It consists of straight leg trousers, a shirt and
a jacket with a standing collar and buttoned up to the top. The
buttons are decorated with the school emblem. Sometimes there are
special collar pins representing the school, class and rank. The
second variant of Japanese school uniform is western type, which
looks very much the same as the English one. It consists of pleated
matched skirt (for girls) or straight legged trousers (for boys), a
blouse or a shirt, a jacket or a vest. The uniform is decorated with
the school emblem. The half-hose and shoes are sometimes included in
the uniform. The British uniform consists of the same clothes, though
the skirt is not usually pleated and matched. The colours for the
uniform are usually chosen by schools.
S
Picture
8 Quarters or semesters?
tudents and graduates did not agree with each other (see
picture 8). Graduates like semesters more because they experienced
this system in higher institutions. They prefer it because students
have more time for studying and improving their marks. However, we
must pay attention to children’s psychology. It is very hard for
children under 13-14 to study for 5 weeks without stopping. It would
be rather reasonable to use quarter system for 5-7 forms and semester
system for 8-9 forms.
W
Picture
9 Would you like to take part in extracurricular sections organized
by students?
Picture
10 Are the student`s council and radio needed?
e have found out that in the UK and Japan there are a lot of
sport sections and student clubs. In Japan they are run by the
students, whereas teachers do not play very important role in these
sections. The main advantages of such activities are the development
of students’ personal characteristics (such as leadership), the
ability to work in a group, the adaptation to their peers with the
same interests and the help in development of skills in different
fields, that may not be covered by the school programme (see picture
9). For example, students may organize a “Foreign club” where
they will not just study a foreign language, but also learn the
culture and traditions of the native country or establish the
connection with foreign students and communication with them. The
students may also create a music club. They may teach the other
students how to play musical instruments, create a band, which would
take part in school concerts and write their own songs. The
indispensable condition is that these sections are run by students of
9 or 10 forms because this is the best time to form the traits of
leadership and these children are more competent than younger ones.
Children are able to understand each other better than teachers and
they know what would be really interesting. The other examples of
such sections are student council or school radio. Student government
is very important for children. It adapts them for a future life.
Although not every student agrees with this idea we believe everyone
would be glad to be friendly met at school (see picture 10).