Антикризисное управление - Дорофеев В.Д., Левин Д.Н., Сенаторов Д.В., Чернецов А.В
.pdf) 4 # # *
, #. :
−)* * !
! ;
−1 !
! 4;
4 !;
−! ;
−# ;
−! )*
#* ! ;
−;
−1
;
−# ,
( 1 ,
);
−! ! ! # ! 4;
−4
;
−1 1 ! 4 # ! ;
−(4)
;
−#
1 ;
−;
−# .
! , #
) *
. , ),
! 4
1. :
−)
−4 , 4 1 -
;
101
−, . .
-
, #, .;
−1 ) 1 #
;
−# #
;
−) ;
−#
;
−1;
−! , !
) .
' ! , 4
# , # 4 # .
, ! ! #
!. $ ! )
, ) #,
# )# . , # )
4 :
−1 4 ( ,
4 4 #
!1 4 !);
−# ! 4 ( 4 4
#, 4
! );
−# ;
−# # ! ! 4;
−4 #7 4 (# 4
#7 4, # 4 )* # ,
, ;
, #7 4 4 #
! ).
# 4 :
102
−4 ( 4, 4,
) ! # 4#);
−, -#
. .
(" 5 4*"2"1 *%& ( !"% ( 4 ,*(&)
& ! ,
4 !,
( ) , * ! #, (#) 1 # ,
( ) 4 # :
1)(. , )* #,
) ,
#.
2))&.
4 1 1 #, * ) # ( , )*
, 1 ) 1 #, * #).
3)# " "$. & 1 ! 1 # )
# 4 )* ! 4 #:
1 ! ( * " " ),
. . )
, * #, !
.
"- ! # #
# ", # 0 – 4
). 4 4 ! )
# ) ! – "- .
5 &1 5.1 (" -#) ( . ! #% *&. 5 *% "(#(+
"% ( 4 |
6 5 |
#", #*" |
|
|
, *(& |
|
|
|
- |
|
8 |
4 |
|
4 |
|
|
|
|
|
2 |
( - |
|
2 |
) |
|
|
& # ! ! |
|
2 |
$ 4 |
|
1 |
4 ( ) |
|
|
103
" " ; *& ( 5 &1$ 5.1
$ : |
|
3 |
, #) 4 |
|
|
, 4 |
|
3 |
, |
|
3 |
|
|
|
( |
|
15 |
, !, , |
|
|
. .) |
|
|
0 4 # |
|
43 |
“! #” |
|
10 |
8 # 1 10, |
|
|
1 # |
|
|
|
|
|
& 1 |
|
15 |
$ # - 1 |
|
15 |
# # |
|
|
$ ( |
|
15 |
! ) |
|
|
0 4 # |
|
45 |
“! #” |
|
15 |
8 # ! # 1 |
|
|
25, |
|
|
! |
|
|
1 ! |
|
3 |
“ #” |
|
3 |
$ # |
|
3 |
(1 , “# ” |
|
|
, 4 ) |
|
|
, (# , |
|
3 |
, ) |
|
|
0 4 # |
|
12 |
0 4 ! "- |
|
100 |
“! #” |
|
25 |
( 1 1 ! |
|
5-18 |
, )* |
|
35-70 |
8 # # 25, 4 |
|
|
# # 4 !1 . |
|
|
' # 1 "- , 4 |
|
|
!. |
|
|
104
5.3.2 « » -
"/88&1& *( 4(' * (&* %# % &("#!"#"5*"#(&).
. 4 1968 .
" (Edward I. Altman). #
* )
(Multiple-discriminant analysis - MDA) # 4
! )* #7 # #.
" # 66 !,
# 4 1946 1965 .,
# 1, 22
, #
4 #. ! # #
. + #, " # ! )
!, )* !
# 1 ! . #*
# (Z- ) :
Z=1.2X1+1.4X2+3.3X3 +0.6X4+X5
-1 – # ! / ; -2 – #/ ;
-3 – #/ ; -4 – !/4; -5 – / .
" ,
# #* )* ! Z 4 [-14, +22], , Z>2,99 )
!, , Z<1,81 )
#- , [1,81-2,99]
.
Z- #* ! ! - *
4 1 1 !,
)* # 4. ! 4
#7 ) ) # . $ ) !
# ,
# # ! ,
! (GAAP). ( :
105
−& 1 ,
! ! ;
), )
! ! ( , ,
,
/ " ").
−& 1 , " #"
0 ,
! 4 (
, 4 ) ! . .)
−# ) 4 !
! , , ) ,
) *
! ! !.
! ! 4
)* ! !, ! ! ! :
Z=1.2X1+1.2X2+3.3X3 +0.6X4+X5
-4 – 1 #* ! . & # #
1, ! + # 1.1. ,
Z ,
)) “ !”
# 1.
5 &1 5.2 < % + ".(*"#(& 5 *% "(#(+
* ) *& Z |
".(*"#(4 5 *% "(#(+ |
1,8 |
|
, 1,81 2,7 |
|
, 2,71 2,99 |
|
3,0 |
|
# *
1 ! #,
.
#
, ) )* # ) !,
)* ,
, # #.
106
1983 . " ! !
!, # 4:
K=8.38K1+K2+0.054K3+0.63K4 ( K4 – #, !.)
" #
. ,, 1 : !
, # ) 1 !
) " ". !
# !
1 # !.
# . + # ! !
88 (Taffler) 4 1977 . ) ($ 08 %(" *-: ! ",*" *-: '" 4, # ! )* ! .
$ ) ! !
) 80 1 ! # 1
4 # !. 3, ! ,
! , 4
4 #, 1,
1 # ) ! . + ! # ! 1 !
) ! ,
, #, # , !
. ,#7
)* # , 4 #
) . +
!, ) # 4,
:
Z=C0+C1X1+C2X2+C3X3+C4X4
:
1=# /* # (53%)2=* /#* # (13%)3=* #/#* (18%)4= (16%)
0,… 4 – , # )
; 1 #, 2 – #
, 3 – ! 4 – .
107
)* ! ! 4
Z- PAS- (Perfomans Analysys Score) – , )* ! 4
. PAS- 1, 4
, 4
.
PAS- – !
, ! Z- !
4 ! 1 100. $ , PAS- ,
! 50, ,
, PAS- , ! 10,
, 1 10% ! 1
4 ( ). , Z-
, 4 # ) )
4 ) !
. , Z- 4
,
4, PAS- 4 ) )
* ) .
& ! ! #
) # # #
1. +, , )* # 1
#, # #, 4 #
# !, # ! 1. + #,
PAS- , 4 # ! ,
! ! !,
. *, , # ,
)*.
! # )
"! " !1
. . ! ,
! Z- , Z-
, Z- ,
4
4. # ) 1, ! 1
" , ) #", 5
"# ) ) 4 4 ",
4 #* #
, .
108
) *$'& %-(#%"2 ,"#- #(+ **"2 /%"*"'&) #%"2 % '&&
4 ) ($ 08 %(" * . '" 4 ! ",*" % 5 *% "(#(+ ('" 4 R), )* ! :
K=8.38K1+K2+0.054K3+0.63K4
1 – # ! / ;2 – #/# ! ;
3 – / ;4 – #/ .
#
R )* # (# 5.3)
5 &1 5.3 &( && + ".(*"#(& 5 *% "(#(+ #", #*" '" & R
* ) *& R |
".(*"#(4 5 *% "(#(+ , ! "1 *("+ |
0 1 0 |
0 (90-100) |
0-0,18 |
(60-80) |
0,18-0,32 |
& (35-50) |
0,32-0,42 |
$ (15-20) |
( 1 0,42 |
0 ( 10) |
" 1
# ) ' (" $ 2(&*,"+"2"1 *%&. ,#* ! ! ! 4 )*
#:
0 = "1* 1 + "2* 2 + … + "
0 – ! (!);
"i – ! i- ( "i 100%);i – i- ;
n – !.
4 ) (
) . & * ) (
) 4 . &
! ! ! !
! ! .
#
!.
, ! #
! ! ) '" &. . " $6%&* (&-# ! ! ).
109
#* )* #1:
0 : 1 = 0.47 1 + 0.14 2 + 0.39 3
0 : 2 = 0.61 4 + 0.39 5
0 : 3 = 0.49 4 + 0.12 2 + 0.19 6 + 0.19 3
1 – # ! ;2 – # # ;
3 – 4 ! 4;4 – ;5 – # ;6 – # 4.
3 ! #
# 5.4
5 &1 5.4 &(&) #%& !"% ( & ##' ( &+ '$0'" 2
" 4 |
,"!" -)*$ |
*% "($ |
"* * "! **"#(& |
I |
0.08-0.16 |
(-0.20)-(-0.08) |
(-0.08)-0.08 |
II |
1.07-1.54 |
0.35-0.49 |
0.49-1.07 |
III |
0.92-1.36 |
0.25-0.38 |
0.38-0.92 |
$ ! !
. , !
! # ) # ) .
1 2 : 1 ". . $ #, http://bizoffice.ru/
110