- •Introduction: Feminist Therapy—Not for Women Only
- •Women and Madness: Exposing Patriarchy in the Consulting Room
- •Kinder, Kuche, Kirche as Scientific Law: Misogyny in the Science of Psychology
- •Sex Role Stereotyping and Clinical Judgments of Mental Health: Science Supporting Politics
- •Difference Feminism and Feminist Therapy
- •Difference/Equal Value Feminism and Feminist Therapy
- •Multicultural, Global, and Postmodern Feminisms and Feminist Therapy
- •Power in the Spiritual Realm
- •Power in the Intrapersonal/intrapsychic Realm
- •Interpersonal/Social–Contextual Power
- •The Egalitarian Relationship
- •Power Dynamics in Therapy: Symbolic Relationship
- •Diagnosis?
- •Bem’s Gender Schema Model
- •Chodorow and the Reproduction of Gender
- •Kaschak’s Self-In-Context
- •Root’s Ecological Model of Identity Development
- •Gender as an Artifact of Power
- •The Question of Formal Assessment in Feminist Practice
- •Micro-Aggression and Insidious Trauma
- •Interpersonal Betrayal as Disempowerment
- •Hays’s addressing Model
- •Root’s Model of Multiple Identities
- •Integrating the Somatic, Intrapsychic, Social, Contextual, and Meaning-Making Dimensions: The Case of Heidi
- •Effectiveness of a Feminist Empowerment Model
- •Feminist Therapy’s Integration With Other Models
- •With Whom Do Feminist Therapists Work?
- •Difficult Contexts
- •Difficult Client Characteristics
- •Feminist Practice in the Absence of the Capacity for Empathy
Hays’s addressing Model
Pamela Hays (2001, 2008) has proposed a feminist-informed epistemological framework for considering the social locations that evolve into multiple identities. Each of these creates social locations, experiences occurring in the psychosocial, political, and historical context that can inform identity. Hays uses an acronym, ADDRESSING, as a mnemonic for her epistemic system; this stands for age, disability (acquired and/or developmental), religion, ethnicity, social class, sexual orientation, indigenous heritage, national origin, and gender/sex. Analysis of points of privilege and disadvantage in current dominant patriarchal cultures can generate other social locations that may be considered by a feminist therapist, including other social locations being (or not) partnered, being (or not) a parent, attractiveness, body size and shape, state of physical health (different from disability), phenotype, and experiences of colonization.
Hays argues for the importance of context for understanding identity in the individual—and of knowing the histories of cultures and societies, not simply the histories of the individuals with whom we work—as a means of comprehending the dynamics of power and privilege that have informed the family context of individual development. Root (2004) proposes a specific feminist multicultural identity development model in which the social locations of ADDRESSING can be seen working together to generate identity.
Root’s Model of Multiple Identities
Root’s model arose from her work with people of mixed phenotype (e.g., “mixed race” or “biracial”), who, because they are externally defined as having multiple identities due to the differing phenotypes of their parents, are people whose experiences of oppression and liberation include an encounter with multiple identities. She argues that in order to avoid pathologizing the human normative experience of multiple identities, paradigms for development must account for within-group bias and oppression, the expressions of internalized oppression. She next argues that any such model must see as positive the experience of multiple identities. This is a striking deviation from patriarchal constructs, which value holding unitary identity. She asserts that identity cannot be understood outside of context, including changes in the social and political contexts and social reference groups informing an individual’s understanding of identity and the meaning of social locations. Her model insists on a biopsychosocial/spiritual/historical strategy for understanding identity. Because identity is contextualized in this way, it is also theorized as being in continuous evolution rather than as having arrived at a fixed location; a flexible stability rather than a fixed and rigid one becomes exemplary of good functioning.
Based on her research, Root has posited five different trajectories of identity development in the context of multiple social locations. Each carries its own vulnerabilities and each its own strengths, emphasizing that this is a paradigm of multiple trajectories as well as multiple identities. The first is a trajectory in which the effects of disempowerment are prominent, and the person’s resistance strategies are harder to perceive. She defines this as accepting societally ascribed identity, a more passive strategy in which the person experiences no power to self-define but rather internalizes those norms and rules propounded by the culture. In this trajectory of identity development, the individual’s resistance strategies may have been those of compliance and invisibility, which are highly effective when a person is in a dangerous situation, one with inadequate or inaccurate information about options, or one where a person is constrained from a more active engagement with self-development.
A second trajectory involves a person experiencing herself or himself as having considered and chosen to accept ascribed identities. Although the visible results of this strategy much resemble those of the first, the individual experiences her or his own agency in the process. This can be problematic when the limitations of the chosen identity become known or emerge in an unpredicted context; thus, the disempowerment embedded in this strategy may only become apparent when those limitations are encountered, as the person’s conscious self-awareness is that of agency and choice.
Root describes a third trajectory as identifying actively with multiple social groups. In this identity strategy a person’s notions of identity are fluid, with each social location being perceived as separate, yet informed by the others, and varying in salience for the person depending on the contexts currently present. This strategy is likely to evoke social push-back from others who wish to require the person to choose one, and only one, important identity, and thus requires active engagement in resistance by that person.
In the fourth trajectory proposed by Root, the person defines a new identity that is an amalgam of all of her or his social locations, blended in a way that defies socially prescribed categories. This strategy is evidence of choice and empowerment on the part of the individual, who has resisted the cultural norm of seeing self as a collection of boxes, and who instead creates a layered, woven, or blended unitary self that is more than the sum of its parts. In this strategy every aspect of self is experienced as salient and available in all contexts, and the person refuses categorization. Like the third strategy, this trajectory of identity development may generate social resistance. This strategy appears to be increasingly common among individuals under age 30 who have multiple marginalized group memberships that are recombined into a new form that is celebrated for its uniqueness.
The final strategy suggested by Root’s model is one in which a person disclaims identities arising from apparent social locations and visible personal attributes and instead embraces an identity that feels internally consistent. She calls this the creation of “symbolic identity” (Root, 2004). This strategy can appear complex because it often resembles survival strategies of passing or assimilation utilized by members of marginalized groups in the past; however, in this strategy a person does not deny her or his biological reality (phenotype or sex, for example), but refuses to allow that to have primacy over felt and phenomenological identity.
For the feminist therapist, understanding that a person will have engaged in one or several of these strategies for creating self-definition also gives hints as to experiences of privilege, power, oppression, and disempowerment. As Root noted (personal communication, October 11, 2007), two people with precisely the same apparent social location markers will move into completely different identity trajectories depending on the specific social contexts available to them. At times this can be quite subtle, as she found in her biracial siblings research study (Root, 1998), in which rarely did two offspring of the same family utilize the same identity development strategies, demonstrating the enormous variability of identity trajectories, all of them potentially functional, and each one equally a potential source of empowerment and privilege or disempowerment and distress.
SUMMARY
With all of these factors forming the framework of theory for feminist therapy, a psychotherapist is in a position to undertake the tasks of client empowerment. How this is enacted will vary, but in each example to be discussed in the next chapter, the feminist therapist’s role has been to uncover potential sources of disempowerment, even those that superficially have appeared to be types of social privilege, and to invite the person working with her or him to consider alternatives that allow for enhanced power on each of the four biopsychosocial/spiritual axes.
1From
“It Could Have Been Me,” by H. Near, 1974. Copyright 1974 by
Hereford Music (ASCAP).
The Therapy Process
Feminist therapy’s vision of humans as biopsychosocial/spiritual–existential entities extends into the development of feminist strategies for transformation via psychotherapy. Feminist therapists will engage with a very wide and diverse range of change strategies with clients. So long as the superordinate goals of empowerment, egalitarianism, and analysis of power, gender, and social location can be integrated, feminist therapy offers a protean integrative model of practice that has allowed it to be utilized with very different individuals in settings ranging from refugee camps on the Thailand–Burma border (Norsworthy, 2007) to a prison in Washington State (Cole, Sarlund-Heinrich, & Brown, 2007) to mainstream dominant culture men receiving psychotherapy in a private practice office (Brooks, 1998).
Feminist therapy, and the induction into the egalitarian model, begins with the process of consent, which I have previously referred to as “empowered consent” (Brown, 1994). My clients are offered a five-page, single-spaced document to take home and review in which the basic frameworks of feminist practice are outlined, with an emphasis on the relational nature of therapy, the rights of clients, and the responsibilities of the therapist (a copy of this document is available at http://www.drlaurabrown.com/resources.php). This document, and those written by other feminist therapists for their clients, serves as an initial invitation for discussions about the nature of feminist therapy practice. The client’s ownership of the therapy, and her or his right to determine its goals and directions, provide a powerful catalyst and jumping-off point for the development of an egalitarian relationship at all steps of therapy.
The following sections discuss strategies for feminist empowerment models on each of the four axes of power. Although in practice no aspect of psychotherapy is purely somatic, interpersonal, contextual, or spiritual, each exchange will have a particular focus and core on one of these axes.
SOMATIC INTERVENTIONS
Feminist therapy values somatic interventions as one integrated component of treatment. A feminist therapist will consider ways in which a client is disempowered on the biological axis and notice how apparent disempowerment may actually represent resistance strategies employed in the service of survival or safety. Feminist therapists practice empowerment at this juncture by framing each of these ways of being as what was available to the person as a way of being in the body that best allowed her or him to function and that was congruent with her or his identity. This is a first step toward inviting that person to consider, then explore, ways of being differently and in a more empowered manner, in her or his body.
Alicia, a Euro American heterosexual woman in her mid-30s, had been bullied by her peers while a child because she walked with a limp, the aftereffects of a childhood accident in which she fell off a playground structure. Her family had no health insurance coverage and was unable to pay for physical therapy after her bones knitted. Alicia had done two things with these experiences. First, the accident had taken on enormous negative salience, representing “the day my life changed for the worse forever.” Second, she had developed shame about how her body moved. The ultimate result of these two important experiences was that she had become physically very immobile. She came into therapy to deal with depressed mood and a loss of motivation for working on her master’s thesis. In the course of exploring how her class background and her being the first in her family to go to college were factors in her fears of inadequacy as a professional and her feelings of disloyalty to her family, her therapist suggested the notion of using exercise as a means of improving mood.
Both therapist and client were surprised at the vehemence of Alicia’s response. “I don’t do that, I don’t have a body,” she told Katarina, the therapist. Katarina invited Alicia to consider how not having a body was a part of her identity. Together they explored the importance to Alicia of this identity marker, which emerged as having two functions that were temporarily empowering to her. Dissociation from her body reduced intrusive memories of the fall and distanced Alicia from her grief over the loss of the active body she had been in before that day. It also allowed her to be as invisible to others as possible, so that her limp would be minimally visible. Each of these were important safety strategies for Alicia. She told Katarina that for the present she would rather take medication for her mood, as she was not yet ready to stop using these strategies, “and I’m not sure if I ever will be.”
Katarina’s response was to validate Alicia as the person in charge of her therapy process; they continued to explore other strategies for Alicia to accomplish her goals. Six months later Alicia told Katarina that she was ready to approach the topic of her accident, now seeing it linked to her difficulties with her thesis. “Being frozen is something I know how to do; being frozen was the best I could do. I didn’t want my family to see me as a stuck-up, overeducated person, or my professors to see me as the working class kid that I am, and I didn’t want to see me as disabled, or the other kids to see my limp. So I freeze. Maybe it’s time to be visible, and thaw. Or not. But let’s talk about it.”
Feminist therapists will integrate a variety of strategies aimed at increasing power on the biological/somatic axis into their work with clients. They may invite clients to consider learning about strengthening or increasing flexibility of body; to develop greater stamina; to discover how to feed themselves in a loving way; to consider tai ch’i or yoga; to use body work treatments such as massage, Feldenkrais, or Hellerwork; and to explore the usefulness of formal medications. No one of these approaches to engaging with the body will be privileged by a feminist therapist; whichever pathway toward somatic empowerment is a fit for the client is the one that the client and therapist will explore.
Feminist psychopharmacology (Jensvold, Halbreich, & Hamilton, 1996) has studied how sex differences in hormones and responses to drugs, while often little known by those prescribing them, need to be taken into account if prescribing is to happen in a nonoppressive and empowering manner. Many modern psychotropic medications, while effective somatic interventions for some people, also carry risks of side effects that dull sexuality, increase risk of weight gain and diabetes, and have unknown consequences for children who are in utero when pregnant women use them. Feminist psychopharmacology supports clients in exercising judgment and autonomy regarding these and other somatic interventions, rather than defaulting to the prescription of a pill.
Kristina was severely depressed after the birth of her first child. She was nursing and unwilling to take medication that might pass through breast milk to her son. She was generally uncomfortable with Western medicine and wanted to do without pills if possible for everything in her life. She was also so depressed that she could barely relate to her baby and was frightened that he would be emotionally harmed by her tears and lethargy. Paralyzed with indecision by her depression and terrified of making the wrong choice, she told Jeneen, her therapist, that she was tempted to just take a pill and be done with it. “But then I’ll hate myself.” Jeneen asked Kris if she would like her to be “more pushy” about what to do, and when Kris assented, Jeneen suggested a step-wise process for making a decision about whether and how to take medication. Kris did a consultation with a physician expert in nutritional foundations for mood, with the understanding that this would work more slowly than medication. If, after a period of time, she was not feeling able to parent well, the next step would be to try an antidepressant medication that her physician had carefully researched as to its safety for nursing mothers and their babies. Kris and Jeneen also worked out a “panic button” strategy by which either one could raise the alarm about the safety of parent and child and speed up the process. With the pressure to make a decision off, Kris improved slightiy with the nutritional intervention, sufficiently for her to become more active again in the decision-making process. She eventually decided to take the offered antidepressant from a position of more power than she had initially been able to muster.
PSYCHOSOCIAL INTERVENTIONS
Because it is a technically integrative approach to psychotherapy, feminist therapy does not prescribe particular psychosocial interventions. The emphasis, as noted throughout this volume, is on tailoring interventions to meet clients at their strengths, skills, and capacities, all with the goal of increasing the client’s movement toward personal power on the four axes and evoking feminist consciousness in the process. In a given day, across sessions, a feminist therapist may utilize tools and strategies from psychodynamic psychotherapies, cognitive therapies, mindfulness-based paradigms, humanistic psychotherapies, expressive and movement therapies, and others. Feminist therapists will offer options to clients when they are available within their own repertoire of skills.
Brendan, a 25-year-old, fourth-generation Japanese American heterosexual man from a middle-class family, started psychotherapy with Deeana, a Euro American, heterosexual, middle-class, 47-year-old feminist therapist. Brendan was struggling with depression, which Deeana was identified as having expertise in treating. He told her that he was slightly taken aback when he read her client consent form, on which she described herself as a feminist therapist. “Dude, I’m a guy. Can you work with me?” he asked her. Deeana told him that she understood his uncertainty. “Lots of men who see me wonder if a feminist therapist can help them, so I’m not surprised. And dude, depression really is a problem because you’re a guy.” She went on to give him information about men’s depression and the stigma placed on men as “weak” if they struggled with these problems. She also offered him the choice of trying out working with her for a month: “If it feels like I’m the wrong therapist, you’ll probably know by then.” Notice that Deeana did not attempt to dissuade Brendan of his misgivings about the appropriateness of a feminist therapist; she began the empowerment process immediately by offering validation for his feelings and then also immediately began to offer gender role analysis as a means of creating feminist consciousness (e.g., that his struggles with depression were not his alone and that as a man, he had special challenges inherent in dealing with sexist views of depressed men as especially defective).
During the month that followed, Deeana invited Brendan to begin acquiring mindfulness strategies of compassionately observing himself as a means of reducing the power of his inner critic. She specifically spoke of how depression’s tendency toward hyper-criticism of the self was a drain on personal power, and while doing so, she noted out loud the sexist nature of much of that critique. “Do you notice how often that critic is telling you that you’re a sissy?” Deeana asked Brendan at the third session while they were reviewing his homework from the previous week. “What does that word mean to you?”
Notice that Deeana is applying several well-supported empirical interventions for depression, including mindfulness strategies and cognitive behavioral therapy. However, her challenges to his distorted thoughts were imbued with the awareness of gender, power, and social location, and this proved to be the factor that, by the end of therapy, Brendan told her had made a difference in his decision to stay in treatment with her. As it turned out, Brendan had been small and slight as a child, consistent with the phenotype of his ethnicity, and had been taunted and teased for being short and slender, bullied by other boys who called him a “sissy” and a “wimp.” His parents had told him to ignore the bullies, and he did, but the words had left a mark on his sense of his masculinity. For Brendan, a growing comprehension of the close relationship between his overly harsh self-assessments and the sexism he had encountered and internalized as a man in a patriarchal culture was eye-opening and empowering.
“You know,” he said during the third month of therapy, “I’m never gonna be a tall guy. I come from little short people; my obaa-chan, my grandma, is about four foot nothing, and my dad’s only five-five. If I spend my whole life taking up bandwidth somewhere in the back of my head about not being able to look like dudes whose grandmas came from Norway, I’m going to be one sorry guy.” Brendan’s feminist consciousness also opened up his hitherto-unexplored awareness of insidious racist trauma in his psychosocial environment.
Brendan’s symptoms of depression lessened after four months of weekly sessions with Deeana. The proverbial fly on the wall would have seen her using mindfulness, cognitive therapy, and behavioral activation strategies throughout that time; the careful observer would have noted that into each of these, Deeana infused feminist analysis of gender, power, and social location. At each session she would offer Brendan options for how to continue pursuing his well-being, which accounted in part for the somewhat diverse mixture of specific interventions that became part of his work with her.
Feminists were among the first psychotherapists to name the realities of abuse and violation in the family setting (Burgess & Holmstrom, 1978; Carmen, Reiker, & Mills, 1984; Herman, 1981; Walker, 1979) and to work with survivors of intimate violence. As a result, many feminist therapists have developed special competencies in addressing the multiple concerns of individuals who are living with what Judith Lewis Herman has called “complex trauma” (Herman, 1992). These are people who are often given the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder by nonfeminist therapists; they have been wounded and disempowered along every point of all four axes of personal power, and their struggles to find ways to maintain voice and presence in the world, while keeping them alive, have often been attended by very high personal and interpersonal prices.
One common price of surviving complex trauma is the use of self-inflicted violence (SIV) as a coping strategy. Feminist therapy with people who utilize SIV exemplifies the applications of the model of empowerment and egalitarian relationship to a problem that most commonly evokes controlling behaviors on the part of therapists who are, not unreasonably, frightened by the wounds that the person with whom they are working with is inflicting on her or his own body. A feminist therapist working with clients using SIV starts with careful attention to the voices of those who practice it, making them the authority as to its meaning and function primary. Self-inflicted violence is described by almost all who practice it as a coping strategy developed to meet one or several functions, which is consistent with the feminist model of symptoms as coping strategies. Those who practice it describe SIV as a highly effective form of emotion regulation that is not only more powerful than drugs, but free and not generally illegal (although when incarcerated, such behavior is usually coded as an infraction that can lead to further within-institution discipline). Many report that when they cut, burn, hit, or otherwise do violence to themselves, they become calmer, more capable of utilizing intellectual resources, and less suicidal. This can create an association of SIV with agency and the capacity for self-care and self-soothing in persons who have experienced chronic pervasive disempowerment and the absence of protection or soothing from others. Tending to present external wounds often helps soothe the internal wounds of the past (Mazelis, 2003, 2007). The symptom is frequently persistent because the coping strategy it embodies is much more effective than many others.
