!!Экзамен зачет 2023 год / Слыщенков. Договор к-п
.pdf<2>.
, <3>.
,
(charge);
:
<4>. ,
.
. "
" ;
,
, .
, .
--------------------------------
<1> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 751.
<2> .: Halsbury's Laws of England. London, 4th ed. (reissue). Vol. 42. Para 177 ( - Halsbury's Laws).
<3> . Leigh & Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Co Ltd (The Aliakmon) [1986] AC 785
, ,
.
, , ,
,
. , ,
,
.
<4> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 755 - 756; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Para 179.
(conveyance).
(formation) ;
(completion) <1>.
" " (exchange of contracts) <2> -
(enquiries as to the quality of title) -
.
(deposit): 10% ,
<3>.
, ,
( ) , ,
<4>. ,
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Farrand J.T. Op. cit. P. 15 - 31, 198 - 202; Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1157, 1184; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Paras 1 sqq.
<2>
(actual) (constructive)
(
; ,
) ( .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1172, 1179 - 1180). <3> Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1170 sqq., 1180 - 1181.
<4> Ibid. P. 757, 1180 - 1181; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Paras 234, 237.
<5> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 757, 1180 - 1181; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Para 245.
(completion) , . ,
, , ,
(deed),
.
. deed,
(mutually dependant acts),
<1>.
; (legal title)
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1184; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Para
185.
<2> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1184.
,
.
.
Killner v France <1>. ,
,
(27 ). 25 ;
, "
,
, " <2>. , 27 .
.
, (
) .
-
, ,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
, .
.
--------------------------------
<1> [1946] 2 All ER 83. <2> Ibid. P. 85 - 86.
,
.
. 2 (1) <1> 1979 .
: " -
- ,
, ". (sale)
(agreement to sell).
, sale.
,
agreement to sell. " " (sale)
,
, ,
, ( . 61 (1)
1979 .). , " " (contract of sale) " " ,
, " " <2>.
, 1979 .
: "
" <3>.
--------------------------------
<1>
: , " . 2 (1)" " . 1 . 2". <2> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 26 - 27; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 41.
2005 (reissue). Paras 28, 29.
<3> Battersby G., Preston A.D. The Concepts of "Property", "Title" and "Owner" Used in the Sale of Goods Act 1893 // Modern Law Review. 1972. N 35. P. 272.
,
( . 17 1979 .).
, . 18 . -
(specific) ( )
. |
|
, |
|
XIX |
. <1>, |
||
|
|
XV . |
<2>. |
( . , , ,
<3>)
,
(appropriated) , . (ascertained)
<4>. ,
, (appropriation)
,
.
, ,
,
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 186.
<2> .: Fifoot C.H.S. History and Sources of the Common Law: Tort and Contract. London, 1949. P. 228 sq.
<3> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 206; - ,
( . 61 (1) 1979 .).
<4> Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 329: " ,
, ,
,
(earmarked) ".
<5> .: Miles R. Blackstone's Sale and Supply of Goods and Services. London, 2001. P. 164 sq.; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 329 - 339; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 211 - 229.
, . ,
(legal wrong)
(public policy) <1>,
(unenforceable),
<2>. ,
(
) <3>.
: "
, (deed),
, " <4> (
. . - .). "
", (§ 817, 873, 929).
:
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 429 - 480.
<2> .: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 9 (1). Para 636.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
<3> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 141; Sajan Singh v Sardara Ali [1960] AC 167
, ;
, ,
.
<4> Higgins M.J. The Transfer of Property under Illegal Transactions // Modern Law Review. 1962. N 25. P. 151. Belvoir Finance Co. Ltd. v Stapleton [1971] 1 QB 210 at 218 (Denning) :
,
, ,
]". . (Op. cit. P. 151) : "
, (enforce)
, ,
,
. ,
, ".
<5> .: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 9 (1). Para 881, fn. 9:
, ;
, .
, ( )
, ,
<1>.
,
, , .
, ( )
, <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Higgins M.J. Op. cit. P. 152 - 153. , ,
:
;
,
(Ibid. P. 161 - 162).
<2> .: Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 498.
-
Holman v Johnson <1>.
,
: ex dolo malo non oritur actio (
). ,
, ,
<2>.
(Eldon) : " ,
" (let the estate lie where it falls) <3>.
, , ,
<4>.
--------------------------------
<1> (1775) 1 Cowp 341.
<2> .: Goff R., Jones G. The Law of Restitution. London, 1998. P. 608. <3> Muckleston v Brown (1801) 6 Ves. Jun. 52 ( . : Rose F.D.
Restitutionary and Proprietory Consequences of Illegality // Consensus Ad Idem. Essays in the Law of Contract / Ed. by F.D. Rose. London, 1996. P. 204).
<4> .: ., . . . . 2. . 333; Sabbath E. Denial of Restitution in Unlawful Transactions - a Study in Comparative Law // International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 1959. N 8. P. 487 - 488.
<1>.
,
, ,
<2>. .
, .
,
: "... ,
, " <3>.
,
. ,
" ":
.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Sabbath E. Op. cit. P. 490.
<2> .: Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 491 - 503; Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 613 - 629; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 141 sq.
<3> Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 491;
.: ., . . . . 2. . 333 - 343; Sabbath E. Op. cit. P. 689 sqq.
, , ,
.
.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
,
.
:
. ,
. :
( ) .
,
; ,
,
.
. 2 1979 .,
(agreement to sell), .
, (sale), . .
,
,
, .
,
.
, .
5.2.1.
, ,
, . 1583
" ... ...")
. - .), (Mackenzie Chalmers), 1893 . <1>. 16 - 20
"
(Transfer of property as between seller and buyer)" (
. - .);
. . . 21 - 26
" (Transfer of title)";
(nemo dat quod non habet),
( . 24) ( . 25),
( . -
;
- ,
).
--------------------------------
<1> .: Lawson F.H. Op. cit. P. 353.
title property
1979 ., 1893 . title property
1979 . <1>.
, <2>.
: ,
,
.
--------------------------------
<1> , .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 309 - 315; Battersby G., Preston A.D. Op. cit. P. 275 - 281; Battersby G. A Reconsideration of "Property" and "Title" in the Sale of Goods Act // Journal of Business Law. 2001, January. P. 1 - 13.
<2> .: Battersby G. Op. cit. P. 1, 13.
. . 24, 25 1979 .
17 (1) 1979 . : "
, " (where there is a contract for the sale of specific or ascertained goods the property in them is transferred to the buyer at such time as the parties to the contract intend it to be transferred). ,
. 18, 1,
. 1979 .
.
.
nemo dat quod non habet (
, ) ( . 21 (1) 1979 .). ,
<1>.
nemo dat,
.
--------------------------------
<1> 1995 . . 22 (1) 1979 . ,
,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
overt, .
, .
nemo dat.
,
: "
;
,
,
,
" <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> (Crowther Committee)
(1971 .) ( . : Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 412).
nemo dat
, ,
, . 24
1979 . : " , , ,
(documents of title) ,
(delivery) (transfer) ,
,
(sale), (pledge) (other disposition) , (in good faith)
(without notice) , ,
, ,
(expressly authorised)
" <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> . 8
(Factors Act) 1889 . , . 8
: . 24 1979 .
" " ,
", . 8 1889 . : "...
, ". 8
1889 . ( .: Miles R. Op. cit. P. 190).
nemo dat,
. 25 (1) 1979 ., ,
,
( )
<1>. , ( . . 24 25 (1) 1979 .)
.
--------------------------------
<1> . 9 1889 .,
, . 25 (1) 1979 .,
, . 8
( . ).
1979 .
(actual) :
,
. : -
, ; ,
( , constructive) , .
.
** *
. . 24, 25 1979 .
(document of title)
. , ( ),
. ,
.
" " " (representing) <1>;
(bill of lading), ,
<2>.
,
, <3>;
" " (mere promises) <4>.
,
( ),
; ,
(attornment) ( ,
) <5>.
--------------------------------
<1> Gunn v Bolckow, Vaugan & Co (1875) 10 Ch App 491, 502:
,
, ". <2> .: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 41. Para 163.
<3> Ibid. Paras 139, 163. <4> Ibid. Para 163.
<5> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 354 - 355; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 35. Para 1254; Vol. 41. Paras 157, 163. 29 (4) 1979 .: "
: PRESSI ( HERSON )